A tale of two theories: A critical comparison of identity theory with social identity theory

Identity theory and social identity theory are two remarkably similar perspectives on the dynamic mediation of the socially constructed self between individual behavior and social structure. Yet there is almost no systematic communication between these two perspectivies; they occupy parallel bur separate universes. This article describes both theories, summarizes their similarities, critically discusses their differences and outlines some research directions. Against a background of metatheoretical similarity, we find marked differences in terms of 1) level of analysis, 2) the role of intergroup behavior, 3) the relationship between roles and groups, and 4) salience of social context and identity. Differences can be traced largely to the microsociological roots of identity theory and the psychological roots of social identity theory. Identiy theory may be more effective in dealing with chronic identities and with interpersonal social interaction, while social identity theory may be more useful in exploring intergroup dimensions and in specifying the sociocognitive generative details of identity dynamics.

[1]  H. Tajfel,et al.  Quantitative judgement in social perception. , 1959, British journal of psychology.

[2]  H. Kelley,et al.  The social psychology of groups , 1960 .

[3]  George J. McCall,et al.  Identities and interactions , 1966 .

[4]  S. Stryker.  Identity Salience and Role Performance: The Relevance of Symbolic Interaction Theory for Family Research , 1968 .

[5]  Simone de Beauvoir.  The Coming of Age , 1970 .

[6]  M. Billig.  Social psychology and intergroup relations , 1976 .

[7]  Peter Burke,et al.  The Measurement of Role Identity , 1977 .

[8]  Ralph H. Turner,et al.  The Role and the Person , 1978, American Journal of Sociology.

[9]  M. Rosenberg.  Conceiving the self , 1979 .

[10]  J. Jaspars.  The coming of age of social psychology in Europe , 1980 .

[11]  Peter Burke,et al.  The Link between Identity and Role Performance , 1981 .

[12]  J. Hoelter.  The effects of role evaluation and commitment on identity salience. , 1983 .

[13]  P. Callero,et al.  Role-identity salience , 1985 .

[14]  W. Doise,et al.  Levels of Explanation in Social Psychology , 1986 .

[15]  P. Callero,et al.  Helping behavior as role behavior: Disclosing social structure and history in the analysis of prosocial action. , 1987 .

[16]  P. Burke,et al.  Ethnic Role Identity among Black and White College Students , 1987 .

[17]  Richard T. Serpe,et al.  Stability and change in self: a structural symbolic interactionist explanation , 1987 .

[18]  M. Hogg,et al.  Book Review: Social identifications: A social psychology of intergroup relations and group processes , 1991 .

[19]  M. Hogg,et al.  Rediscovering the social group: A self-categorization theory. , 1989 .

[20]  Larry Nuttbrock,et al.  Identity Salience and Motherhood: A Test of Stryker's Theory , 1991 .

[21]  Shelley E. Taylor,et al.  Social cognition, 2nd ed. , 1991 .

[22]  M. Wiley,et al.  GENDER, WORK, AND STRESS: The Potential Impact of Role-Identity Salience And Commitment , 1991 .

[23]  P. Thoits,et al.  On merging identity theory and stress research , 1991 .

[24]  M. Hogg,et al.  Social identity theory: Constructive and critical advances. , 1991 .

[25]  M. Brewer.  The Social Self: On Being the Same and Different at the Same Time , 1991 .

[26]  R. Simon,et al.  Parental role strains, salience of parental identity and gender differences in psychological distress. , 1992, Journal of health and social behavior.

[27]  Margaret Wetherell,et al.  Mapping The Language Of Racism , 1992 .

[28]  Michael A. Hogg,et al.  The Social Psychology of Group Cohesiveness: From Attraction to Social Identity , 1992 .

[29]  Dominic Abrams,et al.  Towards a single-process uncertainty-reduction model of social motivation in groups. , 1993 .

[30]  J. Potter,et al.  Mapping the Language of Racism. Discourse and the Legitimation of Exploitation. (Löschper) , 1993 .

[31]  John C. Turner,et al.  Stereotyping and Social Reality , 1994 .

[32]  Richard L. Moreland,et al.  Back to the Future: Social Psychological Research on Groups , 1994 .

[33]  M. Hogg,et al.  Group Norms and the Attitude-Behavior Relationship: A Role for Group Identification , 1996 .