Hydrologic variability and the application of Index of Biotic Integrity metrics to wetlands: A great lakes evaluation

Interest by land-management and regulatory agencies in using biological indicators to detect wetland degradation, coupled with ongoing use of this approach to assess water quality in streams, led to the desire to develop and evaluate an Index of Biotic Integrity (IBI) for wetlands that could be used to categorize the level of degradation. We undertook this challenge with data from coastal wetlands of the Great Lakes, which have been degraded by a variety of human disturbances. We studied six barrier beach wetlands in western Lake Superior, six drowned-river-mouth wetlands along the eastern shore of Lake Michigan, and six open shoreline wetlands in Saginaw Bay of Lake Huron. Plant, fish, and invertebrate communities were sampled in each wetland. The resulting data were assessed in various forms against gradients of human disturbance to identify potential metrics that could be used in IBI development. Our results suggested that the metrics proposed as potential components of an IBI for barrier beach wetlands of Lake Superior held promise. The metrics for Lake Michigan drowned-river-mouth wetlands were inconsistent in identifying gradients of disturbance; those for Lake Huron open embayment wetlands were yet more inconsistent. Despite the potential displayed by the Lake Superior results within the year sampled, we concluded that an IBI for use in Great Lakes wetlands would not be valid unless separate scoring ranges were derived for each of several sequences of water-level histories. Variability in lake levels from year to year can produce variability in data and affect the reproducibility of data collected, primarily due to extreme changes in plant communities and the faunal habitat they provide. Substantially different results could be obtained in the same wetland in different years as a result of the response to lake-level change, with no change in the level of human disturbance. Additional problems included limited numbers of comparable sites, potential lack of undisturbed reference sites, and variable effects of different disturbance types. We also evaluated our conclusions with respect to hydrologic variability and other major natural disturbances affecting wetlands in other regions. We concluded that after segregation of wetland types by geographic, geomorphic, and hydrologic features, a functional IBI may be possible for wetlands with relatively stable hydrology. However, an IBI for wetlands with unpredictable yet recurring influences of climate-induced, long-term high water periods, droughts, or drought-related fires or weather-related catastrophic floods or high winds (hurricanes) would also require differing scales of measurement for years that differ in the length of time since the last major natural disturbance. A site-specific, detailed ecological analysis of biological indicators may indeed be of value in determining the quality or status of wetlands, but we recommend that IBI scores not be used unless the scoring ranges are calibrated for the specific hydrologic history pre-dating any sampling year.

[1]  T. Thompson,et al.  Hydrogeomorphic factors and ecosystem responses in coastal wetlands of the Great Lakes , 1999, Wetlands.

[2]  J. Meeker,et al.  Implications for faunal habitat related to altered macrophyte structure in regulated lakes in northern Minnesota , 1992, Wetlands.

[3]  E. G. Voss,et al.  Michigan Flora, Part III, Dicots (Pyrolaceae-Compositae). , 1997 .

[4]  C. A. Stricker,et al.  Development of a preliminary invertebrate index of biotic integrity for Lake Huron coastal wetlands , 1999, Wetlands.

[5]  M. E. McDonald,et al.  Cause and Effects of a Die-off of Emergent Vegetation , 1955 .

[6]  B. Middleton.  Flood pulsing in wetlands : restoring the natural hydrological balance , 2002 .

[7]  T. A. Bookhout,et al.  Vegetation Changes in a Lake Erie Marsh (Winous Point, Ottawa County, Ohio) During High Water Years , 1982 .

[8]  K. Kramer.  Biomonitoring of coastal waters and estuaries , 1997 .

[9]  T. Barkley,et al.  Michigan Flora Part II: Dicots (Saururaceae-Cornaceae) , 1985 .

[10]  W. B. Scott,et al.  Freshwater fishes of Canada , 1974 .

[11]  Yao Yin,et al.  Naturalization of the flood regime in regulated rivers the case of the upper Mississippi River , 1998 .

[12]  The Fishes of Ohio , 1958 .

[13]  L. Loope,et al.  Hurricane impact on uplands and freshwater swamp forest. , 1994 .

[14]  T. Thompson,et al.  Strand-plain evidence for late Holocene lake-level variations in Lake Michigan , 1997 .

[15]  Douglas A. Wilcox,et al.  Disturbance effects on aquatic vegetation in regulated and unregulated lakes in northern Minnesota , 1991 .

[16]  D. Vitt,et al.  The relationships of vegetation to surface water chemistry and peat chemistry in fens of Alberta, Canada , 1990, Vegetatio.

[17]  Robert J. Steedman,et al.  Modification and Assessment of an Index of Biotic Integrity to Quantify Stream Quality in Southern Ontario , 1988 .

[18]  Steve J. Baedke,et al.  A 4,700-Year Record of Lake Level and Isostasy for Lake Michigan , 2000 .

[19]  J. R. Karr,et al.  Restoring life in running waters , 1998 .

[20]  A. Palmisano,et al.  The Effects of Hurricane Camille on the Marshes of the Mississippi River Delta , 1973 .

[21]  L. C. Roth.  Hurricanes and Mangrove Regeneration: Effects of Hurricane Joan, October 1988, on the Vegetation of Isla del Venado, Bluefields, Nicaragua , 1992 .

[22]  T. J. Smith,et al.  The ecology of tidal freshwater marshes of the United States East Coast: a community profile , 1984 .

[23]  W. Michener,et al.  CLIMATE CHANGE, HURRICANES AND TROPICAL STORMS, AND RISING SEA LEVEL IN COASTAL WETLANDS , 1997 .

[24]  V. Shelford.  Some Lower Mississippi Valley Flood Plain Biotic Communities: Their age and Elevation , 1954 .

[25]  James R. Karr,et al.  Assessing Invertebrate Responses to Human Activities: Evaluating Alternative Approaches , 1996, Journal of the North American Benthological Society.

[26]  K. Cummins,et al.  An Introduction to the Aquatic Insects of North America , 1981 .

[27]  M. Schmidt,et al.  BIOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF AQUATIC POLLUTION: A REVIEW, WITH EMPHASIS ON PLANTS AS BIOMONITORS * , 1994, Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society.

[28]  Thomas C. Winter,et al.  THE VULNERABILITY OF WETLANDS TO CLIMATE CHANGE: A HYDROLOGIC LANDSCAPE PERSPECTIVE 1 , 2000 .

[29]  Michael A. Soukup,et al.  Hurricane Andrew's impact on freshwater resources , 1994 .

[30]  Douglas A. Wilcox,et al.  Use of historical and geospatial data to guide the restoration of a Lake Erie coastal marsh , 1999, Wetlands.

[31]  Claude E. Shannon,et al.  The Mathematical Theory of Communication , 1950 .

[32]  T. Kratz,et al.  Internal Factors Controlling Peatland‐Lake Ecosystem Development , 1986 .

[33]  E. Herricks,et al.  Can we optimize biomonitoring? , 1985 .

[34]  Thomas C. Winter,et al.  Hydrology of Prairie Pothole Wetlands during Drought and Deluge: A 17-Year Study of the Cottonwood Lake Wetland Complex in North Dakota in the Perspective of Longer Term Measured and Proxy Hydrological Records , 1998 .

[35]  S. Dodson,et al.  Zooplankton of the Great Lakes: A Guide to the Identification and Ecology of the Common Crustacean Species , 1984 .

[36]  J. Friedman,et al.  FLOOD DEPENDENCY OF COTTONWOOD ESTABLISHMENT ALONG THE MISSOURI RIVER, MONTANA, USA , 1997 .

[37]  Thomas M. Williams,et al.  Impact of Hurricane Hugo on the South Carolina coastal plain forest , 1991 .

[38]  Michael B. Robblee,et al.  Mangroves, hurricanes and lightning strikes , 1994 .

[39]  B. Haddad.  ECONOMIC INCENTIVES FOR WATER CONSERVATION ON THE MONTEREY PENINSULA: THE MARKET PROPOSAL 1 , 2000 .

[40]  M. Brinson.  A Hydrogeomorphic Classification for Wetlands , 1993 .

[41]  James R. Karr,et al.  Assessing biological integrity in running waters : a method and its rationale , 1986 .

[42]  R. Pennak,et al.  Fresh-Water Invertebrates of the United States: Protozoa to Mollusca , 1989 .

[43]  Francis E. Putz,et al.  Hurricane damage to old growth forest in Congaree Swamp National Monument, South Carolina, USA , 1991 .

[44]  Yao Yin.  Flooding and forest succession in a modified stretch along the Upper Mississippi River , 1998 .

[45]  L. Gunderson,et al.  Fire patterns in the southern Everglades , 1994 .

[46]  M. Brinson.  Riparian ecosystems: their ecology and status , 1981 .

[47]  E. S. Verry,et al.  Peatland and water in the northern Lake States. , 1977 .

[48]  Glenn W. Suter,et al.  A critique of ecosystem health concepts and indexes , 1993 .

[49]  M. Scott,et al.  Fluvial disturbance patches and cottonwood recruitment along the upper Missouri River, Montana , 1998, Wetlands.

[50]  T. C. Winter,et al.  The interaction of ground water with prairie pothole wetlands in the Cottonwood Lake area, east-central North Dakota, 1979–1990 , 1995, Wetlands.

[51]  R. D. Nelson,et al.  Changes in atmospheric circulation patterns affect midcontinent wetlands sensitive to climate , 1996 .

[52]  D. M. Rosenberg,et al.  Freshwater biomonitoring and benthic macroinvertebrates. , 1994 .

[53]  J. Ogden,et al.  Sea Level Control on Stability of Everglades Wetlands , 1994 .

[54]  John R. Jones,et al.  Flooding to Restore Connectivity of Regulated, Large-River Wetlands Natural and controlled flooding as complementary processes along the lower Missouri River , 1998 .

[55]  Suzanne E. Bayley,et al.  Seasonal variation in water chemistry over a bog-rich fen gradient in Continental Western Canada , 1995 .

[56]  John C. Ogden,et al.  Vegetation of the Everglades: Determinants of Community Composition , 1994 .

[57]  Mark M. Brinson,et al.  The Role of Reference Wetlands in Functional Assessment and Mitigation , 1996 .

[58]  J. Karr.  Assessment of Biotic Integrity Using Fish Communities , 1981 .

[59]  James R. Karr,et al.  Biological monitoring: Essential foundation for ecological risk assessment , 1997 .

[60]  E. L. Core.  Plant Ecology of Spruce Mountain, West Virginia , 1929 .

[61]  G. Fraser,et al.  Climatic control of lake levels in the Lake Michigan and Lake Huron basins , 1990 .

[62]  E. G. Voss,et al.  Michigan Flora. Part I. Gymnosperms and Monocots , 1972 .

[63]  William M. Lewis,et al.  Channel narrowing and vegetation development following a great plains flood , 1996 .

[64]  R. Pride,et al.  Interim report on the hydrologic features of the Green Swamp area in Central Florida , 1961 .

[65]  W. B. Scott,et al.  Common and scientific names of fishes from the United States and Canada: Bethesda , 1991 .

[66]  T. J. Blasing,et al.  A dendroclimatic reconstruction of annual precipitation amounts in Iowa since 1680 , 1981 .

[67]  N. H. Euliss,et al.  Wetlands of the Prairie Pothole Region: Invertebrate species composition, ecology, and management , 1999 .

[68]  T. C. Winter,et al.  Hydrologic studies of wetlands in the northern prairie. , 1989 .

[69]  C. Schwintzer.  Nutrient and Water Levels in a Small Michigan Bog with High Tree Mortality , 1978 .

[70]  D. Patten,et al.  Marsh development after large floods in an alluvial, arid-land river , 1997, Wetlands.

[71]  Wayne S. Davis,et al.  Biological assessment and criteria : tools for water resource planning and decision making , 1995 .

[72]  T. J. Smith,et al.  Wind damage effects of Hurricane Andrew on mangrove communities along the southwest coast of Florida, USA , 1995 .

[73]  J. H. Selgeby,et al.  Cyclopoid and harpacticoid copepods of the Laurentian Great Lakes , 1998 .

[74]  Douglas A. Wilcox,et al.  Techniques for restoration of disturbed coastal wetlands of the Great Lakes , 1999, Wetlands.

[75]  James R. Karr,et al.  Sustaining living rivers , 2000, Hydrobiologia.

[76]  Elijah W. Ramsey,et al.  AVHRR imagery used to identify hurricane damage in a forested wetland of Louisiana , 1997 .

[77]  J. C. Morse.  A Checklist of the Trichoptera of North America, including Greenland and Mexico , 1993 .

[78]  John Buonaccorsi,et al.  Development and validation of an estuarine biotic integrity index , 1997 .

[79]  James R. Karr,et al.  Ecological perspective on water quality goals , 1981 .

[80]  P. Keddy,et al.  Great Lakes Vegetation Dynamics: The Role of Fluctuating Water Levels and Buried Seeds , 1986 .

[81]  C. E. SHANNON,et al.  A mathematical theory of communication , 1948, MOCO.

[82]  C. B. Davis,et al.  The Role of Seed Banks in the Vegetation Dynamics of Prairie Glacial Marshes , 1978 .

[83]  Thomas R. Karl,et al.  The Identification of 10- to 20-Year Temperature and Precipitation Fluctuations in the Contiguous United States , 1984 .

[84]  L. L. Jackson,et al.  Hydrological, Geomorphological, and Chemical Effects of Hurricane Andrew on Coastal Marshes of Louisiana , 1992 .

[85]  W. R. Osterkamp,et al.  Processes of fluvial island formation, with examples from Plum Creek, Colorado and Snake River, Idaho , 1998, Wetlands.

[86]  M. Gonsebatt,et al.  Biomonitors and Biomarkers as Indicators of Environmental Change 2 : A Handbook , 2001 .

[87]  S. E. HOLLINGWORTH,et al.  The Great Lakes , 1959, Nature.

[88]  W. Junk.  The flood pulse concept in river-floodplain systems , 1989 .

[89]  S. Rood,et al.  Initial cottonwood seedling recruitment following the flood of the century of the Oldman River, Alberta, Canada , 1998, Wetlands.

[90]  Robert G. Randall,et al.  An Index of Biotic Integrity (IBI) for Fish Assemblages in the Littoral Zone of Great Lakes' Areas of Concern , 1994 .

[91]  L. L. Harrold.  Hydrology, 2nd Edition , 1960 .

[92]  C. Loveless.  A Study of the Vegetation in the Florida Everglades , 1959 .

[93]  A. Lugo,et al.  The Ecology of Mangroves , 1974 .

[94]  J. Karr.  Biological Integrity: A Long-Neglected Aspect of Water Resource Management. , 1991, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.