Is there universal recognition of emotion from facial expression? A review of the cross-cultural studies.

Emotions are universally recognized from facial expressions--or so it has been claimed. To support that claim, research has been carried out in various modern cultures and in cultures relatively isolated from Western influence. A review of the methods used in that research raises questions of its ecological, convergent, and internal validity. Forced-choice response format, within-subject design, preselected photographs of posed facial expressions, and other features of method are each problematic. When they are altered, less supportive or nonsupportive results occur. When they are combined, these method factors may help to shape the results. Facial expressions and emotion labels are probably associated, but the association may vary with culture and is loose enough to be consistent with various alternative accounts, 8 of which are discussed.

[1]  Alexander Bain,et al.  The Emotions and the Will , 1860, The British and foreign medico-chirurgical review.

[2]  C. Darwin.  The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals , .

[3]  D. Spalding.  The Principles of Psychology , 1873, Nature.

[4]  J. L.,et al.  Expression of the Emotions , 1887, Nature.

[5]  Experimental Psychology and Pedagogy, Tr. By R. Pintner , 1912 .

[6]  W. Dearborn.  Experimental Psychology and Pedagogy. , 1913 .

[7]  H. S. Langfeld.  Judgments of facial expression and suggestion. , 1918 .

[8]  H. S. Langfeld.  The judgment of emotions from facial expressions. , 1918 .

[9]  The Control of Another Person by Obscure Signs. , 1921 .

[10]  C. A. Ruckmick.  A preliminary study of the emotions. , 1921 .

[11]  J. Stainer,et al.  The Emotions , 1922, Nature.

[12]  D. E. Buzby.  The Interpretation of Facial Expression. , 1924 .

[13]  C. Landis.  Studies of Emotional Reactions. II. General Behavior and Facial Expression. , 1924 .

[14]  M. Sherman.  The differentiation of emotional responses in infants. II. The ability of observers to judge the emotional characteristics of the crying of infants, and of the voice of an adult. , 1927 .

[15]  S. Fernberger.  False suggestion and the Piderit model. , 1928 .

[16]  Aristotle,et al.  The Works of Aristotle , 1929, Nature.

[17]  J. Guilford.  An experiment in learning to read facial expression. , 1929 .

[18]  A. Jersild,et al.  Feelings and Emotions. , 1929 .

[19]  F. Goodenough.  The expression of the emotions in infancy. , 1931 .

[20]  Florence L. Goodenough,et al.  The relative potency of facial expression and verbal description of stimulus in the judgment of emotion. , 1931 .

[21]  F. Goodenough.  Expression of the emotions in a blind-deaf child. , 1932 .

[22]  S. Fiske,et al.  The Handbook of Social Psychology , 1935 .

[23]  O. Klineberg.  Emotional expression in Chinese literature. , 1938 .

[24]  R. Thouless.  Experimental Psychology , 1939, Nature.

[25]  N. Munn.  The effect of knowledge of the situation upon judgment of emotion from facial expressions. , 1940 .

[26]  J. Thompson.  Development of facial expression of emotion in blind and seeing children. , 1941 .

[27]  H. Scholsberg.  A scale for the judgment of facial expressions. , 1941 .

[28]  Weston Labarre,et al.  The cultural basis of emotions and gestures. , 1947 .

[29]  W. E. Vinacke.  The judgment of facial expressions by three national-racial groups in Hawaii; Caucasian faces. , 1949, Journal of personality.

[30]  H. D. Goldberg,et al.  The role of "cutting" in the perception of the motion picture. , 1951, The Journal of applied psychology.

[31]  H. Schlosberg.  The description of facial expressions in terms of two dimensions. , 1952, Journal of experimental psychology.

[32]  Nico H. Frijda,et al.  The understanding of facial expression of emotion. , 1953 .

[33]  J. Bruner,et al.  THE PERCEPTION OF PEOPLE , 1954 .

[34]  H. Schlosberg.  Three dimensions of emotion. , 1954, Psychological review.

[35]  Claude C. Buxton.  Feelings and Emotions , 1954, The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine.

[36]  N. Frijda.  Facial expression and situational cues. , 1958, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[37]  H. Triandis,et al.  A restatement and test of Schlosberg's theory of emotion with two kinds of subjects from Greece. , 1958, Journal of Abnormal Psychology.

[38]  R. Abelson,et al.  Multidimensional scaling of facial expressions. , 1962, Journal of experimental psychology.

[39]  H. Helson,et al.  Adaptation-level theory , 1964 .

[40]  S. Tomkins,et al.  What and Where are the Primary Affects? Some Evidence for a Theory , 1964, Perceptual and motor skills.

[41]  A. Parducci.  Category judgment: a range-frequency model. , 1965, Psychological review.

[42]  C. Osgood.  Dimensionality of the semantic space for communication via facial expressions. , 1966, Scandinavian journal of psychology.

[43]  M. Manis,et al.  Context effects in communication. , 1967, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[44]  Elizabeth C. Evans,et al.  Physiognomics in the Ancient World , 1970 .

[45]  P. Ekman,et al.  Pan-Cultural Elements in Facial Displays of Emotion , 1969, Science.

[46]  R. Birdwhistell.  Kinesics and context , 1970 .

[47]  R. Howell,et al.  Accuracy of judging unposed emotional behavior in a natural setting: a replication study. , 1970, The Journal of social psychology.

[48]  D. Cüceloğlu.  Perception of Facial Expressions in Three Different Cultures , 1970 .

[49]  P. Ekman,et al.  Constants across cultures in the face and emotion. , 1971, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[50]  S G Watson,et al.  Judgment of emotion from facial and contextual cue combinations. , 1972, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[51]  P. Ekman.  Universals and cultural differences in facial expressions of emotion. , 1972 .

[52]  R. Hinde.  Concepts of emotion. , 1972, Ciba Foundation symposium.

[53]  R. Buck,et al.  Communication of affect through facial expressions in humans. , 1972, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[54]  I. Eibl-Eibesfeldt,et al.  The expressive behavior of the deaf-and-blind born , 1973 .

[55]  R. Buck,et al.  Sex, personality, and physiological variables in the communication of affect via facial expression. , 1974, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[56]  Michael T. Ghiselin,et al.  Darwin and Facial Expression: A Century of Research in Review.@@@Darwin on Man: A Psychological Study of Scientific Creativity. , 1974 .

[57]  Jacob Beck,et al.  Adaptation-level theory. , 1974 .

[58]  P. Ekman.  Unmasking The Face , 1975 .

[59]  E. Sorenson.  Culture and the Expression of Emotion , 1975 .

[60]  R. Passingham.  Social communication and movement : M. Von Cranach and I. Vine (eds.): Academic Press, London, 1973. viii + 489 pp. £8.50 , 1975 .

[61]  P. Ekman,et al.  Measuring facial movement , 1976 .

[62]  Ross Buck,et al.  Human motivation and emotion , 1976 .

[63]  P. Ekman.  Pictures of Facial Affect , 1976 .

[64]  E. Sorenson.  The Edge of the Forest: Land, Childhood, and Change in a New Guinea Protoagricultural Society , 1976 .

[65]  M. Yarczower,et al.  Recognition of Happy and Sad Facial Expressions among Baganda and U.S. Children , 1976 .

[66]  Clayton A. Robarchek.  frustration, aggression, and the nonviolent Semai , 1977 .

[67]  J. Valsiner,et al.  Recognition of facial expressions: An experimental investigation of Ekman's model. , 1977 .

[68]  D. Krantz.  Nebraska symposium on motivation 1977. , 1977, Nebraska Symposium on Motivation. Nebraska Symposium on Motivation.

[69]  R. Exline,et al.  The relative accuracy of U.S. British, and Mexican raters in judging the emotional displays of schizophrenic and normal U.S. women. , 1978, Journal of clinical psychology.

[70]  Michael Argyle,et al.  The intercultural recognition of emotional expressions by three national racial groups : English, Italian and Japanese , 1978 .

[71]  I. Eibl-Eibesfeldt.  Similarities and differences between cultures in expressive movements , 1979 .

[72]  A. W. Siegman,et al.  Nonverbal behavior and communication , 1979 .

[73]  M. Yarczower,et al.  Recognition and Imitation of Facial Expressions , 1980 .

[74]  S. Tomkins.  AFFECT AS AMPLIFICATION: SOME MODIFICATIONS IN THEORY , 1980 .

[75]  P. Ekman,et al.  Facial signs of emotional experience. , 1980 .

[76]  J. Russell.  A circumplex model of affect. , 1980 .

[77]  S. Thayer.  The effect of expression sequence and expressor identity on judgments of the intensity of facial expression , 1980 .

[78]  J. Boucher,et al.  Recognition of Facial Expression in Three Cultures , 1980 .

[79]  T. K. Srull,et al.  Category accessibility: Some theoretical and empirical issues concerning the processing of social stimulus information , 1981 .

[80]  R. Abelson.  Psychological status of the script concept. , 1981 .

[81]  R. Shor,et al.  The Judgment of Emotion from Facial Expressions, Contexts, and Their Combination , 1981 .

[82]  P. Ekman.  The face of man : expressions of universal emotions in a New Guinea village , 1981 .

[83]  S. Fiske,et al.  Social Psychology , 2019, Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences.

[84]  Richard J. Davidson,et al.  Differential contributions of the two cerebral hemispheres to the perception of happy and sad faces , 1981, Neuropsychologia.

[85]  Theodore Shapiro,et al.  Measuring Emotions in Infants and Children , 1982 .

[86]  Luciano Arcuri,et al.  Emotion Recognition in Ethiopia , 1982 .

[87]  C. Brun.  Méthode pour apprendre à dessiner les passions : proposée dans une conférence sur l'expression générale et particulière , 1982 .

[88]  P. Ekman.  Emotion in the human face , 1982 .

[89]  C. W. Hughes.  Emotion: Theory, Research and Experience , 1982 .

[90]  The face of man: Expressions of universal emotions in a New Guinea village: by Paul Ekman. Garland STPM, NY, 1980. 143 pp. $25.00 , 1982 .

[91]  John T. Cacioppo,et al.  Social psychophysiology : a sourcebook , 1983 .

[92]  J. Polivy,et al.  A conical model for the taxonomy of emotional experience. , 1983 .

[93]  M. Yarczower,et al.  Ethnic bias in the recognition of facial expressions , 1983 .

[94]  Harold Knudsen,et al.  The effects of verbal statements of context on facial expressions of emotion , 1983 .

[95]  M. Shapiro.  Emotion in the Human Face. 2nd edition. Edited by P. Ekman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1983. Pp 439. £25.00, £9.95 (paperback). , 1983, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[96]  James A. Russell,et al.  Adaptation level and the affective appraisal of environments , 1984 .

[97]  J. Russell,et al.  Concept of Emotion Viewed From a Prototype Perspective , 1984 .

[98]  W. Rinn,et al.  The neuropsychology of facial expression: a review of the neurological and psychological mechanisms for producing facial expressions. , 1984, Psychological bulletin.

[99]  P. Ekman.  Expression and the Nature of Emotion , 1984 .

[100]  P. Ekman,et al.  Approaches To Emotion , 1985 .

[101]  D. Watson,et al.  Toward a consensual structure of mood. , 1985, Psychological bulletin.

[102]  Bruce Bowe.  The Face of Emotion , 1985 .

[103]  D. Chan.  Perception and Judgment of Facial Expressions Among the Chinese , 1985 .

[104]  W. Montgomery.  Chapter 2 – Charles Darwin's Thought on Expressive Mechanisms in Evolution , 1985 .

[105]  J. Russell,et al.  Fuzzy Concepts and the Perception of Emotion in Facial Expressions , 1986 .

[106]  P. Ekman,et al.  A new pan-cultural facial expression of emotion , 1986 .

[107]  Antony Stephen Reid Manstead,et al.  Communication of individual emotions by spontaneous facial expressions , 1986 .

[108]  Joshua R. Gerow.  Psychology: An Introduction , 1986 .

[109]  Francis T. McAndrew,et al.  A Cross-Cultural Study of Recognition Thresholds for Facial Expressions of Emotion , 1986 .

[110]  J. Russell,et al.  Concepts of emotion in developmental psychology , 1986 .

[111]  Affect, personality, and facial expressive characteristics of older people. , 1987 .

[112]  J. Russell,et al.  Relativity in the Perception of Emotion in Facial Expressions , 1987 .

[113]  J. Messina,et al.  Affect, personality, and facial expressive characteristics of older people. , 1987, Psychology and aging.

[114]  P. Ekman,et al.  DIFFERENCES Universals and Cultural Differences in the Judgments of Facial Expressions of Emotion , 2004 .

[115]  C. Nelson.  The recognition of facial expressions in the first two years of life: mechanisms of development. , 1987, Child development.

[116]  C. Izard,et al.  Perspectives on emotional development I: Differential emotions theory of early emotional development. , 1987 .

[117]  C. Izard,et al.  On the form and universality of the contempt expression: A challenge to Ekman and Friesen's claim of discovery , 1988 .

[118]  Ross Buck,et al.  Human motivation and emotion, 2nd ed. , 1988 .

[119]  Harald G. Wallbott.  In and out of context: Influences of facial expression and context information on emotion attributions , 1988 .

[120]  Paul Ekman,et al.  The universality of a contempt expression: A replication , 1988 .

[121]  M. T. Motley,et al.  Facial expression of emotion: A comparison of posed expressions versus spontaneous expressions in an interpersonal communication setting , 1988 .

[122]  P. Ekman,et al.  Who knows what about contempt: A reply to Izard and Haynes , 1988 .

[123]  Michelle Cohen,et al.  Sensitivity of Canadians, Latin Americans, Ethiopians, and Israelis to interracial facial expressions of emotions , 1988 .

[124]  William B. Gudykunst,et al.  Culture and interpersonal communication , 1988 .

[125]  P. Ekman.  The argument and evidence about universals in facial expressions of emotion. , 1989 .

[126]  J. Russell.  MEASURES OF EMOTION , 1989 .

[127]  A. Young,et al.  Handbook of Research on Face Processing , 1989 .

[128]  P. Johnson-Laird,et al.  The language of emotions: An analysis of a semantic field , 2013 .

[129]  Paul L. Harris,et al.  Children's understanding of emotion , 1989 .

[130]  J. Forgas,et al.  Recent advances in social psychology : an international perspective , 1989 .

[131]  J. Russell,et al.  A cross-cultural study of a circumplex model of affect. , 1989 .

[132]  A. Manstead,et al.  Handbook of social psychophysiology , 1989 .

[133]  P. Ekman,et al.  American-Japanese cultural differences in intensity ratings of facial expressions of emotion , 1989 .

[134]  C A Smith.  Dimensions of appraisal and physiological response in emotion. , 1989, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[135]  H. Oster.  PROCESSING FACIAL AFFECT , 1989 .

[136]  James A. Russell,et al.  Culture, scripts, and children's understanding of emotion. , 1989 .

[137]  R. Zajonc,et al.  Feeling and facial efference: implications of the vascular theory of emotion. , 1989, Psychological review.

[138]  G. Boulogne,et al.  The Mechanism of Human Facial Expression , 1990 .

[139]  U. Wikan.  Managing Turbulent Hearts: A Balinese Formula for Living , 1990 .

[140]  D. A. Kenny,et al.  Relative contributions of expressive behavior and contextual information to the judgment of the emotional state of another. , 1990, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[141]  A. Ortony,et al.  What's basic about basic emotions? , 1990, Psychological review.

[142]  C. Izard.  Facial expressions and the regulation of emotions. , 1990, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[143]  D. Matsumoto.  Cultural similarities and differences in display rules , 1990 .

[144]  B. Mullen,et al.  Facial asymmetry in emotional expression: A meta-analysis of research , 1991 .

[145]  J. A. Russell,et al.  The contempt expression and the relativity thesis , 1991 .

[146]  J. G. Carlson,et al.  Psychology of Emotion , 1991 .

[147]  P. Ekman,et al.  Contradictions in the study of contempt: What's it all about? Reply to Russell , 1991 .

[148]  J. Russell.  Culture and the categorization of emotions. , 1991, Psychological bulletin.

[149]  J. Russell.  Negative results on a reported facial expression of contempt , 1991 .

[150]  K. Strongman.  International review of studies on emotion , 1991 .

[151]  P. Ekman,et al.  Confusions about context in the judgment of facial expression: A reply to “the contempt expression and the relativity thesis” , 1991 .

[152]  A. J. Fridlund.  Evolution and facial action in reflex, social motive, and paralanguage , 1991, Biological Psychology.

[153]  A. J. Fridlund.  Sociality of Solitary Smiling: Potentiation by an Implicit Audience , 1991 .

[154]  H. Wallbott,et al.  Emotion category accessibility and the decoding of emotion from facial expression and context , 1991 .

[155]  Ron Sept.  Culture and Interpersonal Communication , 1991 .

[156]  L. Vistnes.  The Artist??s Complete Guide to Facial Expression , 1992 .

[157]  H. Oster,et al.  Adult Judgments and Fine-Grained Analysis of Infant Facial Expressions: Testing the Validity of A Priori Coding Formulas. , 1992 .

[158]  L. Rubin.  The Mechanism of Human Facial Expression , 1992 .

[159]  David Matsumoto,et al.  More evidence for the universality of a contempt expression , 1992 .

[160]  D. Matsumoto.  American-Japanese Cultural Differences in the Recognition of Universal Facial Expressions , 1992 .

[161]  B. Mesquita,et al.  Cultural variations in emotions: a review. , 1992, Psychological bulletin.

[162]  A. Epstein.  The Language of the Emotions , 1992 .

[163]  Klaus R. Scherer,et al.  What does facial expression express , 1992 .

[164]  D. Buss.  Is There a Universal Human Nature , 1992 .

[165]  K. Oatley.  Best Laid Schemes: The Psychology of Emotions , 1992 .

[166]  P. Ekman.  An argument for basic emotions , 1992 .

[167]  P. Ekman.  Are there basic emotions? , 1992, Psychological review.

[168]  B. Depaulo,et al.  Nonverbal behavior and self-presentation. , 1992, Psychological bulletin.

[169]  A. Ortony,et al.  Basic emotions: can conflicting criteria converge? , 1992, Psychological review.

[170]  K. Oatley,et al.  Human emotions: function and dysfunction. , 1992, Annual review of psychology.

[171]  C. Izard.  Basic emotions, relations among emotions, and emotion-cognition relations. , 1992, Psychological review.

[172]  H. Wagner.  On measuring performance in category judgment studies of nonverbal behavior , 1993 .

[173]  José-Miguel Fernández-Dols,et al.  On the clarity of expressive and contextual information in the recognition of emotions: A methodological critique , 1993 .

[174]  P. Ekman.  Facial expression and emotion. , 1993, The American psychologist.

[175]  J. Russell.  Forced-choice response format in the study of facial expression , 1993 .

[176]  A. J. Fridlund.  DARWIN'S ANTI-DARWINISM IN EXPRESSION OF THE EMOTIONS IN MAN AND ANIMALS , 1994 .

[177]  Stephanie Nelson,et al.  Context effects on the judgment of basic emotions in the face , 1995 .

[178]  Terri Gullickson,et al.  Social Psychology (2nd ed.). , 1995 .