Comparison of retinal nerve fiber layer thickness measurement bias and imprecision across three spectral-domain optical coherence tomography devices.

PURPOSE We compared retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) bias and imprecision among three spectral-domain optical coherence tomographs (SD-OCT). METHODS A total of 152 eyes of 83 subjects (96 healthy and 56 glaucomatous eyes) underwent peripapillary RNFL imaging using at least 2 of the following 3 SD-OCT devices on the same day: Cirrus HD-OCT (optic nerve head [ONH]) cube 200 × 200 protocol), RTVue-100 (ONH protocol [12 radial lines and 13 concentric circles]), and 3D OCT-1000 (3D Scan 256 × 256 protocol). Calibration equations, bias and imprecision of RNFL measurements were calculated using structural equation models. RESULTS The calibration equations for healthy and glaucoma RNFL thickness measurements among the 3 devices were: Cirrus = 2.136 + 0.831*RTVue; Cirrus = -15.521 + 1.056*3D OCT-1000; RTVue = -21.257 + 1.271*3D OCT-1000. Using Cirrus bias as an arbitrary reference, RTVue bias was 1.20 (95% CI 1.09-1.32, P < 0.05) times larger and 3D OCT-1000 was 0.95 (0.87-1.03, P > 0.05) times smaller. Relative to 3D OCT-1000, the RTVue bias was 1.27 (1.13-1.42, P < 0.05). RTVue imprecision (healthy eyes 7.83, 95% CI 6.43-9.58; glaucoma cases 5.71, 4.19-7.64) was statistically significantly higher than both Cirrus (healthy eyes 3.23, 2.11-4.31; glaucoma cases 3.53, 0.69-5.24) and 3D OCT-1000 (healthy eyes 4.07, 3.11-5.35; glaucoma cases 5.33, 3.77-7.67) in healthy eyes. The imprecision also was significantly higher for RTVue measurements in healthy compared to glaucomatous eyes. None of the other comparisons was statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS RTVue-100 showed higher imprecision (or higher measurement variability) than Cirrus HD-OCT and 3D OCT-1000 RNFL measurements. Three-dimensional cube scanning with post-hoc data sampling may be a factor reducing imprecision.

[1]  A. Sommer,et al.  An evaluation of optic disc and nerve fiber layer examinations in monitoring progression of early glaucoma damage. , 1992, Ophthalmology.

[2]  L. Zangwill,et al.  Discriminating between normal and glaucomatous eyes using the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph, GDx Nerve Fiber Analyzer, and Optical Coherence Tomograph. , 2001, Archives of ophthalmology.

[3]  L. Corrado.  Generalized Latent Variable Modeling: Multilevel, Longitudinal, and Structural Equation Models , 2005 .

[4]  F. Medeiros,et al.  Agreement between spectral-domain and time-domain OCT for measuring RNFL thickness , 2009, British Journal of Ophthalmology.

[5]  L. Labree,et al.  Factors associated with variability in retinal nerve fiber layer thickness measurements obtained by optical coherence tomography. , 2007, Ophthalmology.

[6]  John Fox,et al.  OpenMx: An Open Source Extended Structural Equation Modeling Framework , 2011, Psychometrika.

[7]  Wayne A. Fuller,et al.  Measurement Error Models , 1988 .

[8]  L. Zangwill,et al.  Detecting early glaucoma by assessment of retinal nerve fiber layer thickness and visual function. , 2001, Investigative ophthalmology & visual science.

[9]  F. Medeiros,et al.  Reproducibility of RTVue retinal nerve fiber layer thickness and optic disc measurements and agreement with Stratus optical coherence tomography measurements. , 2009, American journal of ophthalmology.

[10]  J. L. Jaech,et al.  Statistical Analysis of Measurement Errors. , 1986 .

[11]  G. Holló,et al.  Reproducibility of retinal nerve fiber layer and macular thickness measurement with the RTVue-100 optical coherence tomograph. , 2010, Ophthalmology.

[12]  J. Fujimoto,et al.  Reproducibility of nerve fiber layer thickness measurements using optical coherence tomography. , 1996, Ophthalmology.

[13]  A. Sommer,et al.  Clinically detectable nerve fiber atrophy precedes the onset of glaucomatous field loss. , 1991, Archives of ophthalmology.

[14]  H. Quigley,et al.  Number of ganglion cells in glaucoma eyes compared with threshold visual field tests in the same persons. , 2000, Investigative ophthalmology & visual science.

[15]  Veit Sturm,et al.  Reproducibility of nerve fiber layer thickness measurements using 3D fourier-domain OCT. , 2008, Investigative ophthalmology & visual science.

[16]  Robert N Weinreb,et al.  Comparison of the diagnostic accuracies of the Spectralis, Cirrus, and RTVue optical coherence tomography devices in glaucoma. , 2011, Ophthalmology.

[17]  F. Medeiros,et al.  Evaluation of retinal nerve fiber layer, optic nerve head, and macular thickness measurements for glaucoma detection using optical coherence tomography. , 2005, American journal of ophthalmology.

[18]  Sophia Rabe-Hesketh,et al.  Classical latent variable models for medical research , 2008, Statistical methods in medical research.

[19]  Wolfgang Drexler,et al.  State-of-the-art retinal optical coherence tomography , 2008, Progress in Retinal and Eye Research.

[20]  E A Swanson,et al.  Quantification of nerve fiber layer thickness in normal and glaucomatous eyes using optical coherence tomography. , 1995, Archives of ophthalmology.