Parents' preferences for interventions to improve childhood immunization uptake in northern Nigeria.

BACKGROUND Routine childhood immunization coverage has been low in northern Nigeria. While local authorities and international partners have been working hard to improve coverage, population preferences for interventions have not been documented. This study aimed to understand parents' preferences and identify possible interventions to improve uptake of childhood immunization. METHODS Preferences for immunization interventions were elicited using a best-worst scaling (BWS) instrument among parents with children under five. We explored the value of six program attributes (each varying across three levels) identified through a literature review and engagement with local stakeholders. In each of 18 hypothetical programs identified through a main effect orthogonal design, respondents selected the best and worst attributes that may facilitate vaccination of children. Assuming sequential best-worst responses, we used conditional logit to estimate preferences. We employed latent class analysis (LCA) to categorize and examine respondents' preferences across interventions. RESULTS 97 men and 101 women in 198 households were surveyed. The most preferred level for each attribute included door-to-door vaccinations, free food supplements, bundling with nutritional support programs, involvement of religious leaders, information dissemination through media campaigns, and strengthening of health services by the government. Three types of preferences were recognized in the LCA. The value-driven group (14%) characterized by youngest age, predominantly female, and lower education perceived bundled services with food and nutritional programs as the most important feature of an intervention. Convenience and information seekers (28%) characterized by oldest age and the lowest employment preferred door-to-door vaccinations and media campaigns. The remaining complacent group (58%), characterized by highest education and highest employment, did not show strong preferences to any intervention compared to the other two groups. CONCLUSIONS Routine immunization programs should consider joining forces with food and nutritional programs to improve vaccination uptake. Incorporating door-to-door visits and media campaigns to target older and unemployed populations may increase childhood immunization uptake in northern Nigeria.

[1]  R. Hornik,et al.  Improving vaccination coverage in urban areas through a health communication campaign: the 1990 Philippine experience. , 1994, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[2]  O. Adetokunboh,et al.  Children who have received no routine polio vaccines in Nigeria: Who are they and where do they live? , 2017, Human vaccines & immunotherapeutics.

[3]  J. Kaldor,et al.  Development of immunity following financial incentives for hepatitis B vaccination among people who inject drugs: A randomized controlled trial. , 2016, Journal of clinical virology : the official publication of the Pan American Society for Clinical Virology.

[4]  P. Nsubuga,et al.  Factors affecting access to information on routine immunization among mothers of under 5 children in Kaduna State Nigeria, 2015 , 2017, The Pan African medical journal.

[5]  Chidiebere A. Nwachukwu,et al.  Access to mass media messages, and use of family planning in Nigeria: a spatio-demographic analysis from the 2013 DHS , 2016, BMC Public Health.

[6]  D. McFadden Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior , 1972 .

[7]  J. Yokley,et al.  Increasing the immunization of preschool children; an evaluation of applied community interventions. , 1984, Journal of applied behavior analysis.

[8]  Wura Jacobs,et al.  Coverage and determinants of childhood immunization in Nigeria: A systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2017, Vaccine.

[9]  N. MacDonald Vaccine hesitancy: Definition, scope and determinants. , 2015, Vaccine.

[10]  B. Tandon,et al.  Immunization coverage in India for areas served by the Integrated Child Development Services programme. The Integrated Child Development Services Consultants. , 1992, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[11]  Heidi J Larson,et al.  Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: a systematic review of published literature, 2007-2012. , 2014, Vaccine.

[12]  J. Ganle Hegemonic Masculinity, HIV/AIDS Risk Perception, and Sexual Behavior Change Among Young People in Ghana , 2016, Qualitative health research.

[13]  S. El-Kamary,et al.  Breaking community barriers to polio vaccination in northern Nigeria: the impact of a grass roots mobilization campaign (Majigi) , 2012, Pathogens and global health.

[14]  N. MacDonald,et al.  Efforts to monitor Global progress on individual and community demand for immunization: Development of definitions and indicators for the Global Vaccine Action Plan Strategic Objective 2. , 2017, Vaccine.

[15]  K. Igarashi,et al.  The impact of an immunization programme administered through the Growth Monitoring Programme Plus as an alternative way of implementing Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses in urban-slum areas of Lusaka, Zambia. , 2010, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[16]  Stavros Petrou,et al.  Discrete Choice Experiments in Health Economics: A Review of the Literature , 2014, PharmacoEconomics.

[17]  Yinglin Xia,et al.  A Behavioral Economic Approach to Improving Human Papillomavirus Vaccination. , 2017, The Journal of adolescent health : official publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine.

[18]  Dustin G Gibson,et al.  The Mobile Solutions for Immunization (M-SIMU) Trial: A Protocol for a Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial That Assesses the Impact of Mobile Phone Delivered Reminders and Travel Subsidies to Improve Childhood Immunization Coverage Rates and Timeliness in Western Kenya , 2016, JMIR research protocols.

[19]  F. Meurice,et al.  Determinants of vaccination coverage in rural Nigeria , 2008, BMC public health.

[20]  È. Dubé,et al.  Strategies intended to address vaccine hesitancy: Review of published reviews. , 2015, Vaccine.

[21]  Mickael Bech,et al.  Effects coding in discrete choice experiments. , 2005, Health economics.

[22]  Deborah Marshall,et al.  Constructing experimental designs for discrete-choice experiments: report of the ISPOR Conjoint Analysis Experimental Design Good Research Practices Task Force. , 2013, Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research.

[23]  C. Griffiths,et al.  Boosting uptake of influenza immunisation: a randomised controlled trial of telephone appointing in general practice. , 2002, The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners.

[24]  M. De Allegri,et al.  Applying stated-preference methods to improve health systems in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review , 2017, Expert review of pharmacoeconomics & outcomes research.

[25]  Peter Zweifel,et al.  Experimental measurement of preferences in health and healthcare using best-worst scaling: an overview , 2016, Health Economics Review.

[26]  T. Peters,et al.  Best--worst scaling: What it can do for health care research and how to do it. , 2007, Journal of health economics.

[27]  S. Ozawa,et al.  Exploring pathways for building trust in vaccination and strengthening health system resilience , 2016, BMC Health Services Research.

[28]  John F P Bridges,et al.  Things are Looking up Since We Started Listening to Patients: Trends in the Application of Conjoint Analysis in Health 1982-2007. , 2008, The patient.

[29]  Sheana Bull,et al.  SMS text message reminders to improve infant vaccination coverage in Guatemala: A pilot randomized controlled trial , 2016, Vaccine.

[30]  S. Ozawa,et al.  Using best-worst scaling to rank factors affecting vaccination demand in northern Nigeria. , 2017, Vaccine.

[31]  J. Bridges,et al.  Using Latent Class Analysis to Model Preference Heterogeneity in Health: A Systematic Review , 2018, PharmacoEconomics.

[32]  A. Comber,et al.  The impact of community-based outreach immunisation services on immunisation coverage with GIS network accessibility analysis in peri-urban areas, Zambia , 2010, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health.

[33]  E. Renne Perspectives on polio and immunization in Northern Nigeria. , 2006, Social science & medicine.

[34]  H. Ichoku,et al.  Explaining socio-economic inequalities in immunization coverage in Nigeria. , 2016, Health policy and planning.

[35]  H. Doctor,et al.  Awareness, use, and unmet need for family planning in rural northern Nigeria. , 2013, African journal of reproductive health.

[36]  A. Ranjan,et al.  Expanding and improving urban outreach immunization in Patna, India , 2011, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[37]  W. Feek,et al.  Understanding vaccine hesitancy in polio eradication in northern Nigeria. , 2017, Vaccine.

[38]  A. Mehrotra,et al.  Alternative vaccination locations: who uses them and can they increase flu vaccination rates? , 2009, Vaccine.

[39]  O. Ajumobi,et al.  Immunisation coverage and its determinants among children aged 12-23 months in Atakumosa-west district, Osun State Nigeria: a cross-sectional study , 2016, BMC Public Health.

[40]  Deborah Marshall,et al.  Conjoint Analysis Applications in Health — How are Studies being Designed and Reported? , 2010, The patient.

[41]  R. Fields,et al.  Drivers of routine immunization coverage improvement in Africa: findings from district-level case studies , 2014, Health policy and planning.

[42]  Andrew Parker,et al.  Perception of Risk and Terrorism-Related Behavior Change: Dual Influences of Probabilistic Reasoning and Reality Testing , 2017, Front. Psychol..

[43]  S. Omer,et al.  Effect of food coupon incentives on timely completion of DTP immunization series in children from a low-income area in Karachi, Pakistan: a longitudinal intervention study. , 2010, Vaccine.

[44]  S. Lewin,et al.  Factors affecting the implementation of childhood vaccination communication strategies in Nigeria: a qualitative study , 2017, BMC Public Health.

[45]  F. Johnson,et al.  Experimental measurement of preferences in health care using best-worst scaling (BWS): theoretical and statistical issues , 2016, Health Economics Review.

[46]  S. Babalola Maternal reasons for non‐immunisation and partial immunisation in northern Nigeria , 2011, Journal of paediatrics and child health.

[47]  David Bishai,et al.  Use of mobile phones for improving vaccination coverage among children living in rural hard-to-reach areas and urban streets of Bangladesh. , 2016, Vaccine.

[48]  Mandy Ryan,et al.  Discrete choice experiments in health economics: a review of the literature. , 2012, Health economics.

[49]  O. Alabi,et al.  Health & demographic surveillance system profile: the Nahuche Health and Demographic Surveillance System, Northern Nigeria (Nahuche HDSS). , 2014, International journal of epidemiology.

[50]  S. Ozawa,et al.  Public trust and vaccine acceptance-international perspectives , 2013, Human vaccines & immunotherapeutics.

[51]  P. Nsubuga,et al.  Determinants of routine immunization coverage in Bungudu, Zamfara State, Northern Nigeria, May 2010 , 2014, The Pan African medical journal.

[52]  Jean Adams,et al.  Acceptability of financial incentives or quasi-mandatory schemes to increase uptake of immunisations in preschool children in the United Kingdom: Qualitative study with parents and service delivery staff. , 2016, Vaccine.

[53]  Maarten J. IJzerman,et al.  Statistical Methods for the Analysis of Discrete Choice Experiments: A Report of the ISPOR Conjoint Analysis Good Research Practices Task Force. , 2016, Value in health : the journal of the International Society for Pharmacoeconomics and Outcomes Research.

[54]  M. Tarrant,et al.  Interventions to increase the uptake of seasonal influenza vaccination among pregnant women: A systematic review. , 2016, Vaccine.