A systematic review and meta-analysis of user acceptance of consumer-oriented health information technologies

Abstract This study was conducted to synthesize existing studies on user acceptance of consumer-oriented health information technologies (CHITs) through a systematic review and meta-analysis. We searched four electronic databases in August 2018 for studies that empirically examined user acceptance of CHITs based on theoretical frameworks of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). Meta-analysis was used to estimate effect sizes of pairwise relationships among TAM constructs, while subgroup analysis was performed to investigate potential factors that may moderate TAM relationships. Sixty-seven studies were identified and included for analysis. The results show that TAM was a robust model in examining user acceptance of CHITs. The results also identified a number of significant relationships between several antecedents (self-efficacy, subjective norm, trust, perceived behavioral control and facilitating conditions) and the core TAM constructs. In addition, many of the relationships could be moderated by study characteristics such as country of origin, type of user and type of technology. The findings demonstrated that TAM represents a good ground theory for examining factors that influence consumer acceptance of CHITs. Further efforts can be dedicated to contextualize the use of TAM theories in CHIT domain and to further examine factors that are able to moderate the model relationships.

[1]  Timo Koivumäki,et al.  Consumer Adoption of Future MyData-Based Preventive eHealth Services: An Acceptance Model and Survey Study , 2017, Journal of medical Internet research.

[2]  Spencer S. Jones,et al.  Health Information Technology: An Updated Systematic Review With a Focus on Meaningful Use , 2014, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[3]  Zhaohua Deng,et al.  Understanding public users' adoption of mobile health service , 2013, Int. J. Mob. Commun..

[4]  Hyeoun-Ae Park,et al.  Development of a Health Information Technology Acceptance Model Using Consumers’ Health Behavior Intention , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[5]  Henry Been-Lirn Duh,et al.  A study on Singaporean women's acceptance of using mobile phones to seek health information , 2011, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[6]  Wei Zhang,et al.  The roles of initial trust and perceived risk in public’s acceptance of automated vehicles , 2019, Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies.

[7]  Fong-Lin Jang,et al.  Patients’ Acceptance towards a Web-Based Personal Health Record System: An Empirical Study in Taiwan , 2013, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[8]  Gunther Eysenbach,et al.  Consumer health informatics , 2000, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[9]  Jennifer Jewer,et al.  Patients' intention to use online postings of ED wait times: A modified UTAUT model , 2018, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[10]  David C. Yen,et al.  Exploring user acceptance of an e-hospital service: An empirical study in Taiwan , 2015, Comput. Stand. Interfaces.

[11]  E. Vance Wilson,et al.  Modeling patients' acceptance of provider-delivered e-health. , 2004, Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association : JAMIA.

[12]  Andrea Chester,et al.  Adolescent and parent content preferences and predictors of intention to use an online health weight website for adolescents , 2010 .

[13]  Qinghua Zhu,et al.  A meta-analysis of the impact of trust on technology acceptance model: Investigation of moderating influence of subject and context type , 2011, Int. J. Inf. Manag..

[14]  Zhimin Zhou,et al.  Factors affecting reposting behaviour using a mobile phone-based user-generated-content online community application among Chinese young adults , 2018, Behav. Inf. Technol..

[15]  Mian Yan,et al.  A 12-week pilot study of acceptance of a computer-based chronic disease self-monitoring system among patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus and/or hypertension , 2019, Health Informatics J..

[16]  Betsy Jane Becker,et al.  The Synthesis of Regression Slopes in Meta-Analysis. , 2007, 0801.4442.

[17]  J. Cegarra-Navarro,et al.  Understanding patient e-loyalty toward online health care services , 2013, Health care management review.

[18]  Peter Trkman,et al.  Analyzing older users' home telehealth services acceptance behavior - applying an Extended UTAUT model , 2016, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[19]  John E. Hunter,et al.  Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings , 1991 .

[20]  Susan S. Woods,et al.  Barriers and drivers of health information technology use for the elderly, chronically ill, and underserved. , 2008, Evidence report/technology assessment.

[21]  Mohammed-Issa Riad Mousa Jaradat,et al.  Mobile Healthcare Adoption among Patients in a Developing Country Environment: Exploring the Influence of Age and Gender Differences , 2015 .

[22]  M. Santana,et al.  Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare Dovepress Adoption of E-health Technology by Physicians: a Scoping Review , 2022 .

[23]  Kok Wei Khong,et al.  Integrating Health Belief Model and Technology Acceptance Model: An Investigation of Health-Related Internet Use , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[24]  G. Smith,et al.  Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test , 1997, BMJ.

[25]  D. Blumenthal,et al.  The benefits of health information technology: a review of the recent literature shows predominantly positive results. , 2011, Health affairs.

[26]  Carmen K M Wong,et al.  Chinese Older Adults’ Internet Use for Health Information , 2014, Journal of applied gerontology : the official journal of the Southern Gerontological Society.

[27]  T. Andreassen,et al.  Electronic healthcare: a study of people's readiness and attitude toward performing self‐diagnosis , 2007 .

[28]  Chien-Lung Hsu,et al.  Research on a Community-based Platform for Promoting Health and Physical Fitness in the Elderly Community , 2013, PloS one.

[29]  Marjan Hericko,et al.  A meta-analysis of e-learning technology acceptance: The role of user types and e-learning technology types , 2011, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[30]  Myron D. Fottler,et al.  Intention to use a personal health record: a theoretical analysis using the technology acceptance model , 2013 .

[31]  Tiffany C. Veinot,et al.  Transforming consumer health informatics through a patient work framework: connecting patients to context , 2015, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[32]  Eun Kyoung Yun,et al.  The impact of user's perceived ability on online health information acceptance. , 2012, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[33]  R. Epstein,et al.  The Values and Value of Patient-Centered Care , 2011, The Annals of Family Medicine.

[34]  J. H. Davis,et al.  An Integrative Model Of Organizational Trust , 1995 .

[35]  Yongqiang Sun,et al.  The dark side of elderly acceptance of preventive mobile health services in China , 2013, Electron. Mark..

[36]  Xiao-hong Chen,et al.  Moderating factors influencing adoption of a mobile chronic disease management system in China , 2018, Informatics for health & social care.

[37]  P. Shekelle,et al.  Systematic Review: Impact of Health Information Technology on Quality, Efficiency, and Costs of Medical Care , 2006, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[38]  Da Tao,et al.  Usability Study of a Computer-Based Self-Management System for Older Adults with Chronic Diseases , 2012, JMIR research protocols.

[39]  Wen-Yen Lin,et al.  Development of a Wearable Instrumented Vest for Posture Monitoring and System Usability Verification Based on the Technology Acceptance Model , 2016, Sensors.

[40]  Da Tao,et al.  The effectiveness of the use of consumer health information technology in patients with heart failure: A meta-analysis and narrative review of randomized controlled trials , 2017, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[41]  D. Altman,et al.  Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[42]  Yiwen Gao,et al.  An empirical study of wearable technology acceptance in healthcare , 2015, Ind. Manag. Data Syst..

[43]  J. Miles,et al.  Applying regression & correlation : a guide for students and researchers , 2001 .

[44]  Steven P. Brown,et al.  On the use of beta coefficients in meta-analysis. , 2005, The Journal of applied psychology.

[45]  Sumedha Chauhan,et al.  Journal of Enterprise Information Management A meta-analysis of e-health applications acceptance : Moderating impact of user types and e-health application types , 2017 .

[46]  Da Tao,et al.  A meta-analysis of the use of electronic reminders for patient adherence to medication in chronic disease care , 2015, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[47]  Danielle Symons Downs,et al.  Elicitation studies and the theory of planned behavior: a systematic review of exercise beliefs , 2003 .

[48]  Dong-Hee Shin,et al.  Understanding technology acceptance in a mandatory environment , 2016 .

[49]  Shu-Ping Lin,et al.  Exploring key factors in the choice of e-health using an asthma care mobile service model. , 2009, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[50]  Jui-Chen Huang,et al.  Innovative health care delivery system - A questionnaire survey to evaluate the influence of behavioral factors on individuals' acceptance of telecare , 2013, Comput. Biol. Medicine.

[51]  D. Blumenthal Stimulating the adoption of health information technology. , 2009, The West Virginia medical journal.

[52]  Tony R. Sahama,et al.  The Australian general public's perceptions of having a personally controlled electronic health record (PCEHR) , 2014, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[53]  Albert L. Lederer,et al.  A Meta-Analysis of the Role of Environment-Based Voluntariness in Information Technology Acceptance , 2009, MIS Q..

[54]  Fred D. Davis,et al.  A Theoretical Extension of the Technology Acceptance Model: Four Longitudinal Field Studies , 2000, Management Science.

[55]  Julia C. M. van Weert,et al.  The effectiveness of interventions using electronic reminders to improve adherence to chronic medication: a systematic review of the literature , 2012, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[56]  S MacRury,et al.  The use of technology to promote physical activity in Type 2 diabetes management: a systematic review , 2013, Diabetic medicine : a journal of the British Diabetic Association.

[57]  Mike W-L Cheung,et al.  Meta-analytic structural equation modeling: a two-stage approach. , 2005, Psychological methods.

[58]  Tiago Oliveira,et al.  Electronic Health Record Patient Portal Adoption by Health Care Consumers: An Acceptance Model and Survey , 2016, Journal of medical Internet research.

[59]  Ming-Chien Hung,et al.  An empirical study of adopting mobile healthcare service: the family's perspective on the healthcare needs of their elderly members. , 2010, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[60]  J. Cleland,et al.  Remote monitoring after recent hospital discharge in patients with heart failure: a systematic review and network meta-analysis , 2013, Heart.

[61]  Tae-Min Song,et al.  Analysis of the Factors Affecting Consumer Acceptance of Accredited Online Health Information , 2017, Journal of Korean medical science.

[62]  Mun Y. Yi,et al.  Understanding information technology acceptance by individual professionals: Toward an integrative view , 2006, Inf. Manag..

[63]  Melinda Whetstone,et al.  Factors influencing intention to use personal health records , 2009 .

[64]  P. Duyck,et al.  User Acceptance of a Picture Archiving and Communication System , 2008, Methods of Information in Medicine.

[65]  Clemens Scott Kruse,et al.  Patient and Provider Attitudes Toward the Use of Patient Portals for the Management of Chronic Disease: A Systematic Review , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[66]  Xitong Guo,et al.  UNDERSTANDING THE ACCEPTANCE OF MOBILE HEALTH SERVICES: A COMPARISON AND INTEGRATION OF ALTERNATIVE MODELS , 2013 .

[67]  Hock Chuan Chan,et al.  The perception and intention to adopt female-focused healthcare applications (FHA): A comparison between healthcare workers and non-healthcare workers , 2009, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[68]  Zhaohua Deng,et al.  Comparison of the middle-aged and older users' adoption of mobile health services in China , 2014, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[69]  L. Hedges,et al.  Introduction to Meta‐Analysis , 2009, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[70]  Da Tao,et al.  Effects of Self-Management Health Information Technology on Glycaemic Control for Patients with Diabetes: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[71]  S. Liu,et al.  Meta-analysis and meta-regression of telehealth programmes for patients with chronic heart failure , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[72]  Mark Srite,et al.  A Research Model for Mobile Phone Service Behaviors: Empirical Validation in the U.S. and Turkey , 2005 .

[73]  Fred D. Davis,et al.  A Model of the Antecedents of Perceived Ease of Use: Development and Test† , 1996 .

[74]  Nazmul Hossain,et al.  Factors Influencing Rural End-Users' Acceptance of e-Health in Developing Countries: A Study on Portable Health Clinic in Bangladesh , 2019, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[75]  Paul Jen-Hwa Hu,et al.  Examining a Model of Information Technology Acceptance by Individual Professionals: An Exploratory Study , 2002, J. Manag. Inf. Syst..

[76]  J. Higgins,et al.  Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2010, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[77]  Gordon B. Davis,et al.  User Acceptance of Information Technology: Toward a Unified View , 2003, MIS Q..

[78]  Wolfgang Maass,et al.  Design and evaluation of Ubiquitous Information Systems and use in healthcare , 2012, Decis. Support Syst..

[79]  Kai-Yu Tang,et al.  Examining a Model of Mobile Healthcare Technology Acceptance by the Elderly in Taiwan , 2015 .

[80]  Jaehee Cho,et al.  The impact of post-adoption beliefs on the continued use of health apps , 2016, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[81]  Patricia Flatley Brennan,et al.  Factors affecting home care patients' acceptance of a web-based interactive self-management technology , 2011, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[82]  B. Cudmore,et al.  Encouraging consumer searching behavior on healthcare web sites , 2011 .

[83]  Ben-Tzion Karsh,et al.  Review Paper: A Systematic Review of Patient Acceptance of Consumer Health Information Technology , 2009, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[84]  Pei-Luen Patrick Rau,et al.  The acceptance of personal health devices among patients with chronic conditions , 2015, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[85]  Ming-Chien Hung,et al.  The Adoption of Mobile Health Management Services: An Empirical Study , 2012, Journal of Medical Systems.

[86]  Shumaila Y. Yousafzai,et al.  Technology acceptance: a meta‐analysis of the TAM: Part 2 , 2007 .

[87]  Audie A Atienza,et al.  Mobile health technology evaluation: the mHealth evidence workshop. , 2013, American journal of preventive medicine.

[88]  Chung-Hung Tsai Integrating Social Capital Theory, Social Cognitive Theory, and the Technology Acceptance Model to Explore a Behavioral Model of Telehealth Systems , 2014, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[89]  Fred D. Davis,et al.  User Acceptance of Computer Technology: A Comparison of Two Theoretical Models , 1989 .

[90]  Ardion Beldad,et al.  Expanding the Technology Acceptance Model with the Inclusion of Trust, Social Influence, and Health Valuation to Determine the Predictors of German Users’ Willingness to Continue using a Fitness App: A Structural Equation Modeling Approach , 2018, Int. J. Hum. Comput. Interact..

[91]  Wen-Yuan Jen,et al.  The adoption of mobile weight management services in a virtual community: the perspective of college students. , 2010, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[92]  Cynthia LeRouge,et al.  Baby Boomers’ Adoption of Consumer Health Technologies: Survey on Readiness and Barriers , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[93]  Tiago Oliveira,et al.  Electronic Health Record Portals adoption: Empirical model based on UTAUT2 , 2018, Informatics for health & social care.

[94]  Amy Butros,et al.  Research Paper: Giving Patients Access to Their Medical Records via the Internet: The PCASSO Experience , 2002, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[95]  Mark W. Lipsey,et al.  Practical Meta-Analysis , 2000 .

[96]  Hyeoun-Ae Park,et al.  Consumers' disease information-seeking behaviour on the Internet in Korea. , 2010, Journal of clinical nursing.

[97]  Dohoon Kim,et al.  Key functional characteristics in designing and operating health information websites for user satisfaction: An application of the extended technology acceptance model , 2007, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[98]  Xitong Guo,et al.  User acceptance of mobile health services from users’ perspectives: The role of self-efficacy and response-efficacy in technology acceptance , 2017, Informatics for health & social care.

[99]  BaoYukun,et al.  Investigating Factors Affecting Elderly's Intention to Use m-Health Services: An Empirical Study. , 2017 .

[100]  Henry Been-Lirn Duh,et al.  An exploratory study of ageing women's perception on access to health informatics via a mobile phone-based intervention , 2012, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[101]  Uma Kumar,et al.  Predicting mobile health adoption behaviour: A demand side perspective , 2014 .

[102]  William R. King,et al.  A meta-analysis of the technology acceptance model , 2006, Inf. Manag..

[103]  Leila Agha The effects of health information technology on the costs and quality of medical care. , 2014, Journal of health economics.

[104]  Thomas Kubiak,et al.  Continuous Glucose Monitoring in Type 1 Diabetes , 2016, Journal of diabetes science and technology.

[105]  Ralf Terlutter,et al.  What Explains Usage of Mobile Physician-Rating Apps? Results From a Web-Based Questionnaire , 2014, Journal of medical Internet research.

[106]  Richard Klein,et al.  An empirical examination of patient-physician portal acceptance , 2007, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[107]  Judy Drennan,et al.  Consumer Acceptance of an SMS-Assisted Smoking Cessation Intervention: A Multicountry Study , 2013, Health marketing quarterly.

[108]  Martin Wetzels,et al.  A meta-analysis of the technology acceptance model: Investigating subjective norm and moderation effects , 2007, Inf. Manag..

[109]  W. Chinyamurindi,et al.  A study on students’ acceptance of mobile phone use to seek health information in South Africa , 2018, Health information management : journal of the Health Information Management Association of Australia.

[110]  Suzanne Bakken,et al.  Research Paper: User Acceptance of HIV TIDES - Tailored Interventions for Management of Depressive Symptoms in Persons Living with HIV/AIDS , 2008, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[111]  Keri K. Stephens,et al.  Design simplicity influences patient portal use: the role of aesthetic evaluations for technology acceptance , 2016, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[112]  Tiago Oliveira,et al.  A weight and a meta-analysis on mobile banking acceptance research , 2016, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[113]  Stephen Sutton,et al.  Eliciting salient beliefs in research on the theory of planned behaviour: The effect of question wording , 2003 .

[114]  J. Grimshaw,et al.  Constructing questionnaires based on the theory of planned behaviour: A manual for health services researchers , 2004 .

[115]  Shu-Ping Lin,et al.  Determinants of adoption of Mobile Healthcare Service , 2011, Int. J. Mob. Commun..

[116]  Richard J. Holden,et al.  The Technology Acceptance Model: Its past and its future in health care , 2010, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[117]  Amy K. Yarbrough,et al.  Technology Acceptance among Physicians , 2007, Medical care research and review : MCRR.

[118]  Da Tao,et al.  Does the use of consumer health information technology improve outcomes in the patient self-management of diabetes? A meta-analysis and narrative review of randomized controlled trials , 2014, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[119]  Louise S. Robbins,et al.  Understanding middle-aged women's health information seeking on the web: A theoretical approach , 2008 .

[120]  Md. Rakibul Hoque An empirical study of mHealth adoption in a developing country: the moderating effect of gender concern , 2016, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[121]  Yukun Bao,et al.  Investigating factors influencing the adoption of e-Health in developing countries: A patient’s perspective , 2017, Informatics for health & social care.

[122]  Hyeoun-Ae Park,et al.  Factors Affecting Acceptance of Smartphone Application for Management of Obesity , 2015, Healthcare informatics research.

[123]  Xingda Qu,et al.  Factors Affecting Consumer Acceptance of an Online Health Information Portal Among Young Internet Users , 2018, Computers, informatics, nursing : CIN.

[124]  Xingda Qu,et al.  Effects of consumer-oriented health information technologies in diabetes management over time: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials , 2017, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[125]  Golam Sorwar,et al.  Understanding factors influencing the adoption of mHealth by the elderly: An extension of the UTAUT model , 2017, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[126]  Luis Villa,et al.  A literature review for large-scale health information system project planning, implementation and evaluation , 2017, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[127]  Anne Moen,et al.  Model Formulation: Health@HomeThe Work of Health Information Management in the Household (HIMH): Implications for Consumer Health Informatics (CHI) Innovations , 2005, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[128]  Yajiong Xue,et al.  Online health information seeking by people with physical disabilities due to neurological conditions , 2011, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[129]  Richard G. Klein,et al.  Internet-Based Patient-Physician Electronic Communication Applications: Patient Acceptance and Trust , 2007 .

[130]  David C. Yen,et al.  Understanding the Mediating Effects of Relationship Quality on Technology Acceptance: An Empirical Study of E-Appointment System , 2013, Journal of Medical Systems.