Trends in tools and approaches for modelling the energy transition

Abstract Energy system models are crucial to plan energy transition pathways and understand their impacts. A vast range of energy system modelling tools is available, providing modelling practitioners, planners, and decision-makers with multiple alternatives to represent the energy system according to different technical and methodological considerations. To better understand this landscape, here we identify current trends in the field of energy system modelling. First, we survey previous review studies, identifying their distinct focus areas and review methodologies. Second, we gather information about 54 energy system modelling tools directly from model developers and users. Unlike previous questionnaire-based studies solely focusing on technical descriptions, we include application aspects of the modelling tools, such as perceived policy-relevance, user accessibility, and model linkages. We find that, to assess the possible applications and to build a common understanding of the capabilities of these modelling tools, it is necessary to engage in dialogue with developers and users. We identify three main trends of increasing modelling of cross-sectoral synergies, growing focus on open access, and improved temporal detail to deal with planning future scenarios with high levels of variable renewable energy sources. However, key challenges remain in terms of representing high resolution energy demand in all sectors, understanding how tools are coupled together, openness and accessibility, and the level of engagement between tool developers and policy/decision-makers.

[1]  Juan Falgueras,et al.  A reflective characterisation of occasional user , 2017, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[2]  S. Kittelsen,et al.  Liberalizing European Energy Markets: An Economic Analysis , 2008 .

[3]  Nouredine Hadjsaid,et al.  Modelling the impacts of variable renewable sources on the power sector: Reconsidering the typology of energy modelling tools , 2015 .

[4]  Mei Zhao,et al.  Methods and tools for community energy planning: A review , 2015 .

[5]  Henrik Lund,et al.  Cross-border versus cross-sector interconnectivity in renewable energy systems , 2017 .

[6]  J.T.B.A. Kessels,et al.  Real-Time Distributed Economic Model Predictive Control for Complete Vehicle Energy Management , 2017 .

[7]  Nate Blair,et al.  System Advisor Model (SAM) General Description (Version 2017.9.5) , 2018 .

[8]  A. Faaij,et al.  Potential of Power-to-Methane in the EU energy transition to a low carbon system using cost optimization , 2018, Applied Energy.

[9]  Rasmus Søgaard Lund,et al.  Heat Roadmap Europe 4: Quantifying the Impact of Low-Carbon Heating and Cooling Roadmaps , 2018 .

[10]  Iain Staffell,et al.  The importance of open data and software: Is energy research lagging behind? , 2017 .

[11]  J. DeCarolis,et al.  The case for repeatable analysis with energy economy optimization models , 2012, 2001.10858.

[12]  Wolfram Sparber,et al.  Classification and challenges of bottom-up energy system models - A review , 2020, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[13]  Christian von Hirschhausen,et al.  Designing a Model for the Global Energy System—GENeSYS-MOD: An Application of the Open-Source Energy Modeling System (OSeMOSYS) , 2017 .

[14]  Constantine Stephanidis,et al.  Unified user interface design: designing universally accessible interactions , 2004, Interact. Comput..

[15]  Robbie Morrison,et al.  Energy system modeling: Public transparency, scientific reproducibility, and open development , 2018 .

[16]  Brian Ó Gallachóir,et al.  The impact of sub-hourly modelling in power systems with significant levels of renewable generation , 2014 .

[17]  P. A. Østergaard,et al.  Assessment and evaluation of flexible demand in a Danish future energy scenario , 2014 .

[18]  D. Vuuren,et al.  Integrated Assessment of Global Environmental Change with IMAGE 3.0 : Model description and policy applications , 2014 .

[19]  Neil Strachan,et al.  Soft-linking energy systems and GIS models to investigate spatial hydrogen infrastructure development in a low-carbon UK energy system , 2009 .

[20]  Russell McKenna,et al.  Reviewing energy system modelling of decentralized energy autonomy , 2020, 2011.05915.

[21]  Gerardo A. Pérez-Valdés,et al.  A multi-horizon stochastic programming model for the European power system , 2016 .

[22]  Backcasting as a policy tool: the role of values , 2012 .

[23]  Brian Ó Gallachóir,et al.  Soft-linking of a power systems model to an energy systems model , 2012 .

[24]  Christian Breyer,et al.  Scenarios for a sustainable energy system in the Åland Islands in 2030 , 2017 .

[25]  Alexander Zerrahn,et al.  Long-run power storage requirements for high shares of renewables: review and a new model , 2017 .

[26]  K. Gillingham,et al.  Assessment of primary impacts of a hydrogen economy in New Zealand using UniSyD , 2009 .

[27]  S. Rosenberger,et al.  Energy storage potential in the Northern German region Osnabrück-Steinfurt , 2016, 2016 International Energy and Sustainability Conference (IESC).

[28]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  Smart Energy Systems for coherent 100% renewable energy and transport solutions , 2015 .

[29]  Tom Brown,et al.  The impact of climate change on a cost-optimal highly renewable European electricity network , 2018, Applied Energy.

[30]  Paula Díaz Redondo,et al.  Modelling the Energy Future of Switzerland after the Phase Out of Nuclear Power Plants , 2015 .

[31]  Marie Münster,et al.  Balmorel open source energy system model , 2018 .

[32]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  Simulation versus Optimisation: Theoretical Positions in Energy System Modelling , 2017 .

[33]  Jacques Després,et al.  Development of a dispatch model of the European power system for coupling with a long-term foresight energy model , 2015 .

[34]  C. Cosmi,et al.  Regression analysis for energy demand projection: An application to TIMES-Basilicata and TIMES-Italy energy models , 2020 .

[35]  G. Krajačić,et al.  Zero carbon energy system of South East Europe in 2050 , 2016 .

[36]  Sunanda Sinha,et al.  Review of recent trends in optimization techniques for solar photovoltaic–wind based hybrid energy systems , 2015 .

[37]  Pantelis Capros,et al.  Energy-system modelling of the EU strategy towards climate-neutrality , 2019, Energy Policy.

[38]  Massimiliano Manfren,et al.  Paradigm shift in urban energy systems through distributed generation: Methods and models , 2011 .

[39]  Russ Hans Peter,et al.  POLES-JRC model documentation , 2017 .

[40]  Detlef Stolten,et al.  A review of current challenges and trends in energy systems modeling , 2018, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[41]  Fabian Scheller,et al.  Energy system optimization at the municipal level: An analysis of modeling approaches and challenges , 2019, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[42]  Narjes Abbasabadi,et al.  Urban energy use modeling methods and tools: A review and an outlook , 2019, Building and Environment.

[43]  Gabriel Bachner,et al.  Macroeconomic implications of switching to process-emission-free iron and steel production in Europe , 2019, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[44]  Francesco Gardumi,et al.  Comprehensive representation of models for energy system analyses: Insights from the Energy Modelling Platform for Europe (EMP-E) 2017 , 2018, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[45]  Semida Silveira,et al.  OSeMOSYS: The Open Source Energy Modeling System: An introduction to its ethos, structure and development , 2011 .

[46]  William D'haeseleer,et al.  Impact of the level of temporal and operational detail in energy-system planning models , 2016 .

[47]  Mattias Höjer,et al.  Determinism and backcasting in futures studies , 2000 .

[48]  Francesca Pianosi,et al.  How successfully is open-source research software adopted? Results and implications of surveying the users of a sensitivity analysis toolbox , 2020, Environ. Model. Softw..

[49]  Iain Staffell,et al.  Opening the black box of energy modelling: strategies and lessons learned , 2017, ArXiv.

[50]  Anders N. Andersen,et al.  Booster heat pumps and central heat pumps in district heating , 2016 .

[51]  Mark Jennings,et al.  A review of urban energy system models: Approaches, challenges and opportunities , 2012 .

[52]  M. Gargiulo,et al.  The role of modal shift in decarbonising the Scandinavian transport sector: Applying substitution elasticities in TIMES-Nordic , 2019, Applied Energy.

[53]  Adam Hawkes,et al.  Societal Transformations in Models for Energy and Climate Policy: The Ambitious Next Step , 2019 .

[55]  A. Fattahi,et al.  A systemic approach to analyze integrated energy system modeling tools: A review of national models , 2020, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[56]  Felix Cebulla,et al.  Raising awareness in model-based energy scenario studies—a transparency checklist , 2016 .

[57]  Johan Lilliestam,et al.  How modelers construct energy costs: Discursive elements in Energy System and Integrated Assessment Models , 2019, Energy Research & Social Science.

[58]  Patrik Söderholm,et al.  Challenges in top-down and bottom-up soft-linking: Lessons from linking a Swedish energy system model with a CGE model , 2017 .

[59]  Alastair R. Buckley,et al.  A review of energy systems models in the UK: Prevalent usage and categorisation , 2016 .

[60]  G. Krajačić,et al.  Modelling smart energy systems in tropical regions , 2018, Energy.

[61]  Maurizio Gargiulo,et al.  Bridging the gap using energy services: Demonstrating a novel framework for soft linking top-down and bottom-up models , 2019, Energy.

[62]  Sara Ben Amer,et al.  Too complicated and impractical? An exploratory study on the role of energy system models in municipal decision-making processes in Denmark , 2020 .

[63]  Mantzos Leonidas,et al.  POTEnCIA model description - version 0.9 , 2016 .

[64]  H. Lund,et al.  Heat Roadmap Chile: A national district heating plan for air pollution decontamination and decarbonisation , 2020 .

[65]  Jonas Allegrini,et al.  A review of modelling approaches and tools for the simulation of district-scale energy systems , 2015 .

[66]  H. Lund,et al.  Implementing cleaner heating solutions towards a future low-carbon scenario in Ireland , 2019, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[67]  Valentin Robu,et al.  A multi-sectoral approach to modelling community energy demand of the built environment , 2019, Energy Policy.

[68]  F. Haghighat,et al.  Integration of storage and renewable energy into district heating systems: A review of modelling and optimization , 2016 .

[69]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  Impact of Germany's energy transition on the Nordic power market – A market-based multi-region energy system model , 2016 .

[70]  I. Staffell,et al.  The Shape of Future Electricity Demand: Exploring Load Curves in 2050s Germany and Britain , 2015 .

[71]  C. Breyer,et al.  Status and perspectives on 100% renewable energy systems , 2019, Energy.

[72]  Wouter Nijs,et al.  Improved Representation of the European Power Grid in Long Term Energy System Models: Case Study of JRC-EU-TIMES , 2015 .

[73]  David Connolly,et al.  Smart energy and smart energy systems , 2017 .

[74]  Olga Ivanova,et al.  Using a hybrid hard-linked model to analyze reduced climate gas emissions from transport , 2018, Energy.

[75]  Laixiang Sun,et al.  Modelling the renewable transition: Scenarios and pathways for a decarbonized future using pymedeas, a new open-source energy systems model , 2020, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[76]  Neil Strachan,et al.  Take me to your leader: Using socio-technical energy transitions (STET) modelling to explore the role of actors in decarbonisation pathways , 2019, Energy Research & Social Science.

[77]  Sylvain Quoilin,et al.  Modelling Future EU Power Systems Under High Shares of Renewables: The Dispa-SET 2.1 open-source model , 2017 .

[78]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  A review of computer tools for analysing the integration of renewable energy into various energy systems , 2010 .

[79]  Hlynur Stefansson,et al.  Integrated energy systems’ modeling studies for sub-Saharan Africa: A scoping review , 2020 .

[80]  Dragan Cvetković,et al.  Survey of software tools for energy efficiency in a community , 2011 .

[81]  Subhes C. Bhattacharyya,et al.  A review of energy system models , 2010 .

[82]  Juan Pablo Jiménez Navarro,et al.  The potential of sector coupling in future European energy systems: Soft linking between the Dispa-SET and JRC-EU-TIMES models , 2020 .

[83]  Petros A. Pilavachi,et al.  Ex-post evaluation of European energy models , 2008 .

[84]  Ross Baldick,et al.  A strategic review of electricity systems models , 2010 .

[85]  Analysis of the European energy system under the aspects of flexibility and technological progress Call : H 2020-LCE-21-2015 , 2016 .

[86]  Philipp Kuhn.  Iteratives Modell zur Optimierung von Speicherausbau und -betrieb in einem Stromsystem mit zunehmend fluktuierender Erzeugung , 2012 .

[87]  Christian Klemm,et al.  Modeling and optimization of multi-energy systems in mixed-use districts: A review of existing methods and approaches , 2021 .

[88]  Tom Brown,et al.  PyPSA: Python for Power System Analysis , 2017, 1707.09913.

[89]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  Full energy system transition towards 100% renewable energy in Germany in 2050 , 2019, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[90]  Roland De Guio,et al.  Integrated energy planning in cities and territories: A review of methods and tools , 2013 .

[91]  Paul Gerard Tuohy,et al.  A modelling tool selection process for planning of community scale energy systems including storage and demand side management , 2018 .

[92]  W. Winiwarter,et al.  EU Reference Scenario 2016 - Energy, transport and GHG emissions Trends to 2050. , 2016 .

[93]  Mark Z. Jacobson,et al.  Impacts of Green New Deal Energy Plans on Grid Stability, Costs, Jobs, Health, and Climate in 143 Countries , 2019, One Earth.

[94]  Kalai Ramea,et al.  Achieving California's 80% greenhouse gas reduction target in 2050: Technology, policy and scenario analysis using CA-TIMES energy economic systems model , 2015 .

[95]  Nate Blair,et al.  Regional Energy Deployment System (ReEDS) Model Documentation: Version 2016 , 2016 .

[96]  Salman Khan,et al.  Simulating climate and energy policy with agent-based modelling: The Energy Modelling Laboratory (EMLab) , 2017, Environ. Model. Softw..

[97]  Markus Groissböck,et al.  Are open source energy system optimization tools mature enough for serious use? , 2019, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[98]  Farzad Rahimi Mougouei,et al.  Effective Approaches to Energy Planning and Classification of Energy Systems Models , 2017 .

[99]  Emanuela Colombo,et al.  Policy Decision Support for Renewables Deployment through Spatially Explicit Practically Optimal Alternatives , 2020 .

[100]  R. Loulou,et al.  Documentation for the TIMES Model PART I April 2005 , 2005 .

[101]  Stefan Pfenninger,et al.  Calliope: a multi-scale energy systems modelling framework , 2018, J. Open Source Softw..

[102]  Axel Gandy,et al.  Importance subsampling: improving power system planning under climate-based uncertainty , 2019, Applied Energy.

[103]  Goran Krajačić,et al.  Agent based modelling and energy planning – Utilization of MATSim for transport energy demand modelling , 2015 .

[104]  M. A. Cameron,et al.  Matching demand with supply at low cost in 139 countries among 20 world regions with 100% intermittent wind, water, and sunlight (WWS) for all purposes , 2018, Renewable Energy.

[105]  S. Iniyan,et al.  A review of energy models , 2006 .

[106]  Henrik Lund,et al.  Survey of energy system modelling tools - Results , 2021 .

[107]  M. Sahakian,et al.  A review of linking models and socio-technical transitions theories for energy and climate solutions , 2020, Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions.

[108]  A. Grunwald.  Energy futures: Diversity and the need for assessment , 2011 .

[109]  Nilay Shah,et al.  A review of policy analysis purpose and capabilities of electricity system models , 2016 .

[110]  S. Darby.  Demand response and smart technology in theory and practice: Customer experiences and system actors , 2020, Energy Policy.

[111]  Christos S. Ioakimidis,et al.  On the planning and analysis of Integrated Community Energy Systems: A review and survey of available tools , 2011 .

[112]  K. Sperling,et al.  Smart energy cities in a 100% renewable energy context , 2019 .

[113]  Frieder Borggrefe,et al.  The gap between energy policy challenges and model capabilities , 2019, Energy Policy.

[114]  E. Laes,et al.  What do energy modellers know? An ethnography of epistemic values and knowledge models , 2020, Energy Research & Social Science.

[115]  Adam Hawkes,et al.  Energy systems modeling for twenty-first century energy challenges , 2014 .

[116]  Christian Breyer,et al.  Vision and initial feasibility analysis of a recarbonised Finnish energy system for 2050 , 2016 .

[117]  M. M. Ardehali,et al.  General procedure for long-term energy-environmental planning for transportation sector of developing countries with limited data based on LEAP (long-range energy alternative planning) and EnergyPLAN , 2014 .

[118]  Emanuela Colombo,et al.  Soft-linking energy demand and optimisation models for local long-term electricity planning: An application to rural India , 2019, Energy.

[119]  Ñ.,et al.  Agent based modelling and energy planning – Utilization of MATSim for transport energy demand modelling , 2016 .

[120]  S. Bolwig,et al.  Climate-friendly but socially rejected energy-transition pathways: The integration of techno-economic and socio-technical approaches in the Nordic-Baltic region , 2020 .

[121]  S. Pfenninger,et al.  Renewables, nuclear, or fossil fuels? Scenarios for Great Britain’s power system considering costs, emissions and energy security , 2015 .

[122]  J. G. Slootweg,et al.  A review of multi-energy system planning and optimization tools for sustainable urban development , 2015, 2015 IEEE Eindhoven PowerTech.

[123]  Brian Vad Mathiesen,et al.  Smart Energy Europe: The technical and economic impact of one potential 100% renewable energy scenario for the European Union , 2016 .

[124]  Poul Alberg Østergaard,et al.  Reviewing EnergyPLAN simulations and performance indicator applications in EnergyPLAN simulations , 2015 .

[125]  Khizir Mahmud,et al.  A review of computer tools for modeling electric vehicle energy requirements and their impact on power distribution networks , 2016 .

[126]  Tom Brown,et al.  PyPSA-Eur: An open optimisation model of the European transmission system , 2018, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[127]  Stefano Moret,et al.  EnergyScope TD: A novel open-source model for regional energy systems , 2019 .

[128]  Lena Neij,et al.  Evaluating energy efficiency policies with energy-economy models , 2010 .

[129]  Jonathan L. Ho,et al.  Regional Energy Deployment System (ReEDS) Model Documentation: Version 2018 , 2019 .

[130]  Peter M. Haugan,et al.  A review of modelling tools for energy and electricity systems with large shares of variable renewables , 2018, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[131]  Walter Mérida,et al.  Optimization of distributed energy resources for electric vehicle charging and fuel cell vehicle refueling , 2020 .

[132]  Rasmus Søgaard Lund,et al.  IDA's Energy Vision 2050: A Smart Energy System strategy for 100% renewable Denmark , 2015 .

[133]  Emanuela Colombo,et al.  A multi-layer energy modelling methodology to assess the impact of heat-electricity integration strategies: The case of the residential cooking sector in Italy , 2019, Energy.

[134]  K. Dreborg.  Essence of backcasting , 1996 .

[135]  David Moser,et al.  Transition pathways optimization methodology through EnergyPLAN software for long-term energy planning , 2019, Applied Energy.

[136]  Dagnija Blumberga,et al.  Review of modelling energy transitions pathways with application to energy system flexibility , 2019, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[137]  Lars Nolting,et al.  Complexity profiles: A large-scale review of energy system models in terms of complexity , 2020, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[138]  Martin Junginger,et al.  Is a 100% renewable European power system feasible by 2050? , 2019, Applied Energy.

[139]  John Robinson.  Energy backcasting A proposed method of policy analysis , 1982 .

[140]  D. Thrän,et al.  Are decisions well supported for the energy transition? A review on modeling approaches for renewable energy policy evaluation , 2017 .

[141]  Mark Howells,et al.  Modeling the long-term impact of demand response in energy planning: The Portuguese electric system case study , 2018, Energy.

[142]  Danny Pudjianto,et al.  Analysis of Alternative UK Heat Decarbonisation Pathways , 2018 .

[143]  Marie Münster,et al.  Scenarios for sustainable heat supply and heat savings in municipalities - The case of Helsingor, Denmark , 2017 .

[144]  Andrew Rice,et al.  Open source software and crowdsourcing for energy analysis , 2012 .

[145]  N. V. Beeck.  Classification of Energy Models , 1999 .

[146]  Pantelis Capros,et al.  Outlook of the EU energy system up to 2050: The case of scenarios prepared for European Commission's “clean energy for all Europeans” package using the PRIMES model , 2018, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[147]  Carlos Silva,et al.  Demand response modeling: A comparison between tools , 2015 .

[148]  F. Piontek,et al.  REMIND - REgional Model of INvestments and Development , 2020 .

[149]  Poul Alberg Østergaard,et al.  Local smart energy systems and cross-system integration , 2018 .

[150]  Simone Ferrari,et al.  Assessment of tools for urban energy planning , 2019, Energy.

[151]  Luis J. de Miguel,et al.  MEDEAS: a new modeling framework integrating global biophysical and socioeconomic constraints , 2020, Energy & Environmental Science.

[152]  Poul Alberg Østergaard,et al.  Energy systems scenario modelling and long term forecasting of hourly electricity demand , 2015 .

[153]  T. Brown,et al.  Synergies of sector coupling and transmission reinforcement in a cost-optimised, highly renewable European energy system , 2018, Energy.

[154]  Wenying Chen,et al.  Modelling building’s decarbonization with application of China TIMES model☆ , 2016 .

[155]  Juha Kiviluoma,et al.  Methodology for modelling plug-in electric vehicles in the power system and cost estimates for a sys , 2011 .

[156]  Evangelos G. Kardakos,et al.  Modelling the energy transition: A nexus of energy system and economic models , 2018 .

[157]  Neil Strachan,et al.  A review of socio-technical energy transition (STET) models , 2015 .

[158]  Jan Jantzen,et al.  Business and socioeconomic assessment of introducing heat pumps with heat storage in small-scale district heating systems , 2019, Renewable Energy.

[159]  H. Madsen,et al.  Benefits and challenges of electrical demand response: A critical review , 2014 .

[160]  Rainer Elsland,et al.  Are open access models able to assess today's energy scenarios? , 2019, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[161]  Keywan Riahi,et al.  The MESSAGEix Integrated Assessment Model and the ix modeling platform (ixmp): An open framework for integrated and cross-cutting analysis of energy, climate, the environment, and sustainable development , 2019, Environ. Model. Softw..

[162]  Stefan Pfenninger,et al.  Dealing with multiple decades of hourly wind and PV time series in energy models: A comparison of methods to reduce time resolution and the planning implications of inter-annual variability , 2017 .

[163]  David Connolly,et al.  Heat Roadmap Europe: Quantitative comparison between the electricity, heating, and cooling sectors for different European countries , 2017 .

[164]  I. Keppo,et al.  Short term decisions for long term problems – The effect of foresight on model based energy systems analysis , 2010 .