Implicit recognition in pure alexia: The Saffran effect—a tale of two systems or two procedures?

Abstract Some patients with pure alexia or letter-by-letter reading demonstrate the Saffran effect: residual activation of higher order lexical-semantic representations despite poor word recognition. This study investigated the reading of patient FD, a letter-by-letter reader with a clear Saffran effect. Two alternative explanations for this effect were tested in a series of experiments and through the impact of whole-word and letter-based therapies on FD's reading. One theory assumes that the disparity between overt recognition and implicit activation of word meaning is underpinned by two separate reading systems. An alternative hypothesis argues for a single whole-word reading system supplemented by the deliberate, compensatory strategy of letter-by-letter reading. Under this hypothesis, the Saffran effect reflects partial activation of the single, whole-word system. FD's results strongly supported the latter hypothesis. FD's reading behaviour was characterised by partial activation of higher word representations, accuracy was graded by word variables known to influence the normal reading system, and most importantly, once the characteristics of the tasks were equated, there was no evidence for a dissociation between word categorisation and recognition. In addition, the whole-word therapy encouraged FD to abandon the letter-by-letter strategy. Without this compensatory technique, FD's emergent deep dyslexia was consistent with a partially activated, whole-word reading system that produces overt reading responses. Comparison of data from this and other studies suggests that the Saffran effect is most likely to be observed in patients with severe pure alexia.

[1]  K Patterson,et al.  Letter-by-letter reading: psychological descriptions of a neurological syndrome. , 1995, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[2]  M. Coltheart SEVEN QUESTIONS ABOUT PURE ALEXIA (LETTER-BY-LETTER READING). , 1998, Cognitive neuropsychology.

[3]  Jonathan J. Evans,et al.  Error-free Learning in the Rehabilitation of People with Memory Impairments , 1996 .

[4]  James L. McClelland,et al.  No Right to Speak? The Relationship between Object Naming and Semantic Impairment:Neuropsychological Evidence and a Computational Model , 2001, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[5]  M. L. Lambon Ralph,et al.  The application of errorless learning to aphasic disorders: A review of theory and practice , 2003, Neuropsychological rehabilitation.

[6]  James L. McClelland,et al.  An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: I. An account of basic findings. , 1981 .

[7]  H. Coslett,et al.  IMPLICIT VS. LETTER-BY-LETTER READING IN PURE ALEXIA: A TALE OF TWO SYSTEMS. , 1998, Cognitive neuropsychology.

[8]  H. Coslett,et al.  Evidence for preserved reading in 'pure alexia'. , 1989, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[9]  L. Caplan Cuing and memory dysfunction in alexia without agraphia. A case report , 2000 .

[10]  A. Kreindler,et al.  A CASE OF `PURE' WORD BLINDNESS , 1961, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[11]  Max Coltheart,et al.  Deep Dyslexia Is Right-Hemisphere Reading , 2000, Brain and Language.

[12]  Max Coltheart,et al.  Psycholinguistic assessments of language processing in aphasia (PALPA) , 1996 .

[13]  T. Shallice,et al.  Deep Dyslexia: A Case Study of , 1993 .

[14]  L. Rapport,et al.  Validation of the Warrington theory of visual processing and the Visual Object and Space Perception Battery. , 1998, Journal of clinical and experimental neuropsychology.

[15]  D. Plaut,et al.  A LITERATURE REVIEW AND NEW DATA SUPPORTING AN INTERACTIVE ACCOUNT OF LETTER-BY-LETTER READING. , 1998, Cognitive neuropsychology.

[16]  H. Branch Coslett,et al.  Reading in pure alexiaThe effect of strategy , 1993 .

[17]  Patricia A. Reuter-Lorenz,et al.  A prelexical basis for letter-by-letter reading: A case study , 1990 .

[18]  Elizabeth K. Warrington Pat McKenna Lisa Orpwood Single Word Comprehension: A Concrete and Abstract Word Synonym Test , 1998 .

[19]  H. Coslett,et al.  Preserved object recognition and reading comprehension in optic aphasia. , 1989, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[20]  M. Behrmann,et al.  Visual complexity in letter-by-letter reading: Pure alexia is not pure , 1998, Neuropsychologia.

[21]  M. L. Ralph,et al.  Using errorless learning to treat letter-by-letter reading: Contrasting word versus letter-based therapy , 2005, Neuropsychological rehabilitation.

[22]  Iconic reading in a case of alexia without agraphia caused by a brain tumor: A tachistoscopic study , 1980, Brain and Language.

[23]  James L. McClelland,et al.  An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: part 1.: an account of basic findings , 1988 .

[24]  Martha J. Farah Pure alexia as a visual impairment: A reconsideration , 1995 .

[25]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  A Functional Neuroimaging Description of Two Deep Dyslexic Patients , 1998, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[26]  A. Damasio,et al.  The anatomic basis of pure alexia , 1983, Neurology.

[27]  A Yamadori,et al.  Comprehension in alexia. , 1973, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[28]  Karalyn Patterson,et al.  Letter-by-letter Reading: Psychological Descriptions of a Neurologial Syndrome , 1982 .

[29]  E. Kaplan,et al.  The Boston naming test , 2001 .

[30]  M. Coltheart Right-hemisphere reading , 1981, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[31]  A. Ellis,et al.  "Patterns of Paralexia" Revisited: Report of a Case of Visual Dyslexia , 1997 .

[32]  H. Coslett,et al.  Reading with the Right-Hemisphere: Evidence from Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation , 1994, Brain and Language.

[33]  D. Plaut Double dissociation without modularity: evidence from connectionist neuropsychology. , 1995, Journal of clinical and experimental neuropsychology.

[34]  Marlene Behrmann,et al.  Notice Warning concerning Copyright Restrictions Cognitive Neuropsychology Pure Alexia and Covert Reading: Evidence from Stroop Tasks Pure Alexia and Covert Reading: Evidence from Stroop Tasks , 2022 .

[35]  Tim Shallice,et al.  Lexical processing in the absence of explicit word identification: Evidence from a letter-by-letter reader , 1986 .

[36]  H B Coslett,et al.  Reading in pure alexia. The effect of strategy. , 1993, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[37]  L. Buxbaum,et al.  Deep Dyslexic Phenomena in a Letter-by-Letter Reader , 1996, Brain and Language.