Does pretreatment severity moderate the efficacy of psychological treatment of adult outpatient depression? A meta-analysis.

OBJECTIVE It is widely believed that psychological treatment has little effect on more severely depressed patients. This study assessed whether pretreatment severity moderates psychological treatment outcome relative to controls by means of meta-analyses. METHOD We included 132 studies (10,134 participants) from a database of studies (www.evidencebasedpsychotherapies.org) in which the effects of psychological treatment on adult outpatients with a depressive disorder or an elevated level of depressive symptoms were compared with a control condition in a randomized controlled trial. Two raters independently extracted outcome data and rated study characteristics. We conducted metaregression analyses assessing whether mean pretreatment depression scores predicted psychological treatment versus control condition posttreatment effect size and subgroup analyses summarizing the results of studies reporting within-study analyses of depression severity and psychological treatment outcome. RESULTS Psychological treatment was found to be consistently superior to control conditions (d = 0.40-0.88). We found no indication that pretreatment mean depression scores predicted psychological treatment versus control condition posttreatment effect size, even after adjusting for relevant study characteristics. However, among the smaller subset of studies that reported within-study severity analyses, posttreatment effect sizes were higher for high-severity patients (d = 0.63) than for low-severity patients (d = 0.22) when psychological treatment was efficacious relative to a more stringent control. CONCLUSION Contrary to conventional wisdom, our findings suggest that when compared with control conditions, psychological treatment might be more efficacious for high-severity than for low-severity patients. Because the number of studies reporting within-study severity analyses is small, we recommend that future studies routinely report tests for Severity × Treatment interactions.

[1]  M. Hamilton,et al.  Development of a rating scale for primary depressive illness. , 1967, The British journal of social and clinical psychology.

[2]  M. Hautzinger,et al.  Kognitive Verhaltenstherapie bei Depressionen im Klimakterium , 2004 .

[3]  H. Kraemer,et al.  Mediators and moderators of treatment effects in randomized clinical trials. , 2002, Archives of general psychiatry.

[4]  P. Cuijpers,et al.  Effectiveness of the Coping With Depression (CWD) course for older adults provided by the community-based mental health care system in the Netherlands: a randomized controlled field trial , 2005, International Psychogeriatrics.

[5]  D. Hedeker,et al.  Initial severity and differential treatment outcome in the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. , 1995, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.

[6]  A. Beck,et al.  Beck Depression Inventory–II , 2011 .

[7]  G. Andersson,et al.  Are psychological and pharmacologic interventions equally effective in the treatment of adult depressive disorders? A meta-analysis of comparative studies. , 2008, The Journal of clinical psychiatry.

[8]  John C. Markowitz,et al.  Treatment and Prevention of Depression , 2002, Psychological science in the public interest : a journal of the American Psychological Society.

[9]  A. Beekman,et al.  Interpersonal psychotherapy for elderly patients in primary care. , 2006, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[10]  R. DeRubeis,et al.  Cognitive therapy vs medications in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. , 2005, Archives of general psychiatry.

[11]  M. Hamilton.  A RATING SCALE FOR DEPRESSION , 1960, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[12]  S D Imber,et al.  National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. General effectiveness of treatments. , 1989, Archives of general psychiatry.

[13]  J. Cox,et al.  Counselling in a general practice setting: controlled study of health visitor intervention in treatment of postnatal depression. , 1989, BMJ.

[14]  P. Lewinsohn,et al.  A psychoeducational approach to the treatment of depression: comparison of group, individual, and minimal contact procedures. , 1984, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[15]  J. Cullen.  Testing the Effectiveness of Behavioral Activation Therapy in the Treatment of Acute Unipolar Depression , 2002 .

[16]  S. Simpson,et al.  A randomized controlled trial to evaluate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of psychodynamic counselling for general practice patients with chronic depression , 2003, Psychological Medicine.

[17]  D. Altman,et al.  Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[18]  A. Hakstian,et al.  Clinical depression: comparative efficacy of outpatient treatments. , 1979, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[19]  David J. Kupfer,et al.  Size of Treatment Effects and Their Importance to Clinical Research and Practice , 2006, Biological Psychiatry.

[20]  P. Cuijpers,et al.  Characteristics of effective psychological treatments of depression: a metaregression analysis , 2008, Psychotherapy research : journal of the Society for Psychotherapy Research.

[21]  Gerhard Andersson,et al.  Adding psychotherapy to pharmacotherapy in the treatment of depressive disorders in adults: a meta-analysis. , 2009, The Journal of clinical psychiatry.

[22]  J. Greist,et al.  Computer-administered cognitive-behavioral therapy for depression. , 1990, The American journal of psychiatry.

[23]  W. Marshall,et al.  Experimental analysis of a cognitive-behavioral therapy for depression , 1977, Cognitive Therapy and Research.

[24]  David C. Atkins,et al.  Randomized trial of behavioral activation, cognitive therapy, and antidepressant medication in the acute treatment of adults with major depression. , 2006, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[25]  R. Bagby,et al.  The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale: has the gold standard become a lead weight? , 2004, The American journal of psychiatry.

[26]  G. Andersson,et al.  Is psychotherapy for depression equally effective in younger and older adults? A meta-regression analysis , 2009, International Psychogeriatrics.

[27]  M. Perri,et al.  Social problem-solving therapy for unipolar depression: an initial dismantling investigation. , 1989, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[28]  L. Teri,et al.  Behavioral treatment of depression in dementia patients: a controlled clinical trial. , 1997, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[29]  A. Whitehead.  Psychological treatment of depression: a review. , 1979, Behaviour research and therapy.

[30]  S. Hollon,et al.  Cognitive-behavior therapy versus pharmacotherapy: Now that the jury's returned its verdict, it's time to present the rest of the evidence. , 1996, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[31]  Lillian Comas-D az,et al.  Effects of cognitive and behavioral group treatment on the depressive symptomatology of Puerto Rican women. , 1981, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[32]  G. Andersson,et al.  The effects of psychotherapy for adult depression are overestimated: a meta-analysis of study quality and effect size , 2009, Psychological Medicine.

[33]  M. Lipsey,et al.  The efficacy of psychological, educational, and behavioral treatment. Confirmation from meta-analysis. , 1993, American Psychologist.

[34]  L. Comas-Díaz.  Effects of cognitive and behavioral group treatment on the depressive symptomatology of Puerto Rican women. , 1981, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[35]  B. Wampold,et al.  The placebo is powerful: estimating placebo effects in medicine and psychotherapy from randomized clinical trials. , 2005, Journal of clinical psychology.

[36]  P. Wilson,et al.  Comparative efficacy of behavioral and cognitive treatments of depression , 1983, Cognitive Therapy and Research.

[37]  P. Areán,et al.  Comparative effectiveness of social problem-solving therapy and reminiscence therapy as treatments for depression in older adults. , 1993, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[38]  J. Markowitz,et al.  Practice guideline for the treatment of patients with major depressive disorder (revision). American Psychiatric Association. , 2000, The American journal of psychiatry.

[39]  Anne Marie Albano,et al.  Computer-assisted cognitive therapy for depression: maintaining efficacy while reducing therapist time. , 2005, The American journal of psychiatry.

[40]  Gerhard Andersson,et al.  Psychotherapy for Depression in Adults: A Meta-Analysis of Comparative Outcome Studies , 2010 .

[41]  C. Ashton,et al.  A randomized trial of self-management and psychoeducational group therapies for comorbid chronic posttraumatic stress disorder and depressive disorder. , 2007, Journal of traumatic stress.

[42]  F. Scogin,et al.  Cognitive Therapy for Depression , 2004, Behavior modification.

[43]  A. M. Friedman.  [Psychotherapy of depression]. , 1990, Zhurnal nevropatologii i psikhiatrii imeni S.S. Korsakova.

[44]  Gerhard Andersson,et al.  Efficacy of cognitive–behavioural therapy and other psychological treatments for adult depression: meta-analytic study of publication bias , 2010, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[45]  K. Dobson,et al.  Cognitive therapy of depression: pretreatment patient predictors of outcome. , 2002, Clinical psychology review.

[46]  R. DeRubeis,et al.  Medications versus cognitive behavior therapy for severely depressed outpatients: mega-analysis of four randomized comparisons. , 1999, The American journal of psychiatry.

[47]  D. Kavanagh,et al.  Mechanisms of improvement in treatment for depression : test of a self-efficacy and performance model , 1990 .

[48]  Blair T. Johnson,et al.  Initial Severity and Antidepressant Benefits: A Meta-Analysis of Data Submitted to the Food and Drug Administration , 2008, PLoS medicine.

[49]  S. Hollon,et al.  6 – Cognitive Therapy of Depression1 , 1979 .

[50]  A. Beck,et al.  An inventory for measuring depression. , 1961, Archives of general psychiatry.

[51]  P. Cuijpers,et al.  The efficacy of short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy for depression: a meta-analysis. , 2010, Clinical psychology review.

[52]  R. DeRubeis,et al.  Prediction of response to medication and cognitive therapy in the treatment of moderate to severe depression. , 2009, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[53]  H. Kraemer,et al.  The history and current state of antidepressant clinical trial design: a call to action for proof-of-concept studies. , 2008, The Journal of clinical psychiatry.

[54]  M. Schaffer,et al.  Treatment of atypical depression with cognitive therapy or phenelzine: a double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. , 2000, Archives of general psychiatry.

[55]  R. Carney,et al.  Cognitive Behavior Therapy, Relaxation Training, and Tricyclic Antidepressant Medication in the Treatment of Depression , 1995, Psychological reports.

[56]  Robyn M Leventhal,et al.  Severity of Depression and Response to Antidepressants and Placebo: An Analysis of the Food and Drug Administration Database , 2002, Journal of clinical psychopharmacology.

[57]  S. Hollon,et al.  Prospects for future comparisons between drugs and psychotherapy: lessons from the CBT-versus-pharmacotherapy exchange. , 1996, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[58]  G. Andersson,et al.  Psychological treatment of depression: A meta-analytic database of randomized studies , 2008, BMC psychiatry.

[59]  Dc Washington.  Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Ed. , 1994 .

[60]  R. DeRubeis,et al.  Antidepressant drug effects and depression severity: a patient-level meta-analysis. , 2010, JAMA.