Analysis of epidemiological models for disease control in single and multiple populations under resource constraints

Efficient management of epidemics is one of the primary motivations for computational modelling of disease dynamics. Examples range from reactive control measures, where the resources used to manage the epidemic in real time may be limited to prophylactic control measures such as deployment of genetically resistant plant varieties, which may lead to economic trade-offs. In such situations the question is how should resources for disease control be deployed to ensure the efficient management of the epidemic. Mathematical models are a powerful tool to investigate such questions since experiments are usually infeasible and the primary aim of this thesis is to study selected mathematical models of disease control to improve the current understanding of their behaviour. We initially analyse the dynamical behaviour that arises from incorporating an economic constraint into two simple, but widely used epidemic models with reactive control. Despite the selection of simple models, the addition of constrained control leads to mathematically rich dynamics, including the coexistence of multiple stable equilibria and stable limit cycles arising from global bifurcations. We use the analytical understanding obtained from the simple model to explore how to allocate a limited resource optimally between a number of separate populations that are exposed to an epidemic. Initially, we assume that the allocation is done at the beginning and cannot be changed later. We seek to answer the question of how the resource should be allocated efficiently to minimise the long-term number of infections. We show that the optimal allocation strategy can be approximated by a solution to a knapsack-type problem, that is the problem of how to select items of varying values and weights to maximise combined value without going over certain combined weight. The weights and values are given as functions of the population sizes, initial conditions, and the disease parameters. Later, we relax the assumptions to allow for reallocation and use the understanding of the dynamics gained from the simple models in the

[1]  S. Levin,et al.  Periodicity in Epidemiological Models , 1989 .

[2]  Colin J. Sutherland,et al.  Determination of the Processes Driving the Acquisition of Immunity to Malaria Using a Mathematical Transmission Model , 2007, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[3]  M. Deakin Catastrophe theory. , 1977, Science.

[4]  Margaret L Brandeau,et al.  Dynamic resource allocation for epidemic control in multiple populations. , 2002, IMA journal of mathematics applied in medicine and biology.

[5]  J. Gamarra,et al.  Metapopulation Ecology , 2007 .

[6]  James Watmough,et al.  Further Notes on the Basic Reproduction Number , 2008 .

[7]  Harvey Weiss,et al.  A Mathematical Programming Model for Test Construction and Scoring , 1973 .

[8]  T. W. Barrett,et al.  Catastrophe Theory, Selected Papers 1972-1977 , 1978, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics.

[9]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Measures of durability of resistance. , 2003, Phytopathology.

[10]  Ross K. Meentemeyer,et al.  Effects of landscape heterogeneity on the emerging forest disease sudden oak death , 2007 .

[11]  C. Gilligan,et al.  A model for the invasion and spread of rhizomania in the United kingdom: implications for disease control strategies. , 2004, Phytopathology.

[12]  J. D. Millar,et al.  Modeling potential responses to smallpox as a bioterrorist weapon. , 2001, Emerging infectious diseases.

[13]  R. May,et al.  Modelling vaccination strategies against foot-and-mouth disease , 2003, Nature.

[14]  E. H. Kaplan Economic Evaluation and HIV Prevention Community Planning , 1998 .

[15]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Optimization of control strategies for epidemics in heterogeneous populations with symmetric and asymmetric transmission. , 2010, Journal of theoretical biology.

[16]  Danielle F. P. Toupo,et al.  Nonlinear dynamics of the rock-paper-scissors game with mutations. , 2015, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[17]  R. K. Shyamasundar,et al.  Introduction to algorithms , 1996 .

[18]  W. Spielmeyer,et al.  The past, present and future of breeding rust resistant wheat , 2014, Front. Plant Sci..

[19]  C. Castillo-Chavez,et al.  To treat or not to treat: the case of tuberculosis , 1997, Journal of mathematical biology.

[20]  M. Keeling,et al.  Networks and epidemic models , 2005, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[21]  Christopher A. Gilligan,et al.  Optimal control of epidemics in metapopulations , 2009, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[22]  Laurence V. Madden,et al.  The study of plant disease epidemics , 2007 .

[23]  N. Grassly,et al.  Host immunity and synchronized epidemics of syphilis across the United States , 2005, Nature.

[24]  M. Keeling The implications of network structure for epidemic dynamics. , 2005, Theoretical population biology.

[25]  Nico Stollenwerk,et al.  Meningitis, pathogenicity near criticality: the epidemiology of meningococcal disease as a model for accidental pathogens. , 2003, Journal of theoretical biology.

[26]  Andrei Korobeinikov,et al.  Lyapunov Functions and Global Stability for SIR and SIRS Epidemiological Models with Non-Linear Transmission , 2006, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[27]  Ellis Horowitz,et al.  Computing Partitions with Applications to the Knapsack Problem , 1974, JACM.

[28]  L. Allen,et al.  Comparison of deterministic and stochastic SIS and SIR models in discrete time. , 2000, Mathematical biosciences.

[29]  Huaiping Zhu,et al.  An SIS Infection Model Incorporating Media Coverage , 2008 .

[30]  Herbert W. Hethcote,et al.  Stability of the endemic equilibrium in epidemic models with subpopulations , 1985 .

[31]  E. Oerke Crop losses to pests , 2005, The Journal of Agricultural Science.

[32]  R. Anderson,et al.  Persistence and dynamics in lattice models of epidemic spread. , 1996, Journal of theoretical biology.

[33]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Thirteen challenges in modelling plant diseases. , 2015, Epidemics.

[34]  Odo Diekmann,et al.  Mathematical Tools for Understanding Infectious Disease Dynamics , 2012 .

[35]  Paolo Toth,et al.  Knapsack Problems: Algorithms and Computer Implementations , 1990 .

[36]  D. J. Bailey,et al.  An Epidemiological Analysis of the Role of Disease-Induced Root Growth in the Differential Response of Two Cultivars of Winter Wheat to Infection by Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici. , 2006, Phytopathology.

[37]  H. Monod,et al.  Influence of cultivated landscape composition on variety resistance: an assessment based on wheat leaf rust epidemics. , 2011, The New phytologist.

[38]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Trade-off between disease resistance and crop yield: a landscape-scale mathematical modelling perspective , 2016, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[39]  Christopher A Gilligan,et al.  Impact of scale on the effectiveness of disease control strategies for epidemics with cryptic infection in a dynamical landscape: an example for a crop disease , 2007, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[40]  I B Schwartz,et al.  Multiple stable recurrent outbreaks and predictability in seasonally forced nonlinear epidemic models , 1985, Journal of mathematical biology.

[41]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Balancing Detection and Eradication for Control of Epidemics: Sudden Oak Death in Mixed-Species Stands , 2010, PloS one.

[42]  D. Gillespie A General Method for Numerically Simulating the Stochastic Time Evolution of Coupled Chemical Reactions , 1976 .

[43]  O. Bjørnstad,et al.  Chapter 17 , 2019 .

[44]  Roy M. Anderson,et al.  Spatial heterogeneity and the design of immunization programs , 1984 .

[45]  C. Hollier,et al.  Crop losses due to diseases and their implications for global food production losses and food security , 2012, Food Security.

[46]  Ross K. Meentemeyer,et al.  Epidemiological modeling of invasion in heterogeneous landscapes: spread of sudden oak death in California (1990–2030) , 2011 .

[47]  Ben Adams,et al.  Disease and disaster: Optimal deployment of epidemic control facilities in a spatially heterogeneous population with changing behaviour. , 2016, Journal of theoretical biology.

[48]  L. Madden,et al.  Perceptions of disease risk: from social construction of subjective judgments to rational decision making. , 2011, Phytopathology.

[49]  R. May,et al.  Infectious Diseases of Humans: Dynamics and Control , 1991, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[50]  Hans Kellerer,et al.  Knapsack problems , 2004 .

[51]  Steven Skiena,et al.  Who is interested in algorithms and why?: lessons from the Stony Brook algorithms repository , 1999, SIGA.

[52]  D. Stoyan,et al.  Stochastic Geometry and Its Applications , 1989 .

[53]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Evaluating the Performance of Chemical Control in the Presence of Resistant Pathogens , 2007, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[54]  D. Haydon,et al.  Alternative stable states in ecology , 2003 .

[55]  M. Keeling,et al.  Modeling Infectious Diseases in Humans and Animals , 2007 .

[56]  S. Cinti,et al.  Bacterial pneumonias during an influenza pandemic: how will we allocate antibiotics? , 2009, Biosecurity and bioterrorism : biodefense strategy, practice, and science.

[57]  C. Dye,et al.  Modeling the SARS Epidemic , 2003, Science.

[58]  G. A. Ngwa,et al.  A mathematical model for endemic malaria with variable human and mosquito populations , 2000 .

[59]  M. Génard,et al.  Fruit thinning and shade improve bean characteristics and beverage quality of coffee (Coffea arabica L.) under optimal conditions , 2006 .

[60]  D. J. Bailey,et al.  Modeling and analysis of disease-induced host growth in the epidemiology of take-all. , 2004, Phytopathology.

[61]  R. Macarthur,et al.  Graphical Representation and Stability Conditions of Predator-Prey Interactions , 1963, The American Naturalist.

[62]  Gregory Gutin,et al.  When the greedy algorithm fails , 2004, Discret. Optim..

[63]  J. Hayes,et al.  Bat activity in thinned, unthinned, and old-growth forests in western Oregon , 1999 .

[64]  James Watmough,et al.  A simple SIS epidemic model with a backward bifurcation , 2000, Journal of mathematical biology.

[65]  Alison P. Galvani,et al.  Free-Riding Behavior in Vaccination Decisions: An Experimental Study , 2014, PloS one.

[66]  Serfling Re,et al.  Historical review of epidemic theory. , 1952 .

[67]  Richard Baker,et al.  The UK Plant Health Risk Register: a tool for prioritizing actions , 2014 .

[68]  James K. M. Brown,et al.  Fitness costs and trade‐offs of disease resistance and their consequences for breeding arable crops , 2013 .

[69]  C. M. Place Dynamical Systems: Differential Equations, Maps, and Chaotic Behaviour , 1992 .

[70]  Fred Brauer,et al.  Compartmental Models in Epidemiology , 2008, Mathematical Epidemiology.

[71]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Invasion and persistence of plant parasites in a spatially structured host population , 2001 .

[72]  C A Gilligan,et al.  Bubonic plague: a metapopulation model of a zoonosis , 2000, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[73]  W. John Edmunds,et al.  Assessing Optimal Target Populations for Influenza Vaccination Programmes: An Evidence Synthesis and Modelling Study , 2013, PLoS medicine.

[74]  J. Velasco-Hernández,et al.  A simple vaccination model with multiple endemic states. , 2000, Mathematical biosciences.

[75]  Roy Johnson The Gene‐for‐Gene Relationship in Plant–Parasite Interactions , 1998 .

[76]  Lin Wang,et al.  Spatial epidemiology of networked metapopulation: an overview , 2014, bioRxiv.

[77]  L. S. King The Story of Medicine , 1969 .

[78]  Christopher A. Gilligan,et al.  Optimising and Communicating Options for the Control of Invasive Plant Disease When There Is Epidemiological Uncertainty , 2015, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[79]  C. Winslow Conquest of Epidemic Disease: A Chapter in the History of Ideas , 1967 .

[80]  A. Langworthy,et al.  An influenza simulation model for immunization studies. , 1976, American journal of epidemiology.

[81]  Herbert W. Hethcote,et al.  An SIS epidemic model with variable population size and a delay , 1995, Journal of mathematical biology.

[82]  James K. M. Brown Durable resistance of crops to disease: a Darwinian perspective. , 2015, Annual review of phytopathology.

[83]  Joan L. Aron,et al.  Mathematical modelling of immunity to malaria , 1988 .

[84]  James K. M. Brown Yield penalties of disease resistance in crops. , 2002, Current opinion in plant biology.

[85]  Bryan T Grenfell,et al.  Synthesizing epidemiological and economic optima for control of immunizing infections , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[86]  J. Jensen,et al.  Associations between three ml-o powdery mildew resistance genes and agronomic traits in barley , 1990, Euphytica.

[87]  Yang Kuang,et al.  Uniqueness of limit cycles in Gause-type models of predator-prey systems , 1988 .

[88]  Stefan Riedel,et al.  Edward Jenner and the History of Smallpox and Vaccination , 2005, Proceedings.

[89]  C. M. Guldberg,et al.  Études sur les affinitès chimiques , 1867 .

[90]  M. Keeling Models of foot-and-mouth disease , 2005, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[91]  C. Lacomme Plant Pathology , 2015, Methods in Molecular Biology.

[92]  Frank van den Bosch,et al.  Durable Resistance to Crop Pathogens: An Epidemiological Framework to Predict Risk under Uncertainty , 2013, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[93]  H. R. Noori Hysteresis Phenomena in Biology , 2013 .

[94]  R. Singh,et al.  Effect of Leaf Rust Resistance Gene Lr34 on Grain Yield and Agronomic Traits of Spring Wheat , 1997 .

[95]  J. Zadoks,et al.  Epidemiology and plant disease management , 1979 .

[96]  Sze-Bi Hsu,et al.  On the Role of Asymptomatic Infection in Transmission Dynamics of Infectious Diseases , 2007, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[97]  J. Medlock,et al.  Optimizing Influenza Vaccine Distribution , 2009, Science.

[98]  I. Bendixson Sur les courbes définies par des équations différentielles , 1901 .

[99]  L. Mailleret,et al.  Durable strategies to deploy plant resistance in agricultural landscapes. , 2012, The New phytologist.

[100]  Aaron M Wendelboe,et al.  Duration of Immunity Against Pertussis After Natural Infection or Vaccination , 2005, The Pediatric infectious disease journal.

[101]  J. Goodman,et al.  Dictionary of Finance and Investment Terms , 1985 .

[102]  P van den Driessche,et al.  Backward bifurcation in epidemic control. , 1997, Mathematical biosciences.

[103]  C. Spinage,et al.  Cattle Plague , 2003, Springer US.

[104]  E. Oerke Crop Production and Crop Protection: Estimated Losses in Major Food and Cash Crops , 1994, The Journal of Agricultural Science.

[105]  J. Yorke,et al.  A Deterministic Model for Gonorrhea in a Nonhomogeneous Population , 1976 .

[106]  H. P. Hudson,et al.  An application of the theory of probabilities to the study of a priori pathometry.—Part I , 1917 .

[107]  Liana N. Joseph,et al.  Optimal Allocation of Resources among Threatened Species: a Project Prioritization Protocol , 2009, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[108]  G. Rebetzke,et al.  Guiding deployment of resistance in cereals using evolutionary principles , 2014, Evolutionary applications.

[109]  Christopher A. Gilligan,et al.  Economic incentives and mathematical models of disease , 2007, Environment and Development Economics.

[110]  L. Madden Botanical epidemiology:some key advances and its continuing role in disease management , 2006 .

[111]  R. Johnson A critical analysis of durable resistance , 1984 .

[112]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  The plant immune system , 2006, Nature.

[113]  Reka Albert,et al.  Mean-field theory for scale-free random networks , 1999 .

[114]  R. Brookmeyer,et al.  Incubation periods of acute respiratory viral infections: a systematic review , 2009, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[115]  S. Sethi,et al.  Optimal Control of Some Simple Deterministic Epidemic Models , 1978 .

[116]  R. Anderson,et al.  Pulse mass measles vaccination across age cohorts. , 1993, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[117]  M. Keeling,et al.  Metapopulation dynamics of bubonic plague , 2000, Nature.

[118]  David M. Rizzo,et al.  Sudden oak death: endangering California and Oregon forest ecosystems , 2003 .

[119]  D. Gent,et al.  Perceptions of risk, risk aversion, and barriers to adoption of decision support systems and integrated pest management: an introduction. , 2011, Phytopathology.

[120]  J. Snow On the Mode of Communication of Cholera , 1856, Edinburgh medical journal.

[121]  I B Schwartz,et al.  Small amplitude, long period outbreaks in seasonally driven epidemics , 1992, Journal of mathematical biology.

[122]  Knut Sydsæter,et al.  Optimal control theory with economic applications , 1987 .

[123]  W. Mcneill Plagues and Peoples , 1977, The Review of Politics.

[124]  Catherine H Mercer,et al.  Vicious and virtuous circles in the dynamics of infectious disease and the provision of health care: gonorrhea in Britain as an example. , 2005, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[125]  T. Sideris Ordinary Differential Equations and Dynamical Systems , 2013 .

[126]  A. Nizam,et al.  Containing Bioterrorist Smallpox , 2002, Science.

[127]  Thilo Gross,et al.  Epidemic dynamics on an adaptive network. , 2005, Physical review letters.

[128]  J. Plange-Rhule,et al.  Shortage of healthcare workers in developing countries--Africa. , 2009, Ethnicity & disease.

[129]  Fred Brauer,et al.  Mathematical epidemiology is not an oxymoron , 2009, BMC public health.

[130]  S. Goldman,et al.  Cost Optimization in the SIS Model of Infectious Disease with Treatment , 2002 .

[131]  Christopher A. Gilligan,et al.  Resource Allocation for Epidemic Control in Metapopulations , 2011, PloS one.

[132]  S. Ruan,et al.  Bifurcations in an epidemic model with constant removal rate of the infectives , 2004 .

[133]  S. Savary,et al.  Peanut rust in West Africa: a new component in a multiple pathosystem. , 1988 .

[134]  Kate E. Jones,et al.  Global trends in emerging infectious diseases , 2008, Nature.

[135]  O. Bjørnstad,et al.  Travelling waves and spatial hierarchies in measles epidemics , 2001, Nature.

[136]  I B Schwartz,et al.  Seasonality and period-doubling bifurcations in an epidemic model. , 1984, Journal of theoretical biology.

[137]  P. Klepac,et al.  Self-enforcing regional vaccination agreements , 2016, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[138]  J. Parlevliet Components of Resistance that Reduce the Rate of Epidemic Development , 1979 .

[139]  M. L. Chambers The Mathematical Theory of Optimal Processes , 1965 .

[140]  A. Hastings Transient dynamics and persistence of ecological systems , 2001 .

[141]  Julien Arino,et al.  A final size relation for epidemic models. , 2007, Mathematical biosciences and engineering : MBE.

[142]  W. O. Kermack,et al.  A contribution to the mathematical theory of epidemics , 1927 .

[143]  Otso Ovaskainen,et al.  Metapopulation theory for fragmented landscapes. , 2003, Theoretical population biology.

[144]  J. Wilen,et al.  Individual and Cooperative Management of Invasive Species in Human‐Mediated Landscapes , 2015 .

[145]  P. Geoffard,et al.  Rational Epidemics and Their Public Control , 1996 .

[146]  M. Brandeau,et al.  Resource allocation for control of infectious diseases in multiple independent populations: beyond cost-effectiveness analysis. , 2003, Journal of health economics.

[147]  C. Gilligan,et al.  Complex Dynamical Behaviour in an Epidemic Model with Control , 2016, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[148]  Epidemics in heterogeneous populations: aspects of optimal vaccination policies. , 1989, IMA journal of mathematics applied in medicine and biology.

[149]  G S Zaric,et al.  Resource allocation for epidemic control over short time horizons. , 2001, Mathematical biosciences.

[150]  Otso Ovaskainen,et al.  The metapopulation capacity of a fragmented landscape , 2000, Nature.

[151]  Christopher A Gilligan,et al.  Optimizing the control of disease infestations at the landscape scale , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[152]  L. Wahl,et al.  Perspectives on the basic reproductive ratio , 2005, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[153]  Hanwu Liu,et al.  Stability of periodic solutions for an SIS model with pulse vaccination , 2003 .

[154]  J. Heesterbeek,et al.  The law of mass-action in epidemiology: a historical perspective , 2005 .

[155]  Shiwu Xiao,et al.  An SIRS model with a nonlinear incidence rate , 2007 .

[156]  Pejman Rohani,et al.  Seasonnally forced disease dynamics explored as switching between attractors , 2001 .

[157]  D. Lathrop Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos: With Applications to Physics, Biology, Chemistry, and Engineering , 2015 .

[158]  C. Mundt Durable resistance: a key to sustainable management of pathogens and pests. , 2014, Infection, genetics and evolution : journal of molecular epidemiology and evolutionary genetics in infectious diseases.