Data-Based Analysis of Winner-Loser Models of Hierarchy Formation in Animals

We review winner-loser models, the currently popular explanation for the occurrence of linear dominance hierarchies, via a three-part approach. (1) We isolate the two most significant components of the mathematical formulation of three of the most widely-cited models and rigorously evaluate the components’ predictions against data collected on hierarchy formation in groups of hens. (2) We evaluate the experimental support in the literature for the basic assumptions contained in winner-loser models. (3) We apply new techniques to the hen data to uncover several behavioral dynamics of hierarchy formation not previously described. The mathematical formulations of these models do not show satisfactory agreement with the hen data, and key model assumptions have either little or no conclusive support from experimental findings in the literature. In agreement with the latest experimental results concerning social cognition, the new behavioral dynamics of hierarchy formation discovered in the hen data suggest that members of groups are intensely aware both of their own interactions as well as interactions occurring among other members of their group. We suggest that more adequate models of hierarchy formation should be based upon behavioral dynamics that reflect more sophisticated levels of social cognition.

[1]  Richard C. Francis,et al.  Experiential Effects On Agonistic Behavior in the Paradise Fish, Macropodus Opercularis , 1983 .

[2]  H. Landau.  On dominance relations and the structure of animal societies: I. Effect of inherent characteristics , 1951 .

[3]  P. J. B. Slater,et al.  Individual differences and dominance hierarchies , 1986, Animal Behaviour.

[4]  M. D. Beecher,et al.  The role of unshared songs in singing interactions between neighbouring song sparrows , 2005, Animal Behaviour.

[5]  H. Drummond,et al.  Training siblings to be submissive losers: dominance between booby nestlings , 1992, Animal Behaviour.

[6]  J. Beaugrand,et al.  The role of individual differences in the formation of triadic dominance orders of male green swordtail fish (Xiphophorus helleri) , 1996, Behavioural Processes.

[7]  D. Kroodsma,et al.  Ecology and evolution of acoustic communication in birds , 1997 .

[8]  Guillermo Paz-y-Miño C,et al.  Pinyon jays use transitive inference to predict social dominance , 2004, Nature.

[9]  W. Jackson,et al.  Can Individual Differences in History of Dominance Explain the Development of Linear Dominance Hierarchies , 2010 .

[10]  Ivan D. Chase,et al.  Models of hierarchy formation in animal societies , 1974 .

[11]  J Atema,et al.  Chemical Communication in Social Behavior of a Fish, the Yellow Bullhead (Ictalurus natalis) , 1967, Science.

[12]  John Skvoretz,et al.  Social structure, networks, and E‐state structuralism models , 1996 .

[13]  J. Beaugrand,et al.  Coherent use of information by hens observing their former dominant defeating or being defeated by a stranger , 1996, Behavioural Processes.

[14]  William A. Roberts,et al.  Transitive Inference in Rats: A Test of the Spatial Coding Hypothesis , 1994 .

[15]  Michael J. Raleigh,et al.  Serotonergic mechanisms promote dominance acquisition in adult male vervet monkeys , 1991, Brain Research.

[16]  R A Johnstone,et al.  Eavesdropping and animal conflict , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[17]  R. Church,et al.  Time left: linear versus logarithmic subjective time. , 1981, Journal of experimental psychology. Animal behavior processes.

[18]  R. Huber,et al.  The formation and maintenance of crayfish hierarchies: behavioral and self-structuring properties , 2000, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[19]  Mike Mesterton-Gibbons,et al.  Social Eavesdropping: A Game-Theoretic Analysis , 2007, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[20]  A. Bond,et al.  Social complexity and transitive inference in corvids , 2003, Animal Behaviour.

[21]  E. Simmel,et al.  The relationship between dominance and leadership in a flock of ewes , 1980 .

[22]  C Cannings,et al.  Modelling dominance hierarchy formation as a multi-player game. , 1999, Journal of theoretical biology.

[23]  Patrick Doreian.  Actor network utilities and network evolution , 2006, Soc. Networks.

[24]  Akira Sasaki,et al.  Can transitive inference evolve in animals playing the hawk-dove game? , 2003, Journal of theoretical biology.

[25]  L. Keeling,et al.  Social discrimination and aggression by laying hens in large groups: from peck orders to social tolerance , 2003 .

[26]  P. K. McGregor.  Animal Communication Networks: Index , 2005 .

[27]  P. K. McGregor,et al.  Animal Communication Networks: Behaviours specific to communication networks , 2005 .

[28]  R. Sapolsky,et al.  Rank‐related differences in cardiovascular function among wild baboons: Role of sensitivity to glucocorticoids , 1994, American journal of primatology.

[29]  H. Drummond.  Dominance in Vertebrate Broods and Litters , 2006, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[30]  L. Murray,et al.  Determinants of Dominance in the Tree Lizard Urosaurus ornatus: the Relative Importance of Mass, Previous Experience and Coloration , 2010 .

[31]  J. Beacham.  The relative importance of body size and aggressive experience as determinants of dominance in pumpkinseed sunfish, Lepomis gibbosus , 1988, Animal Behaviour.

[32]  Ivan D. Chase,et al.  Two methods for quantifying the development of dominance hierarchies in large groups with applications to Harris' sparrows , 1987, Animal Behaviour.

[33]  R. C. Francis.  The interaction of genotype and experience in the dominance success of paradise fish (Macropodus opercularis) , 1987 .

[34]  E. Tibbetts.  Visual signals of individual identity in the wasp Polistes fuscatus , 2002, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[35]  Janice N. Steirn,et al.  Transitive inference in pigeons: Simplified procedures and a test of value transfer theory , 1995 .

[36]  J. Altmann,et al.  Long-Term Consistency of Dominance Relations Among Female Baboons (Papio cynocephalus) , 1982, Science.

[37]  Guy Theraulaz,et al.  Mathematical model of self-organizing hierarchies in animal societies , 1996 .

[38]  I. Chase,et al.  Aggressive interactions and inter-contest interval: how long do winners keep winning?. , 1994, Animal Behaviour.

[39]  M. Nelissen.  Structure of the Dominance Hierarchy and Dominance Determining "Group Factors" in Melanochromis Auratus (Pisces, Cichlidae) , 1985 .

[40]  I. Chase,et al.  Behavioral Sequences During Dominance Hierarchy Formation in Chickens , 1982, Science.

[41]  Ivan D. Chase,et al.  The sequential analysis of aggressive acts during hierarchy formation: an application of the ‘jigsaw puzzle’ approach , 1985, Animal Behaviour.

[42]  W. Jackson,et al.  Linearity in dominance hierarchies: a second look at the individual attributes model , 1988, Animal Behaviour.

[43]  J. Heinze,et al.  Individual Recognition in Ant Queens , 2005, Current Biology.

[44]  L. Ellis.  Dominance and reproductive success among nonhuman animals: A cross-species comparison , 1995 .

[45]  E. Wasserman,et al.  Transitive responding in hooded crows requires linearly ordered stimuli. , 2004, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[46]  D. Gillan.  Reasoning in the chimpanzee: II. Transitive inference. , 1981 .

[47]  Mark Broom,et al.  Modelling Dominance Hierarchy formation as a Multi-player game , 2002 .

[48]  J. Atema,et al.  Memory of Social Partners in Hermit Crab Dominance , 2005 .

[49]  Lee Alan Dugatkin,et al.  Individual recognition, dominance hierarchies and winner and loser effects , 2004, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[50]  I. Chase,et al.  Music notation: a new method for visualizing social interaction in animals and humans , 2006, Frontiers in Zoology.

[51]  Lee Alan Dugatkin,et al.  Winner and loser effects and the structure of dominance hierarchies , 1997 .

[52]  Peter K. McGregor,et al.  Know thine enemy: fighting fish gather information from observing conspecific interactions , 1998, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[53]  L. L. Wolf,et al.  The winner and loser effect: integrating multiple experiences , 1999, Animal Behaviour.

[54]  J. Heinze.  Dominance behavior among ant females , 2005, Naturwissenschaften.

[55]  W. Post.  Dominance and mating success in male boat-tailed grackles , 1992, Animal Behaviour.

[56]  R. Seyfarth,et al.  How Monkeys See the World: Inside the Mind of Another Species , 1990 .

[57]  J. Newman,et al.  Social experience and the formation of dominance relationships in the pumpkinseed sunfish, Lepomis gibbosus , 1987, Animal Behaviour.

[58]  P. Colgan,et al.  Individual and species recognition in centrarchid fishes: evidence and hypotheses , 1986, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[59]  J. Atema,et al.  Individual recognition and memory in lobster dominance , 1998, Animal Behaviour.

[60]  C. Drews.  THE CONCEPT AND DEFINITION OF DOMINANCE IN ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR , 1993 .

[61]  Jerram L. Brown,et al.  Social dominance in communal Mexican jays Aphelocoma ultramarina , 1986, Animal Behaviour.

[62]  J. Beacham.  Models of Dominance Hierarchy Formation: Effects of Prior Experience and Intrinsic Traits , 2003 .

[63]  R. Johnston,et al.  Recognition of Familiar Individuals in Golden Hamsters: A New Method and Functional Neuroanatomy , 2005, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[64]  Guy Theraulaz,et al.  Dominance orders in animal societies: The self-organization hypothesis revisited , 1999, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[65]  Lee Alan Dugatkin,et al.  Eavesdropping on visual cues in green swordtail (Xiphophorus helleri) fights: a case for networking , 2002, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[66]  ritch c. savin-williams.  Dominance hierarchies in groups of middle to late adolescent males , 1980, Journal of youth and adolescence.

[67]  T. Bakker,et al.  Determinants of Dominance in Male Sticklebacks (Gasterosteus Aculeatus L.) , 1983 .

[68]  T. Clutton‐Brock,et al.  Maternal dominance, breeding success and birth sex ratios in red deer , 1984, Nature.

[69]  Craig A. Tovey,et al.  Two's Company, Three's a Crowd: Differences in Dominance Relationships in Isolated Versus Socially Embedded Pairs of Fish , 2003 .

[70]  Craig Tovey,et al.  Individual differences versus social dynamics in the formation of animal dominance hierarchies , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[71]  J. Beaugrand,et al.  The role of individual differences and patterns of resolution in the formation of dominance orders in domestic hen triads , 1996, Behavioural Processes.

[72]  Rodger P. White,et al.  Discrimination of conspecifics by juvenile domestic pigs, Sus scrofa , 2005, Animal Behaviour.

[73]  T. Bakker,et al.  Asymmetrical Effects of Prior Winning and Losing on Dominance in Sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) , 2010 .

[74]  C. Hemelrijk.  An individual–orientated model of the emergence of despotic and egalitarian societies , 1999, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[75]  J. Staddon,et al.  Transitive inference formation in pigeons. , 1991 .

[76]  H. Drummond,et al.  Dominance between booby nestlings involves winner and loser effects , 1998, Animal Behaviour.

[77]  Charlotte K. Hemelrijk,et al.  Towards the integration of social dominance and spatial structure , 2000, Animal Behaviour.

[78]  H. Davis.  Transitive inference in rats (Rattus norvegicus). , 1992, Journal of comparative psychology.

[79]  E. Kravitz,et al.  Learning and memory associated with aggression in Drosophila melanogaster , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[80]  Lee Alan Dugatkin,et al.  Bystander effects and the structure of dominance hierarchies , 2001 .

[81]  Steven Skiena,et al.  Implementing discrete mathematics - combinatorics and graph theory with Mathematica , 1990 .

[82]  L. A. Carneiro,et al.  Watching fights raises fish hormone levels , 2001, Nature.

[83]  D. Frey,et al.  The Establishment of Dominance Relationships in the Blue Gourami, Trichogaster Trichopter Us (Pallas) , 1972 .

[84]  L. Dugatkin,et al.  Group fusion: the impact of winner, loser, and bystander effects on hierarchy formation in large groups , 2003 .