Telehealth exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Objective Despite proven effectiveness, participation in traditional supervised exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (exCR) remains low. Telehealth interventions that use information and communication technologies to enable remote exCR programme delivery can overcome common access barriers while preserving clinical supervision and individualised exercise prescription. This meta-analysis aimed to determine the benefits of telehealth exCR on exercise capacity and other modifiable cardiovascular risk factors compared with traditional exCR and usual care, among patients with coronary heart disease (CHD). Methods CINAHL, The Cochrane Library, Embase, MEDLINE, PubMed and PsycINFO were searched from inception through 31 May 2015 for randomised controlled trials comparing telehealth exCR with centre-based exCR or usual care among patients with CHD. Outcomes included maximal aerobic exercise capacity, modifiable cardiovascular risk factors and exercise adherence. Results 11 trials (n=1189) met eligibility criteria and were included in the review. Physical activity level was higher following telehealth exCR than after usual care. Compared with centre-based exCR, telehealth exCR was more effective for enhancing physical activity level, exercise adherence, diastolic blood pressure and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol. Telehealth and centre-based exCR were comparably effective for improving maximal aerobic exercise capacity and other modifiable cardiovascular risk factors. Conclusions Telehealth exCR appears to be at least as effective as centre-based exCR for improving modifiable cardiovascular risk factors and functional capacity, and could enhance exCR utilisation by providing additional options for patients who cannot attend centre-based exCR. Telehealth exCR must now capitalise on technological advances to provide more comprehensive, responsive and interactive interventions.

[1]  D. M. Servantes,et al.  How much do the benefits cost? Effects of a home-based training programme on cardiovascular fitness, quality of life, programme cost and adherence for patients with coronary disease , 2008, Clinical rehabilitation.

[2]  Rod S Taylor,et al.  Home-based cardiac rehabilitation compared with centre-based rehabilitation and usual care: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2006, International journal of cardiology.

[3]  J. Higgins Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration , 2011 .

[4]  Dominique Hansen,et al.  Increasing the medium-term clinical benefits of hospital-based cardiac rehabilitation by physical activity telemonitoring in coronary artery disease patients , 2015, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[5]  Nigel Lever,et al.  Measurement and Data Transmission Validity of a Multi-Biosensor System for Real-Time Remote Exercise Monitoring Among Cardiac Patients , 2015, JMIR rehabilitation and assistive technologies.

[6]  R. McKelvie,et al.  Differences in sustainability of exercise and health-related quality of life outcomes following home or hospital-based cardiac rehabilitation , 2004, European journal of cardiovascular prevention and rehabilitation : official journal of the European Society of Cardiology, Working Groups on Epidemiology & Prevention and Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology.

[7]  C. Del Mar,et al.  Exercise for overweight or obesity. , 2006, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[8]  Tiny Jaarsma,et al.  Compliance in heart failure patients: the importance of knowledge and beliefs. , 2006, European heart journal.

[9]  R. Arena,et al.  Cardiovascular fitness and mortality after contemporary cardiac rehabilitation. , 2013, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[10]  K. Jolly,et al.  Home based versus centre based cardiac rehabilitation: Cochrane systematic review and meta-analysis , 2010, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[11]  H. Dalal,et al.  Cardiac rehabilitation in the United Kingdom , 2008, Heart.

[12]  C. Worringham,et al.  Development and Feasibility of a Smartphone, ECG and GPS Based System for Remotely Monitoring Exercise in Cardiac Rehabilitation , 2011, PloS one.

[13]  Vera Bittner,et al.  Core components of cardiac rehabilitation/secondary prevention programs: 2007 update: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association Exercise, Cardiac Rehabilitation, and Prevention Committee, the Council on Clinical Cardiology; the Councils on Cardiovascular Nursing, Epidemiology and Pr , 2007, Circulation.

[14]  R. McKelvie,et al.  Six-year follow-up of a randomised controlled trial examining hospital versus home-based exercise training after coronary artery bypass graft surgery , 2011, Heart.

[15]  P. Doherty,et al.  BACPR scientific statement: British standards and core components for cardiovascular disease prevention and rehabilitation , 2013, Heart.

[16]  Julie Redfern,et al.  Participating in cardiac rehabilitation: a systematic review and meta-synthesis of qualitative data , 2012, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[17]  F. McAlister,et al.  A meta-analysis of randomized control trials of home-based secondary prevention programs for coronary artery disease , 2010, European journal of cardiovascular prevention and rehabilitation : official journal of the European Society of Cardiology, Working Groups on Epidemiology & Prevention and Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology.

[18]  A R Jadad,et al.  What contributions do languages other than English make on the results of meta-analyses? , 2000, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[19]  Joanna Bates,et al.  Utilization of the internet to deliver cardiac rehabilitation at a distance: a pilot study. , 2007, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[20]  H. Bethell,et al.  The rise and fall of cardiac rehabilitation in the United Kingdom since 1998. , 2007, Journal of public health.

[21]  A J Mourant,et al.  Home-based versus hospital-based rehabilitation after myocardial infarction: A randomized trial with preference arms--Cornwall Heart Attack Rehabilitation Management Study (CHARMS). , 2007, International journal of cardiology.

[22]  A. Rolleston,et al.  The remote exercise monitoring trial for exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (REMOTE-CR): a randomised controlled trial protocol , 2014, BMC Public Health.

[23]  L. Bosquet,et al.  Telephone support oriented by accelerometric measurements enhances adherence to physical activity recommendations in noncompliant patients after a cardiac rehabilitation program. , 2012, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[24]  Lisa Hartling,et al.  Meta-Analysis: Secondary Prevention Programs for Patients with Coronary Artery Disease , 2005, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[25]  Wei Liu,et al.  Telehealth interventions versus center-based cardiac rehabilitation of coronary artery disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis , 2015, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[26]  Paul Dendale,et al.  A review of telerehabilitation for cardiac patients , 2015, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[27]  G. Hillis,et al.  Design and rationale of the tobacco, exercise and diet messages (TEXT ME) trial of a text message-based intervention for ongoing prevention of cardiovascular disease in people with coronary disease: a randomised controlled trial protocol , 2012, BMJ Open.

[28]  Adrian Bauman,et al.  Telehealth interventions for the secondary prevention of coronary heart disease: a systematic review , 2009, European journal of cardiovascular prevention and rehabilitation : official journal of the European Society of Cardiology, Working Groups on Epidemiology & Prevention and Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology.

[29]  J. Korewicki,et al.  A new model of home‐based telemonitored cardiac rehabilitation in patients with heart failure: effectiveness, quality of life, and adherence , 2010, European journal of heart failure.

[30]  S. Ebrahim,et al.  Exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation for coronary heart disease. , 2016, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[31]  S. Ebrahim,et al.  Exercise-based rehabilitation for patients with coronary heart disease: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. , 2004, The American journal of medicine.

[32]  Rosy Tirimacco,et al.  Alternative models of cardiac rehabilitation: A systematic review , 2015, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[33]  Sharon-Lise T Normand,et al.  Use of Cardiac Rehabilitation by Medicare Beneficiaries After Myocardial Infarction or Coronary Bypass Surgery , 2007, Circulation.

[34]  C. Lavie,et al.  Cardiac rehabilitation and exercise training in secondary coronary heart disease prevention. , 2011, Progress in cardiovascular diseases.

[35]  C. Worringham,et al.  Exercise-Based Cardiac Rehabilitation for the 21st Century , 2013, Current Cardiovascular Risk Reports.

[36]  Mary A. Dolansky,et al.  Predictors of women's exercise maintenance after cardiac rehabilitation. , 2003, Journal of cardiopulmonary rehabilitation.

[37]  Tiffany Moxham,et al.  Home-based versus centre-based cardiac rehabilitation. , 2010, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[38]  B. Franklin,et al.  Effectiveness of three models for comprehensive cardiovascular disease risk reduction. , 2002, The American journal of cardiology.

[39]  David R Thompson,et al.  Exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation for coronary heart disease. , 2016, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[40]  J. Harvey-Berino,et al.  High-Calorie-Expenditure Exercise: A New Approach to Cardiac Rehabilitation for Overweight Coronary Patients , 2009, Circulation.

[41]  Niels Peek,et al.  Effects of home-based training with telemonitoring guidance in low to moderate risk patients entering cardiac rehabilitation: short-term results of the FIT@Home study , 2014, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[42]  J. Chan,et al.  Body mass index, waist circumference and waist:hip ratio as predictors of cardiovascular risk—a review of the literature , 2010, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.

[43]  G A Naughton,et al.  Exercise for type 2 diabetes mellitus. , 2006, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[44]  Ralph Maddison,et al.  A mobile phone intervention increases physical activity in people with cardiovascular disease: Results from the HEART randomized controlled trial , 2015, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[45]  I. Piña,et al.  Core Components of Cardiac Rehabilitation/Secondary Prevention Programs: Statement for Healthcare Professionals From the American Heart Association and the American Association of Cardiovascular and Pulmonary Rehabilitation , 2000 .

[46]  Marlien Varnfield,et al.  Smartphone-based home care model improved use of cardiac rehabilitation in postmyocardial infarction patients: results from a randomised controlled trial , 2014, Heart.

[47]  E. Piotrowicz,et al.  Cardiac telerehabilitation: current situation and future challenges , 2013, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[48]  P. Vandervoort,et al.  Telerehab III: a multi-center randomized, controlled trial investigating the long-term effectiveness of a comprehensive cardiac telerehabilitation program - Rationale and study design , 2015, BMC Cardiovascular Disorders.

[49]  Young-Hwa Lee,et al.  Impact of Home-Based Exercise Training with Wireless Monitoring on Patients with Acute Coronary Syndrome Undergoing Percutaneous Coronary Intervention , 2013, Journal of Korean medical science.

[50]  R. Taylor,et al.  Home-based versus centre-based cardiac rehabilitation. , 2017, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[51]  Chris Blanchard,et al.  Randomized trial of an internet-based computer-tailored expert system for physical activity in patients with heart disease , 2012, European journal of preventive cardiology.

[52]  David R Thompson,et al.  Home versus hospital-based cardiac rehabilitation: a systematic review. , 2011, Rural and remote health.