OBJECTIVE
To determine the effect of the use of abbreviations and acronyms on citation retrieval in MEDLINE searches.
METHODS
Twenty common medical abbreviations that retrieved a minimum of 400 citations each in MEDLINE text word searches were studied. Each abbreviation was entered in a MEDLINE subject search to determine whether it mapped to an appropriate medical subject heading (MeSH) term. The MeSH category and the number of citations retrieved were recorded. The abbreviation and its definition were each entered in separate text word searches, and the number of citations retrieved was recorded. Sets were combined to determine the number of identical and unique citations retrieved in the searches.
RESULTS
MEDLINE recognized all 20 abbreviations and mapped them to appropriate MeSH headings. MeSH term assignment, however, may be case- and space-sensitive. MeSH term searches retrieved more citations than text word searches for 18 of 20 abbreviations. Comparison of the document sets yielded by each search method revealed a subset of citations common to each. Although all sets retrieved showed overlap, no two were identical. In addition, each citation set contained a proportion of unique documents.
CONCLUSION
Retrieval of all unique citations required three searches; subject with abbreviation, text word with abbreviation, and text word with definition. These results have important implications for MEDLINE users.
[1]
D Fitzgerald,et al.
How good are clinical MEDLINE searches? A comparative study of clinical end-user and librarian searches.
,
1990,
Computers and biomedical research, an international journal.
[2]
F. Davidoff,et al.
Uniform requirements for manuscripts submitted to biomedical journals. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors.
,
1997,
Annals of Internal Medicine.
[3]
H. Lowe,et al.
Understanding and using the medical subject headings (MeSH) vocabulary to perform literature searches.
,
1994,
JAMA.
[4]
B M Wildemuth,et al.
End-user search behaviors and their relationship to search effectiveness.
,
1995,
Bulletin of the Medical Library Association.
[5]
Frequency of Uncommon Abbreviations in Medical Journals
,
1995,
Southern medical journal.
[6]
M F Earl,et al.
Library instruction in the medical school curriculum: a survey of medical college libraries.
,
1996,
Bulletin of the Medical Library Association.