Performance Funding for Higher Education

Since the 1970s, federal and state policy-makers have become increasingly concerned with improving higher education performance. In this quest, state performance funding for higher education has become widely used. As of June 2014, twenty-six states were operating performance funding programs and four more have programs awaiting implementation. This article reviews the forms, extent, origins, implementation, impacts (intended and unintended), and policy prospects of performance funding. Performance funding has become quite widespread with formidable political support, yet it has also experienced considerable implementation vicissitudes, with many programs being discontinued and even those that have survived encountering substantial obstacles and unintended impacts. Although evidence suggests that performance funding does stimulate colleges and universities to substantially change their policies and practices, it is yet unclear whether performance funding improves student outcomes. The article concludes by advancing policy recommendations for addressing the implementation obstacles and unintended side effects associated with performance funding.

[1]  L. Davies.  State 'Shared Responsibility' Policies for Improved Outcomes: Lessons Learned , 2014 .

[2]  Roger G. Noll,et al.  Administrative Procedures as Instruments of Political Control , 1987 .

[3]  Michael Mintrom,et al.  Policy Entrepreneurship and Policy Change , 2009 .

[4]  W. Powell,et al.  The iron cage revisited institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields , 1983 .

[5]  J. Shin.  Impacts of performance-based accountability on institutional performance in the U.S. , 2010 .

[6]  T. Moe.  The New Economics of Organization , 1984 .

[7]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  Unintended Impacts of Performance Funding on Community Colleges and Universities in Three States , 2014 .

[8]  Michael K. Mclendon,et al.  Called to Account: Analyzing the Origins and Spread of State Performance-Accountability Policies for Higher Education , 2006 .

[9]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  Popular but Unstable: Explaining Why State Performance Funding Systems in the United States Often Do Not Persist , 2012 .

[10]  Victor J. Friedman,et al.  A Multifacet Model of Organizational Learning , 2002 .

[11]  T. Sanford,et al.  Impact of Performance Funding on Retention and Graduation Rates , 2011 .

[12]  Davis Jenkins,et al.  Metrics, Dollars, and Systems Change: Learning From Washington State's Student Achievement Initiative to Design Effective Postsecondary Performance Funding Policies , 2013 .

[13]  Davis Jenkins,et al.  Performance Incentives to Improve Community College Completion: Learning from Washington State's Student Achievement Initiative , 2011 .

[14]  Michelle Hodara.  Improving Students’ College Math Readiness: A Review of the Evidence on Postsecondary Interventions and Reforms , 2013 .

[15]  P. Light.  Sustaining Nonprofit Performance: The Case for Capacity Building and the Evidence to Support It , 2004 .

[16]  David A. Tandberg,et al.  State Higher Education Performance Funding for Community Colleges: Diverse Effects and Policy Implications , 2014, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[17]  Vincent Tinto,et al.  Completing College: Rethinking Institutional Action , 2012 .

[18]  Daniel A. Mazmanian,et al.  Implementation and public policy , 1983 .

[19]  D. Brinkerhoff,et al.  Capacity and capacity development: Coping with complexity , 2010 .

[20]  Susan J. Wells,et al.  Selecting outcome measures for child welfare settings: lessons for use in performance management , 2001 .

[21]  Jeannette A. Colyvas.  Performance Metrics as Formal Structures and through the Lens of Social Mechanisms: When Do They Work and How Do They Influence? , 2012, American Journal of Education.

[22]  S. Milton,et al.  The Effects of Performance Budgeting and Funding Programs on Graduation Rate in Public Four-Year Colleges and Universities. , 2004 .

[23]  Allen G. Schick.  Opportunity, strategy and tactics in reforming public management , 2003 .

[24]  Massimo Marraffa,et al.  Organizational learning II: Theory, method and practice , 1998 .

[25]  T. Bailey.  CHALLENGE AND OPPORTUNITY: RETHINKING THE ROLE AND FUNCTION OF DEVELOPMENTAL EDUCATION IN COMMUNITY COLLEGE , 2009 .

[26]  Katherine L. Hughes,et al.  Assessing Developmental Assessment in Community Colleges , 2011 .

[27]  Davis Jenkins.  Redesigning Community Colleges for Completion: Lessons from Research on High-Performance Organizations. CCRC Brief. Number 48. , 2011 .

[28]  Kevin B Smith,et al.  The Public Policy Theory Primer , 2009 .

[29]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  It's Not Enough to Get through the Open Door: Inequalities by Social Background in Transfer from Community Colleges to Four-Year Colleges. , 2006 .

[30]  Michael Cragg,et al.  Performance Incentives in the Public Sector: Evidence from the Job Training Partnership Act , 1997 .

[31]  Donald P. Moynihan,et al.  The Dynamics of Performance Management: Constructing Information and Reform , 2008 .

[32]  R. Merton.  Social Theory and Social Structure , 1958 .

[33]  Marc Cutright,et al.  Performance indicators as conceptual technologies , 2000 .

[34]  D. L. Wright.  Structuring State Policy for Student Success - Applying Incentives in the Volunteer State , 2016 .

[35]  C. Hood.  A PUBLIC MANAGEMENT FOR ALL SEASONS , 1991 .

[36]  A. Schneider,et al.  Policy Design for Democracy , 1997 .

[37]  D. Stone.  Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making , 1997 .

[38]  Werner Z. Hirsch,et al.  The costs of higher education : how much do colleges and universities spend per student and how much should they spend? , 1982 .

[39]  Mitchell L. Stevens,et al.  A Sociology of Quantification* , 2008, European Journal of Sociology.

[40]  Dall W. Forsythe.  Quicker, Better, Cheaper? Managing Performance in American Government. , 2001 .

[41]  T. Parveva,et al.  Higher Education Governance in Europe: Policies, Structures, Funding and Academic Staff. , 2008 .

[42]  Jeffrey N. Jones,et al.  The Kalamazoo Promise and Perceived Changes in School Climate , 2011 .

[43]  J. Henig.  Spin cycle : how research is used in policy debates : the case of charter schools , 2008 .

[44]  David B. Tyack.  The One Best System: A History of American Urban Education , 1974 .

[45]  Bettye Johnson,et al.  Performance Incentives and Public College Accountability in the United States: A Quarter Century Policy Audit. , 2010 .

[46]  Amitai Etzioni,et al.  A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organizations. , 1962 .

[47]  Social Capital in Data-Driven Community College Reform , 2015 .

[48]  J. Elster,et al.  Nuts and bolts for the social sciences , 1989 .

[49]  E. Bensimon.  Closing the achievement gap in higher education: An organizational learning perspective , 2005 .

[50]  Market forces and private sector processes in government policy: The job training partnership act , 1988 .

[51]  Thomas Rabovsky,et al.  Accountability in Higher Education: Exploring Impacts on State Budgets and Institutional Spending Patterns , 2012 .

[52]  Monica Reid Kerrigan,et al.  A Framework for Understanding Community Colleges’ Organizational Capacity for Data Use , 2014 .

[53]  S. Timmermans,et al.  A World of Standards but not a Standard World: Toward a Sociology of Standards and Standardization* , 2010 .

[54]  Hans de Bruijn,et al.  Managing Performance in the Public Sector , 2002 .

[55]  Donald A. Schön,et al.  Organizational Learning II: Theory, Method, and Practice , 1995 .

[56]  Oscar S. Cerna,et al.  Turning the Tide: Five Years of Achieving the Dream in Community Colleges , 2011 .

[57]  L. Mcdonnell,et al.  Getting the Job Done: Alternative Policy Instruments , 1987 .

[58]  Alicia C. Dowd,et al.  Accountability, Assessment, and the Scholarship of “Best Practice” , 2007 .

[59]  John M. Cohen.  Capacity Building in the Public Sector: A Focused Framework for Analysis and Action , 1995 .

[60]  E. Bensimon,et al.  Creating a Culture of Inquiry around Equity and Student Success , 2012 .

[61]  David A. Tandberg,et al.  Performance Funding in Higher Education: Do Financial Incentives Impact College Completions? , 2014 .

[62]  R. Rothstein.  Holding Accountability to Account: How Scholarship and Experience in Other Fields Inform Exploration of Performance Incentives in Education. Working Paper 2008-04. , 2008 .

[63]  C. Belfield.  Washington State Student Achievement Initiative: Achievement Points Analysis for Academic Years 2007-2011. CCRC-IHELP Student Achievement Initiative Policy Study. , 2012 .

[64]  Richard E. Matland.  Synthesizing the Implementation Literature: The Ambiguity-Conflict Model of Policy Implementation , 1995 .

[65]  Guy Neave,et al.  The Evaluative State Reconsidered. , 1998 .

[66]  Kara S. Finnigan,et al.  Do Accountability Policy Sanctions Influence Teacher Motivation? Lessons From Chicago’s Low-Performing Schools , 2007 .

[67]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  The Politics of Performance Funding for Higher Education , 2015 .

[68]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  Envisioning Performance Funding Impacts: The Espoused Theories of Action for State Higher Education Performance Funding in Three States , 2014 .

[69]  Keith E. Hamm,et al.  Legislative Politics in the States , 2012 .

[70]  Davis Jenkins,et al.  Access and Success with Less: Improving Productivity in Broad-Access Postsecondary Institutions , 2013, The Future of children.

[71]  L. Friedrich,et al.  Orientations for the Teaching of Writing: A Legacy of the National Writing Project , 2013 .

[72]  Affectivity, expertise, and inequality: three foundations of trust in education. Reflections on presuppositions, (unintended) consequences, and possible alternatives , 2012 .

[73]  David N. Figlio,et al.  Feeling the Florida Heat? How Low-Performing Schools Respond to Voucher and Accountability Pressure , 2007 .

[74]  M. Golden.  What Motivates Bureaucrats?: Politics and Administration During the Reagan Years , 2000 .

[75]  C. Weible,et al.  The Advocacy Coalition Framework , 2012, Theories of the Policy Process.

[76]  Carolyn J. Heinrich,et al.  Do Short-run performance measures predict long-run impacts? , 2011 .

[77]  L. Yorks.  Adult Learning and the Generation of New Knowledge and Meaning: Creating Liberating Spaces for Fostering Adult Learning through Practitioner-Based Collaborative Action Inquiry , 2005, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[78]  B. Stensaker,et al.  Trance, Transparency and Transformation: The impact of external quality monitoring on higher education , 2003 .

[79]  A. Rutherford,et al.  Evaluating Impacts of Performance Funding Policies on Student Outcomes in Higher Education , 2014 .

[80]  Davis Jenkins,et al.  Institutional Research and the Culture of Evidence at Community Colleges. Report No. 1 in the Culture of Evidence Series. , 2007 .

[81]  J. Pfeffer,et al.  The External Control of Organizations. , 1978 .

[82]  Gail L. Sunderman,et al.  The Expansion of Federal Power and the Politics of Implementing the No Child Left behind Act , 2007, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[83]  Joseph C. Burke.  Achieving Accountability in Higher Education: Balancing Public, Academic, and Market Demands , 2003 .

[84]  Clive Bean,et al.  Parties and elections , 1997 .

[85]  D. Hicks.  Performance-based university research funding systems , 2012 .

[86]  T. Wilder,et al.  Grading Education: Getting Accountability Right , 2008 .

[87]  R. Leander,et al.  Morale of Teachers in High Poverty Schools: A Post-NCLB Mixed Methods Analysis , 2010 .

[88]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  Organizational Learning by Colleges Responding to Performance Funding: Deliberative Structures and Their Challenges , 2014 .

[89]  Evanthia Kalpazidou Schmidt,et al.  Funding systems for higher education and their impacts on institutional strategies and academia: A comparative perspective , 2010 .

[90]  C. Coburn,et al.  Rethinking Scale: Moving Beyond Numbers to Deep and Lasting Change , 2003 .

[91]  Kevin J. Dougherty.  The Contradictory College: The Conflicting Origins, Impacts, and Futures of the Community College. SUNY Series, Frontiers in Education. , 1994 .

[92]  Raymond E. Callahan.  Education and the Cult of Efficiency , 1962 .

[93]  Henry Braun,et al.  Reconsidering the Impact of High-stakes Testing , 2004 .

[94]  P. Benneworth,et al.  Engaging in the modernisation agenda for European higher education , 2012 .

[95]  John W. Kingdon.  Agendas, alternatives, and public policies , 1984 .

[96]  P. Lingenfelter.  The Financing of Public Colleges and Universities in the United States , 2007 .

[97]  Mary M. Juzwik,et al.  Supporting Dialogically Organized Instruction in an English Teacher Preparation Program: A Video-Based, Web 2.0-Mediated Response and Revision Pedagogy , 2012, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[98]  Alicia C. Dowd.  Engaging the "Race Question": Accountability and Equity in U.S. Higher Education , 2015 .

[99]  David A. Tandberg,et al.  State Higher Education Performance Funding: Data, Outcomes, and Policy Implications* , 2014 .

[100]  Juan Carlos Calcagno,et al.  Community College Student Success: What Institutional Characteristics Make a Difference?. , 2005 .

[101]  Davis Jenkins.  Redesigning Community Colleges for Completion: Lessons from Research on High-Performance Organizations. CCRC Working Paper No. 24. Assessment of Evidence Series. , 2011 .

[102]  Michael Power,et al.  The audit society : rituals of verification , 1997 .

[103]  Performance Funding in Higher Education: A Critical Analysis of Tennessee's Experience. , 1986 .

[104]  A. Frans,et al.  Policy models and policy instruments in higher education. The effects of governmental policy-making on the innovative behaviour of higher education institutions. IHS Political Science Series 26, October 1995 , 1993 .

[105]  David Altstadt.  Tying Funding to Community College Outcomes: Models, Tools, and Recommendations for States. Executive Summary. , 2012 .

[106]  Steven J. Balla,et al.  Interstate Professional Associations and the Diffusion of Policy Innovations , 2001 .

[107]  V. Marsick,et al.  Teams as Learners , 1997 .

[108]  Bob Blankenberger,et al.  Performance Funding in Illinois Higher Education , 2016 .

[109]  Michael J. Weiss,et al.  More Graduates: Two-Year Results from an Evaluation of Accelerated Study in Associate Programs (ASAP) for Developmental Education Students , 2013 .

[110]  Kevin J. Dougherty,et al.  Performance Funding for Higher Education: What Are the Mechanisms What Are the Impacts , 2013 .

[111]  T. Dee,et al.  The Impact of No Child Left Behind on Student Achievement. NBER Working Paper No. 15531. , 2009 .

[112]  Peter T. Ewell,et al.  Linking Performance Measures to Resource Allocation: exploring unmapped terrain , 1999 .

[113]  Marvin A. Titus.  An Examination of the Influence of Institutional Context on Student Persistence at 4-Year Colleges and Universities: A Multilevel Approach , 2004 .

[114]  Beryl A. Radin,et al.  Challenging the Performance Movement: Accountability, Complexity, and Democratic Values , 2006 .