Studying Transcriptional Enhancers: The Founder Fallacy, Validation Creep, and Other Biases.

Transcriptional enhancers play a major role in regulating metazoan gene expression. Recent developments in genomics and next-generation sequencing have accelerated and revitalized the study of this important class of sequence elements. Increased interest and attention, however, has also led to troubling trends in the enhancer literature. In this Opinion, I describe some of these issues and show how they arise from shifting and nonuniform enhancer definitions, and genome-era biases. I discuss how they can lead to interpretative errors and an unduly narrow focus on certain aspects of enhancer biology to the potential exclusion of others.

[1]  G. Pesole.  What is a gene? An updated operational definition. , 2008, Gene.

[2]  Lee E. Edsall,et al.  A map of the cis-regulatory sequences in the mouse genome , 2012, Nature.

[3]  Nathaniel D. Heintzman,et al.  Histone modifications at human enhancers reflect global cell-type-specific gene expression , 2009, Nature.

[4]  David H. Sharp,et al.  Quantitative and predictive model of transcriptional control of the Drosophila melanogaster even skipped gene , 2006, Nature Genetics.

[5]  Marc S Halfon,et al.  Computation-based discovery of related transcriptional regulatory modules and motifs using an experimentally validated combinatorial model. , 2002, Genome research.

[6]  Scott Barolo,et al.  Shadow enhancers: Frequently asked questions about distributed cis‐regulatory information and enhancer redundancy , 2012, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[7]  Marc S Halfon,et al.  Large-scale analysis of transcriptional cis-regulatory modules reveals both common features and distinct subclasses , 2007, Genome Biology.

[8]  Michael Q. Zhang,et al.  Combinatorial patterns of histone acetylations and methylations in the human genome , 2008, Nature Genetics.

[9]  M. Kreitman,et al.  Functional Evolution of a cis-Regulatory Module , 2005, PLoS biology.

[10]  Wendy A Bickmore,et al.  Histone H3 globular domain acetylation identifies a new class of enhancers , 2016, Nature Genetics.

[11]  Steven M. Gallo,et al.  REDfly v3.0: toward a comprehensive database of transcriptional regulatory elements in Drosophila , 2010, Nucleic Acids Res..

[12]  R. Young,et al.  Super-Enhancers in the Control of Cell Identity and Disease , 2013, Cell.

[13]  A. Stark,et al.  Assessing sufficiency and necessity of enhancer activities for gene expression and the mechanisms of transcription activation , 2018, Genes & development.

[14]  Panos Kalnis,et al.  Progress and challenges in bioinformatics approaches for enhancer identification , 2015, Briefings Bioinform..

[15]  Martin S. Taylor,et al.  Bidirectional transcription initiation marks accessible chromatin and is not specific to enhancers , 2017, Genome Biology.

[16]  Edwin Smith,et al.  Enhancer biology and enhanceropathies , 2014, Nature Structural &Molecular Biology.

[17]  Nathaniel D. Heintzman,et al.  Distinct and predictive chromatin signatures of transcriptional promoters and enhancers in the human genome , 2007, Nature Genetics.

[18]  Yoshihide Hayashizaki,et al.  Enhanced Identification of Transcriptional Enhancers Provides Mechanistic Insights into Diseases. , 2016, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[19]  M. Levine,et al.  Shadow Enhancers as a Source of Evolutionary Novelty , 2008, Science.

[20]  M Klingler,et al.  Disperse versus compact elements for the regulation of runt stripes in Drosophila. , 1996, Developmental biology.

[21]  M. Fujioka,et al.  Regulation of a duplicated locus: Drosophila sloppy paired is replete with functionally overlapping enhancers. , 2012, Developmental biology.

[22]  Danwei Huangfu,et al.  Decoding the noncoding genome via large-scale CRISPR screens. , 2018, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[23]  David A. Orlando,et al.  Master Transcription Factors and Mediator Establish Super-Enhancers at Key Cell Identity Genes , 2013, Cell.

[24]  Manolis Kellis,et al.  ChromHMM: automating chromatin-state discovery and characterization , 2012, Nature Methods.

[25]  E. Davidson,et al.  Genomic cis-regulatory logic: experimental and computational analysis of a sea urchin gene. , 1998, Science.

[26]  G. Stormo,et al.  Identification of a novel cis-regulatory element involved in the heat shock response in Caenorhabditis elegans using microarray gene expression and computational methods. , 2002, Genome research.

[27]  A. McGregor,et al.  The Functionality and Evolution of Eukaryotic Transcriptional Enhancers. , 2016, Advances in genetics.

[28]  T. Meehan,et al.  An atlas of active enhancers across human cell types and tissues , 2014, Nature.

[29]  J. Lieb,et al.  What are super-enhancers? , 2014, Nature Genetics.

[30]  A. Stark,et al.  Transcriptional enhancers: from properties to genome-wide predictions , 2014, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[31]  Li M. Li,et al.  Genome-wide errant targeting by Hairy , 2015, eLife.

[32]  B. Cohen,et al.  High-throughput functional testing of ENCODE segmentation predictions , 2014, Genome research.

[33]  David S. Lorberbaum,et al.  An ancient yet flexible cis-regulatory architecture allows localized Hedgehog tuning by patched/Ptch1 , 2016, eLife.

[34]  W. Bickmore,et al.  H4K16 acetylation marks active genes and enhancers of embryonic stem cells, but does not alter chromatin compaction , 2013, Genome research.

[35]  M. Halfon,et al.  Regulation of gene expression in the genomic context , 2014, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[36]  J. Wysocka,et al.  Ever-Changing Landscapes: Transcriptional Enhancers in Development and Evolution , 2016, Cell.

[37]  Christopher A. Lavender,et al.  Widespread transcriptional pausing and elongation control at enhancers , 2018, Genes & development.

[38]  Yanhui Hu,et al.  FlyBase at 25: looking to the future , 2016, Nucleic Acids Res..

[39]  A. Wilkins,et al.  The Evolving Definition of the Term “Gene” , 2017, Genetics.

[40]  D. Stern,et al.  Comprehensive Analysis of a cis-Regulatory Region Reveals Pleiotropy in Enhancer Function. , 2018, Cell reports.

[41]  J. Kawai,et al.  Cap analysis gene expression for high-throughput analysis of transcriptional starting point and identification of promoter usage , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[42]  L. Pennacchio,et al.  Genetic dissection of the α-globin super-enhancer in vivo , 2016, Nature Genetics.

[43]  M. Fujioka,et al.  Analysis of an even-skipped rescue transgene reveals both composite and discrete neuronal and early blastoderm enhancers, and multi-stripe positioning by gap gene repressor gradients. , 1999, Development.

[44]  M. Halfon,et al.  Identifying transcriptional cis‐regulatory modules in animal genomes , 2015, Wiley interdisciplinary reviews. Developmental biology.

[45]  B. Garcia,et al.  Mll3 and Mll4 Facilitate Enhancer RNA Synthesis and Transcription from Promoters Independently of H3K4 Monomethylation. , 2017, Molecular cell.

[46]  M. Halfon.  (Re)modeling the transcriptional enhancer , 2006, Nature Genetics.

[47]  J. Banerji,et al.  Expression of a β-globin gene is enhanced by remote SV40 DNA sequences , 1981, Cell.

[48]  Antónia Monteiro,et al.  Wings, Horns, and Butterfly Eyespots: How Do Complex Traits Evolve? , 2009, PLoS biology.

[49]  Jennifer A. Mitchell,et al.  Enhancers and super-enhancers have an equivalent regulatory role in embryonic stem cells through regulation of single or multiple genes , 2017, Genome research.

[50]  A. Shilatifard,et al.  Histone H3K4 monomethylation catalyzed by Trr and mammalian COMPASS-like proteins at enhancers is dispensable for development and viability , 2017, Nature Genetics.

[51]  David Z. Pan,et al.  Genome-wide analysis of enhancer RNA in gene regulation across 12 mouse tissues , 2015, Scientific Reports.

[52]  E. Furlong,et al.  Tissue-specific analysis of chromatin state identifies temporal signatures of enhancer activity during embryonic development , 2012, Nature Genetics.

[53]  William Stafford Noble,et al.  Unsupervised pattern discovery in human chromatin structure through genomic segmentation , 2012, Nature Methods.

[54]  M. Gerstein,et al.  What is a gene, post-ENCODE? History and updated definition. , 2007, Genome research.

[55]  S. Bolshakov,et al.  Identification of regulatory regions driving the expression of the Drosophila spalt complex at different developmental stages. , 1999, Developmental biology.

[56]  A. Shilatifard,et al.  Enhancer Logic and Mechanics in Development and Disease. , 2018, Trends in cell biology.