Luria–Delbrück, revisited: the classic experiment does not rule out Lamarckian evolution

We re-examined data from the classic Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiment, which is often credited with establishing a Darwinian basis for evolution. We argue that, for the Lamarckian model of evolution to be ruled out by the experiment, the experiment must favor pure Darwinian evolution over both the Lamarckian model and a model that allows both Darwinian and Lamarckian mechanisms (as would happen for bacteria with CRISPR-Cas immunity). Analysis of the combined model was not performed in the original 1943 paper. The Luria-Delbrück paper also did not consider the possibility of neither model fitting the experiment. Using Bayesian model selection, we find that the Luria-Delbrück experiment, indeed, favors the Darwinian evolution over purely Lamarckian. However, our analysis does not rule out the combined model, and hence cannot rule out Lamarckian contributions to the evolutionary dynamics.

[1]  J. L. Gould,et al.  The Quarterly Review of Biology , 2005, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[2]  R. Punnett,et al.  The journal of genetics , 1910, Zeitschrift für Induktive Abstammungs- und Vererbungslehre.

[3]  G. Jaeger,et al.  On the distribution of bacterial mutants: The effects of differential fitness of mutants and non-mutants , 1995, Genetica.

[4]  J. Lederberg,et al.  REPLICA PLATING AND INDIRECT SELECTION OF BACTERIAL MUTANTS , 1952, Journal of bacteriology.

[5]  H. Newcombe.  Origin of Bacterial Variants , 1949, Nature.

[6]  Yuhong Yang,et al.  Information Theory, Inference, and Learning Algorithms , 2005 .

[7]  P. Barber,et al.  Mutation Research/Fundamental and Molecular Mechanisms of Mutagenesis , 2009 .

[8]  B. Bainbridge,et al.  Genetics , 1981, Experientia.

[9]  W P Angerer,et al.  An explicit representation of the Luria–Delbrück distribution , 2001, Journal of mathematical biology.

[10]  V. Braun,et al.  Functional Interaction of the tonA/tonB Receptor System in Escherichia coli , 1978, Journal of bacteriology.

[11]  C. A. Coulson,et al.  The distribution of the numbers of mutants in bacterial populations , 1949, Journal of Genetics.

[12]  A. L. Taylor.  BACTERIOPHAGE-INDUCED MUTATION IN ESCHERICHIA COLI. , 1963, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[13]  E. Jablonka,et al.  The Changing Concept of Epigenetics , 2002, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[14]  A. L. Koch.  Mutation and growth rates from Luria-Delbrück fluctuation tests , 1982 .

[15]  Qi Zheng.  On Haldane's formulation of Luria and Delbrück's mutation model. , 2007, Mathematical biosciences.

[16]  S. Sarkar,et al.  On fluctuation analysis: a new, simple and efficient method for computing the expected number of mutants , 2004, Genetica.

[17]  F. M. Stewart,et al.  Fluctuation analysis: the probability distribution of the number of mutants under different conditions. , 1990, Genetics.

[18]  S. Sarkar,et al.  Haldane's solution of the Luria-Delbrück distribution. , 1991, Genetics.

[19]  M. Delbrück,et al.  Mutations of Bacteria from Virus Sensitivity to Virus Resistance. , 1943, Genetics.

[20]  E. Koonin,et al.  Is evolution Darwinian or/and Lamarckian? , 2009, Biology Direct.

[21]  Sahotra Sarkar,et al.  Analysis of the Luria–Delbrück distribution using discrete convolution powers , 1992, Journal of Applied Probability.

[22]  Robert W Sobol,et al.  Mutation research/fundamental and molecular mechanisms of mutagenesis: special issue: DNA repair and genetic instability. , 2013, Mutation research.

[23]  M. E. Jones,et al.  Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiments: design and analysis. , 1994, Genetics.

[24]  M. S. Bartlett,et al.  An introduction to stochastic processes, with special reference to methods and applications , 1955 .

[25]  Eugene V. Koonin,et al.  Just how Lamarckian is CRISPR-Cas immunity: the continuum of evolvability mechanisms , 2016, Biology Direct.

[26]  L. Christophorou.  Science , 2018, Emerging Dynamics: Science, Energy, Society and Values.

[27]  F. M. Stewart.  Fluctuation analysis: the effect of plating efficiency , 2004, Genetica.

[28]  David J. C. MacKay,et al.  Bayesian Interpolation , 1992, Neural Computation.

[29]  M. V. Rossum,et al.  In Neural Computation , 2022 .

[30]  Avinash Bhandoola,et al.  Biology Direct , 2006 .

[31]  P. Mitage,et al.  The Statistical Theory of Bacterial Populations subject to Mutation. , 1952 .

[32]  David J. C. MacKay,et al.  Information Theory, Inference, and Learning Algorithms , 2004, IEEE Transactions on Information Theory.

[33]  Henry E. Kyburg,et al.  Chance , 1976, J. Philos. Log..

[34]  P. Armitage,et al.  The Statistical Theory of Bacterial Populations Subject to Mutation , 1952 .

[35]  Philip C Nelson.  Physical Models of Living Systems , 2014 .

[36]  Eva Jablonka,et al.  Transgenerational Epigenetic Inheritance: Prevalence, Mechanisms, and Implications for the Study of Heredity and Evolution , 2009, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[37]  Q Zheng,et al.  Progress of a half century in the study of the Luria-Delbrück distribution. , 1999, Mathematical biosciences.

[38]  R. Barrangou,et al.  CRISPR Provides Acquired Resistance Against Viruses in Prokaryotes , 2007, Science.

[39]  Bernard Ycart,et al.  Fluctuation Analysis: Can Estimates Be Trusted? , 2013, PloS one.