Automatic lameness detection in cattle.

There is an increasing demand for health and welfare monitoring in modern dairy farming. The development of various innovative techniques aims at improving animal behaviour monitoring and thus animal welfare indicators on-farm. Automated lameness detection systems have to be valid, reliable and practicable to be applied in veterinary practice or under farm conditions. The objective of this literature review was to describe the current automated systems for detection of lameness in cattle, which have been recently developed and investigated for application in dairy research and practice. The automatic methods of lameness detection broadly fall into three categories: kinematic, kinetic and indirect methods. The performance of the methods were compared with the reference standard (locomotion score and/or lesion score) and evaluated based on level-based scheme defining the degree of development (level I, sensor technique; level II, validation of algorithm; level III, performance for detection of lameness and/or lesion; level IV, decision support with early warning system). Many scientific studies have been performed on levels I-III, but there are no studies of level IV technology. The adoption rate of automated lameness detection systems by herd managers mainly yields returns on investment by the early identification of lame cows. Long-term studies, using validated automated lameness detection systems aiming at early lameness detection, are still needed in order to improve welfare and production under field conditions.

[1]  C. G. van Reenen,et al.  Automatic monitoring of lying, standing and walking behavior in dairy cattle , 2007 .

[2]  J. Rushen,et al.  Producer estimates of prevalence and perceived importance of lameness in dairy herds with tiestalls, freestalls, and automated milking systems. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[3]  S. Martin,et al.  Veterinary Epidemiologic Research , 2009 .

[4]  D. Weary,et al.  Hoof pathologies influence kinematic measures of dairy cow gait. , 2005, Journal of dairy science.

[5]  T. Manske,et al.  Topical treatment of digital dermatitis associated with severe heel-horn erosion in a Swedish dairy herd. , 2002, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[6]  A Steiner,et al.  Moderate lameness leads to marked behavioral changes in dairy cows. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[7]  A. J. Channon,et al.  Variability of Manson and Leaver locomotion scores assigned to dairy cows by different observers , 2009, Veterinary Record.

[8]  J. Rushen,et al.  Measures of weight distribution of dairy cows to detect lameness and the presence of hoof lesions. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[9]  Daniel Berckmans,et al.  Implementation of an automatic 3D vision monitor for dairy cow locomotion in a commercial farm , 2017, Biosystems Engineering.

[10]  M. Endres,et al.  Prevalence of lameness in high-producing holstein cows housed in freestall barns in Minnesota. , 2006, Journal of dairy science.

[11]  M Alsaaod,et al.  Development and validation of a novel pedometer algorithm to quantify extended characteristics of the locomotor behavior of dairy cows. , 2015, Journal of dairy science.

[12]  D C J Main,et al.  Working towards a reduction in cattle lameness: 1. Understanding barriers to lameness control on dairy farms. , 2010, Research in veterinary science.

[13]  W Saeys,et al.  Farmers' preferences for automatic lameness-detection systems in dairy cattle. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[14]  J. Rushen,et al.  Cow- and farm-level risk factors for lameness on dairy farms with automated milking systems. , 2016, Journal of dairy science.

[15]  R. Bicalho,et al.  Association between a visual and an automated locomotion score in lactating Holstein cows. , 2007, Journal of dairy science.

[16]  Arno Pluk,et al.  Development of a real time cow gait tracking and analysing tool to assess lameness using a pressure sensitive walkway: the GAITWISE system , 2011 .

[17]  Daniel Berckmans,et al.  Online lameness detection in dairy cattle using Body Movement Pattern (BMP) , 2011, 2011 11th International Conference on Intelligent Systems Design and Applications.

[18]  J. Rushen,et al.  Associations between lying behavior and lameness in Canadian Holstein-Friesian cows housed in freestall barns. , 2016, Journal of dairy science.

[19]  L. Ózsvári Economic Cost of Lameness in Dairy Cattle Herds , 2017 .

[20]  Claudia Bahr,et al.  Original paper: Real-time automatic lameness detection based on back posture extraction in dairy cattle: Shape analysis of cow with image processing techniques , 2010 .

[21]  W. Weijs,et al.  The pressure distribution under the bovine claw during square standing on a flat substrate. , 2002, Journal of dairy science.

[22]  C. Winckler,et al.  Evaluation of data loggers, sampling intervals, and editing techniques for measuring the lying behavior of dairy cattle. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[23]  J Rushen,et al.  Measurement of acceleration while walking as an automated method for gait assessment in dairy cattle. , 2011, Journal of dairy science.

[24]  John D Wright,et al.  A systematic review of tests for the detection and diagnosis of foot lesions causing lameness in dairy cows. , 2018, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[25]  Jeffrey Rushen,et al.  Can automated measures of lying time help assess lameness and leg lesions on tie-stall dairy farms? , 2016 .

[26]  Jeffrey Rushen,et al.  Effect of lameness on dairy cows' visits to automatic milking systems , 2008 .

[27]  R. Rossi,et al.  Lameness Prevalence and Risk Factors in Large Dairy Farms in Upstate New York. Model Development for the Prediction of Claw Horn Disruption Lesions , 2016, PloS one.

[28]  F. Henson,et al.  Thermography of a septic metatarsophalangeal joint in a heifer , 2000, Veterinary Record.

[29]  D Berckmans,et al.  Analysis of individual classification of lameness using automatic measurement of back posture in dairy cattle. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[30]  H. Whay,et al.  The prevalence of lameness on New Zealand dairy farms: a comparison of farmer estimate and locomotion scoring. , 2014, Veterinary journal.

[31]  N. Neerchal,et al.  Enhancing the prediction accuracy of bovine lameness models through transformations of limb movement variables. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[32]  Christian Peham,et al.  [Lameness detection in cows by accelerometric measurement of motion at walk]. , 2012, Berliner und Munchener tierarztliche Wochenschrift.

[33]  C J Rutten,et al.  Invited review: sensors to support health management on dairy farms. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[34]  T. Turner Thermography as an aid to the clinical lameness evaluation. , 1991, The Veterinary clinics of North America. Equine practice.

[35]  C Kamphuis,et al.  Applying additive logistic regression to data derived from sensors monitoring behavioral and physiological characteristics of dairy cows to detect lameness. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[36]  Stefano Viazzi,et al.  Effect of merging levels of locomotion scores for dairy cows on intra- and interrater reliability and agreement. , 2014, Journal of dairy science.

[37]  Wolfgang Büscher,et al.  The Role of Infrared Thermography as a Non-Invasive Tool for the Detection of Lameness in Cattle , 2015, Sensors.

[38]  L. Gygax,et al.  Short communication: Detection of lameness in dairy cows using a grooming device. , 2018, Journal of dairy science.

[39]  Michael Voigt,et al.  Computerized identification and classification of stance phases as made by front or hind feet of walking cows based on 3-dimensional ground reaction forces , 2013 .

[40]  D M Weary,et al.  Gait assessment in dairy cattle. , 2009, Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience.

[41]  M Pastell,et al.  Contactless measurement of cow behavior in a milking robot , 2006, Behavior research methods.

[42]  R M de Mol,et al.  Applicability of day-to-day variation in behavior for the automated detection of lameness in dairy cows. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[43]  Apinan Aurasopon Dynamic Time Warping for classifying cattle behaviors and reducing acceleration data size , 2016 .

[44]  Nils Zehner,et al.  System specification and validation of a noseband pressure sensor for measurement of ruminating and eating behavior in stable-fed cows , 2017, Comput. Electron. Agric..

[45]  A. Steiner,et al.  Analysis of behavioral changes in dairy cows associated with claw horn lesions. , 2016, Journal of dairy science.

[46]  D M Weary,et al.  Lying behavior as an indicator of lameness in dairy cows. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[47]  E. Vasseur,et al.  Validation of the Ability of a 3D Pedometer to Accurately Determine the Number of Steps Taken by Dairy Cows When Housed in Tie-Stalls , 2017 .

[48]  M Pastell,et al.  Use of force sensors to detect and analyse lameness in dairy cows , 2008, Veterinary Record.

[49]  A. D. Kennedy,et al.  Short communication: infrared thermography and visual examination of hooves of dairy cows in two stages of lactation. , 2005, Journal of dairy science.

[50]  S. Calsamiglia,et al.  Effect of amount of concentrate offered in automatic milking systems on milking frequency, feeding behavior, and milk production of dairy cattle consuming high amounts of corn silage. , 2007, Journal of dairy science.

[51]  T. Knowles,et al.  Infrared thermometry for lesion monitoring in cattle lameness , 2014, Veterinary Record.

[52]  Mark Freeman,et al.  Detecting heat events in dairy cows using accelerometers and unsupervised learning , 2016, Comput. Electron. Agric..

[53]  M Alsaaod,et al.  Locomotion characteristics of dairy cows walking on pasture and the effect of artificial flooring systems on locomotion comfort. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[54]  F. Manson,et al.  The influence of concentrate amount on locomotion and clinical lameness in dairy cattle , 1988 .

[55]  J. Kaler,et al.  Effect of mobility score on milk yield and activity in dairy cattle. , 2011, Journal of dairy science.

[56]  N. Bell,et al.  Evaluating an intervention to reduce lameness in dairy cattle. , 2012, Journal of dairy science.

[57]  L. Munksgaard,et al.  Lameness detection via leg-mounted accelerometers on dairy cows on four commercial farms. , 2015, Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience.

[58]  Wouter Saeys,et al.  Exploration of measurement variation of gait variables for early lameness detection in cattle using the GAITWISE , 2013 .

[59]  N. Chapinal,et al.  Automated methods for detecting lameness and measuring analgesia in dairy cattle. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[60]  D M Weary,et al.  Evaluation of a system for monitoring rumination in heifers and calves. , 2011, Journal of dairy science.

[61]  W. Maertens,et al.  Reliability of categorical versus continuous scoring of welfare indicators: lameness in cows as a case study , 2009, Animal Welfare.

[62]  Daniel Berckmans,et al.  Comparison of a three-dimensional and two-dimensional camera system for automated measurement of back posture in dairy cows , 2014 .

[63]  D Berckmans,et al.  Lameness detection based on multivariate continuous sensing of milk yield, rumination, and neck activity. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[64]  J. Amory,et al.  Associations between locomotion score and kinematic measures in dairy cows with varying hoof lesion types. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[65]  M. Coffey,et al.  Changes in feeding behavior as possible indicators for the automatic monitoring of health disorders in dairy cows. , 2008, Journal of dairy science.

[66]  N. Cook Prevalence of lameness among dairy cattle in Wisconsin as a function of housing type and stall surface. , 2003, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.

[67]  W Heuwieser,et al.  Technical note: evaluation of data loggers for measuring lying behavior in dairy calves. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[68]  W. Weijs,et al.  The vertical ground reaction force and the pressure distribution on the claws of dairy cows while walking on a flat substrate. , 2003, Journal of dairy science.

[69]  D. Mullineaux,et al.  Early detection of lameness in heifers with hairy heel warts using a pressure plate , 2007, Animal Welfare.

[70]  Helen R. Whay,et al.  Locomotion scoring and lameness detection in dairy cattle , 2002, In Practice.

[71]  Tony P. Pridmore,et al.  Behavioural changes in dairy cows with lameness in an automatic milking system , 2014 .

[72]  E. Pajor,et al.  Cow-level associations of lameness, behavior, and milk yield of cows milked in automated systems. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[73]  N. Bell,et al.  Recovery of chronically lame dairy cows following treatment for claw horn lesions: a randomised controlled trial , 2016, Veterinary Record.

[74]  D. Weary,et al.  Effect of hoof pathologies on subjective assessments of dairy cow gait. , 2006, Journal of dairy science.

[75]  Joachim Krieter,et al.  Mastitis and lameness detection in dairy cows by application of fuzzy logic , 2009 .

[76]  V. Redaelli,et al.  Potential application of thermography (IRT) in animal production and for animal welfare. A case report of working dogs. , 2014, Annali dell'Istituto superiore di sanita.

[77]  W. Maertens,et al.  Cow gait scores and kinematic gait data: can people see gait irregularities? , 2009, Animal Welfare.

[78]  Veronica Redaelli,et al.  Heat generation and the role of infrared thermography in pathological conditions. , 2013 .

[79]  F. Skjøth,et al.  Short communication: Changes in gait symmetry in healthy and lame dairy cows based on 3-dimensional ground reaction force curves following claw trimming. , 2014, Journal of dairy science.

[80]  B. A. Wadsworth,et al.  A validation of technologies monitoring dairy cow feeding, ruminating, and lying behaviors. , 2016, Journal of dairy science.

[81]  R. M. Dyer,et al.  A System for Identifying Lameness in Dairy Cattle , 2002 .

[82]  M Pastell,et al.  Short communication: Lameness impairs feeding behavior of dairy cows. , 2014, Journal of dairy science.

[83]  Ephraim Maltz,et al.  Automatic lameness detection based on consecutive 3D-video recordings , 2014 .

[85]  L. Green,et al.  Assessment of the welfare of dairy caftle using animal-based measurements: direct observations and investigation of farm records , 2003, Veterinary Record.

[86]  D C J Main,et al.  The effects of early treatment for hindlimb lameness in dairy cows on four commercial UK farms. , 2012, Veterinary journal.

[87]  Assessment of observer performance in a subjective scoring system: visual classification of the gait of cows , 2003, The Journal of Agricultural Science.

[88]  J. Rushen,et al.  Validation of two measures of lameness in dairy cows , 2007 .

[89]  R. M. Dyer,et al.  Diversity in the magnitude of hind limb unloading occurs with similar forms of lameness in dairy cows. , 2011, The Journal of dairy research.

[90]  Niamh O'Connell,et al.  Relationships between lameness and feeding behaviour in cubicle-housed Holstein–Friesian dairy cows , 2012 .

[91]  S. Mokaram Ghotoorlar,et al.  Lameness scoring system for dairy cows using force plates and artificial intelligence , 2011, Veterinary Record.

[92]  Matti Pastell,et al.  Detecting cow's lameness using force sensors , 2008 .

[93]  J. Oldenbroek,et al.  Factors determining the carcass value of culled dairy cows , 1984 .

[94]  D. Weary,et al.  Hoof discomfort changes how dairy cattle distribute their body weight. , 2006, Journal of dairy science.

[95]  Y T Gröhn,et al.  The cost of different types of lameness in dairy cows calculated by dynamic programming. , 2010, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[96]  G. B. Scott Changes in limb loading with lameness for a number of Friesian cattle. , 1989, The British veterinary journal.

[97]  A Bach,et al.  Short communication: lying behavior of lactating dairy cows is influenced by lameness especially around feeding time. , 2012, Journal of dairy science.

[98]  L. Plümer,et al.  Electronic detection of lameness in dairy cows through measuring pedometric activity and lying behavior , 2012 .

[99]  D. Sprecher,et al.  A lameness scoring system that uses posture and gait to predict dairy cattle reproductive performance. , 1997, Theriogenology.

[100]  A. Hrõbjartsson,et al.  Guidelines for Reporting Reliability and Agreement Studies (GRRAS) were proposed. , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[101]  E. Aizinbud,et al.  A field investigation of the use of the pedometer for the early detection of lameness in cattle. , 2006, The Canadian veterinary journal = La revue veterinaire canadienne.

[102]  M. Heppelmann,et al.  Postoperative analgesic efficacy of meloxicam in lame dairy cows undergoing resection of the distal interphalangeal joint. , 2013, Journal of dairy science.

[103]  Wouter Saeys,et al.  Farm-specific economic value of automatic lameness detection systems in dairy cattle: From concepts to operational simulations. , 2018, Journal of dairy science.

[104]  Bart Sonck,et al.  Variables of gait inconsistency outperform basic gait variables in detecting mildly lame cows , 2015 .

[105]  Craig Michie,et al.  Lameness Affects Cow Feeding But Not Rumination Behavior as Characterized from Sensor Data , 2016, Front. Vet. Sci..

[106]  Maher Alsaaod,et al.  Use of Extended Characteristics of Locomotion and Feeding Behavior for Automated Identification of Lame Dairy Cows , 2016, PloS one.

[107]  M. Pérez-Cabal,et al.  Effect of claw disorders on milk production, fertility, and longevity, and their economic impact in Spanish Holstein cows. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[108]  Joachim Krieter,et al.  Detection of mastitis and lameness in dairy cows using wavelet analysis , 2012 .

[109]  M Alsaaod,et al.  Technical note: Validation of a semi-automated software tool to determine gait-cycle variables in dairy cows. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[110]  T Pfau,et al.  Assessment of dairy cow locomotion in a commercial farm setting: the effects of walking speed on ground reaction forces and temporal and linear stride characteristics. , 2010, Research in veterinary science.

[111]  Solveig March,et al.  Effect of training on the inter-observer reliability of lameness scoring in dairy cattle , 2007, Animal Welfare.

[112]  A. Lefcourt,et al.  Comparison of models to identify lame cows based on gait and lesion scores, and limb movement variables. , 2006, Journal of dairy science.

[113]  D. Berckmans,et al.  Relation between observed locomotion traits and locomotion score in dairy cows. , 2015, Journal of dairy science.

[114]  K. Abdul Jabbar,et al.  Early and non-intrusive lameness detection in dairy cows using 3-dimensional video , 2017 .

[115]  D. Weary,et al.  Using gait score, walking speed, and lying behavior to detect hoof lesions in dairy cows. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[116]  D. Fraser,et al.  Hot topic: Management of cull dairy cows-Consensus of an expert consultation in Canada. , 2018, Journal of dairy science.

[117]  D Berckmans,et al.  Lameness detection in dairy cattle: single predictor v. multivariate analysis of image-based posture processing and behaviour and performance sensing. , 2016, Animal : an international journal of animal bioscience.

[118]  Lars Relund Nielsen,et al.  Quantifying walking and standing behaviour of dairy cows using a moving average based on output from an accelerometer. , 2010 .

[119]  M Kujala,et al.  A probabilistic neural network model for lameness detection. , 2007, Journal of dairy science.

[120]  M. Pastell,et al.  A wireless accelerometer system with wavelet analysis for assessing lameness in cattle. , 2009 .

[121]  N. Chapinal,et al.  Validation of an automated method to count steps while cows stand on a weighing platform and its application as a measure to detect lameness. , 2012, Journal of dairy science.

[122]  L. Green,et al.  Associations between hoof lesions and locomotion score in 1098 unsound dairy cows. , 2010, Veterinary journal.

[123]  H Hogeveen,et al.  Assessing economic consequences of foot disorders in dairy cattle using a dynamic stochastic simulation model. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[124]  M. Kolehmainen,et al.  Cow behaviour pattern recognition using a three-dimensional accelerometer and support vector machines , 2009 .

[125]  D. Weary,et al.  Benchmarking cow comfort on North American freestall dairies: lameness, leg injuries, lying time, facility design, and management for high-producing Holstein dairy cows. , 2012, Journal of dairy science.

[126]  M Alsaaod,et al.  A field trial of infrared thermography as a non-invasive diagnostic tool for early detection of digital dermatitis in dairy cows. , 2014, Veterinary journal.

[127]  M Alsaaod,et al.  Detection of hoof lesions using digital infrared thermography in dairy cows. , 2012, Journal of dairy science.

[128]  Daniel Berckmans,et al.  Automatic detection of lameness in dairy cattle-Vision-based trackway analysis in cow's locomotion , 2008 .

[129]  M Alsaaod,et al.  The cow pedogram-Analysis of gait cycle variables allows the detection of lameness and foot pathologies. , 2017, Journal of dairy science.

[130]  D. Weary,et al.  Technical note: Validation of a system for monitoring rumination in dairy cows. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[131]  Uri Tasch,et al.  Predictive models of lameness in dairy cows achieve high sensitivity and specificity with force measurements in three dimensions , 2015, Journal of Dairy Research.