Quantification of Interlaboratory Cell-free Protein Synthesis Variability.

Cell-free protein synthesis (CFPS) platforms, once primarily a research tool to produce difficult to express proteins, are increasingly being pursued by the synthetic biology community for applications including biomanufacturing, rapid screening systems, and field-ready sensors. While consistency within individual studies is apparent in the literature, challenges with reproducing results between laboratories, or even between individuals within a laboratory, are discussed openly by practitioners. As the field continues to grow and move towards applications, a quantitative understanding of expected variability for CFPS and the relative contribution of underlying sources will become increasingly important. Here we offer the first quantitative assessment of interlaboratory variability in CFPS. Three laboratories implemented a single CFPS protocol and performed a series of exchanges, both of material and personnel, designed to quantify relative contributions to variability associated with the site, operator, cell extract preparation, and supplemental reagent preparation. We found that materials prepared at each laboratory, exchanged pairwise, and tested at each site resulted in 40.3% coefficient of variation compared to 7.64% for a single operator across days using a single set of materials. Reagent preparations contributed significantly to observed variability; extract preparations, however, surprisingly did not explain any of the observed variability, even when prepared in different laboratories by different operators. Subsequent exchanges showed that both the site and the operator each contributed to observed interlaboratory variability. In addition to providing the first quantitative assessment of interlaboratory variability in CFPS, these results establish a baseline for individual operator variability across days that can be used as an initial benchmark for community-driven standardization efforts. We anticipate that our results will narrow future avenues of investigation to develop best practices that will ultimately drive down interlaboratory variability, accelerating research progress and informing the suitability of CFPS for real-world applications.

[1]  T. Hothorn,et al.  Simultaneous Inference in General Parametric Models , 2008, Biometrical journal. Biometrische Zeitschrift.

[2]  G. Church,et al.  Establishing a Cell-Free Vibrio natriegens Expression System. , 2018, ACS synthetic biology.

[3]  Rui Gan,et al.  Cell-free protein synthesis: applications come of age. , 2012, Biotechnology advances.

[4]  T. Terwilliger,et al.  Engineering and characterization of a superfolder green fluorescent protein , 2006, Nature Biotechnology.

[5]  Vincent Noireaux,et al.  Linear DNA for rapid prototyping of synthetic biological circuits in an Escherichia coli based TX-TL cell-free system. , 2014, ACS synthetic biology.

[6]  J. Hillebrecht,et al.  A comparative study of protein synthesis in in vitro systems: from the prokaryotic reconstituted to the eukaryotic extract-based , 2008, BMC biotechnology.

[7]  Nancy Kelley-Loughnane,et al.  Deconstructing Cell-Free Extract Preparation for in Vitro Activation of Transcriptional Genetic Circuitry. , 2018, ACS synthetic biology.

[8]  Michael C. Jewett,et al.  Establishing a high yielding streptomyces‐based cell‐free protein synthesis system , 2017, Biotechnology and bioengineering.

[9]  Per B. Brockhoff,et al.  lmerTest Package: Tests in Linear Mixed Effects Models , 2017 .

[10]  R. Murray,et al.  Gene circuit performance characterization and resource usage in a cell-free "breadboard". , 2014, ACS synthetic biology.

[11]  D. Bates,et al.  Fitting Linear Mixed-Effects Models Using lme4 , 2014, 1406.5823.

[12]  Michael C. Jewett,et al.  High-throughput preparation methods of crude extract for robust cell-free protein synthesis , 2015, Scientific Reports.

[13]  David K Karig,et al.  Cell-free synthetic biology for environmental sensing and remediation. , 2017, Current opinion in biotechnology.

[14]  Keith Pardee,et al.  Perspective: Solidifying the impact of cell-free synthetic biology through lyophilization , 2018, Biochemical engineering journal.

[15]  Zachary Z. Sun,et al.  Characterizing and prototyping genetic networks with cell-free transcription-translation reactions. , 2015, Methods.

[16]  Christopher A. Voigt,et al.  Ribozyme-based insulator parts buffer synthetic circuits from genetic context , 2012, Nature Biotechnology.

[17]  D. G. Gibson,et al.  Establishing a High-Yielding Cell-Free Protein Synthesis Platform Derived from Vibrio natriegens. , 2018, ACS synthetic biology.

[18]  Bradley C. Bundy,et al.  Cell‐free protein synthesis of a cytotoxic cancer therapeutic: Onconase production and a just‐add‐water cell‐free system , 2016, Biotechnology journal.

[19]  V. Noireaux,et al.  Cell-free expression with the toxic amino acid canavanine. , 2015, Bioorganic & medicinal chemistry letters.

[20]  Michael C Jewett,et al.  Lysate of engineered Escherichia coli supports high-level conversion of glucose to 2,3-butanediol. , 2015, Metabolic engineering.

[21]  Drew Endy,et al.  Measuring the activity of BioBrick promoters using an in vivo reference standard , 2009, Journal of biological engineering.

[22]  James Chappell,et al.  A Cell-Free Biosensor for Detecting Quorum Sensing Molecules in P. aeruginosa-Infected Respiratory Samples. , 2017, ACS synthetic biology.

[23]  James J. Collins,et al.  Portable, On-Demand Biomolecular Manufacturing , 2016, Cell.

[24]  Bastian Blombach,et al.  Cell-Free Protein Synthesis From Fast-Growing Vibrio natriegens , 2018, Front. Microbiol..

[25]  Jens Nielsen,et al.  Integrated multilaboratory systems biology reveals differences in protein metabolism between two reference yeast strains. , 2010, Nature communications.

[26]  By Jared L Dopp,et al.  Cell-free supplement mixtures: Elucidating the history and biochemical utility of additives used to support in vitro protein synthesis in E. coli extract. , 2019, Biotechnology advances.

[27]  S. L. Mayo,et al.  Cell‐free protein synthesis enables high yielding synthesis of an active multicopper oxidase , 2016, Biotechnology journal.

[28]  James J. Collins,et al.  Paper-Based Synthetic Gene Networks , 2014, Cell.

[29]  David W Wood,et al.  Cell-Free Protein Synthesis Approach to Biosensing hTRβ-Specific Endocrine Disruptors. , 2017, Analytical chemistry.

[30]  Takuya Ueda,et al.  PURE technology. , 2010, Methods in molecular biology.

[31]  Jacob Beal,et al.  Reproducibility of Fluorescent Expression from Engineered Biological Constructs in E. coli , 2016, PloS one.

[32]  Ken Kelley,et al.  Confidence Intervals for Standardized Effect Sizes: Theory, Application, and Implementation , 2007 .

[33]  C. Wilson,et al.  Laser-mediated, site-specific inactivation of RNA transcripts. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[34]  Takuya Ueda,et al.  Cell-free translation reconstituted with purified components , 2001, Nature Biotechnology.

[35]  Vincent Noireaux,et al.  Rapid and Scalable Characterization of CRISPR Technologies Using an E. coli Cell-Free Transcription-Translation System. , 2018, Molecular cell.

[36]  Guillaume Lambert,et al.  Rapid, Low-Cost Detection of Zika Virus Using Programmable Biomolecular Components , 2016, Cell.

[37]  T. Oshima,et al.  Effects of novel polyamines on cell-free polypeptide synthesis catalyzed by Thermus thermophilus HB8 extract. , 1993, Journal of biochemistry.

[38]  Kim A Woodrow,et al.  Cell-free protein synthesis with prokaryotic combined transcription-translation. , 2004, Methods in molecular biology.

[39]  Michael C Jewett,et al.  Development of a CHO-Based Cell-Free Platform for Synthesis of Active Monoclonal Antibodies. , 2017, ACS synthetic biology.