Strengthening the Financial Reporting System: Can Audit Committees Deliver?

This paper reviews the literature on audit committees in order to evaluate the extent to which committees are effective in terms of strengthening financial reporting. The paper aims to achieve two goals: first. to provide updated information about the effectiveness of the audit committee, and second to identify research opportunities. Compared with other reviews on the matter, we cover a broader spectrum of theoretical perspectives from various fields, methods, and countries. In particular, our review investigates from a meta-perspective the results reported in studies which examine the relationship between certain audit committee characteristics and measures of audit committee effectiveness. It is hoped that this work will sensitize accounting researchers about the appropriateness of extending the boundaries of research on audit committees, from methodological, theoretical, and geographical points of view.

[1]  J. Krishnan,et al.  Audit Committees and Quarterly Earnings Management , 2005 .

[2]  Dasaratha V. Rama,et al.  Audit fees, non-audit fees, and auditor reporting on UK stressed companies , 2003 .

[3]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Audit Committee Composition and Auditor Reporting , 2000 .

[4]  I. Steiner.  Group process and productivity , 1972 .

[5]  Rong-Ruey Duh,et al.  The Effect of Audit Committees on Earnings Return Association: Evidence from Foreign Registrants in the United States , 2008 .

[6]  F. DeZoort,et al.  An analysis of experience effects on audit committee members' oversight judgments , 1998 .

[7]  Dana R. Hermanson,et al.  Audit Committee Incentive Compensation and Accounting Restatements , 2008 .

[8]  Gary F. Peters,et al.  Corporate Governance, Audit Quality and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act: Evidence from Internal Audit Outsourcing , 2007 .

[9]  T. Palys.  Research Decisions, Quantitative and Qualitative Perspectives , 1997 .

[10]  R. D'amico.  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison , 1978, Telos.

[11]  Rebecca N. Hann,et al.  Does the Market Value Financial Expertise on Audit Committees of Boards of Directors? , 2004 .

[12]  K. Raghunandan,et al.  Audit Committee Composition and Shareholder Actions: Evidence from Voting on Auditor Ratification , 2003 .

[13]  M. C. Pucheta‐Martínez,et al.  The Impact of Audit Committee Characteristics on the Enhancement of the Quality of Financial Reporting: An Empirical Study in the Spanish Context , 2007 .

[14]  Sonda Chtourou,et al.  The Effect of Audit Committee Expertise, Independence, and Activity on Aggressive Earnings Management , 2004 .

[15]  P. Koh,et al.  Accountability and Value Enhancement Roles of Corporate Governance , 2007 .

[16]  Deborah S. Archambeault,et al.  Auditor Opinion Shopping and the Audit Committee: An Analysis of Suspicious Auditor Switches , 2001 .

[17]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Fraudulent Financial Reporting: Consideration of Industry Traits and Corporate Governance Mechanisms , 2000 .

[18]  Michael Power,et al.  The risk management of everything: rethinking the politics of uncertainty , 2004 .

[19]  C. Lennox,et al.  Audit Firm Appointments, Audit Firm Alumni, and Audit Committee Independence , 2007 .

[20]  Gary F. Peters,et al.  The Association between Audit Committee Characteristics and Audit Fees , 2003 .

[21]  James D. Westphal,et al.  Keeping Directors in Line: Social Distancing as a Control Mechanism in the Corporate Elite , 2003 .

[22]  Charles P. Cullinan.  Enron as a symptom of audit process breakdown: can the Sarbanes-Oxley Act cure the disease? , 2004 .

[23]  John P. Kotter,et al.  Power and Influence , 1985 .

[24]  M. Zaman,et al.  The Corporate Governance Effects of Audit Committees , 2004 .

[25]  Edward J. Zajac,et al.  The Social Construction of Market Value: Institutionalization and Learning Perspectives on Stock Market Reactions , 2004 .

[26]  C. Hardy.  Understanding Power: Bringing about Strategic Change , 1996 .

[27]  John W. Meyer,et al.  Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony , 1977, American Journal of Sociology.

[28]  M. Zaman,et al.  Audit Committee Effectiveness: Informal Processes and Behavioural Effects , 2007 .

[29]  Yves Gendron,et al.  On the constitution of audit committee effectiveness , 2006 .

[30]  Hugh Willmott,et al.  THE IMPOSSIBILITY OF ELIMINATING THE EXPECTATIONS GAP: SOME THEORY AND EVIDENCE , 1998 .

[31]  P. Wolnizer.  Are Audit Committees Red Herrings , 1995 .

[32]  J. Goodwin,et al.  Two factors affecting internal audit independence and objectivity: Evidence from Singapore , 2001 .

[33]  P. Kent,et al.  Relation between External Audit Fees, Audit Committee Characteristics and Internal Audit , 2006 .

[34]  N. Vafeas.  Audit Committee Appointments , 2001 .

[35]  Douglas E. Ziegenfuss,et al.  Audit committee pre‐Enron efforts to increase the effectiveness of corporate governance , 2006 .

[36]  E. Boo,et al.  Effect of Regulatory Oversight on the Association between Internal Governance Characteristics and Audit Fees , 2007 .

[37]  R. Houston,et al.  Audit Committee Member Support for Proposed Audit Adjustments: Pre‐SOX versus Post‐SOX Judgments , 2008 .

[38]  D. Coulombe,et al.  Audit Committee, Underpricing of IPOs, and Accuracy of Management Earnings Forecasts , 2008 .

[39]  J. Krishnan,et al.  Why Some Companies Seek Shareholder Ratification on Auditor Selection , 2005 .

[40]  J. Solomon,et al.  Corporate Governance in Taiwan: Empirical Evidence from Taiwanese Company Directors , 2003 .

[41]  Richard Leblanc,et al.  Inside the Boardroom: How Boards Really Work and the Coming Revolution in Corporate Governance , 2005 .

[42]  Gregory Jackson,et al.  Continuity and Change in Corporate Governance: Comparing Germany and Japan , 2005 .

[43]  M. Beasley.  An Empirical Analysis of the Relation between Board of Director Composition and Financial Statement Fraud , 1998 .

[44]  James A. Hall,et al.  The Sarbanes-Oxley Act: Implications for large-scale IT outsourcing , 2007, Commun. ACM.

[45]  N. O’Sullivan.  Board characteristics and audit pricing post-Cadbury: a research note , 1999 .

[46]  Weili Ge,et al.  Accruals Quality and Internal Control Over Financial Reporting , 2007 .

[47]  Jean Bédard,et al.  Expertise in auditing: Myth or reality? , 1989 .

[48]  April Klein,et al.  Audit Committee, Board of Director Characteristics, and Earnings Management , 2002 .

[49]  P. Tetlock,et al.  Accounting for the effects of accountability. , 1999, Psychological bulletin.

[50]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Firm Characteristics and Voluntary Management Reports on Internal Control , 2006 .

[51]  A. Wright,et al.  The Corporate Governance Mosaic and Financial Reporting Quality , 2008 .

[52]  R. Walker.  Gaps in Guidelines on Audit Committees , 2004 .

[53]  J. Goodwin.  The Relationship Between the Audit Committee and the Internal Audit Function: Evidence from Australia and New Zealand , 2003 .

[54]  George J. Benston,et al.  Enron: what happened and what we can learn from it , 2002 .

[55]  W. Powell,et al.  The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis , 1993 .

[56]  L. Spira.  The Audit Committee: Performing Corporate Governance , 2002 .

[57]  Patricia M. Dechow,et al.  Causes and Consequences of Earnings Manipulation: An Analysis of Firms Subject to Enforcement Actions by the SEC* , 1996 .

[58]  R. Houston,et al.  Audit Committee Member Support for Proposed Audit Adjustments: A Source Credibility Perspective , 2003 .

[59]  Robyn A. Moroney,et al.  Audit Committee Composition and the Use of an Industry Specialist Audit Firm , 2005 .

[60]  Evidence from the U.S. on the Effect of Auditor Involvement in Assessing Internal Control over Financial Reporting , 2008 .

[61]  K. James.  The Effects of Internal Audit Structure on Perceived Financial Statement Fraud Prevention , 2003 .

[62]  R. Romano,et al.  The Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the Making of Quack Corporate Governance , 2004 .

[63]  V. Beattie,et al.  Behind the Audit Report: A Descriptive Study of Discussions and Negotiations Between Auditors and Directors , 2000 .

[64]  I. Millstein.  Introduction to the Report and Recommendations of the Blue Ribbon Committee on Improving the Effectiveness of Corporate Audit Committees , 1999 .

[65]  Stewart Clegg,et al.  Frameworks of power , 1989 .

[66]  S. K. Asare,et al.  Internal Auditors' Evaluation of Fraud Factors in Planning an Audit: The Importance of Audit Committee Quality and Management Incentives , 2008 .

[67]  David G. Mathiasen.  Groups that work (and those that Don't): Creating Conditions for Effective Teamwork, edited by J. Richard Hackman. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass 1990, 512 pp. Price: $39.95 cloth , 1991 .

[68]  P. Hancock,et al.  Factors Influencing Voluntary Corporate Disclosure by Kenyan Companies , 2006 .

[69]  A. Melis.  Corporate Governance Failures. To What Extent is Parmalat a Particularly Italian Case? , 2004 .

[70]  Roger Simnett,et al.  Impact of Stakeholder Characteristics on Voluntary Dissemination of Interim Information and Communication of its Level of Assurance , 2007 .

[71]  J. Stewart,et al.  The Impact of Audit Committee Existence and Audit Committee Meeting Frequency on the External Audit: Perceptions of Australian Auditors , 2007 .

[72]  J. Bedard,et al.  Academic Auditing Research: An Exploratory Investigation into its Usefulness , 2001 .

[73]  Maurice Gosselin,et al.  Getting Inside the Black Box: A Field Study of Practices in “Effective” Audit Committees , 2004 .

[74]  Jeffrey R. Cohen,et al.  Auditors' Consideration of Corporate Governance and Management Control Philosophy in Preplanning and Planning Judgments , 2000 .

[75]  Jere R. Francis.  What do we know about audit quality , 2004 .

[76]  James D. Westphal,et al.  Pluralistic Ignorance in Corporate Boards and Firms' Strategic Persistence in Response to Low Firm Performance , 2005 .

[77]  D. Larcker,et al.  Corporate Governance, Accounting Outcomes, and Organizational Performance , 2007 .

[78]  Jayanth K. Krishnan.  Audit Committee Quality and Internal Control: An Empirical Analysis , 2005 .

[79]  Rupert Brown,et al.  Group Processes: Dynamics Within and Between Groups , 1988 .

[80]  Reggy Hooghiemstra,et al.  The Independence Paradox: (Im)Possibilities Facing Non-Executive Directors in the Netherlands , 2004 .

[81]  Dana R. Hermanson,et al.  Board Characteristics and Audit Fees , 2000 .

[82]  Arnold M. Wright,et al.  Corporate Governance and the Audit Process , 2002 .

[83]  P. Pope,et al.  Board Monitoring and Earnings Management: Do Outside Directors Influence Abnormal Accruals? , 2000 .

[84]  V. Beattie,et al.  Audit market competition: auditor changes and the impact of tendering , 1998 .

[85]  J. Weimer,et al.  A Taxonomy of Systems of Corporate Governance , 1999 .

[86]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Audit Committee Financial Experts: A Closer Examination Using Firm Designations , 2006 .

[87]  F. DeZoort.  An Investigation of Audit Committees' Oversight Responsibilities , 1997 .

[88]  P. Kivisto.  Chaos of disciplines , 2002 .

[89]  N. Subramaniam,et al.  Internal Auditors Assessment of Their Contribution to Financial Statement Audits: The Relation With Audit Committee and Internal Audit Function Characteristics , 2006 .

[90]  Gary F. Peters,et al.  An Empirical Investigation of Audit Fees, Nonaudit Fees, and Audit Committees* , 2003 .

[91]  Dana R. Hermanson,et al.  Disclosures in Audit Committee Charters and Reports , 2002 .

[92]  Gopal V. Krishnan,et al.  Reporting Internal Control Deficiencies in the Post-Sarbanes-Oxley Era: The Role of Auditors and Corporate Governance , 2005 .

[93]  Yves Gendron,et al.  Discussion of "The Audit Committee Oversight Process": Advocating Openness in Accounting Research* , 2009 .

[94]  Lois Quam,et al.  The Audit Society: Rituals of Verification , 1998 .

[95]  Brian P. Shapiro.  Accounting Science's Contribution to the Corporate Governance and Executive Accountability Problem , 2006 .

[96]  Elaine G. Mauldin,et al.  Auditor rotation and the appearance of independence: Evidence from non-professional investors , 2008 .

[97]  J. Parkinson,et al.  The Combined Code on Corporate Governance , 1999 .

[98]  P. Kent,et al.  Internal Governance Structures and Earnings Management , 2005 .

[99]  J. Bedard,et al.  Qualitative Research on Accounting: Some Thoughts on What Occurs Behind the Scene , 2004 .

[100]  Alan Gregory,et al.  Audit committee effectiveness and the audit fee , 1996 .

[101]  Paul F. Williams,et al.  The winnowing away of behavioral accounting research in the US: The process for anointing academic elites , 2006 .

[102]  V. Tauringana,et al.  Audit Committees and Voluntary External Auditor Involvement in UK Interim Reporting , 2008 .

[103]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Factors Associated with U.S. Public Companies' Investment in Internal Auditing , 2005 .

[104]  Guy P. Lander.  The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 , 2002 .

[105]  W. Powell,et al.  The iron cage revisited institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields , 1983 .

[106]  N. Subramaniam,et al.  Internal Auditor Perceptions on Audit Committee Interactions: A Qualitative Study in Malaysian Public Corporations , 2007 .

[107]  Weihong Xu,et al.  Market Reaction to Voluntary Announcements of Audit Committee Appointments: The Effect of Financial Expertise , 2004 .

[108]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  Audit Committee Independence and Disclosure: Choice for Financially Distressed Firms , 2003 .

[109]  B. Flyvbjerg.  Making Social Science Matter , 2001 .

[110]  Marleen Willekens,et al.  The Role of Risk Management and Governance in Determining Audit Demand , 2006 .

[111]  J. Goodwin,et al.  The Influence of Corporate Governance Mechanisms on the Quality of Financial Reporting and Auditing: Perceptions of Auditors and Directors in Singapore , 2002 .

[112]  Deborah S. Archambeault,et al.  Audit Committee Effectiveness: A Synthesis of the Empirical Audit Committee Literature , 2002 .

[113]  Karla M. Zehms,et al.  Earnings Manipulation Risk, Corporate Governance Risk, and Auditors' Planning and Pricing Decisions , 2004 .

[114]  Ruth Bender,et al.  Compare and Contrast: Perspectives on Board Committees , 2004 .

[115]  Jenny Stewart,et al.  Corporate Governance and Disclosures on the Transition to International Financial Reporting Standards , 2008 .

[116]  M. Birnbaum,et al.  Source Credibility in Social Judgment : Bias , Expertise , and the Judge ' s Point of View , 1979 .

[117]  David B. Farber,et al.  Restoring Trust after Fraud: Does Corporate Governance Matter? , 2004 .

[118]  N. Vafeas,et al.  The Association between Corporate Boards, Audit Committees, and Management Earnings Forecasts: An Empirical Analysis , 2005 .

[119]  Steven E. Salterio,et al.  The Effects of Corporate Governance Experience and Financial‐Reporting and Audit Knowledge on Audit Committee Members' Judgments , 2001 .

[120]  P. Tetlock,et al.  Social and cognitive strategies for coping with accountability: conformity, complexity, and bolstering. , 1989, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[121]  M. Foucault,et al.  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. , 1978 .

[122]  P. Goodman.  Groups That Work (and Those That Don't)Groups That Work (and Those That Don't) by Hackman Richard. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1991, 512 pp. , 1992 .

[123]  Dana R. Hermanson,et al.  The Audit Committee Oversight Process , 2009 .

[124]  Jian Zhou,et al.  Audit committee quality, auditor independence, and internal control weaknesses , 2007 .

[125]  Beatriz García Osma,et al.  The Effect of the Board Composition and its Monitoring Committees on Earnings Management: Evidence from Spain , 2007 .

[126]  Ruth V. Aguilera,et al.  An Organizational Approach to Comparative Corporate Governance: Costs, Contingencies, and Complementarities , 2007, Organ. Sci..

[127]  Laura J. Kornish,et al.  Discipline with Common Agency: The Case of Audit and Nonaudit Services , 2004 .

[128]  J. Brierley,et al.  An Examination of the Role of Audit Committees in the Saudi Arabian Corporate Sector , 2002 .

[129]  Andrew Pettigrew,et al.  Power and Influence in and Around the Boardroom , 1995 .

[130]  Philip Gendall,et al.  Audit Committees in Private and Public Sector Corporates in New Zealand: An Empirical Investigation , 1998 .

[131]  H. Tan,et al.  Effects of Authoritative Guidance Availability and Audit Committee Effectiveness on Auditors' Judgments in an Auditor‐Client Negotiation Context , 2003 .

[132]  Jian Zhou,et al.  Audit Committee, Board Characteristics and Auditor Switch Decisions by Andersen's Clients , 2007 .

[133]  V. Tauringana,et al.  Corporate Compliance with Non-Mandatory Statements of Best Practice: The Case of the ASB Statement on Interim Reports , 2007 .

[134]  David Yermack,et al.  Remuneration, Retention, and Reputation Incentives for Outside Directors , 2002 .

[135]  Charles Piot,et al.  External Auditors, Audit Committees and Earnings Management in France , 2007 .

[136]  K. Raghunandan,et al.  Audit Committee Composition, “Gray Directors,” and Interaction with Internal Auditing , 2001 .

[137]  B. McSweeney.  Comment: ‘Action research’: mission impossible? Commentary on ‘Towards the increased use of action research in accounting information systems’ by C. Richard Baker , 2000 .

[138]  J. J. Wild,et al.  Managerial Accountability To Shareholders: Audit Committees And The Explanatory Power Of Earnings For Returns , 1994 .

[139]  Ronald C. Anderson,et al.  Board Characteristics, Accounting Report Integrity, and the Cost of Debt , 2004 .

[140]  J. Goodwin.  Auditors' Conflict Management Styles: An Exploratory Study , 2002 .

[141]  Gary F. Peters,et al.  Audit Committee Characteristics and Restatements , 2004 .

[142]  J. Song,et al.  Benchmarking Audit Committee Effectiveness in Financial Reporting , 2004 .

[143]  Linda S. McDaniel,et al.  The Effects of Joint Provision and Disclosure of Nonaudit Services on Audit Committee Members' Decisions and Investors' Preferences , 2006 .

[144]  C. Richard Baker.  Towards the Increased use of Action Research in Accounting Information Systems , 2000 .

[145]  Jacob M. Rose,et al.  Can Directors' Self-Interests Influence Accounting Choices? , 2008 .

[146]  L. Spira.  An Evolutionary Perspective on Audit Committee Effectiveness , 1998 .

[147]  Steven E. Salterio,et al.  The Chief Financial Officer's Perspective on Auditor Client Negotiations , 2007 .

[148]  N. Vafeas,et al.  Audit Committees, Boards, and the Quality of Reported Earnings* , 2005 .

[149]  Joseph V. Carcello,et al.  AUDIT COMMITTEE CHARACTERISTICS AND AUDITOR DISMISSALS FOLLOWING NEW GOING CONCERN REPORTS , 2003 .

[150]  Linda S. McDaniel,et al.  Evaluating Financial Reporting Quality: The Effects of Financial Expertise vs. Financial Literacy , 2002 .

[151]  Vivek Mande,et al.  The Effect of Audit Committee and Board of Director Independence on Auditor Resignation , 2004 .

[152]  Jules Townshend,et al.  Power, A Radical View , 2007 .

[153]  R. Houston,et al.  Audit committee support for auditors: The effects of materiality justification and accounting precision , 2003 .

[154]  M. Zaman,et al.  Convergence in European Corporate Governance: The Audit Committee Concept , 2005 .

[155]  Andrea Melis,et al.  Corporate Governance Failures: To What Extent is Parmalat a Particularly Italian Case? , 2005 .

[156]  Neil Fligstein,et al.  LAW AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE , 2005 .

[157]  Gerrit Sarens,et al.  The Relationship Between Internal Audit and Senior Management: A Qualitative Analysis of Expectations and Perceptions , 2006 .

[158]  Erik F. Gerding.  The Next Epidemic: Bubbles and the Growth and Decay of Securities Regulation , 2007 .

[159]  Rani Hoitash,et al.  Evidence from the United States on the Effect of Auditor Involvement in Assessing Internal Control over Financial Reporting , 2009 .

[160]  Lawrence J. Abbott,et al.  Auditor Selection and Audit Committee Characteristics , 2000 .

[161]  P. Joshi,et al.  The Role and Functions of Audit Committees in the Indian Corporate Governance: Empirical Findings , 2004 .

[162]  Ya‐wen Yang,et al.  The impact of corporate governance on Internet financial reporting , 2008 .

[163]  Gopal V. Krishnan,et al.  Does the SOX Definition of an Accounting Expert Matter? the Association between Audit Committee Directors' Accounting Expertise and Accounting Conservatism , 2007 .