Physician supply forecast: better than peering in a crystal ball?

BackgroundAnticipating physician supply to tackle future health challenges is a crucial but complex task for policy planners. A number of forecasting tools are available, but the methods, advantages and shortcomings of such tools are not straightforward and not always well appraised. Therefore this paper had two objectives: to present a typology of existing forecasting approaches and to analyse the methodology-related issues.MethodsA literature review was carried out in electronic databases Medline-Ovid, Embase and ERIC. Concrete examples of planning experiences in various countries were analysed.ResultsFour main forecasting approaches were identified. The supply projection approach defines the necessary inflow to maintain or to reach in the future an arbitrary predefined level of service offer. The demand-based approach estimates the quantity of health care services used by the population in the future to project physician requirements. The needs-based approach involves defining and predicting health care deficits so that they can be addressed by an adequate workforce. Benchmarking health systems with similar populations and health profiles is the last approach. These different methods can be combined to perform a gap analysis. The methodological challenges of such projections are numerous: most often static models are used and their uncertainty is not assessed; valid and comprehensive data to feed into the models are often lacking; and a rapidly evolving environment affects the likelihood of projection scenarios. As a result, the internal and external validity of the projections included in our review appeared limited.ConclusionThere is no single accepted approach to forecasting physician requirements. The value of projections lies in their utility in identifying the current and emerging trends to which policy-makers need to respond. A genuine gap analysis, an effective monitoring of key parameters and comprehensive workforce planning are key elements to improving the usefulness of physician supply projections.

[1]  P. Gavel.  Medical workforce planning in Australia: process, methodology and technical issues. , 2004, Cahiers de sociologie et de demographie medicales.

[2]  K. Basu,et al.  [A physician demand and supply forecast model for Nova Scotia]. , 2005, Cahiers de sociologie et de demographie medicales.

[3]  R. Byrick,et al.  A physician workforce planning model applied to Canadian anesthesiology: assessment of needs , 2002, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[4]  G. Stoddart,et al.  Estimates of the potential impact of nurse practitioners on future requirements for physicians in office-based general practice. , 1985, Canadian journal of public health = Revue canadienne de sante publique.

[5]  A. Mackenzie,et al.  Health human resources planning and the production of health: development of an extended analytical framework for needs-based health human resources planning. , 2009, Journal of public health management and practice : JPHMP.

[6]  V. Velanovich.  Why estimates of physician supply and requirements disagree. , 1993, JAMA.

[7]  C. Joyce,et al.  Time for a new approach to medical workforce planning , 2004, The Medical journal of Australia.

[8]  Committee Amwac.  Toward gender balance in the Australian medical workforce: some planning implications. , 2000, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[9]  L O'Brien-Pallas,et al.  Forecasting models for human resources in health care. , 2001, Journal of advanced nursing.

[10]  J. Lipscomb,et al.  Determining VA physician requirements through empirically based models. , 1995, Health services research.

[11]  O. Adams.  Management of human resources in health care: the Canadian experience. , 1992, Health economics.

[12]  E. Fisher,et al.  Benchmarking the US physician workforce. An alternative to needs-based or demand-based planning. , 1996, JAMA.

[13]  D. N. Jones,et al.  1996 Australian radiology workforce report. , 1997, Australasian radiology.

[14]  M. Intriligator,et al.  Health manpower planning: an econometric approach. , 1972, Health services research.

[15]  B. Doan,et al.  [Forecast of physician workforce in the 22 French regions (1998-2013)]. , 2003, Cahiers de sociologie et de demographie medicales.

[16]  F. Schellevis,et al.  General practice in the Netherlands: major findings from the second Dutch National Survey of General Practice , 2018, Morbidity, Performance and Quality in Primary Care.

[17]  T Rathwell,et al.  Stochastic simulation and sensitivity analysis: estimating future demand for health resources in China. , 1994, World health statistics quarterly. Rapport trimestriel de statistiques sanitaires mondiales.

[18]  S. Stordeur,et al.  Physician workforce supply in Belgium: current situation and challenges , 2008 .

[19]  M. Mckee,et al.  Human Resources for Health in Europe , 2005 .

[20]  J. Weiner,et al.  Forecasting the effects of health reform on US physician workforce requirement. Evidence from HMO staffing patterns. , 1994, JAMA.

[21]  S. Stordeur,et al.  Association between physician density and health care consumption: a systematic review of the evidence. , 2009, Health policy.

[22]  R. Rizza,et al.  A model to determine workforce needs for endocrinologists in the United States until 2020. , 2003, Endocrine practice : official journal of the American College of Endocrinology and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists.

[23]  Andrea Baumann,et al.  Integrating workforce planning, human resources and service planning , 2001 .

[24]  Schroeder Sa.  Managing the U.S. health care workforce: creating policy amidst uncertainty. , 1994 .

[25]  G. Forte.  U.S. physician workforce forecasting: a tale of two states. , 2006, Cahiers de sociologie et de demographie medicales.

[26]  Peter C Arnold,et al.  More doctors, but not enough: Australian medical workforce supply 2001–2012 , 2006, The Medical journal of Australia.

[27]  M. D. Dal Poz,et al.  Imbalance in the health workforce , 2004, Human resources for health.

[28]  J. Lavis,et al.  The answer is ......., now what was the question? Applying alternative approaches to estimating nurse requirements. , 1997, Canadian journal of nursing administration.

[29]  R Cockerill,et al.  Determining Ontario's supply and requirements for ophthalmologists in 2000 and 2005: 1. Methods. , 1999, Canadian journal of ophthalmology. Journal canadien d'ophtalmologie.

[30]  S. Birch.  Health human resource planning for the new millennium: inputs in the production of health, illness, and recovery in populations. , 2002, The Canadian journal of nursing research = Revue canadienne de recherche en sciences infirmieres.

[31]  J. Cultice,et al.  Forecasting the need for physicians in the United States: the Health Resources and Services Administration's physician requirements model. , 1997, Health services research.

[32]  R. Miller,et al.  A comparison of three methods for estimating the requirements for medical specialists: the case of otolaryngologists. , 1997, Health services research.

[33]  E. Fisher,et al.  Why estimates of physician supply and requirements disagree. , 1993, JAMA.

[34]  D C Angus,et al.  Caring for the critically ill patient. Current and projected workforce requirements for care of the critically ill and patients with pulmonary disease: can we meet the requirements of an aging population? , 2000, JAMA.

[35]  R. Wuerz,et al.  Workforce projections for emergency medicine: how many emergency physicians does the United States need? , 1997, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[36]  Bui Dang Ha Doan,et al.  [Demographic forecasts of medical workforce supply in France (2000-2050). What numerus clausus for what future?]. , 2004, Cahiers de sociologie et de demographie medicales.

[37]  D. N. Jones,et al.  1998 Australian radiology workforce report. , 2000, Australasian radiology.

[38]  S. Schroeder.  Managing the U.S. health care workforce: creating policy amidst uncertainty. , 1994, Inquiry : a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing.

[39]  F. Mullan,et al.  Matching physician supply and requirements: testing policy recommendations. , 1996, Inquiry : a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing.

[40]  R Cockerill,et al.  Determining Ontario's supply and requirements for ophthalmologists in 2000 and 2005: 2. A comparison of projected supply and requirements. , 1999, Canadian journal of ophthalmology. Journal canadien d'ophtalmologie.

[41]  G. Morgan,et al.  Projected requirements for radiation oncologists and trainees in Australia and New Zealand to 2007. , 2000, Australasian radiology.

[42]  R. Wedel,et al.  Morbidity, performance and quality in primary care , 2008 .

[43]  S. Duckett,et al.  The Australian health workforce: facts and futures. , 2000, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[44]  J. Lurie,et al.  Benchmarking the future generalist workforce. , 2002, Effective clinical practice : ECP.

[45]  J. Lurie,et al.  The general pediatrician: projecting future workforce supply and requirements. , 2004, Pediatrics.

[46]  T. Getzen,et al.  Economic expansion is a major determinant of physician supply and utilization. , 2003, Health services research.