Workshop on acceleration of the validation and regulatory acceptance of alternative methods and implementation of testing strategies.

This report describes the proceedings of the BfR-RIVM workshop on validation of alternative methods which was held 23 and 24 March 2017 in Berlin, Germany. Stakeholders from governmental agencies, regulatory authorities, universities, industry and the OECD were invited to discuss current problems concerning the regulatory acceptance and implementation of alternative test methods and testing strategies, with the aim to develop feasible solutions. Classical validation of alternative methods usually involves one to one comparison with the gold standard animal study. This approach suffers from the reductionist nature of an alternative test as compared to the animal study as well as from the animal study being considered as the gold standard. Modern approaches combine individual alternatives into testing strategies, for which integrated and defined approaches are emerging at OECD. Furthermore, progress in mechanistic toxicology, e.g. through the adverse outcome pathway approach, and in computational systems toxicology allows integration of alternative test battery results into toxicity predictions that are more fine-tuned to the human situation. The road towards transition to a mechanistically-based human-focused hazard and risk assessment of chemicals requires an open mind towards stepping away from the animal study as the gold standard and defining human biologically based regulatory requirements for human hazard and risk assessment.

[1]  Silke Gabbert,et al.  A Tutorial for Analysing the Cost-effectiveness of Alternative Methods for Assessing Chemical Toxicity: The Case of Acute Oral Toxicity Prediction , 2014, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[2]  Andrew Worth,et al.  Applying Adverse Outcome Pathways (AOPs) to support Integrated Approaches to Testing and Assessment (IATA). , 2014, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[3]  Mirjam Luijten,et al.  A critical appraisal of the process of regulatory implementation of novel in vivo and in vitro methods for chemical hazard and risk assessment , 2014, Critical reviews in toxicology.

[4]  山上 鋭享 Globally Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals (GHS) 化学品の分類および表示に関する世界調和システム , 2007 .

[5]  Carmichael Neil,et al.  ESAC Opinion on the use of Performance Standards to evaluate test methods similar to a Validated Reference Method , 2016 .

[6]  George Daston,et al.  Framework for identifying chemicals with structural features associated with the potential to act as developmental or reproductive toxicants. , 2013, Chemical research in toxicology.

[7]  CChem FRSC,et al.  Guidelines for the testing of chemicals for mutagenicity. Committee on Mutagenicity of Chemicals in Food, Consumer Products and the Environment. , 1989, Reports on health and social subjects.

[8]  Valérie Zuang,et al.  A Modular Approach to the ECVAM Principles on Test Validity , 2004, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[9]  Silke Gabbert,et al.  The borderline range of toxicological methods: Quantification and implications for evaluating precision. , 2017, ALTEX.

[10]  OECD GUIDELINE FOR THE TESTING OF CHEMICALS In Vitro Membrane Barrier Test Method for Skin Corrosion , 2006 .

[11]  Robert Landsiedel,et al.  Applicability of in vitro tests for skin irritation and corrosion to regulatory classification schemes: substantiating test strategies with data from routine studies. , 2012, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[12]  Silke Gabbert,et al.  Sequential Testing of Chemicals When Costs Matter: A Value of Information Approach , 2013 .

[13]  Markus Schulz,et al.  Refinement and Reduction of Acute Oral Toxicity Testing: A Critical Review of the Use of Cytotoxicity Data , 2011, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[14]  Silvia Casati,et al.  Performance standards and alternative assays: practical insights from skin sensitization. , 2013, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[15]  Joanna Jaworska Integrated Testing Strategies for Skin Sensitization Hazard and Potency Assessment—State of the Art and Challenges , 2016 .

[16]  Michael Schubert,et al.  Retinoic acid signaling in development: Tissue‐specific functions and evolutionary origins , 2008, Genesis.

[17]  GabbertSilke,et al.  A Critical Review of Adverse Outcome Pathway-Based Concepts and Tools for Integrating Information from Nonanimal Testing Methods: The Case of Skin Sensitization , 2017 .

[18]  TG 442D OECD GUIDELINE FOR THE TESTING OF CHEMICALS In Vitro Skin Sensitisation: ARE-Nrf2 Luciferase Test Method , 2000 .

[19]  Daniel L Villeneuve,et al.  Adverse outcome pathways: A conceptual framework to support ecotoxicology research and risk assessment , 2010, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[20]  Robert Landsiedel,et al.  Lacking applicability of in vitro eye irritation methods to identify seriously eye irritating agrochemical formulations: Results of bovine cornea opacity and permeability assay, isolated chicken eye test and the EpiOcular™ ET‐50 method to classify according to UN GHS , 2017, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[21]  Robert Landsiedel,et al.  Experience with local lymph node assay performance standards using standard radioactivity and nonradioactive cell count measurements , 2012, Journal of applied toxicology : JAT.

[22]  Robert Landsiedel,et al.  Acute Oral Toxicity Testing: Scientific Evidence and Practicability Should Govern Three Rs Activities , 2016, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[23]  OECD GUIDELINE FOR THE TESTING OF CHEMICALS Short Time Exposure In Vitro Test Method for Identifying i ) Chemicals Inducing Serious Eye Damage and ii ) Chemicals Not Requiring Classification for Eye Irritation or Serious Eye Damage , 2016 .

[24]  Thomas B Knudsen,et al.  Computational modeling and simulation of genital tubercle development. , 2016, Reproductive toxicology.

[25]  Petra S Kern,et al.  Assessing skin sensitization hazard in mice and men using non-animal test methods. , 2015, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[26]  Silke Gabbert,et al.  Evaluation of Non-animal Methods for Assessing Skin Sensitisation Hazard: A Bayesian Value-of-Information Analysis , 2016, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[27]  Jeroen L A Pennings,et al.  An adverse outcome pathway framework for neural tube and axial defects mediated by modulation of retinoic acid homeostasis. , 2015, Reproductive toxicology.

[28]  Thomas Hartung,et al.  Integrated Testing Strategies (ITS) for safety assessment. , 2015, ALTEX.

[29]  Irene Manou,et al.  Knowledge sharing to facilitate regulatory decision-making in regard to alternatives to animal testing: Report of an EPAA workshop. , 2015, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[30]  Robert Landsiedel,et al.  Regulatory accepted but out of domain: In vitro skin irritation tests for agrochemical formulations , 2017, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[31]  Yu-Mei Tan,et al.  Adverse Outcome Pathways—Organizing Toxicological Information to Improve Decision Making , 2016, The Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics.

[32]  Francesco Falciani,et al.  Adverse Outcome Pathways for Regulatory Applications: Examination of Four Case Studies With Different Degrees of Completeness and Scientific Confidence. , 2015, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[33]  REVISED DRAFT OECD GUIDELINE FOR THE TESTING OF CHEMICALS Fluorescein Leakage Test Method for Identifying Ocular Corrosives and Severe Irritants , 2010 .

[34]  Hans Raabe,et al.  The Bovine Corneal Opacity and Permeability Test in Routine Ocular Irritation Testing and its Improvement within the Limits of OECD Test Guideline 437 , 2011, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[35]  Catherine Mahony,et al.  Aligning the 3Rs with new paradigms in the safety assessment of chemicals. , 2015, Toxicology.

[36]  Andrew P Worth,et al.  Integrated Approaches to Testing and Assessment. , 2016, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[37]  Sebastian Hoffmann,et al.  LLNA variability: An essential ingredient for a comprehensive assessment of non-animal skin sensitization test methods and strategies. , 2015, ALTEX.

[38]  Silvia Casati Contact hypersensitivity: Integrated Approaches to Testing and Assessment , 2017 .

[39]  Test No. 438: Isolated Chicken Eye Test Method for Identifying i) Chemicals Inducing Serious Eye Damage and ii) Chemicals Not Requiring Classification for Eye Irritation or Serious Eye Damage , 2018, OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals, Section 4.

[40]  Emilio Benfenati,et al.  In silico tools and transcriptomics analyses in the mutagenicity assessment of cosmetic ingredients: a proof-of-principle on how to add weight to the evidence. , 2016, Mutagenesis.

[41]  David Dix,et al.  A Computational Model Predicting Disruption of Blood Vessel Development , 2013, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[42]  Vera Rogiers,et al.  Retrospective analysis of the mutagenicity/genotoxicity data of the cosmetic ingredients present on the Annexes of the Cosmetic EU legislation (2000-12). , 2014, Mutagenesis.

[43]  Vera Rogiers,et al.  The Vitotox and ToxTracker assays: A two-test combination for quick and reliable assessment of genotoxic hazards. , 2016, Mutation research.

[44]  Test No. 492: Reconstructed human Cornea-like Epithelium (RhCE) test method for identifying chemicals not requiring classification and labelling for eye irritation or serious eye damage , 2019, OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals, Section 4.

[45]  Anne Marie Api,et al.  Chemical applicability domain of the Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA) for skin sensitisation potency. Part 3. Apparent discrepancies between LLNA and GPMT sensitisation potential: False positives or differences in sensitivity? , 2016, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[46]  Nancy C Baker,et al.  Computational Model of Secondary Palate Fusion and Disruption. , 2017, Chemical research in toxicology.

[47]  Antony J. Williams,et al.  ToxCast Chemical Landscape: Paving the Road to 21st Century Toxicology. , 2016, Chemical research in toxicology.