Comparison of five methods for assessing impacts of nutrient enrichment using estuarine case studies

There are several approaches for assessing nutrient enrichment impacts in marine waters including the OSPAR* Comprehensive Procedure, the TRIX* ranking process, the WFD, ASSETS* and EPA NCA*. They differ in definitions and application, but all use key indicators for evaluating eutrophication status. Data from two estuaries in the United Kingdom (UK) were used to test the hypothesis that these five methods would result in the same outcome. The intent is to provide managers with information for selecting an appropriate method, insight about how each method works, how results from different methods compare and a basis for improvement of methods. Results from all approaches indicate that both estuaries required management intervention, but detailed results differed. Methods using more than one biological indicator show that secondary biological impacts were minimal, with the exception of moderate macroalgal problems in the Medway. Comparison of final results was difficult due to differences in: timeframes of data analysis (seasonal versus annual), characteristics included in indicator metrics (concentration, spatial coverage, frequency of occurrence), and methods for combining indicators to determine eutrophication status. This comparison suggests that use of annual data, inclusion frequency of occurrence, spatial coverage and, secondary biological indicators in the index, and a multi-category rating scale results in a more representative assessment.

[1]  S. Nixon Eutrophication and the macroscope , 2009, Hydrobiologia.

[2]  S. Malcolm,et al.  Assessing the impact of nutrient enrichment in estuaries: susceptibility to eutrophication. , 2007, Marine pollution bulletin.

[3]  M. D. Gastrich,et al.  A Brown Tide Bloom Index based on the potential harmful effects of the brown tide alga, Aureococcus anophagefferens , 2002 .

[4]  R. Vollenweider,et al.  Trophic conditions of marine coastal waters: experience in applying the Trophic Index TRIX to two areas of the Adriatic and Tyrrhenian seas , 2004 .

[5]  Marcel J. W. Veldhuis,et al.  Phaeocystis blooms and nutrient enrichment in the continental coastal zones of the North sea , 1987 .

[6]  M. Best,et al.  Dissolved oxygen as a physico-chemical supporting element in the Water Framework Directive. , 2007, Marine pollution bulletin.

[7]  M. Gillbricht Phytoplankton and nutrients in the Helgoland region , 1988, Helgoländer Meeresuntersuchungen.

[8]  S. Bricker,et al.  An integrated methodology for assessment of estuarine trophic status , 2003 .

[9]  T. Simas,et al.  Management of coastal eutrophication: integration of field data, ecosystem-scale simulations and screening models , 2005 .

[10]  S. Bricker,et al.  Application and sensitivity testing of a eutrophication assessment method on coastal systems in the United States and European Union. , 2007, Journal of environmental management.

[11]  W. Boynton,et al.  A comparative analysis of eutrophication patterns in a temperate coastal lagoon , 1996 .

[12]  J. Cloern The relative importance of light and nutrient limitation of phytoplankton growth: a simple index of coastal ecosystem sensitivity to nutrient enrichment , 1999, Aquatic Ecology.

[13]  Caroline Cusack,et al.  Establishing boundary classes for the classification of UK marine waters using phytoplankton communities. , 2007, Marine pollution bulletin.

[14]  Jon Barry,et al.  Relationships between suspended particulate material, light attenuation and Secchi depth in UK marine waters , 2008 .

[15]  Pat Hutchings,et al.  Overview of integrative tools and methods in assessing ecological integrity in estuarine and coastal systems worldwide. , 2008, Marine pollution bulletin.

[16]  S. Bricker,et al.  National estuarine eutrophication assessment: effects of nutrient enrichment in the nation's estuaries , 1999 .

[17]  Jo Foden,et al.  Searching for undesirable disturbance: an application of the OSPAR eutrophication assessment method to marine waters of England and Wales , 2011 .

[18]  Michael Elliott,et al.  Classifying Ecological Quality and Integrity of Estuaries , 2011 .

[19]  Ulrich Claussen,et al.  Relationship between eutrophication reference conditions and boundary settings considering OSPAR recommendations and the Water Framework Directive—examples from the German Bight , 2009, Hydrobiologia.

[20]  Mike Best,et al.  Setting nutrient thresholds to support an ecological assessment based on nutrient enrichment, potential primary production and undesirable disturbance. , 2007, Marine Pollution Bulletin.

[21]  D. Scavia,et al.  Coastal eutrophication assessment in the United States , 2006 .

[22]  Jon Barry,et al.  Estimating the diffuse attenuation coefficient from optically active constituents in UK marine waters , 2009 .

[23]  U. Brockmann,et al.  Assessment of the eutrophication status of transitional, coastal and marine waters within OSPAR , 2009, Hydrobiologia.

[24]  K. Boicourt,et al.  Effects of nutrient enrichment in the nation's estuaries: A decade of change , 2008 .

[25]  C. Reynolds,et al.  Community Assembly in Marine Phytoplankton: Application of Recent Models to Harmful Dinoflagellate Blooms , 2001 .

[26]  T. Simas,et al.  Does biodiversity of estuarine phytoplankton depend on hydrology , 2005 .

[27]  O. A. L. Paramor,et al.  On the loss of saltmarshes in south-east England and methods for their restoration , 2004 .

[28]  R. W. Butcher Zostera. Report on the Present Condition of Eel Grass on the Coasts of England, based on a Survey during August to October, 1933 , 1934 .

[29]  J. Nunes,et al.  Trophic Assessment in Chinese coastal systems-review of methods and application to the Changjiang (Yangtze) Estuary and Jiaozhou Bay , 2007 .

[30]  J. Andersen,et al.  Eutrophication in the Baltic Sea – An integrated thematic assessment of the effects of nutrient enrichment and eutrophication in the Baltic Sea region. , 2009 .

[31]  Attilio Rinaldi,et al.  Characterization of the trophic conditions of marine coastal waters with special reference to the NW Adriatic Sea: proposal for a trophic scale, turbidity and generalized water quality index , 1998 .

[32]  S. Bricker,et al.  Improving methods and indicators for evaluating coastal water eutrophication: a pilot study in the Gulf of Maine , 2006 .

[33]  Mark Huxham,et al.  The European Water Framework Directive: a new era in the management of aquatic ecosystem health? , 1998 .

[34]  J. Cloern Our evolving conceptual model of the coastal eutrophication problem , 2001 .

[35]  W. Wolff,et al.  Biological Surveys of Estuaries and Coasts , 1987 .