Assessing the patterns and controls of fine root dynamics: an empirical test and methodological review

1 Elucidation of the patterns and controls of forest net primary production at ecosystem scales has been hindered by a poor understanding of fine root production, due largely to technical limitations. 2 Fine root (≤ 0.5 mm diameter) production was assessed using minirhizotron, soil core, ingrowth core, nitrogen budget and carbon budget techniques in three longleaf pine‐wiregrass forest ecosystem types (hydric, mesic and xeric) forming an edaphic resource availability and above‐ground productivity gradient. 3 Fine root production estimates differed substantially in magnitude, e.g. values ranged from 0 to 4618 kg ha−1 year−1 for the soil core and minirhizotron techniques, respectively, in the hydric site. 4 Minirhizotron production estimates in the hydric, mesic and xeric sites were 4618, 1905 and 2295 kg ha−1 year−1, respectively. 5 Soil core and ingrowth core root production estimates were on average 81 and 54% lower, respectively, than corresponding minirhizotron production estimates, and minirhizotron estimates were negatively related to soil core and ingrowth core estimates across the resource gradient. 6 The N budget method yielded unreliable root production estimates, presumably due to the underestimation of N availability for plant assimilation. 7 C budget estimates of total below‐ground C allocation (6773, 5646 and 4647 kg C ha−1 year−1) were positively related to minirhizotron production estimates, but negatively related to soil core and ingrowth core production estimates. 8 Critical evaluations of the assumptions, potential errors and results for each method suggest that the minirhizotron technique yielded the most reliable root production estimates, and that the negative relationship between minirhizotron and core‐based estimates may be attributed to the inherent deficiency of the core techniques in assessing root production when mortality and production occur simultaneously. 9 Minirhizotron root production estimates were positively related to foliage production estimates, supporting the hypothesis of constant proportional allocation of production to foliage, wood and fine roots across resource availability gradients in temperate forests. 10 These results suggest that fine root production is not negatively correlated with soil resource availability and foliage production as is commonly perceived in the ecological community and represented in ecosystem computer models.

[1]  H. J. Praag,et al.  Root turnover in a beech and a spruce stand of the Belgian Ardennes , 1988, Plant and Soil.

[2]  A. Fitter.  Darkness visible: reflections on underground ecology , 2005 .

[3]  K. Pregitzer,et al.  Applications of minirhizotrons to understand root function in forests and other natural ecosystems , 1996, Plant and Soil.

[4]  D. Raynal,et al.  Fine root growth phenology, production, and turnover in a northern hardwood forest ecosystem , 1994, Plant and Soil.

[5]  Robert J. Mitchell,et al.  Fine root branch orders respond differentially to carbon source-sink manipulations in a longleaf pine forest , 2004, Oecologia.

[6]  H. Takeda,et al.  Above- and belowground biomass and net primary production in a cool-temperate deciduous forest in relation to topographical changes in soil nitrogen , 2004 .

[7]  J. Schimel,et al.  NITROGEN MINERALIZATION: CHALLENGES OF A CHANGING PARADIGM , 2004 .

[8]  L. Donovan,et al.  Fine root production and turnover across a complex edaphic gradient of a Pinus palustris–Aristida stricta savanna ecosystem , 2004 .

[9]  D. Hertel,et al.  A comparison of four different fine root production estimates with ecosystem carbon balance data in a Fagus–Quercus mixed forest , 2002, Plant and Soil.

[10]  H. Helmisaari,et al.  Assessing fine-root biomass and production in a Scots pine stand – comparison of soil core and root ingrowth core methods , 1999, Plant and Soil.

[11]  R. Hendrick,et al.  Fine root length production, mortality and standing root crop dynamics in an intensively managed sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua L.) coppice , 1998, Plant and Soil.

[12]  J. Bloomfield,et al.  Analysis of some direct and indirect methods for estimating root biomass and production of forests at an ecosystem level , 1998, Plant and Soil.

[13]  J. Aber,et al.  Fine root turnover in forest ecosystems in relation to quantity and form of nitrogen availability: a comparison of two methods , 1985, Oecologia.

[14]  Peter B Reich,et al.  The impact of material used for minirhizotron tubes for root research. , 2003, The New phytologist.

[15]  Susan E. Trumbore,et al.  The Secret Lives of Roots , 2003, Science.

[16]  R. Ruess,et al.  Coupling fine root dynamics with ecosystem carbon cycling in black spruce forests of interior Alaska , 2003 .

[17]  R. Ruess,et al.  Substituting root numbers for length: Improving the use of minirhizotrons to study fine root dynamics , 2003 .

[18]  J. Hiers,et al.  Legumes native to longleaf pine savannas exhibit capacity for high N2 -fixation rates and negligible impacts due to timing of fire. , 2003, The New phytologist.

[19]  R. Mitchell,et al.  Rapid fine root disappearance in a pine woodland: a substantial carbon flux , 2002 .

[20]  H. Persson,et al.  Fine-root response to nitrogen supply in nitrogen manipulated Norway spruce catchment areas , 2002 .

[21]  M. G. Ryan,et al.  Total Belowground Carbon Allocation in a Fast-growing Eucalyptus Plantation Estimated Using a Carbon Balance Approach , 2002, Ecosystems.

[22]  L. Boring,et al.  Foliar litter position and decomposition in a fire-maintained longleaf pine wiregrass ecosystem , 2002 .

[23]  H. L. Allen,et al.  Below-ground carbon input to soil is controlled by nutrient availability and fine root dynamics in loblolly pine. , 2002, The New phytologist.

[24]  R. Mitchell,et al.  Soil nitrogen dynamics in a fire-maintained forest ecosystem: results over a 3-year burn interval , 2002 .

[25]  Michael F. Allen,et al.  FINE ROOT ARCHITECTURE OF NINE NORTH AMERICAN TREES , 2002 .

[26]  T. Fahey,et al.  Fine root turnover in a northern hardwood forest: a direct comparison of the radiocarbon and minirhizotron methods , 2002 .

[27]  L. Donovan,et al.  Fine root demography and morphology in response to soil resources availability among xeric and mesic sandhill tree species , 2002 .

[28]  J. Klopatek.  Belowground carbon pools and processes in different age stands of Douglas-fir. , 2002, Tree physiology.

[29]  James M. Vose,et al.  Quantitative comparison of in situ soil CO 2 flux measurement methods , 2002 .

[30]  Christina E. Wells,et al.  Changes in the risk of fine-root mortality with age: a case study in peach, Prunus persica (Rosaceae). , 2002, American journal of botany.

[31]  M. Drew,et al.  Productivity and species richness across an environmental gradient in a fire-dependent ecosystem. , 2001, American journal of botany.

[32]  E. Bååth,et al.  Estimation of the biomass and seasonal growth of external mycelium of ectomycorrhizal fungi in the field. , 2001, The New phytologist.

[33]  N. McDowell,et al.  Belowground carbon allocation of Rocky Mountain Douglas-fir , 2001 .

[34]  D. Phillips,et al.  Advancing fine root research with minirhizotrons. , 2001, Environmental and experimental botany.

[35]  K. Nadelhoffer.  The potential effects of nitrogen deposition on fine-root production in forest ecosystems , 2000 .

[36]  R. B. Jackson,et al.  Root dynamics and global change : seeking an ecosystem perspective , 2000 .

[37]  F. I. Woodward,et al.  The representation of root processes in models addressing the responses of vegetation to global change , 2000 .

[38]  Petteri Vanninen,et al.  Estimation of fine root mortality and growth from simple measurements: a method based on system dynamics , 2000, Trees.

[39]  W. Lauenroth.  Methods of Estimating Belowground Net Primary Production , 2000 .

[40]  J. Aber,et al.  Nitrogen Controls on Fine Root Substrate Quality in Temperate Forest Ecosystems , 2000, Ecosystems.

[41]  H. Ilvesniemi,et al.  Carbon storage of microbes and roots and the flux of CO2 across a moisture gradient , 1999 .

[42]  Stephen D. Pecot,et al.  Patterns and controls of ecosystem function in longleaf pine - wiregrass savannas. I. Aboveground net primary productivity , 1999 .

[43]  R. Mitchell,et al.  Patterns and controls of ecosystem function in longleaf pine — wiregrass savannas. II. Nitrogen dynamics , 1999 .

[44]  R. Rytter.  Fine-root Production and Turnover in a Willow Plantation Estimated by Different Calculation Methods , 1999 .

[45]  L. Boring,et al.  N2-fixation by native herbaceous legumes in burned pine ecosystems of the southeastern United States , 1999 .

[46]  G. Robertson,et al.  Standard soil methods for long-term ecological research , 1999 .

[47]  C. Bledsoe,et al.  Fine root production and demography , 1999 .

[48]  J. Devereux Joslin,et al.  Disturbances During Minirhizotron Installation Can Affect Root Observation Data , 1999 .

[49]  H. L. Allen,et al.  Leaf Area and Above- and Belowground Growth Responses of Loblolly Pine to Nutrient and Water Additions , 1998, Forest Science.

[50]  K. Pregitzer,et al.  Integration of Ecophysiological and Biogeochemical Approaches to Ecosystem Dynamics , 1998 .

[51]  J. Aber,et al.  A 15N tracer technique for assessing fine root production and mortality , 1997, Oecologia.

[52]  John M. Norman,et al.  Root mass, net primary production and turnover in aspen, jack pine and black spruce forests in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, Canada. , 1997, Tree physiology.

[53]  S. Gower,et al.  A global trend in belowground carbon allocation: Can we use the relationship at smaller scales? , 1996 .

[54]  R. Littell.  SAS System for Mixed Models , 1996 .

[55]  S. Gower,et al.  Belowground carbon allocation in unfertilized and fertilized red pine plantations in northern Wisconsin. , 1995, Tree physiology.

[56]  P. Curtis,et al.  Atmospheric CO2, soil nitrogen and turnover of fine roots , 1995 .

[57]  O. Andrén,et al.  Fine-root production and mortality in degraded vegetation in horqin sandy rangeland in Inner Mongolia, China , 1995 .

[58]  J. Landers,et al.  The Longleaf Pine Forests of the Southeast: Requiem or Renaissance? , 1995, Journal of Forestry.

[59]  Bernard T. Bormann,et al.  Biases of Chamber Methods for Measuring Soil CO2 Efflux Demonstrated with a Laboratory Apparatus , 1994 .

[60]  K. Pregitzer,et al.  The dynamics of fine root length, biomass, and nitrogen content in two northern hardwood ecosystems , 1993 .

[61]  K. Pregitzer,et al.  The demography of fine roots in response to patches of water and nitrogen. , 1993, The New phytologist.

[62]  K. Vogt,et al.  A comparison of methods for estimating forest fine root production with respect to sources of error , 1993 .

[63]  J. Aber,et al.  Assessing the role of fine roots in carbon and nutrient cycling. , 1993, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[64]  Christopher Neill,et al.  Comparison of Soil Coring and Ingrowth Methods for Measuring Belowground Production , 1992 .

[65]  K. Nadelhoffer,et al.  Fine Root Production Estimates and Belowground Carbon Allocation in Forest Ecosystems , 1992 .

[66]  Kurt S. Pregitzer,et al.  THE DEMOGRAPHY OF FINE ROOTS IN A NORTHERN HARDWOOD FOREST , 1992 .

[67]  R. Smith,et al.  Ecology and Field Biology, 4th edn. , 1992 .

[68]  S. Gower,et al.  CARBON DYNAMICS OF ROCKY MOUNTAIN DOUGLAS-FIR: INFLUENCE OF WATER AND NUTRIENT AVAILABILITY' , 1992 .

[69]  W. Cropper,et al.  Carbohydrate dynamics in mature Pinuselliottii var. elliottii trees , 1991 .

[70]  Paul J. Curran,et al.  Dynamics of Canopy Structure and Light Interception in Pinus Elliottii Stands, North Florida , 1991 .

[71]  Knute J. Nadelhoffer,et al.  Belowground Carbon Allocation in Forest Ecosystems: Global Trends , 1989 .

[72]  F. Day,et al.  Evaluation of Two Methods for Estimating Belowground Production in a Freshwater Swamp Forest , 1988 .

[73]  M. Caldwell,et al.  Seasonal Timing of Root Growth in Favorable Microsites , 1988 .

[74]  J. P. Kimmins,et al.  Analysis of some sources of error in methods used to determine fine root production in forest ecosystems: a simulation approach , 1987 .

[75]  G. Henderson,et al.  Organic Matter and Nutrients Associated with Fine Root Turnover in a White Oak Stand , 1987, Forest Science.

[76]  Henry L. Gholz,et al.  Soil CO2 evolution in Florida slash pine plantations. II: Importance of root respiration , 1987 .

[77]  W. Cropper,et al.  Organic matter dynamics of fine roots in plantations of slash pine (Pinuselliottii) in north Florida , 1986 .

[78]  J. Aber,et al.  Fine Roots, Net Primary Production, and Soil Nitrogen Availability: A New Hypothesis , 1985 .

[79]  R. Fisher,et al.  Nutrient Dynamics in Slash Pine Plantation Ecosystems , 1985 .

[80]  R. K. Hermann,et al.  Standing crop, production, and turnover of fine roots on dry, moderate, and wet sites of mature Douglas-fir in western Oregon , 1985 .

[81]  H. W. Hunt,et al.  Bias and Random Errors in Estimators of Net Root Production: A Simulation Approach , 1984 .

[82]  K. Vogt,et al.  Organic Matter and Nutrient Dynamics in Forest Floors of Young and Mature Abies amabilis Stands in Western Washington, as Affected by Fine‐Root Input , 1983 .

[83]  J. Aber,et al.  The Role of Fine Roots in the Organic Matter and Nitrogen Budgets of Two Forested Ecosystems , 1982 .

[84]  F. Day,et al.  Litter nutrient content and production in the Great Dismal Swamp [Virginia, tree communities]. , 1982 .

[85]  D. Santantonio.  Production and turnover of fine roots of mature Douglas-fir in relation to site , 1982 .

[86]  K. Vogt,et al.  Mycorrhizal Role in Net Primary Priduction and Nutrient Cytcling in Abies Amabilis Ecosystems in Western Washington , 1982 .

[87]  C. C. Grier,et al.  Above- and below-ground net production in 40-year-old Douglas-fir stands on low and high productivity sites , 1981 .

[88]  R. Smith,et al.  Ecology and Field Biology , 1966 .