Reading Comprehension Is Not Always the Product of Nonsense Word Decoding and Linguistic Comprehension: Evidence From Teenagers Who Are Extremely Poor Readers

In the influential "simple view of reading" (Gough & Tunmer, 1986), Reading Comprehension (R) = Decoding (D) × Linguistic Comprehension (C). To evaluate this model, this article explores the performance of 15-year-olds with severe reading delays. Results showed that D and C described reading comprehension better than D and verbal cognitive ability as long as nonword reading was used to measure D. If text-reading accuracy was used to index D, then verbal ability, not C, provided the best fit. An additive model (D + C) fitted the data well when either nonsense-word decoding or text-reading accuracy was used as an index of D. The addition of the product term (D × C) did not add to the predictive power of the model. Implications of findings for the simple view of reading are considered in the light of different measures of D.

[1]  C. Hulme,et al.  A longitudinal case study of developmental phonological dyslexia , 1989 .

[2]  V. Standish.  Skilled Reading with Impaired Phonology: A Case Study , 1996 .

[3]  Seymour.  FOUNDATIONS OF ORTHOGRAPHIC DEVELOPMENT , 1997 .

[4]  E. Funnell,et al.  Learning to read : psychology in the classroom , 1995 .

[5]  D. Francis,et al.  A Matthew effect for IQ but not for reading : results from a longitudinal study , 1995 .

[6]  W. Warde,et al.  THE COMPONENT MODEL OF READING: SIMPLE VIEW OF READING MADE A LITTLE MORE COMPLEX , 2000 .

[7]  Hugh W. Catts,et al.  Subgrouping Poor Readers on the Basis of Individual Differences in Reading-Related Abilities , 2003, Journal of learning disabilities.

[8]  Mary E. Curtis,et al.  Development of Components of Reading Skill. , 1980 .

[9]  Peter J. Hatcher,et al.  Phonemes, rhymes, and intelligence as predictors of children's responsiveness to remedial reading instruction: evidence from a longitudinal intervention study. , 1999, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[10]  R. Savage.  The 'Simple View' of Reading: Some evidence and possible implications , 2001 .

[11]  Betty Ann Levy,et al.  Reading and Its Development: Component Skills Approaches , 1990 .

[12]  M. Lovett,et al.  Treatment, subtype, and word type effects in dyslexic children's response to remediation , 1988, Brain and Language.

[13]  K. Stanovich.  The right and wrong places to look for the cognitive locus of reading disability , 1988, Annals of dyslexia.

[14]  Charles Hulme,et al.  Deficits in output phonology: an explanation of reading failure? Cognit , 1992 .

[15]  D. Share.  Phonological recoding and self-teaching: sine qua non of reading acquisition , 1995, Cognition.

[16]  Philip B. Gough,et al.  Decoding, Reading, and Reading Disability , 1986 .

[17]  K. Stanovich.  TOWARD AN INTERACTIVE-COMPENSATORY MODEL OF INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF READING FLUENCY , 1980 .

[18]  Jack M. Fletcher,et al.  Comprehension and Decoding: Patterns of Association in Children With Reading Difficulties , 1999 .

[19]  Maryanne Wolf,et al.  Reading Fluency and Its Intervention , 2001 .

[20]  Joy Stackhouse,et al.  Phonological dyslexia and dysgraphia—a developmental analysis , 1986 .

[21]  P. Aaron,et al.  Can Reading Disabilities Be Diagnosed Without Using Intelligence Tests? , 1991, Journal of learning disabilities.

[22]  H. Scarborough,et al.  Late-emerging reading disabilities. , 2003 .

[23]  Nancy Ewald Jackson,et al.  Resilient Readers? University Students Who Are Poor Recoders but Sometimes Good Text Comprehenders. , 2002 .

[24]  E. B. Huey.  The Psychology And Pedagogy Of Reading , 1908 .

[25]  K. Cain,et al.  The dissociation of word reading and text comprehension: Evidence from component skills , 2003 .

[26]  Kim A. Lindsey,et al.  Decoding and sight-word naming: Are they independent components of word recognition skill? , 1999 .

[27]  Ronald P. Carver,et al.  Predicting reading level in grades 1 to 6 from listening level and decoding level: Testing theory relevant to the simple view of reading , 1998 .

[28]  P. Aaron.  The Impending Demise of the Discrepancy Formula , 1997 .

[29]  Linda S. Siegel,et al.  Phonological Processing Deficits as the Basis of a Reading Disability , 1993 .

[30]  L. Siegel,et al.  Cognitive Functioning as Measured by the WISC-R , 2003, Journal of learning disabilities.

[31]  Rusan Chen,et al.  Prediction of Reading Ability: A Cross-Validation Study of the Simple View of Reading , 1997 .

[32]  James M. Royer,et al.  A cognitive theoretical approach to reading diagnostics , 1994 .

[33]  M. Snowling,et al.  Cognitive assessment of dyslexic students in higher education. , 2002, The British journal of educational psychology.

[34]  Philip H. K. Seymour,et al.  Beginning reading without phonology , 1986 .

[35]  K. Stanovich.  Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. , 1986 .

[36]  A F Jorm.  Children with reading and spelling retardation: functioning of whole-word and correspondence-rule mechanisms. , 1981, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[37]  Margaret J. Snowling,et al.  Semantic processing and the development of word-recognition skills: Evidence from children with reading comprehension difficulties. , 1998 .

[38]  J. Marshall,et al.  A case study of developmental phonological dyslexia. , 1983, British journal of psychology.

[39]  M. Wolf,et al.  The double-deficit hypothesis for the developmental dyslexias. , 1999 .

[40]  L. Siegel.  IQ Is Irrelevant to the Definition of Learning Disabilities , 1989, Journal of learning disabilities.

[41]  Phil A. Silva,et al.  Gender Bias in IQ-Discrepancy and Post-Discrepancy Definitions of Reading Disability , 2003, Journal of learning disabilities.

[42]  D. Share.  Phonological recoding and orthographic learning: A direct test of the self-teaching hypothesis. , 1999, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[43]  Richard J. Brown.  Neuropsychology Mental Structure , 1989 .

[44]  Ruth Fielding-Barnsley,et al.  Evaluation of a program to teach phonemic awareness to young children: A 2- and 3-year follow-up and a new preschool trial. , 1995 .

[45]  M. Snowling,et al.  A Longitudinal Study of Reading Development in Dyslexic Children. , 1996 .

[46]  S. Hecht,et al.  Explaining the Predictive Accuracy of Teacher Judgments of Their Students' Reading Achievement: The Role of Gender, Classroom Behavior, and Emergent Literacy Skills in a Longitudinal Sample of Children Exposed to Poverty , 2002 .

[47]  J. Healy.  The Enigma of Hyperlexia. , 1982 .

[48]  E. Funnell,et al.  Lexical Capture: A Developmental Disorder of Reading and Spelling , 1989, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[49]  L. Thompson,et al.  The Role of IQ in a Component Model of Reading , 2003, Journal of learning disabilities.

[50]  J. Gombert,et al.  Phonological awareness as a predictor of recoding skills and syntactic awareness as a predictor of comprehension skills , 1996 .

[51]  Peter Freebody,et al.  Word-Reading Strategies in Elementary School Children: Relations to Comprehension, Reading Time, and Phonemic Awareness. , 1988 .

[52]  C. Sawyer,et al.  Handwriting Speed, Specific Learning Difficulties and the GCSE , 1992 .

[53]  H. Swanson,et al.  Cognitive Processes as Predictors of Word Recognition and Reading Comprehension in Learning-Disabled and Skilled Readers: Revisiting the Specificity Hypothesis. , 1997 .

[54]  R. Joshi.  A Diagnostic Procedure Based on Reading Component Model , 1999 .

[55]  M. Bruck.  Persistence of dyslexics' phonological awareness deficits. , 1992 .

[56]  K. Stanovich.  Changing models of reading and reading acquisition. , 1991 .

[57]  K. Nation,et al.  Assessing reading difficulties: the validity and utility of current measures of reading skill. , 1997, The British journal of educational psychology.

[58]  M. Bruck.  Word Recognition and Component Phonological Processing Skills of Adults with Childhood Diagnosis of Dyslexia , 1993 .

[59]  R. Campbell,et al.  Phonological Dyslexia and Dysgraphia in a Highly Literate Subject: A Developmental Case with Associated Deficits of Phonemic Processing and Awareness , 1985, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.