Tracing app technology: an ethical review in the COVID-19 era and directions for post-COVID-19

We conducted a systematic literature review on the ethical considerations of the use of contact tracing app technology, which was extensively implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic. The rapid and extensive use of this technology during the COVID-19 pandemic, while benefiting the public well-being by providing information about people's mobility and movements to control the spread of the virus, raised several ethical concerns for the post-COVID-19 era. To investigate these concerns for the post-pandemic situation and provide direction for future events, we analyzed the current ethical frameworks, research, and case studies about the ethical usage of tracing app technology. The results suggest there are seven essential ethical considerations, namely privacy, security, acceptability, government surveillance, transparency, justice, and voluntariness in the ethical use of contact tracing technology. In this paper, we explain and discuss these considerations and how they are needed for the ethical usage of this technology. The findings also highlight the importance of developing integrated guidelines and frameworks for implementation of such technology in the post-COVID-19 world.

[1]  Vedran Sekara,et al.  Digital Contact Tracing and Surveillance during COVID-19 , 2020 .

[2]  Gerhard Schewe,et al.  The Role of Transparency, Trust, and Social Influence on Uncertainty Reduction in Times of Pandemics: Empirical Study on the Adoption of COVID-19 Tracing Apps , 2020, Journal of medical Internet research.

[3]  C. Althaus,et al.  The role of the SwissCovid digital contact tracing app during the pandemic response: results for the Canton of Zurich , 2021, medRxiv.

[4]  Ezekiel J Emanuel,et al.  Fair Allocation of Scarce Medical Resources in the Time of Covid-19. , 2020, The New England journal of medicine.

[5]  Abdul Razzaq,et al.  Best Practice Guidance for Digital Contact Tracing Apps: A Cross-disciplinary Review of the Literature , 2021, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[6]  Daniel Schnurr,et al.  Incentivizing Data Donations and the Adoption of COVID-19 Contact-Tracing Apps: A Randomized Controlled Online Experiment on the German Corona-Warn-App , 2021 .

[7]  F. Alnajjar,et al.  Technology, Privacy, and User Opinions of COVID-19 Mobile Apps for Contact Tracing: Systematic Search and Content Analysis , 2021, Journal of Medical Internet Research.

[8]  T. Nakaya,et al.  Survey on usage and concerns of a COVID-19 contact tracing application in Japan , 2021, Public Health in Practice.

[9]  Urs Gasser,et al.  Digital tools against COVID-19: taxonomy, ethical challenges, and navigation aid , 2020, The Lancet Digital Health.

[10]  Stephanie B. Johnson,et al.  COVID-19 and Contact Tracing Apps: Ethical Challenges for a Social Experiment on a Global Scale , 2020, Journal of Bioethical Inquiry.

[11]  Danilo Doneda,et al.  Personal data usage and privacy considerations in the COVID-19 global pandemic. , 2020, Ciencia & saude coletiva.

[12]  L. White,et al.  Privacy versus Public Health? A Reassessment of Centralised and Decentralised Digital Contact Tracing , 2021, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[13]  Renate Klar,et al.  The ethics of COVID-19 tracking apps – challenges and voluntariness , 2020 .

[14]  Abdul Razzaq,et al.  A national survey of attitudes to COVID-19 digital contact tracing in the Republic of Ireland , 2020, Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -).

[15]  Steffen Staab,et al.  Bias in data‐driven artificial intelligence systems—An introductory survey , 2020, WIREs Data Mining Knowl. Discov..

[16]  R. Vinuesa,et al.  COVIDTAS COVID-19 Tracing App Scale—An Evaluation Framework , 2021, Sustainability.

[17]  Z. Zhang,et al.  Information technology solutions, challenges, and suggestions for tackling the COVID-19 pandemic , 2020, International Journal of Information Management.

[18]  G. Pandey,et al.  Technological and analytical review of contact tracing apps for COVID-19 management , 2021, J. Locat. Based Serv..

[19]  T. Velavan,et al.  The COVID‐19 epidemic , 2020, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[20]  Mark.,et al.  The ethical imperatives of the COVID-19 pandemic: A review from data ethics , 2020 .

[21]  The World After Coronavirus , 2020, Post-COVID Asia.

[22]  M. Mello,et al.  Ethics and governance for digital disease surveillance , 2020, Science.

[23]  Banita Lal,et al.  Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on information management research and practice: Transforming education, work and life , 2020, Int. J. Inf. Manag..

[24]  Nscc.  Racism and Discrimination , 2019 .

[25]  Ayoung Suh,et al.  Digital Tracing during the COVID-19 Pandemic: User Appraisal, Emotion, and Continuance Intention , 2021, Sustainability.

[26]  M. Mbwogge.  Mass Testing With Contact Tracing Compared to Test and Trace for the Effective Suppression of COVID-19 in the United Kingdom: Systematic Review , 2021, JMIRx med.

[27]  Tamar Sharon,et al.  Blind-sided by privacy? Digital contact tracing, the Apple/Google API and big tech’s newfound role as global health policy makers , 2020, Ethics and Information Technology.

[28]  Christoph U. Lehmann,et al.  Ethics and informatics in the age of COVID-19: challenges and recommendations for public health organization and public policy , 2020, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[29]  Young Ern Saw,et al.  Predicting Public Uptake of Digital Contact Tracing During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Results From a Nationwide Survey in Singapore (Preprint) , 2020 .

[30]  N. Smoll,et al.  The barriers and enablers to downloading the COVIDSafe app – a topic modelling analysis , 2021, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health.

[31]  Stephan Lewandowsky,et al.  Public acceptance of privacy-encroaching policies to address the COVID-19 pandemic in the United Kingdom , 2021, PloS one.

[32]  Thomas N. Friemel,et al.  A Typology-Based Approach to Tracing-App Adoption During the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Case of the SwissCovid App , 2021, Journal of Quantitative Description: Digital Media.

[33]  M. Hernán,et al.  A population-based controlled experiment assessing the epidemiological impact of digital contact tracing , 2021, Nature communications.

[34]  Ida Sim,et al.  Ethical Framework for Assessing Manual and Digital Contact Tracing for COVID-19 , 2020, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[35]  E. Vayena,et al.  Digital contact-tracing during the Covid-19 pandemic: An analysis of newspaper coverage in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland , 2020, medRxiv.

[36]  Karem H Alzoubi,et al.  COVID-19 Contact-Tracing Technology: Acceptability and Ethical Issues of Use , 2020, Patient preference and adherence.

[37]  Ethics in the COVID-19 pandemic: myths, false dilemmas, and moral overload , 2021, Ethics and information technology.

[38]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[39]  Terence Lee,et al.  Tracing surveillance and auto-regulation in Singapore: ‘smart’ responses to COVID-19 , 2020, Media International Australia.

[40]  J. Henderson.  Patient privacy in the COVID-19 era: Data access, transparency, rights, regulation and the case for retaining the status quo , 2020, Health information management : journal of the Health Information Management Association of Australia.

[41]  Hyunghoon Cho,et al.  Contact Tracing Mobile Apps for COVID-19: Privacy Considerations and Related Trade-offs , 2020, ArXiv.

[42]  Iniobong Ekong,et al.  COVID-19 Mobile Positioning Data Contact Tracing and Patient Privacy Regulations: Exploratory Search of Global Response Strategies and the Use of Digital Tools in Nigeria , 2020, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[43]  David Leslie,et al.  Tackling COVID-19 through Responsible AI Innovation: Five Steps in the Right Direction , 2020, Harvard Data Science Review.

[44]  Yann Sweeney.  Tracking the debate on COVID-19 surveillance tools , 2020, Nat. Mach. Intell..

[45]  Improvement of Contact Tracing with Citizen’s Distributed Risk Maps , 2021, Entropy.

[47]  Frantz Rowe,et al.  Contact tracing apps and values dilemmas: A privacy paradox in a neo-liberal world , 2020, International Journal of Information Management.

[48]  M. Puhan,et al.  Drivers of Acceptance of COVID-19 Proximity Tracing Apps in Switzerland: Panel Survey Analysis , 2020, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[49]  Andrew Tzer-Yeu Chen,et al.  Exploring the drivers and barriers to uptake for digital contact tracing , 2021, Social Sciences & Humanities Open.

[50]  Helge Janicke,et al.  A Survey of COVID-19 Contact Tracing Apps , 2020, IEEE Access.

[51]  Andrew Urbaczewski,et al.  Information Technology and the pandemic: a preliminary multinational analysis of the impact of mobile tracking technology on the COVID-19 contagion control , 2020, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[52]  M. Cho,et al.  Digital Contact Tracing, Privacy, and Public Health , 2020, The Hastings Center report.

[53]  Delan Devakumar,et al.  Racism and discrimination in COVID-19 responses , 2020, The Lancet.

[54]  V. Wild,et al.  Pandemic Surveillance and Racialized Subpopulations: Mitigating Vulnerabilities in COVID-19 Apps , 2020, Journal of Bioethical Inquiry.

[55]  Michael J Parker,et al.  Ethics of instantaneous contact tracing using mobile phone apps in the control of the COVID-19 pandemic , 2020, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[56]  S. McLennan,et al.  Early Perceptions of COVID-19 Contact Tracing Apps in German-Speaking Countries: Comparative Mixed Methods Study , 2021, Journal of medical Internet research.

[57]  Jun Yao,et al.  To disclose or to falsify: The effects of cognitive trust and affective trust on customer cooperation in contact tracing , 2021, International journal of hospitality management.

[58]  A. Kurup,et al.  The experience of contact tracing in Singapore in the control of COVID-19: highlighting the use of digital technology , 2020, International Orthopaedics.

[59]  P. Varalakshmi,et al.  A Survey on Security and Privacy Issues in Contact Tracing Application of Covid-19 , 2021, SN Comput. Sci..

[60]  John Batani,et al.  COVID-19 Digital Vaccination Certificates and Digital Technologies: Lessons from Digital Contact Tracing Apps , 2021, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[61]  C. Heneghan,et al.  Assessment of physiological signs associated with COVID-19 measured using wearable devices , 2020, npj Digital Medicine.

[62]  Sacha Alanoca,et al.  Digital contact tracing against COVID-19: a governance framework to build trust , 2021, International Data Privacy Law.

[63]  C. Pagliari.  The ethics and value of contact tracing apps: International insights and implications for Scotland’s COVID-19 response , 2020, Journal of global health.

[64]  Yogesh K. Dwivedi,et al.  Digital Health Innovation: Exploring Adoption of COVID-19 Digital Contact Tracing Apps , 2020, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management.

[65]  Alex Dubov,et al.  The Value and Ethics of Using Technology to Contain the COVID-19 Epidemic , 2020, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[66]  T. Mackey,et al.  Test, Trace, and Put on the Blockchain?: A Viewpoint Evaluating the Use of Decentralized Systems for Algorithmic Contact Tracing to Combat a Global Pandemic , 2020, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[67]  Peter J. F. Lucas,et al.  The thorny problems of COVID-19 Contact Tracing Apps: The need for a holistic approach , 2020 .

[68]  S. Fonn,et al.  South Africa's COVID-19 Tracing Database: Risks and rewards of which doctors should be aware. , 2020, South African medical journal = Suid-Afrikaanse tydskrif vir geneeskunde.

[69]  T. Callender,et al.  Automated and partly automated contact tracing: a systematic review to inform the control of COVID-19 , 2020, The Lancet Digital Health.

[70]  Seumas Miller,et al.  Ethics, public health and technology responses to COVID‐19 , 2021, Bioethics.

[71]  S. Basu.  Effective Contact Tracing for COVID-19 Using Mobile Phones: An Ethical Analysis of the Mandatory Use of the Aarogya Setu Application in India , 2020, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.

[72]  D. Durrheim,et al.  A dangerous measles future looms beyond the COVID-19 pandemic , 2021, Nature Medicine.

[73]  E. Kelly,et al.  Establishing prison-led contact tracing to prevent outbreaks of COVID-19 in prisons in Ireland , 2020, Journal of public health.

[74]  Alena Buyx,et al.  Digital contact tracing and exposure notification: ethical guidance for trustworthy pandemic management , 2020, Ethics and information technology.

[75]  David Leslie.  Tackling COVID-19 through Responsible AI Innovation: Five Steps in the Right Direction , 2020, Harvard Data Science Review.

[76]  Deborah Bunker,et al.  Who do you trust? The digital destruction of shared situational awareness and the COVID-19 infodemic , 2020, International Journal of Information Management.

[77]  H. Duijf,et al.  Ethics of digital contact tracing and COVID-19: who is (not) free to go? , 2020, Ethics and Information Technology.

[78]  Marcello Ienca,et al.  Digital tools against COVID-19: Framing the ethical challenges and how to address them , 2020, ArXiv.

[79]  S. McLennan,et al.  COVID-19 contact tracing apps: UK public perceptions , 2021, Critical public health.

[80]  Mariarosaria Taddeo,et al.  Ethical guidelines for COVID-19 tracing apps , 2020, Nature.

[81]  Keng Siau,et al.  Building Trust in Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, and Robotics , 2018 .

[82]  Airo Hino,et al.  COVID-19, digital privacy, and the social limits on data-focused public health responses , 2020, International Journal of Information Management.

[83]  N. Kawakami,et al.  The Effects of Downloading a Government-Issued COVID-19 Contact Tracing App on Psychological Distress During the Pandemic Among Employed Adults: Prospective Study , 2020, JMIR mental health.

[84]  L. White,et al.  Without a trace: Why did corona apps fail? , 2021, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[85]  Elliot Mbunge,et al.  Integrating emerging technologies into COVID-19 contact tracing: Opportunities, challenges and pitfalls , 2020, Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome: Clinical Research & Reviews.

[86]  K. Kolasa,et al.  State of the Art in Adoption of Contact Tracing Apps and Recommendations Regarding Privacy Protection and Public Health: Systematic Review , 2021, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[87]  Sheikh Mohammad Idrees,et al.  Blockchain-Based Digital Contact Tracing Apps for COVID-19 Pandemic Management: Issues, Challenges, Solutions, and Future Directions , 2020, JMIR medical informatics.

[88]  A. Mostafavi,et al.  Empathic Design in Engineering Education and Practice: An Approach for Achieving Inclusive and Effective Community Resilience , 2021, Sustainability.