Remote spatial analysis lacking ethnographic grounding mischaracterizes sustainability of Indigenous burning regime

Abstract: Scientific research that purports to evaluate Indigenous fire regimes in the absence of ethnographically contextualized ecological data runs the risk of exacerbating the fire blame game and providing evidence to support distorted narratives advanced by anti-Indigenous advocates. Spatial analysis of fire scars in Indigenous territories can be an effective tool for characterizing cultural fire regimes in terms of distribution and frequency, especially when qualified by linkages to different local ecosystems. A recently published article drew on fire scar mapping from satellite imagery to assess anthropogenic fire distribution and frequency in the Pimentel Barbosa Indigenous Land, Central Brazil. The authors use their findings to characterize A'uwẽ (Xavante) use of fire as unmanaged and a model of unsustainable use of cerrado resources. In this article, we discuss Aguiar & Martins's recent paper in light of our long-term research on A'uwẽ hunting with fire in the Pimentel Barbosa Indigenous Land, arguing that A'uwẽ hunters do burn according to established cultural protocols, manage their use of fire for conservationist purposes, and do not cause environmental degradation by burning.

[1]  Frank K. Lake,et al.  Fire and biodiversity in the Anthropocene , 2020, Science.

[2]  J. Welch,et al.  Indigenous fire ecologies, restoration, and territorial sovereignty in the Brazilian Cerrado: The case of two Xavante reserves , 2019 .

[3]  V. H. M. Prado,et al.  Trends and gaps of the scientific literature about the effects of fire on Brazilian Cerrado , 2018 .

[4]  A. Berardi,et al.  Community owned solutions for fire management in tropical ecosystems: case studies from Indigenous communities of South America , 2016, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[5]  R. Bird,et al.  A Landscape Architecture of Fire , 2016, Current Anthropology.

[6]  C. Trauernicht,et al.  Local and global pyrogeographic evidence that indigenous fire management creates pyrodiversity , 2015, Ecology and evolution.

[7]  J. Welch Learning to Hunt by Tending the Fire: Xavante Youth, Ethnoecology, and Ceremony in Central Brazil , 2015 .

[8]  E. Rodrigues,et al.  Impact of invasion by molasses grass (Melinis minutiflora P. Beauv.) on native species and on fires in areas of campo-cerrado in Brazil , 2014 .

[9]  J. Welch Xavante Ritual Hunting: Anthropogenic Fire, Reciprocity, and Collective Landscape Management in the Brazilian Cerrado , 2014 .

[10]  Eduardo S Brondízio,et al.  Indigenous Burning as Conservation Practice: Neotropical Savanna Recovery amid Agribusiness Deforestation in Central Brazil , 2013, PloS one.

[11]  C. Saito,et al.  The Practice of Burning Savannas for Hunting by the Xavante Indians Based on the Stars and Constellations , 2013 .

[12]  C. Saito,et al.  Regime de Queima das Caçadas com Uso do Fogo Realizadas pelos Xavante no Cerrado , 2011 .

[13]  A. Edwards,et al.  Fire heterogeneity in Kakadu National Park, 1980–2000 , 2005 .

[14]  D. Bowman,et al.  Contemporary landscape burning patterns in the far North Kimberley region of north‐west Australia: human influences and environmental determinants , 2004 .

[15]  E. M. Vieira,et al.  Post-fire succession of small mammals in the Cerrado of central Brazil , 2004, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[16]  D. Bowman,et al.  Impact of Aboriginal landscape burning on woody vegetation in Eucalyptus tetrodonta savanna in Arnhem Land, northern Australia , 2004 .

[17]  W. Hoffmann,et al.  Impact of the invasive alien grass Melinis minutiflora at the savanna‐forest ecotone in the Brazilian Cerrado , 2004 .

[18]  Frank K. Lake,et al.  The Role of Indigenous Burning in Land Management , 2001, Journal of Forestry.

[19]  V. Pivello,et al.  Alien grasses in Brazilian savannas: a threat to the biodiversity , 1999, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[20]  Jeremy Russell-Smith,et al.  A LANDSAT MSS-derived fire history of Kakadu National Park, monsoonal northern Australia, 1980-94: seasonal extent, frequency and patchiness. , 1997 .

[21]  M. Prada Effects of fire on the abundance of large mammalian herbivores in Mato Grosso, Brazil , 2001 .