The tripartite model of representation

Robert Cummins [(1996) Representations, targets and attitudes, Cambridge, MA: Bradford/MIT, p. 1] has characterized the vexed problem of mental representation as "the topic in the philosophy of mind for some time now." This remark is something of an understatement. The same topic was central to the famous controversy between Nicolas Malebranche and Antoine Arnauld in the 17th century and remained central to the entire philosophical tradition of "ideas" in the writings of Locke, Berkeley, Hume, Reid and Kant. However, the scholarly, exegetical literature has almost no overlap with that of contemporary cognitive science. I show that the recurrence of certain deep perplexities about the mind is a systematic and pervasive pattern arising not only throughout history, but also in a number of independent domains today such as debates over visual imagery, symbolic systems and others. Such historical and contemporary convergences suggest that the fundamental issues cannot arise essentially from the theoretical guise they take in any particular case.

[1]  William Bechtel,et al.  Representations and Cognitive Explanations: Assessing the Dynamicist's Challenge in Cognitive Science , 1998, Cogn. Sci..

[2]  Richmond H. Thomason,et al.  Logic and Articial Intelligence , 2002 .

[3]  G. Currie,et al.  Internal and external pictures , 1999 .

[4]  Ned Block,et al.  Advertisement for a Semantics for Psychology , 1987 .

[5]  D. B. Robins,et al.  Representations, Targets, and Attitudes , 1997, Information Processing & Management.

[6]  R. Gregory,et al.  Knowledge in perception and illusion. , 1997, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[7]  J. Fodor,et al.  Concepts: a potboiler , 1994, Cognition.

[8]  A puzzling element in the notion of thinking , 1958 .

[9]  E. Zahar.  SECOND THOUGHTS ABOUT MACHIAN POSITIVISM: A REPLY TO FEYERABEND , 1981, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science.

[10]  H. Feigl,et al.  Minnesota studies in the philosophy of science , 1956 .

[11]  J. Sullivan.  ON CARTESIAN LINGUISTICS , 1977 .

[12]  Walter J. Freeman,et al.  Representations: Who Needs Them? , 1990 .

[13]  J. Greeno.  Situations, mental models, and generative knowledge. , 1989 .

[14]  Daniel C. Dennett,et al.  A cure for the common code , 1978 .

[15]  J. Yolton.  Locke and the Way of Ideas , 1993 .

[16]  Lawrence Birnbaum,et al.  Rigor Mortis: A Response to Nilsson's "Logic and Artificial Intelligence" , 1991, Artif. Intell..

[17]  K. Sterelny.  The Imagery Debate , 1986, Philosophy of Science.

[18]  Pierre Nicole,et al.  Logic or the Art of Thinking , 1996 .

[19]  Chris Eliasmith,et al.  The third contender: A critical examination of the Dynamicist theory of cognition , 1996 .

[20]  Peter Carruthers,et al.  Theories of theories of mind: What is acquired – theory-theory versus simulation-theory , 1996 .

[21]  Vladimir Ilʹich Lenin.  Materialism and empirio-criticism : critical notes concerning a reactionary philosophy , 1927 .

[22]  Nils J. Nilsson.  Commentary on McDermott , 1987 .

[23]  Z. Pylyshyn.  Mental imagery: In search of a theory , 2002, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[24]  P. Winch,et al.  The Idea of a Social Science , 1960 .

[25]  Ray Jackendo,et al.  Languages of the Mind , 1992 .

[26]  Donald A. Norman,et al.  Representation in Memory. , 1983 .

[27]  A. Pyle.  Malebranche and Ideas , 1995 .

[28]  Zenon W. Pylyshyn,et al.  What the Mind’s Eye Tells the Mind’s Brain: A Critique of Mental Imagery , 1973 .

[29]  J. Fodor,et al.  The elm and the expert : mentalese and its semantics , 1995 .

[30]  Kenneth Kotovsky,et al.  Complex Information Processing: The Impact of Herbert A. Simon , 1989 .

[31]  Roger Smith,et al.  Philosophy and memory traces: Descartes to connectionism , 2000, Medical History.

[32]  D. Smith.  Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature , 1981 .

[33]  lan Tattersall,et al.  Treatise on man , 1993, Nature.

[34]  U. T. Place,et al.  Is consciousness a brain process? , 1956, British journal of psychology.

[35]  S. Kosslyn.  Image and Brain: The Resolution of the Imagery Debate , 1994, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[36]  Keith A. Coleman,et al.  On the Propositional Attitudes , 1991 .

[37]  Peter Carruthers,et al.  Thinking in Language?: Evolution and a Modularist Possibility , 1998 .

[38]  Stephen Gaukroger,et al.  Descartes: An Intellectual Biography , 1996 .

[39]  Geoffrey E. Hinton.  Mental simulation , 1990, Nature.

[40]  T. C. Meyering.  Representation and resemblance: A review essay of Richard A. Watson's representational ideas. From Plato to Patricia Churchland , 1997 .

[41]  Gillian Romney,et al.  SENSE AND SENSIBILIA , 1962 .

[42]  S. Kosslyn.  Image and mind , 1982 .

[43]  S. Stich,et al.  Connectionism, Eliminativism, and the Future of Folk Psychology , 1990 .

[44]  R. W. Field,et al.  LANGUAGE, THOUGHT AND CONSCIOUSNESS , 1999 .

[45]  Peter Carruthers,et al.  Language, Thought and Consciousness: An Essay in Philosophical Psychology , 1996 .

[46]  John R. Searle,et al.  Minds, brains, and programs , 1980, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[47]  Nils J. Nilsson,et al.  Logic and Artificial Intelligence , 1991, Artif. Intell..

[48]  J. Locke.  An Essay concerning Human Understanding , 1924, Nature.

[49]  S. Pinker,et al.  Emergent two-dimensional patterns in images rotated in depth. , 1980, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[50]  P. Slezak.  Man not a subject for science , 1990 .

[51]  F. Bartlett,et al.  Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology , 1932 .

[52]  Jerry A. Fodor,et al.  Fodor's guide to mental representation: the intelligent auntie's Vade-Mecum , 1993 .

[53]  S. Kemp.  Theories of cognition in the later Middle Ages , 1999 .

[54]  P. Slezak.  Thinking about thinking: language, thought and introspection , 2002 .

[55]  S Edelman,et al.  Representation is representation of similarities , 1996, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[56]  Michael Tye,et al.  The Adverbial Approach to Visual Experience , 1984 .

[57]  James B. Seaborn,et al.  The Starry Messenger , 1998 .

[58]  Steven P. Shwartz,et al.  On the demystification of mental imagery , 1979, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[59]  T. Gelder,et al.  The dynamical hypothesis in cognitive science , 1998, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[60]  Steven Nadler,et al.  The Search After Truth , 2003 .

[61]  R. Shepard,et al.  Mental Rotation of Three-Dimensional Objects , 1971, Science.

[62]  Donald Davidson,et al.  Thought and Talk , 2001 .

[63]  A. Markman,et al.  In Defense of Representation , 2000, Cognitive Psychology.

[64]  James L. McGaugh,et al.  Brain Organization and Memory: Cells, Systems, and Circuits , 1992 .

[65]  Behaviorism at fifty. , 1963 .

[66]  S. Kosslyn.  Seeing and imagining in the cerebral hemispheres: a computational approach. , 1987, Psychological review.

[67]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Beliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception , 1983, Cognition.

[68]  H. Dingle,et al.  The Foundations of Empirical Knowledge , 1941, Nature.

[69]  The argument from illusion , 2000 .

[70]  R. A. Brooks,et al.  Intelligence without Representation , 1991, Artif. Intell..

[71]  J. Fodor.  Methodological solipsism considered as a research strategy in cognitive psychology , 1980, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[72]  John W. Yolton,et al.  Perceptual Acquaintance From Descartes to Reid. , 1986 .

[73]  S. Stich,et al.  What is folk psychology? , 1994, Cognition.

[74]  Peter Carruthers,et al.  Theories of theories of mind: Frontmatter , 1996 .