Variability in school closure decisions in response to 2009 H1N1: a qualitative systems improvement analysis

BackgroundSchool closure was employed as a non-pharmaceutical intervention against pandemic 2009 H1N1, particularly during the first wave. More than 700 schools in the United States were closed. However, closure decisions reflected significant variation in rationales, decision triggers, and authority for closure. This variability presents the opportunity for improved efficiency and decision-making.MethodsWe identified media reports relating to school closure as a response to 2009 H1N1 by monitoring high-profile sources and searching Lexis-Nexis and Google news alerts, and reviewed reports for key themes. News stories were supplemented by observing conference calls and meetings with health department and school officials, and by discussions with decision-makers and community members.ResultsThere was significant variation in the stated goal of closure decision, including limiting community spread of the virus, protecting particularly vulnerable students, and responding to staff shortages or student absenteeism. Because the goal of closure is relevant to its timing, nature, and duration, unclear rationales for closure can challenge its effectiveness. There was also significant variation in the decision-making authority to close schools in different jurisdictions, which, in some instances, was reflected in open disagreement between school and public health officials. Finally, decision-makers did not appear to expect the level of scientific uncertainty encountered early in the pandemic, and they often expressed significant frustration over changing CDC guidance.ConclusionsThe use of school closure as a public health response to epidemic disease can be improved by ensuring that officials clarify the goals of closure and tailor closure decisions to those goals. Additionally, authority to close schools should be clarified in advance, and decision-makers should expect to encounter uncertainty disease emergencies unfold and plan accordingly.

[1]  D. Swerdlow,et al.  Household Effects of School Closure during Pandemic (H1N1) 2009, Pennsylvania, USA , 2010, Emerging infectious diseases.

[2]  B. Altevogt,et al.  Research Priorities in Emergency Preparedness and Response for Public Health Systems: A Letter Report , 2008 .

[3]  Shawn T. Brown,et al.  Simulating school closure strategies to mitigate an influenza epidemic. , 2010, Journal of public health management and practice : JPHMP.

[4]  C. Macken,et al.  Mitigation strategies for pandemic influenza in the United States. , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[5]  B. Berkman.  Mitigating pandemic influenza: the ethics of implementing a school closure policy. , 2008, Journal of public health management and practice : JPHMP.

[6]  N. Ferguson,et al.  Closure of schools during an influenza pandemic , 2009, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[7]  M. Stoto,et al.  Local variation in public health preparedness: lessons from California. , 2004, Health affairs.

[8]  D. Cummings,et al.  Strategies for mitigating an influenza pandemic , 2006, Nature.

[9]  J. A. Navarro,et al.  Nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented by US cities during the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic. , 2007, JAMA.

[10]  Michael Seid,et al.  Using quality improvement methods to improve public health emergency preparedness: PREPARE for Pandemic Influenza. , 2008, Health affairs.

[11]  Howard Markel,et al.  Nonpharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918–1919 Influenza Pandemic , 2008 .

[12]  John S. Brownstein,et al.  Evidence-based tool for triggering school closures during influenza outbreaks, Japan. , 2009, Emerging infectious diseases.

[13]  L. Finelli,et al.  Emergence of a novel swine-origin influenza A (H1N1) virus in humans. , 2009, The New England journal of medicine.

[14]  Gabriel Chodick,et al.  INFLUENCE OF SCHOOL CLOSURE ON THE INCIDENCE OF VIRAL RESPIRATORY DISEASES AMONG CHILDREN AND ON HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION , 2004, The Pediatric infectious disease journal.

[15]  A. Hatzakis,et al.  School closure is currently the main strategy to mitigate influenza A(H1N1)v: a modeling study. , 2009, Euro surveillance : bulletin Europeen sur les maladies transmissibles = European communicable disease bulletin.

[16]  A. Kumar,et al.  Emergence of a Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus in Humans , 2010 .

[17]  K. Glass,et al.  How Much Would Closing Schools Reduce Transmission During an Influenza Pandemic? , 2007, Epidemiology.

[18]  James G Hodge,et al.  The legal landscape for school closures in response to pandemic flu or other public health threats. , 2009, Biosecurity and bioterrorism : biodefense strategy, practice, and science.

[19]  A. Nizam,et al.  Containing Pandemic Influenza at the Source , 2005, Science.

[20]  L. Finelli,et al.  Household Responses to School Closure Resulting from Outbreak of Influenza B, North Carolina , 2008, Emerging infectious diseases.

[21]  L. Curry.  The Future of the Public's Health in the 21st Century , 2005 .

[22]  Benjamin J. Cowling,et al.  School Closure and Mitigation of Pandemic (H1N1) 2009, Hong Kong , 2010, Emerging infectious diseases.

[23]  Joel C. Miller,et al.  Student Behavior during a School Closure Caused by Pandemic Influenza A/H1N1 , 2010, PloS one.

[24]  N. Lurie,et al.  Quality improvement in public health emergency preparedness. , 2007, Annual review of public health.

[25]  D M Berwick,et al.  A primer on leading the improvement of systems , 1996, BMJ.

[26]  C. Macken,et al.  Modeling targeted layered containment of an influenza pandemic in the United States , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[27]  M. Lipsitch,et al.  Public health interventions and epidemic intensity during the 1918 influenza pandemic , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[28]  Elizabeth M. Sloss,et al.  Learning from Experience: The Public Health Response to West Nile Virus, SARS, Monkeypox, and Hepatitis A Outbreaks in the United States , 2005 .

[29]  Joshua M. Epstein,et al.  Economic Cost and Health Care Workforce Effects of School Closures in the U.S. , 2009, PLoS Currents.

[30]  R. Vogt.  Evidence-based Tool for Triggering School Closures during Influenza Outbreaks , 2010, Emerging infectious diseases.