Measuring the Returns to R&D

We review the econometric literature on measuring the returns to R&D. The theoretical frameworks that have been used are outlined, followed by an extensive discussion of measurement and econometric issues that arise when estimating the models. We then provide a series of tables summarizing the major results that have been obtained and conclude with a presentation of R&D spillover returns measurement. In general, the private returns to R&D are strongly positive and somewhat higher than those for ordinary capital, while the social returns are even higher, although variable and imprecisely measured in many cases.

[1]  Z. Griliches Market Value, R&D, and Patents , 1981 .

[2]  Min-Hsien Chiang,et al.  International R&D Spillovers: An Application of Estimation and Inference in Panel Cointegration , 1999 .

[3]  L. Raut,et al.  R & D spillover and productivity growth: Evidence from Indian private firms , 1995 .

[4]  Michele Cincera,et al.  International R&D spillovers: a survey , 2001 .

[5]  Stephen Bond,et al.  GMM Estimation with persistent panel data: an application to production functions , 1999 .

[6]  B. Smith,et al.  Technology, R&D, and the economy , 1996 .

[7]  S. Nguyen,et al.  Measuring total factor productivity, technical change and the rate of returns to research and development , 1992 .

[8]  Robert Arnold R&D and Productivity Growth , 2005 .

[9]  A. Jaffe Real Effects of Academic Research , 1989 .

[10]  Albert N. Link,et al.  Firm Size, University Based Research, and the Returns to R&D , 1990 .

[11]  Bronwyn H Hall,et al.  The Private and Social Returns to Research and Development , 1996 .

[12]  Elhanan Helpman,et al.  International R&D spillovers , 1995 .

[13]  Sergio Perelman,et al.  R&D, Technological Progress and Efficiency Change in Industrial Activities , 1995 .

[14]  Ingmar R. Prucha,et al.  R&D, production structure and rates of return in the U.S., Japanese and German manufacturing sectors: A non-separable dynamic factor demand model , 1986 .

[15]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Issues in Assessing the Contribution of Research and Development to Productivity Growth , 1979 .

[16]  Cristiano Antonelli,et al.  Technological districts localized spillovers and productivity growth. The Italian evidence on technological externalities in the core regions , 1994 .

[17]  Bruno Van Pottelsberghe,et al.  R&D and productivity growth: a panel data analysis of 16 OECD countries , 2001 .

[18]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Productivity and R and D at the Firm Level , 1981 .

[19]  John W. Paterson,et al.  Science in Agriculture , 1923, Nature.

[20]  Giuseppe Medda,et al.  On the Relationship between R&D and Productivity: A Treatment Effect Analysis , 2003 .

[21]  J. Bernstein,et al.  Canadian-Japanese R&D spillovers and productivity growth , 1996 .

[22]  T. Bresnahan Measuring the Spillovers from Technical Advance: Mainframe Computers inFinancial Services , 1986 .

[23]  B. Kogut,et al.  Localization of Knowledge and the Mobility of Engineers in Regional Networks , 1999 .

[24]  G. Cameron Why Did UK Manufacturing Productivity Growth Slow Down in the 1970s and Speed Up in the 1980s? , 2003 .

[25]  Theofanis P. Mamuneas,et al.  Depreciation , Stocks , User Costs and Productivity Growth for US Knowledge Intensive Industries , 2004 .

[26]  M. Kafouros R&D and productivity growth: Evidence from the UK , 2005 .

[27]  Ariel Pakes,et al.  Estimates of the Value of Patent Rights in European Countries During Thepost-1950 Period , 1985 .

[28]  J. Bernstein International R&D Spillovers Between Industries in Canada and the United States , 1994 .

[29]  Edward N. Wolff,et al.  Spillover effects, linkage structure, and research and development , 1993 .

[30]  Z. Griliches Productivity, R&D, and the Data Constraint , 1998 .

[31]  Pierre Mohnen,et al.  International R&D Spillovers between U.S. And Japanese R&D Intensive Sectors , 1994 .

[32]  Jacques Mairesse,et al.  Exploring the Relationship between R&D and Productivity in French Manufacturing Firms , 1992 .

[33]  P. Mohnen The relationship between R&D and productivity growth in Canada and other major industrialized countries , 1992 .

[34]  Barry J. Seldon A Nonresidual Estimation of Welfare Gains from Research: The Case of Public R&D in a Forest Product Industry , 1987 .

[35]  Bruno Crépon,et al.  Research, Innovation, and Productivity: an Econometric Analysis at the Firm Level , 1998 .

[36]  Frederic M. Scherer,et al.  Inter-Industry Technology Flows and Productivity Growth , 1982 .

[37]  Hiroyuki Odagiri,et al.  The impact of R&D on productivity increase in Japanese manufacturing companies , 1986 .

[38]  D. Bosworth The Rate of Obsolescence of Technical Knowledge-A Note , 1978 .

[39]  Edwin Mansfield,et al.  Basic Research and Productivity Increase in Manufacturing , 1980 .

[40]  Edwin Mansfield,et al.  Social and Private Rates of Return from Industrial Innovations , 1977 .

[41]  D. Harhoff,et al.  Corporate R&D and productivity in Germany and the United Kingdom , 2003 .

[42]  Paul A. David,et al.  Heart of Darkness: Public-Private Interaction Inside the R&D Black Box , 1999 .

[43]  G. Leeuwen,et al.  R&D and productivity growth: evidence from firm-level data for the Netherlands , 1996 .

[44]  J. Bernstein,et al.  The Structure of Canadian Inter-industry R&D Spillovers, and the Rates of Return to R&D , 1989 .

[45]  Jiann-Chyuan Wang,et al.  Productivity Growth and R&D Expenditure in Taiwan's Manufacturing Firms , 2003 .

[46]  I. Prucha,et al.  Sources of growth of output and convergence of productivity in major OECD countries , 1997 .

[47]  J. Bernstein,et al.  Product Demand, Cost of Production, Spillovers, and the Social Rate of Return to R&D , 1991 .

[48]  P. Cuneo L'impact de la recherche et développement sur la productivité industrielle , 1984 .

[49]  F. Lichtenberg,et al.  The Impact of R&D Investment on Productivity - New Evidence Using Linked R&D-Lrd Data , 1989 .

[50]  Bronwyn H Hall,et al.  Measuring the Returns to R&D: The Depreciation Problem , 2007 .

[51]  Maryann P. Feldman,et al.  Real Effects of Academic Research: Comment , 1992 .

[52]  Bronwyn H Hall,et al.  Does Cash Flow Cause Investment and R&D?: An Exploration Using Panel Data for French, Japanese, and United States Scientific Firms , 1998 .

[53]  William R. Kerr,et al.  Ethnic Scientific Communities and International Technology Diffusion , 2007, The Review of Economics and Statistics.

[54]  P. Mohnen,et al.  Recherche-Développement et productivité: un survol de la littérature économétrique , 1990 .

[55]  Frederic M. Scherer,et al.  Corporate Inventive Output, Profits, and Growth , 1965, Journal of Political Economy.

[56]  D. Harhoff R&D Spillovers, Technological Proximity, and Productivity Growth — Evidence from German Panel Data , 2000 .

[57]  M. Sassenou Recherche-développement et productivité dans les entreprises japonaises : une étude économétrique sur données de panel , 1988 .

[58]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Patents and R&D: is There a Lag? , 1984 .

[59]  P. Mohnen,et al.  The Importance of R&D and Innovation for Productivity: A Reexamination in Light of the 2000 French Innovation Survey , 2005 .

[60]  Petri Rouvinen The existence of R&D spillovers: A cost function estimation with random coefficients , 2002 .

[61]  Tadashi Yamada,et al.  Labor Productivity and Market Competition in Japan , 1991 .

[62]  P. Reiss,et al.  Cost-Reducing and Demand-Creating R&D with Spillovers , 1988 .

[63]  E. Bartelsman Federally sponsored R&D and productivity growth , 1990 .

[64]  A. Pakes,et al.  The Rate of Obsolescence of Knowledge, Research Gestation Lags, and the Private Rate of Return to Research Resources , 1979 .

[65]  Z. Griliches Research Costs and Social Returns: Hybrid Corn and Related Innovations , 1958, Journal of Political Economy.

[66]  M. Nadiri,et al.  Innovations and Technological Spillovers , 1993 .

[67]  Peter Hanel L’effet des dépenses en R&D sur la productivité de travail au Québec , 2009 .

[68]  J. Bernstein International R&D Spillovers between Industries in Canada and the United States, Social Rates of Return and Productivity Growth , 1996 .

[69]  Ulrich Kaiser Measuring knowledge spillovers in manufacturing and services: an empirical assessment of alternative approaches , 2002 .

[70]  Leonard Solomon Silk,et al.  Communicating Economic Ideas and Controversies , 1986 .

[71]  P. Hanel R&D, Inter-Industry and International Spillovers of Technology and the Total Factor Productivity Growth of Manufacturing Industries in Canada, 1974 - 1989 , 1994 .

[72]  M. Nadiri,et al.  Interindustry R&D Spillovers, Rates of Return, and Production in High-Tech Industries , 1988 .

[73]  James D. Adams,et al.  Fundamental Stocks of Knowledge and Productivity Growth , 1990, Journal of Political Economy.

[74]  Michele Cincera,et al.  Exploring the Spillover Impact on Productivity of World-Wide Manufacturing Firms , 1998 .

[75]  M. Piva SOME GUIDELINES FOR EUROPEAN RESEARCH POLICY , 2009 .

[76]  Ulrich Doraszelski,et al.  R&D and productivity: The knowledge capital model revisited ⁄ , 2006 .

[77]  Heart of darkness: modeling public-private funding interactions inside the R&D black box , 2000 .

[78]  Wesley M. Cohen,et al.  Empirical studies of innovation and market structure , 1989 .

[79]  Akira Goto,et al.  R&D Capital, Rate of Return on R&D Investment and Spillover of R&D in Japanese Manufacturing Industries , 1989 .

[80]  H. Capron Economic quantitative methods for the evaluation of the impact of R&D programmes. A state-of-the-art. EUR 14864 EN. Research evaluation , 1993 .

[81]  M. Rogers R&D and productivity: using UK firm-level data to inform policy , 2010 .

[82]  Elhanan Helpman,et al.  North-South R & D Spillovers , 1997 .

[83]  J. Bernstein Factor Intensities, Rates of Return, and International R&D Spillovers: The Case of Canadian and U.S. Industries , 1998 .

[84]  Jacques Mairesse,et al.  R&D Productivity: A Survey of Econometric Studies at the Firm Level , 1991 .

[85]  V. Ruttan Bureaucratic productivity: The case of agricultural research , 1978 .

[86]  Walter G. Park,et al.  INTERNATIONAL R&D SPILLOVERS AND OECD ECONOMIC GROWTH , 1995 .

[87]  J. Bernstein,et al.  Rates of Return on Physical and R&D Capital and Structure of the Production Process: Cross Section and Time Series Evidence , 1988 .

[88]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Interindustry Technology Flows and Productivity Growth: A Reexamination , 1984 .

[89]  J. Mairesse,et al.  Recherche-développement et performances des entreprises: une étude économétrique sur données individuelles , 1985 .

[90]  Samuel Kortum,et al.  Research, Patenting, and Technological Change , 1997 .

[91]  C.-Y. Cynthia Lin,et al.  Measuring the social rate of return to R&D in coal, petroleum and nuclear manufacturing: A study of the OECD countries , 2011 .

[92]  Research activity, output growth and productivity increase in Japanese manufacturing industries , 1985 .

[93]  J. Bernstein,et al.  International R&D Spillovers between Canadian and Japanese Industries , 1995 .

[94]  P. Mohnen,et al.  Productivity and Research and Development in Two Canadian Forest Product Industries , 1996, Forest Science.

[95]  T. Klette On the importance of R&D and ownership for productivity growth: Evidence from Norwegian Micro-Data 1976-85 , 1991 .

[96]  M. Alpers,et al.  Research and Development , 1960, Nature.

[97]  A. Torre Quand les économistes mesurent l'intangible , 1990 .

[98]  Wolfgang Keller,et al.  Are International R&D Spillovers Trade-Related? Analyzing Spillovers Among Randomly Matched Trade Partners , 1997 .

[99]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Returns to Research and Development Expenditures in the Private Sector , 1998 .

[100]  Z. Griliches Research Expenditures and Growth Accounting , 1973 .

[101]  Theofanis P. Mamuneas,et al.  The Effects of Public Infrastructure and R&D Capital on the Cost Structure and Performance of U.S. Manufacturing Industries , 1991 .

[102]  Mark A. Schankerman,et al.  Identifying Technology Spillovers and Product Market Rivalry , 2005 .

[103]  L. Grünfeld International R&D Spillovers and , 2002 .

[104]  Bronwyn H Hall The Effect of Takeover Activity on Corporate Research and Development , 1987 .

[105]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Productivity Growth and R&D at the Business Level: Results from the Pims Data Base , 1982 .

[106]  F. Scherer Concentration, R&D, and Productivity Change , 1983 .

[107]  B. Weisbrod Costs and Benefits of Medical Research: A Case Study of Poliomyelitis , 1971, Journal of Political Economy.

[108]  Laurent Bach,et al.  Measuring and Managing Spinoffs: The Case of the Spinoffs Generated by ESA programs , 1992 .

[109]  Theofanis P. Mamuneas,et al.  R&D depreciation, stocks, user costs and productivity growth for US R&D intensive industries , 2006 .

[110]  Bart Verspagen,et al.  R&D spillovers and productivity: Evidence from U.S. manufacturing microdata , 2000 .

[111]  Daniel E. Sichel,et al.  Intangible Capital and U.S. Economic Growth , 2006 .

[112]  Nathan Rosenberg,et al.  Inside the black box: How exogenous is science? , 1983 .

[113]  Bronwyn H Hall,et al.  Testing for Unit Roots in Panel Data: An Exploration Using Real and Simulated Data , 2006 .

[114]  Bettina Peters,et al.  Firm Level Innovation and Productivity - is There a Common Story Across Countries? , 2003 .

[115]  P. Mohnen,et al.  R&D, R&D spillovers and payments for technology: Canadian evidence , 1991 .

[116]  L. Soete,et al.  Recherche-développement, importations de technologie et croissance économique : une tentative de comparaison internationale , 1985 .

[117]  Rachel Griffith,et al.  How Special is the Special Relationship? Using the Impact of Us R&D Spillovers on UK Firms as a Test of Technology Sourcing , 2004 .

[118]  Elhanan Helpman,et al.  R&D Spillovers and Global Growth , 1996, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[119]  P. Mohnen International R&D Spillovers and Economic Growth , 2001 .

[120]  James D. Adams,et al.  Bounding the Effects of R&D an Investigation Using Matched Establishment-Firm Data , 1996 .

[121]  A. Pakes,et al.  The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment Industry , 1992 .

[122]  A. Link Inter-firm technology flows and productivity growth , 1983 .

[123]  R. Oriani,et al.  R & D and Financial Investors , 2009 .

[124]  David Greenaway,et al.  Imports, exports, knowledge spillovers and growth , 2004 .

[125]  Jora R. Minasian,et al.  Research and Development, Production Functions, and Rates of Return , 1969 .

[126]  Vittorio Chiesa,et al.  Evaluation and Performance Measurement of Research and Development , 2009 .

[127]  M. Nadiri Contributions and Determinants of Research and Development Expenditures in the U.S. Manufacturing Industries , 1979 .

[128]  Harsha Aturupane Poverty, human development and growth : an emerging consensus? , 1994 .

[129]  Mark Schankerman,et al.  The effects of double-counting and expensing on the measured returns to r&d , 1981 .

[130]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  R&D and the Productivity Slowdown , 1980 .

[131]  J. G. Tewksbury,et al.  Measuring the Societal Benefits of Innovation , 1980, Science.

[132]  Dominique Foray,et al.  Pitfalls in Estimating the Returns to Corporate R&D Using Accounting Data , 2007 .

[133]  D. Harhoff R&D and Productivity in German Manufacturing Firms , 1998 .

[134]  B. Verspagen R&D and productivity: A broad cross-section cross-country look , 1995 .

[135]  N. Terleckyj,et al.  Direct and Indirect Effects of Industrial Research and Development on the Productivity Growth of Industries , 1980 .

[136]  Mark Funk Trade and International R&D Spillovers among OECD Countries , 2001 .

[137]  A. Link Rates of Induced Technology from Investments in Research and Development , 1978 .

[138]  Ariel Pakes,et al.  Estimates of the Value of Patent Rights in European Countries During Thepost-1950 Period , 1985 .

[139]  Leo Sveikauskas R&D and Productivity Growth: A Review of the Literature , 2007 .

[140]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  R&D and Productivity: The Econometric Evidence , 2007 .

[141]  Leo Sveikauskas,et al.  Technological Inputs and Multifactor Productivity Growth , 1981 .

[142]  F. Lichtenberg,et al.  R&D Investment and International Productivity Differences , 1992 .

[143]  Bruno van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie,et al.  International R&D spillovers: A comment , 1998 .

[144]  Jerry A. Hausman,et al.  Errors in Variables in Panel Data , 1984 .

[145]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  R&D and Productivity Growth at the Industry Level: Is There Still a Relationship? , 1998 .

[146]  H. Meijl Measuring Intersectoral Spillovers: French Evidence , 1997 .

[147]  Daniel E. Sichel,et al.  Measuring Capital and Technology: An Expanded Framework , 2004 .

[148]  Alessandro Sterlacchini,et al.  R&D, innovations, and total factor productivity growth in British manufacturing , 1989 .

[149]  Andreas Stephan,et al.  A Schumpeter-inspired approach to the construction of R&D capital stocks , 2007 .

[150]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Empirical Patterns of Firm Growth and R&D Investment: A Quality Ladder Model Interpretation , 1997 .

[151]  C. I. Jones,et al.  Measuring the Social Return to R&D , 1997 .

[152]  Edwin Mansfield,et al.  Industrial R&D in Japan and the United States: A Comparative Study , 1988 .

[153]  F. Q. Raines,et al.  The impact of applied research and development on productivity , 1968 .

[154]  N. Rosenberg The Direction of Technological Change: Inducement Mechanisms and Focusing Devices , 1969, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[155]  Nadine Massard,et al.  Spatial knowledge diffusion through collaborative networks , 2007 .

[156]  Edwin Mansfield,et al.  R&D Price Indexes and Real R&D Expenditures in the United States , 1982 .

[157]  Sergio Perelman,et al.  Productivity growth and technical efficiency in OECD industrial activities , 1991 .

[158]  John J. McGowan,et al.  On the Misuse of Accounting Rates of Return to Infer Monopoly Profits , 1983 .

[159]  Z. Griliches The Search for R&D Spillovers , 1991 .

[160]  Paul Geroski,et al.  Entry, innovation and productivity growth , 1989 .

[161]  Luc Soete,et al.  Technology and growth: the complex dynamics of catching up, falling behind and taking over , 1993 .

[162]  Gustavo Crespi,et al.  Productivity Growth, Knowledge Flows, and Spillovers , 2007 .

[163]  E. Bartelsman R&D spending and manufacturing productivity: an empirical analysis , 1990 .

[164]  J. Bernard,et al.  Defence Innovation Stock and Total Factor Productivity , 1992 .

[165]  F. M. Scherer,et al.  The lag structure of returns to research and development , 1982 .

[166]  A. Jaffe Technological Opportunity and Spillovers of R&D: Evidence from Firms&Apos; Patents, Profits and Market Value , 1986 .

[167]  Paul Stoneman,et al.  Handbook of the economics of innovation and technological change , 1995 .

[168]  Yaw Nyarko,et al.  Research and Productivity , 1995 .

[169]  Seongjun Kim,et al.  International R&D Spillovers, Trade and Productivity in Major OECD Countries , 1996 .

[170]  C. I. Jones,et al.  Too Much of a Good Thing? The Economics of Investment in R&D , 1999 .

[171]  M. Nadiri Sectoral Productivity Slowdown , 1980 .

[172]  Jacques Mairesse,et al.  Productivity and R&D at the Firm Level in French Manufacturing , 1983 .

[173]  John Vaizey,et al.  Science and Technology in Economic Growth , 1973 .

[174]  Stefan C. Norrbin,et al.  The Relation between Price and Marginal Cost in U.S. Industry: A Contradiction , 1993, Journal of Political Economy.

[175]  Lee G. Branstetter Looking for International Knowledge Spillovers A Review of the Literature with Suggestions for New Approaches , 1998 .

[176]  J. Bernstein Costs of Production, Intra- and Interindustry R&D Spillovers: Canadian Evidence , 1988 .

[177]  Bart Nooteboom,et al.  Optimal Cognitive Distance and Absorptive Capacity , 2005 .

[178]  A. Jaffe Demand and Supply Influences in R&D Intensity and Productivity Growth , 1988 .

[179]  Kazuyuki Suzuki,et al.  R&D spillovers and technology transfer among and within vertical keiretsu groups: Evidence from the Japanese electrical machinery industry , 1993 .

[180]  Zvi Griliches,et al.  Productivity, R&D, and Basic Research at the Firm Level in the 1970s , 1985 .

[181]  P. Mohnen,et al.  Is inter-firm labor mobility a channel of knowledge spillovers? Evidence from a linked employer--employee panel , 2009 .

[182]  Z. Griliches,et al.  Patents and R and D: Is There a Lag? , 1986 .

[183]  A. Chakrabarti,et al.  Defence and space expenditures in the US: An inter-firm analysis , 1992 .

[184]  Bronwyn H. Hall,et al.  Industrial Research During the 1980s: Did the Rate of Return Fall? , 1993 .

[185]  Mariacristina Piva,et al.  Is Corporate R&D Investment in High-Tech Sectors More Effective? , 2009 .

[186]  Manuel Trajtenberg,et al.  The Welfare Analysis of Product Innovations, with an Application to Computed Tomography Scanners , 1989, Journal of Political Economy.

[187]  F. Scherer,et al.  Using Linked Patent and R&D Data to Measure Interindustry Technology Flows , 1984 .

[188]  Bait Verspagen,et al.  Estimating international technology spillovers using technology flow matrices , 1997 .

[189]  Knowledge Flows and Productivity , 2004 .

[190]  Katharina Wakelin,et al.  Productivity growth and R&D expenditure in UK manufacturing firms , 2001 .

[191]  T. Klette R&D, Scope Economies and Company Structure: A "Not-so-Fixed Effect" Model of Plant Performance , 1994 .

[192]  Petr Hanel,et al.  Effects of R & D Spillovers on the Profitability of Firms , 2002 .

[193]  S. Perelman,et al.  Productivity growth, technological progress and R&D in OECD industrial activities , 1990 .

[194]  Elhanan Helpman,et al.  International R&D Spillovers and Institutions , 2008 .

[195]  C. Debresson,et al.  L' analyse inter-industrielle et le changement technologique , 1990 .

[196]  Stephen J. Redding,et al.  Mapping The Two Faces Of R&D: Productivity Growth In A Panel Of OECD Industries , 2000 .

[197]  W. N. Leonard Research and Development in Industrial Growth , 1971, Journal of Political Economy.

[198]  Carmine Ornaghi,et al.  Spillovers in product and process innovation: Evidence from manufacturing firms , 2006 .

[199]  I. Prucha,et al.  Comparison and Analysis of Productivity Growth and R&D Investment in Theelectrical Machinery Industries of the United States and Japan , 1986 .

[200]  Bronwyn H Hall,et al.  Innovation and Market Value , 1998 .

[201]  Bruno van Pottelsberghe de la Potterie,et al.  Does Foreign Direct Investment Transfer Technology Across Borders? , 2001, Review of Economics and Statistics.

[202]  B. Lev Intangibles: Management, Measurement, and Reporting , 2001 .

[203]  D. Emmanuel Innovation height, spillovers and TFP growth at the firm level: Evidence from French manufacturing , 2004 .

[204]  Z. Griliches,et al.  R&D and Productivity Growth: Comparing Japanese and U.S. Manufacturing Firms , 1985 .

[205]  H. H. Postner,et al.  Canadian productivity growth : an alternative (input-output) analysis , 1985 .

[206]  J. Bernstein,et al.  Research and Development and Intraindustry Spillovers: an Empirical Application of Dynamic Duality , 1986 .

[207]  Theofanis P. Mamuneas,et al.  The Effects of Public Infrastructure and R&D Capital on the Cost Structure and Performance of U.S. Manufacturing Industries , 1991 .

[208]  Matti Pohjola,et al.  Information technology, productivity, and economic growth : international evidence and implications for economic development , 2001 .

[209]  S. Globerman The empirical relationship between R and D and industrial growth in Canada , 1972 .