A distinction is proposed between two different senses of the treatment by background interaction (termed 'external invalidity' by Campbell & Stanley, 1966). The distinction parallels the dichotomy between universalistic (or theory centered) and particularistic (or context centered) objectives of behavioral research. In its universalistic sense the interaction above suggests a redefinition of the abstract meaning attached to the independent variables effective with respect to a given phenomenon of interest. In its particularistic sense this interaction defines the concrete contexts over which a given outcome will hold. The implications of the proposed distinction are discussed in reference to the phases of (1) designing the experiment and (2) evaluating the obtained results.
[1]
M. Orne.
On the social psychology of the psychological experiment: With particular reference to demand characteristics and their implications.
,
1962
.
[2]
Robert M. Gagne,et al.
Decisions, Values, and Groups
,
1961
.
[3]
D P Schultz,et al.
The human subject in psychological research.
,
1969,
Psychological bulletin.
[4]
A. Kruglanski.
Much ado about the "volunteer artifacts."
,
1973
.
[5]
R. Rosenthal,et al.
Artifact in behavioral research
,
1969
.
[6]
S. Fiske,et al.
The Handbook of Social Psychology
,
1935
.
[7]
Q. Mcnemar,et al.
Opinion-attitude methodology.
,
1946,
Psychological bulletin.