Blinding is compromised for transcranial direct current stimulation at 1 mA for 20 min in young healthy adults

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a non‐invasive brain stimulation method that is frequently used to study cortical excitability changes and their impact on cognitive functions in humans. While most stimulators are capable of operating in double‐blind mode, the amount of discomfort experienced during tDCS may break blinding. Therefore, specifically designed sham stimulation protocols are being used. The “fade‐in, short‐stimulation, fade‐out” (FSF) protocol has been used in hundreds of studies and is commonly believed to be indistinguishable from real stimulation applied at 1 mA for 20 min. We analysed subjective reports of 192 volunteers, who either received real tDCS (n = 96) or FSF tDCS (n = 96). Participants reported more discomfort for real tDCS and correctly guessed the condition above chance‐level. These findings indicate that FSF does not ensure complete blinding and that better active sham protocols are needed.

[1]  Walter Paulus,et al.  Evidence for Cognitive Placebo and Nocebo Effects in Healthy Individuals , 2018, Scientific Reports.

[2]  The Time Course of Ineffective Sham Blinding During 1mA tDCS , 2017 .

[3]  Tjeerd W. Boonstra,et al.  Change in Mean Frequency of Resting-State Electroencephalography after Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation , 2016, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[4]  A. Antal,et al.  Placebo Intervention Enhances Reward Learning in Healthy Individuals , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[5]  Todd W. Thompson,et al.  Enhancing cognition using transcranial electrical stimulation , 2015, Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences.

[6]  B. Guleyupoglu,et al.  Reduced discomfort during high-definition transcutaneous stimulation using 6% benzocaine , 2014, Frontiers in Neuroengineering.

[7]  N. Cooper,et al.  Perceived Comfort and Blinding Efficacy in Randomised Sham-Controlled Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) Trials at 2 mA in Young and Older Healthy Adults , 2016, PloS one.

[8]  Paul-Christian Bürkner,et al.  Ordinal Regression Models in Psychology: A Tutorial , 2019, Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science.

[9]  Lucas C. Parra,et al.  Rigor and reproducibility in research with transcranial electrical stimulation: An NIMH-sponsored workshop , 2017, Brain Stimulation.

[10]  M. Nitsche,et al.  Evaluation of Sham Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation for Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trials , 2013, Brain Stimulation.

[11]  A. Antal,et al.  Safety aspects of transcranial direct current stimulation concerning healthy subjects and patients , 2007, Brain Research Bulletin.

[12]  Louise Marston,et al.  Rethinking Clinical Trials of Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation: Participant and Assessor Blinding Is Inadequate at Intensities of 2mA , 2012, PloS one.

[13]  Axel Thielscher,et al.  On the importance of electrode parameters for shaping electric field patterns generated by tDCS , 2015, NeuroImage.

[14]  Guy E. Hawkins,et al.  Increasing propensity to mind‐wander by transcranial direct current stimulation? A registered report , 2020, The European journal of neuroscience.

[15]  Geraint Rees,et al.  Increasing propensity to mind-wander with transcranial direct current stimulation , 2015, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[16]  Lena Sarp,et al.  The fade-in – Short stimulation – Fade out approach to sham tDCS – Reliable at 1 mA for naïve and experienced subjects, but not investigators , 2012, Brain Stimulation.

[17]  Yoshikazu Ugawa,et al.  Adverse events of tDCS and tACS: A review , 2016, Clinical neurophysiology practice.

[18]  N. Wenderoth,et al.  A technical guide to tDCS, and related non-invasive brain stimulation tools , 2016, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[19]  The effect of transcranial direct current stimulation on experimentally induced heat pain , 2014, Experimental Brain Research.

[20]  Alvaro Pascual-Leone,et al.  Challenges of proper placebo control for non‐invasive brain stimulation in clinical and experimental applications , 2013, The European journal of neuroscience.

[21]  G. Thickbroom,et al.  Perception of comfort during transcranial DC stimulation: Effect of NaCl solution concentration applied to sponge electrodes , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[22]  Riccardo Russo,et al.  Perception of Comfort During Active and Sham Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation: A Double Blind Study , 2013, Brain Stimulation.

[23]  S. Rossi,et al.  Low intensity transcranial electric stimulation: Safety, ethical, legal regulatory and application guidelines , 2017, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[24]  William W. McDonald,et al.  International randomized-controlled trial of transcranial Direct Current Stimulation in depression , 2018, Brain Stimulation.

[25]  Mark S. George,et al.  Reducing procedural pain and discomfort associated with transcranial direct current stimulation , 2011, Brain Stimulation.

[26]  L. Cohen,et al.  Transcranial DC stimulation (tDCS): A tool for double-blind sham-controlled clinical studies in brain stimulation , 2006, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[27]  Torrin M. Liddell,et al.  Analyzing Ordinal Data with Metric Models: What Could Possibly Go Wrong? , 2017, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.

[28]  Felipe Fregni,et al.  The Influence of Skin Redness on Blinding in Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Studies: A Crossover Trial , 2017, Neuromodulation : journal of the International Neuromodulation Society.

[29]  Marom Bikson,et al.  Reducing Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation‐Induced Erythema With Skin Pretreatment: Considerations for Sham‐Controlled Clinical Trials , 2015, Neuromodulation : journal of the International Neuromodulation Society.

[30]  J L Saumet,et al.  Vasodilatation in response to repeated anodal current application in the human skin relies on aspirin‐sensitive mechanisms , 2002, The Journal of physiology.

[31]  P. Turkeltaub,et al.  Differences in the experience of active and sham transcranial direct current stimulation , 2012, Brain Stimulation.

[32]  Carlo Miniussi,et al.  What do you feel if I apply transcranial electric stimulation? Safety, sensations and secondary induced effects , 2015, Clinical Neurophysiology.