The present series of studies explores the relationship between two conceptions of self-esteem: the self as experienced by the individual and the self as presented to others. Traditional measures of self-esteem are employed, and two new methods of assessing self-esteem in adolescents are introduced: an observational measure of self-esteem behavior (presented self) and a repeated self-report measure (experienced self). The presented self (observed behavior and peer ratings) and the experienced self (Rosenberg, Lerner, and a new method, paging devices) measures were consistent within themselves in assessing self-esteem. The presented self and the experienced self were not, however, significantly related to each other. We propose a moderator variable (“defensiveness”) to explain these discrepancies, and suggest that the observation of adolescent behavior provides a more accurate assessment of self-esteem than self-report measures.
[1]
R. Savin-Williams,et al.
Dominance Hierarchies in Groups of Early Adolescents.
,
1979
.
[2]
Richard A. Shweder,et al.
Rethinking Culture and Personality Theory Part II: A Critical Examination of Two More Classical Postulates
,
1979
.
[3]
M. Rosenberg,et al.
Self-esteem and delinquency
,
1978,
Journal of youth and adolescence.
[4]
M. Csíkszentmihályi,et al.
The ecology of adolescent activity and experience
,
1977,
Journal of youth and adolescence.
[5]
W. Mischel.
On the future of personality measurement.
,
1977
.
[6]
R. Ziller.
The alienation syndrome: a triadic pattern of self-other orientation.
,
1969,
Sociometry.