Reassessment of the C-13/C-12 and C-14/C-12 isotopic fractionation ratio and its impact on high-precision radiocarbon dating

Abstract The vast majority of radiocarbon measurement results (14C/12C isotopic ratios or sample activities) are corrected for isotopic fractionation processes (measured as 13C/12C isotopic ratios) that occur in nature, in sample preparation and measurement. In 1954 Harmon Craig suggested a value of 2.0 for the fractionation ratio b that is used to correct 14C/12C ratios for shifts in the 13C/12C ratios and this value has been applied by the radiocarbon community ever since. While theoretical considerations suggest moderate deviations of b from 2.0, some measurements have suggested larger differences (e.g. b = 2.3, measured by Saliege and Fontes in 1984). With the high precision attained in radiocarbon measurements today (±2‰), even a relatively small deviation of b from 2.0 can impact the accuracy of radiocarbon data, and it is, therefore, of interest to re-evaluate the fractionation corrections. In the present study, the fractionation ratio b was determined by independent experiments on the chemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) to elemental carbon (graphitization reaction) and on the photosynthetic uptake of CO2 by C3 and C4 plants. The results yielded b = 1.882 ± 0.019 for the reduction of CO2 to solid graphite and b = 1.953 ± 0.025 for the weighted mean of measurements involving C3 and C4 photosynthesis pathways. In addition, the analysis of over 9600 full-sized OX-I and OX-II normalizing standards measured between 2002 and 2012 confirms b values lower than 2.0. The obtained values are in good agreement with quantum mechanical estimates of the equilibrium fractionation and classic kinetic fractionation as well as with results from other light three-isotope systems (oxygen, magnesium, silicon and sulfur). While the value of the fractionation ratio varies with the relative importance of kinetic and equilibrium fractionation, the values obtained in the present study cluster around b = 1.9. Our findings suggest that a significant fraction of all samples (“unknowns”) would be shifted by 2‰ (16 radiocarbon years) or more due to this effect: for example, for b = 1.882, between 16.8% and 25.9% of almost 60,000 radiocarbon values measured at the Keck Carbon Cycle AMS facility between 2002 and 2012 would be affected. The implications for radiocarbon dating and its accuracy are discussed.

[1]  C. Hinshelwood,et al.  The intramolecular isotope effect in the pyrolysis of 1–14C propane , 1956, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences.

[2]  P. E. Yankwich,et al.  C$sup 14$ AND C$sup 13$ INTRAMOLECULAR ISOTOPE EFFECTS IN THE DECARBOXYLATION OF LIQUID MALONIC ACID AT 140.5 , 1954 .

[3]  J. van der Plicht,et al.  Reporting 14C Activities and Concentrations , 1999, Radiocarbon.

[4]  P. Vogel,et al.  Relative 14C–13C Kinetic Isotope Effects , 1971 .

[5]  P. Richet,et al.  A Review of Hydrogen, Carbon, Nitrogen, Oxygen, Sulphur, and Chlorine Stable Isotope Fractionation Among Gaseous Molecules , 1977 .

[6]  I. Rodushkin,et al.  Chromatographic purification for the determination of dissolved silicon isotopic compositions in natural waters by high-resolution multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. , 2006, Analytical chemistry.

[7]  H. Craig.  Isotopic standards for carbon and oxygen and correction factors for mass-spectrometric analysis of carbon dioxide , 1957 .

[8]  D. Fleitmann,et al.  A coupled δ13C-radiocarbon investigation of cave and soil processes recorded by three European speleothems during the Late Glacial and early Holocene , 2011 .

[9]  W. H. Stevens,et al.  Relative Isotope Effects of C13 and C14 , 1952 .

[10]  M. Stuiver,et al.  Discussion: Reporting of 14 C Data , 1977 .

[11]  G. E. Dunn,et al.  ISOTOPE EFFECTS IN THE COMBUSTION OF CARBON MONOXIDE , 1954 .

[12]  B. Kromer,et al.  The Influence of Soil Organic Matter Age Spectrum on the Reconstruction of Atmospheric 14C Levels Via Stalagmites , 2010, Radiocarbon.

[13]  Harro A. J. Meijer,et al.  The use of electrolysis for accurate delta O-17 and delta O-18 isotope measurements in water , 1998 .

[14]  M. Calvin,et al.  The Isotope Effect in the Decomposition of Oxalic Acid , 1952 .

[15]  Xiaomei Xu,et al.  Modifying a sealed tube zinc reduction method for preparation of AMS graphite targets: Reducing background and attaining high precision , 2007 .

[16]  J. Bigeleisen,et al.  Calculation of Equilibrium Constants for Isotopic Exchange Reactions , 1947 .

[17]  H. Meijer,et al.  Biogenic Carbon Fraction of Biogas and Natural Gas Fuel Mixtures Determined with 14C , 2014, Radiocarbon.

[18]  Alan D. Martin,et al.  Review of Particle Physics , 2014, 1412.1408.

[19]  J. Southon,et al.  AMS 14C Sample Preparation at the KCCAMS/UCI Facility: Status Report and Performance of Small Samples , 2007, Radiocarbon.

[20]  The Carbon Isotope Effect in the Acid Hydrolysis of Urea , 1953 .

[21]  C. Collins,et al.  Natural variations in the isotopic content of sulphur and their significance. , 1949, Canadian journal of research.

[22]  G. B. Gibbs,et al.  Scale stresses during protective and breakaway corrosion of iron and rimming steel in CO2 , 1973 .

[23]  J. Southon.  Are the Fractionation Corrections Correct: Are the Isotopic Shifts for 14C/12C Ratios in Physical Processes and Chemical Reactions Really Twice Those for 13C/12C? , 2011, Radiocarbon.

[24]  C. D. L. Rocha,et al.  Measurement of silicon stable isotope natural abundances via multicollector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC‐ICP‐MS) , 2002 .

[25]  D. Rumble,et al.  Preparation of SF6 for sulfur isotope analysis by laser heating sulfide minerals in the presence of F2 gas , 1993 .

[26]  Caffee,et al.  Primordial noble gases from Earth's mantle: identification of a primitive volatile component , 1999, Science.

[27]  J. Bigeleisen.  The Effects of Isotopic Substitution on the rates of Chemical Reactions , 1952 .

[28]  M. Stuiver,et al.  University of Washington Geosecs North Atlantic carbon-14 results , 1974 .

[29]  J. Fontes,et al.  Essai de détermination expérimentale du fractionnement des isotopes 13C et 14C du carbone au cours de processus naturels , 1984 .

[30]  Q. Hua,et al.  Using the 14C Bomb Pulse to Date Young Speleothems , 2011, Radiocarbon.

[31]  H. Craig.  Carbon 13 in Plants and the Relationships between Carbon 13 and Carbon 14 Variations in Nature , 1954, The Journal of Geology.

[32]  E. Hewitt,et al.  Plant mineral nutrition. , 1974 .

[33]  M. O'Leary,et al.  Carbon Isotopes in PhotosynthesisFractionation techniques may reveal new aspects of carbon dynamics in plants , 1988 .

[34]  D. Donahue,et al.  Isotope-Ratio and Background Corrections for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry Radiocarbon Measurements , 1990, Radiocarbon.

[35]  C. Pillinger,et al.  High precision δ17O isotope measurements of oxygen from silicates and other oxides: method and applications , 1999 .

[36]  A. Galy,et al.  High-precision measurement of magnesium isotopes by multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry , 2001 .

[37]  J. Southon,et al.  Catalyst and binder effects in the use of filamentous graphite for AMS , 1987 .

[38]  Donald E. Canfield,et al.  Multiple sulphur isotopic interpretations of biosynthetic pathways: implications for biological signatures in the sulphur isotope record , 2003 .

[39]  J. Southon,et al.  Magnesium Perchlorate as an Alternative Water Trap in AMS Graphite Sample Preparation: A Report On Sample Preparation at Kccams at the University of California, Irvine , 2004, Radiocarbon.

[40]  W. Kutschera,et al.  Pushing the Precision Limit of 14C AMS , 2004, Radiocarbon.

[41]  J. Schwieters,et al.  Determination of silicon isotope ratios in silicate materials by high-resolution MC-ICP-MS using a sodium hydroxide sample digestion method , 2006 .

[42]  P. R. Bevington,et al.  Data Reduction and Error Analysis for the Physical Sciences , 1969 .

[43]  P. E. Yankwich,et al.  Intramolecular Isotope Effects in the Decarboxylation of Malonic Acid , 1952 .

[44]  M. F. Miller.  Isotopic fractionation and the quantification of 17O anomalies in the oxygen three-isotope system: an appraisal and geochemical significance , 2002 .

[45]  A. Galy,et al.  Kinetic and equilibrium mass-dependent isotope fractionation laws in nature and their geochemical and cosmochemical significance , 2002 .

[46]  J. Berry,et al.  Photosynthetic Fractionation of the Stable Isotopes of Oxygen and Carbon , 1993, Plant physiology.

[47]  R. B. Georg,et al.  Re-assessment of silicon isotope reference materials using high-resolution multi-collector ICP-MS , 2006 .

[48]  I. Olsson.  Modern aspects of radiocarbon datings , 1968 .

[49]  A. Chédin,et al.  Critical analysis of the series expansion of the potential energy function of CO2 , 1975 .

[50]  C. D. Wagner,et al.  Isotope Effect in the Thermal Cracking of Propane−1‐C13 , 1948 .

[51]  H. Synal,et al.  Improving a gas ion source for 14C AMS , 2013 .

[52]  P. E. Yankwich,et al.  CARBON ISOTOPE EFFECTS IN THE DECARBOXYLATION OF MALONIC ACID AND BROMOMALONIC ACID , 1952 .

[53]  J. van der Plicht,et al.  High-Accuracy 14C Measurements for Atmospheric CO2 Samples by AMS , 2006, Radiocarbon.

[54]  D L BUCHANAN,et al.  Carbon isotope effects in biological systems. , 1953, Science.

[55]  E. Scott,et al.  The IAEA 14C Intercomparison Exercise 1990 , 1992 .

[56]  D. Fleitmann,et al.  The coupled δ13C-radiocarbon systematics of three Late Glacial/early Holocene speleothems; insights into soil and cave processes at climatic transitions , 2011 .

[57]  T. Wigley,et al.  Fractionation corrections in radiocarbon dating. , 1981 .

[58]  J. Bigeleisen,et al.  Application of Finite Orthogonal Polynomials to the Thermal Functions of Harmonic Oscillators. I. Reduced Partition Function of Isotopic Molecules , 1968 .

[59]  Philip L. Walker,et al.  Carbon Mixture over Iron Catalysts. II. Rates of Carbon Formation , 1959 .

[60]  Glenn A. Jones,et al.  Illumination of a Black Box: Analysis of Gas Composition During Graphite Target Preparation , 1992, Radiocarbon.

[61]  A. Brown,et al.  THE RELATIVE RATES OF PHOTOSYNTHETIC ASSIMILATION OF ISOTOPIC FORMS OF CARBON DIOXIDE. , 1952, Plant physiology.

[62]  J. Southon,et al.  Performance of catalytically condensed carbon for use in accelerator mass spectrometry , 1984 .