High-dimensional Switches and the Modeling of Cellular Differentiation 2.2 Mathematical Models

Many genes have been identified as driving cellular differentiation, but because of their complex interactions, the understanding of their collective behaviour requires mathematical modelling. Intriguingly, it has been observed in numerous developmental contexts, and particularly haematopoiesis, that genes regulating differentiation are initially co-expressed in progenitors despite their antagonism, before one is upregulated and others downregulated. We characterise conditions under which three classes of generic "master regulatory networks", modelled at the molecular level after experimentally observed interactions (including bHLH protein dimerisation), and including an arbitrary number of antagonistic components, can behave as a "multi-switch", directing differentiation in an all-or-none fashion to a specific cell-type chosen among more than two possible outcomes. bHLH dimerisation networks can readily display coexistence of many antagonistic factors when competition is low (a simple characterisation is derived). Decision-making can be forced by a transient increase in competition, which could correspond to some unexplained experimental observations related to Id proteins; the speed of response varies with the initial conditions the network is subjected to, which could explain some aspects of cell behaviour upon reprogramming. The coexistence of antagonistic factors at low levels, early in the differentiation process or in pluripotent stem cells, could be an intrinsic property of the interaction between those factors, not requiring a specific regulatory system.

[1]  D. Tenen,et al.  Octamer Binding Factors and Their Coactivator Can Activate the Murine PU.1 (spi-1) Promoter* , 1996, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[2]  S. Cory Immunology: Wavering on commitment , 1999, Nature.

[3]  H. Blau,et al.  Plasticity of the differentiated state. , 1985, Science.

[4]  I. Weissman,et al.  A clonogenic common myeloid progenitor that gives rise to all myeloid lineages , 2000, Nature.

[5]  M. Greaves,et al.  Multilineage gene expression precedes commitment in the hemopoietic system. , 1997, Genes & development.

[6]  J. Wozney,et al.  Bone morphogenetic protein 2 transiently enhances expression of a gene, Id (inhibitor of differentiation), encoding a helix-loop-helix molecule in osteoblast-like cells. , 1993, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[7]  A. Ghysen,et al.  Deconstructing cell determination: proneural genes and neuronal identity , 1999, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[8]  C. Bever,et al.  Hematopoietic progenitors express neural genes , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[9]  K. Akashi,et al.  Hematopoietic stem cells expressing the myeloid lysozyme gene retain long-term, multilineage repopulation potential. , 2003, Immunity.

[10]  J. Demongeot,et al.  Positive and negative feedback: striking a balance between necessary antagonists. , 2002, Journal of theoretical biology.

[11]  Y. Jan,et al.  Neuronal type information encoded in the basic-helix-loop-helix domain of proneural genes. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[12]  A. Lassar,et al.  Inhibition of Myogenic bHLH and MEF2 Transcription Factors by the bHLH Protein Twist , 1996, Science.

[13]  E. Querfurth,et al.  GATA-1 interacts with the myeloid PU.1 transcription factor and represses PU.1-dependent transcription. , 2000, Blood.

[14]  V. Reuter,et al.  ID gene expression varies with lineage during differentiation of pluripotential male germ cell tumor cell lines , 2001, Cell and Tissue Research.

[15]  M. Weiss,et al.  Immunofluorescence analysis of the time-course of extinction, reexpression, and activation of albumin production in rat hepatoma- mouse fibroblast heterokaryons and hybrids , 1981, The Journal of cell biology.

[16]  Kevin Eggan,et al.  Mice cloned from olfactory sensory neurons , 2004, Nature.

[17]  J. Gouzé Positive and Negative Circuits in Dynamical Systems , 1998 .

[18]  Min Ye,et al.  Myeloid or lymphoid promiscuity as a critical step in hematopoietic lineage commitment. , 2002, Developmental cell.

[19]  T. Enver,et al.  The lineage commitment of haemopoietic progenitor cells. , 1997, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[20]  Ertugrul M. Ozbudak,et al.  Multistability in the lactose utilization network of Escherichia coli , 2004, Nature.

[21]  T. Jessell,et al.  Control of Interneuron Fate in the Developing Spinal Cord by the Progenitor Homeodomain Protein Dbx1 , 2001, Neuron.

[22]  S. Orkin,et al.  A "knockdown" mutation created by cis-element gene targeting reveals the dependence of erythroid cell maturation on the level of transcription factor GATA-1. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[23]  F. Wardle,et al.  Refinement of gene expression patterns in the early Xenopus embryo , 2004, Development.

[24]  C. Soulé Graphic Requirements for Multistationarity , 2004, Complexus.

[25]  D. Krause,et al.  Toward a new paradigm of cell plasticity , 2002, Leukemia.

[26]  J. Norton,et al.  Id Proteins Negatively Regulate Basic Helix-Loop-Helix Transcription Factor Function by Disrupting Subnuclear Compartmentalization* , 2003, Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[27]  René Thomas On the Relation Between the Logical Structure of Systems and Their Ability to Generate Multiple Steady States or Sustained Oscillations , 1981 .

[28]  J. Visvader,et al.  GATA‐1 but not SCL induces megakaryocytic differentiation in an early myeloid line. , 1992, The EMBO journal.

[29]  T. Kaletta,et al.  Binary specification of the embryonic lineage in Caenorhabditis elegans , 1997, Nature.

[30]  J. Posakony,et al.  extramacrochaetae, a negative regulator of sensory organ development in Drosophila, defines a new class of helix-loop-helix proteins , 1990, Cell.

[31]  N. Sonenberg,et al.  Translational control of gene expression , 2000 .

[32]  J D Norton,et al.  ID helix-loop-helix proteins in cell growth, differentiation and tumorigenesis. , 2000, Journal of cell science.

[33]  C. Bunce,et al.  The development of cell lineages: a sequential model. , 1988, Differentiation; research in biological diversity.

[34]  M. Levine,et al.  hairy mediates dominant repression in the Drosophila embryo , 1997, The EMBO journal.

[35]  R. Lin,et al.  POP-1 and Anterior–Posterior Fate Decisions in C. elegans Embryos , 1998, Cell.

[36]  F R Adler,et al.  How to make a biological switch. , 2000, Journal of theoretical biology.

[37]  F. Sablitzky,et al.  Id helix-loop-helix proteins in cell growth and differentiation. , 1998, Trends in cell biology.

[38]  R. Shigemoto,et al.  Two mammalian helix-loop-helix factors structurally related to Drosophila hairy and Enhancer of split. , 1992, Genes & development.

[39]  E. Rothenberg,et al.  Transcriptional regulation of lymphocyte lineage commitment , 1999, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[40]  D. Melton,et al.  Single-cell transcript analysis of pancreas development. , 2003, Developmental cell.

[41]  P. Ebert,et al.  Crossinhibitory Activities of Ngn1 and Math1 Allow Specification of Distinct Dorsal Interneurons , 2001, Neuron.

[42]  Harold Weintraub,et al.  The MyoD family and myogenesis: Redundancy, networks, and thresholds , 1993, Cell.

[43]  Paul W. Sternberg,et al.  The combined action of two intercellular signaling pathways specifies three cell fates during vulval induction in C. elegans , 1989, Cell.

[44]  D. Tenen,et al.  Function of PU.1 (Spi-1), C/EBP, and AML1 in early myelopoiesis: regulation of multiple myeloid CSF receptor promoters. , 1996, Current topics in microbiology and immunology.

[45]  C. Murre,et al.  Helix-Loop-Helix Proteins: Regulators of Transcription in Eucaryotic Organisms , 2000, Molecular and Cellular Biology.

[46]  J. Gurdon,et al.  The developmental capacity of nuclei taken from intestinal epithelium cells of feeding tadpoles. , 1962, Journal of embryology and experimental morphology.

[47]  A. Baldwin,et al.  NF-κB mediates inhibition of mesenchymal cell differentiation through a posttranscriptional gene silencing mechanism , 2003 .

[48]  M. Wickens,et al.  15 Translational Control of Developmental Decisions , 1996 .

[49]  W. Godwin Article in Press , 2000 .

[50]  J. Modolell,et al.  The Drosophila extramacrochaetae locus, an antagonist of proneural genes that, like these genes, encodes a helix-loop-helix protein , 1990, Cell.

[51]  H. Blau,et al.  Differentiation requires continuous regulation , 1991, The Journal of cell biology.

[52]  R. McKay,et al.  Id genes encoding inhibitors of transcription are expressed during in vitro astrocyte differentiation and in cell lines derived from astrocytic tumors. , 1997, Cancer research.

[53]  F. A. Seiler,et al.  Numerical Recipes in C: The Art of Scientific Computing , 1989 .

[54]  M. Jensen,et al.  Fat depot origin affects adipogenesis in primary cultured and cloned human preadipocytes. , 2002, American journal of physiology. Regulatory, integrative and comparative physiology.

[55]  H. Axelson,et al.  Induced neuroblastoma cell differentiation, associated with transient HES‐1 activity and reduced HASH‐1 expression, is inhibited by Notch1 , 2000, International journal of cancer.

[56]  T. Graf,et al.  GATA-1 reprograms avian myelomonocytic cell lines into eosinophils, thromboblasts, and erythroblasts. , 1995, Genes & development.

[57]  Stuart H. Orkin,et al.  Diversification of haematopoietic stem cells to specific lineages , 2000, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[58]  R. Heller,et al.  Global expression profiling of fibroblast responses to transforming growth factor-beta1 reveals the induction of inhibitor of differentiation-1 and provides evidence of smooth muscle cell phenotypic switching. , 2003, The American journal of pathology.

[59]  David A. Cox,et al.  Ideals, Varieties, and Algorithms , 1997 .

[60]  E. Rothenberg,et al.  Stepwise specification of lymphocyte developmental lineages. , 2000, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[61]  R. Ellis,et al.  The fog-3 gene and regulation of cell fate in the germ line of Caenorhabditis elegans. , 1995, Genetics.

[62]  T. Ohtsuka,et al.  Regulated expression of neurogenic basic helix-loop-helix transcription factors during differentiation of the immortalized neuronal progenitor cell line HC2S2 into neurons , 1998, Cell and Tissue Research.

[63]  G. Fishell,et al.  Parsing the prosencephalon , 2002, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[64]  K. Nave,et al.  Helix‐loop‐helix proteins in Schwann cells: A study of regulation and subcellular localization of Ids, REB, and E12/47 during embryonic and postnatal development , 1997, Journal of neuroscience research.

[65]  Jiang Zhu,et al.  Hematopoietic cytokines, transcription factors and lineage commitment , 2002, Oncogene.

[66]  W. Forrester,et al.  Inhibition of an Erythroid Differentiation Switch by the Helix-Loop-Helix Protein Id1 (*) , 1995, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[67]  M. Busslinger,et al.  Independent regulation of the two Pax5 alleles during B-cell development , 1999, Nature Genetics.

[68]  J. Collins,et al.  Construction of a genetic toggle switch in Escherichia coli , 2000, Nature.

[69]  S. Orkin Priming the hematopoietic pump. , 2003, Immunity.

[70]  Hitoshi Sakano,et al.  Mutually exclusive expression of odorant receptor transgenes , 2000, Nature Neuroscience.

[71]  E. Hill Journal of Theoretical Biology , 1961, Nature.

[72]  M. Greaves,et al.  Loops, Lineage, and Leukemia , 1998, Cell.

[73]  M. Wickens,et al.  A conserved RNA-binding protein controls germline stem cells in Caenorhabditis elegans , 2002, Nature.

[74]  K. Tomita,et al.  The bHLH Gene Hes1 Regulates Differentiation of Multiple Cell Types , 2000, Molecules and cells.

[75]  Thomas Mestl,et al.  FEEDBACK LOOPS, STABILITY AND MULTISTATIONARITY IN DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS , 1995 .

[76]  Harold Weintraub,et al.  The protein Id: A negative regulator of helix-loop-helix DNA binding proteins , 1990, Cell.

[77]  K. Todokoro,et al.  Activation of helix-loop-helix proteins Id1, Id2 and Id3 during neural differentiation. , 1994, Biochemical and biophysical research communications.

[78]  L. Kedes,et al.  The basic domain of myogenic basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) proteins is the novel target for direct inhibition by another bHLH protein, Twist , 1997, Molecular and cellular biology.

[79]  A. Halsall,et al.  Transcript profiling of functionally related groups of genes during conditional differentiation of a mammalian cochlear hair cell line. , 2002, Genome research.

[80]  I. Weissman,et al.  Cell-fate conversion of lymphoid-committed progenitors by instructive actions of cytokines , 2000, Nature.

[81]  M. Israel,et al.  Id2 expression increases with differentiation of human myeloid cells. , 1996, Blood.

[82]  Erich Bornberg-Bauer,et al.  Convergent evolution of gene networks by single‐gene duplications in higher eukaryotes , 2004, EMBO reports.

[83]  T. Jessell,et al.  A Homeodomain Protein Code Specifies Progenitor Cell Identity and Neuronal Fate in the Ventral Neural Tube , 2000, Cell.

[84]  K. Akashi,et al.  GATA-1 converts lymphoid and myelomonocytic progenitors into the megakaryocyte/erythrocyte lineages. , 2003, Immunity.

[85]  El Houssine Snoussi Necessary Conditions for Multistationarity and Stable Periodicity , 1998 .

[86]  H. Okano,et al.  Musashi: a translational regulator of cell fate. , 2002, Journal of cell science.

[87]  Helen M. Blau,et al.  Stable reprogrammed heterokaryons form spontaneously in Purkinje neurons after bone marrow transplant , 2003, Nature Cell Biology.

[88]  Mark Daly,et al.  Stochastic yet biased expression of multiple Dscam splice variants by individual cells , 2004, Nature Genetics.

[89]  H. Blau,et al.  Plasticity of cell fate: insights from heterokaryons. , 1999, Seminars in cell & developmental biology.

[90]  H. Weintraub,et al.  B-lymphocyte development is regulated by the combined dosage of three basic helix-loop-helix genes, E2A, E2-2, and HEB , 1996, Molecular and cellular biology.

[91]  Xi C. He,et al.  Transcriptional accessibility for genes of multiple tissues and hematopoietic lineages is hierarchically controlled during early hematopoiesis. , 2003, Blood.

[92]  H. Axelson,et al.  Modulation of Basic Helix-Loop-Helix Transcription Complex Formation by Id Proteins during Neuronal Differentiation* , 2002, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[93]  William H. Press,et al.  Book-Review - Numerical Recipes in Pascal - the Art of Scientific Computing , 1989 .

[94]  A. Chess,et al.  YAC transgene‐mediated olfactory receptor gene choice , 2000, Developmental dynamics : an official publication of the American Association of Anatomists.

[95]  N. Rekhtman,et al.  Direct interaction of hematopoietic transcription factors PU.1 and GATA-1: functional antagonism in erythroid cells. , 1999, Genes & development.

[96]  Marvin Wickens,et al.  A PUF family portrait: 3'UTR regulation as a way of life. , 2002, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[97]  K. Jermyn,et al.  Comparison of the Dictyostelium rasD and ecmA genes reveals two distinct mechanisms whereby an mRNA may become enriched in prestalk cells. , 1995, Differentiation; research in biological diversity.

[98]  J. D. Da Ponte,et al.  Cross-repressive interactions of identity genes are essential for proper specification of cardiac and muscular fates in Drosophila. , 2002, Development.

[99]  A. Iserles Numerical recipes in C—the art of scientific computing , by W. H. Press, B. P. Flannery, S. A. Teukolsky and W. T. Vetterling. Pp 735. £27·50. 1988. ISBN 0-521-35465-X (Cambridge University Press) , 1989, The Mathematical Gazette.

[100]  Philippe Collas,et al.  Reprogramming fibroblasts to express T-cell functions using cell extracts , 2002, Nature Biotechnology.

[101]  D. Tenen,et al.  Negative cross-talk between hematopoietic regulators: GATA proteins repress PU.1. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[102]  T. Kealey,et al.  Id proteins are dynamically expressed in normal epidermis and dysregulated in squamous cell carcinoma. , 2000, Cancer research.

[103]  J. Gurdon,et al.  The developmental capacity of nuclei transplanted from keratinized skin cells of adult frogs. , 1975, Journal of embryology and experimental morphology.