Industrial sustainability performance measurement systems: A novel framework

Abstract Improved sustainability of industrial activities and measurement of its performance are becoming prime topics of discussion among policy-makers and industrial decision-makers. The current literature proposes a number of performance measurement systems and related indicators, but mainly lacks a real capability to address all sustainability pillars and their intersections, as well as scalability to firms of different sizes, availability of internal resources, and maturity over sustainability issues, suggesting that further research is needed in this area. Building on the literature, our work develops a new framework for the evaluation of industrial sustainability performance, proposing three different Industrial Sustainability Performance Measurement Systems (ISPMSs), with a decreasing number of indicators suitable in different contexts of application. In the framework, selection mechanisms have been conceived and used to reduce the number of indicators considered, while still guaranteeing complete and adequate coverage of all sustainability pillars, as well as their intersections. The framework has been tested through semi-structured case studies in heterogeneous Northern Italian manufacturing firms. The preliminary results are sound as the different ISPMSs proved to be complete, useful, and easy to use. The proposed ISPMSs provide industrial decision-makers with a scalable framework applicable in different contexts, allowing benchmarking and development of specific implementation strategies for increased sustainability, and provide policy-makers with a framework to develop a more effective regulatory policy, better understanding how sustainability performance can be addressed in an integrated manner across industrial firms.

[1]  Anna Maria Ferrari,et al.  Building a Sustainability Benchmarking Framework of Ceramic Tiles Based on Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment (LCSA) , 2019, Resources.

[2]  Henry Mintzberg,et al.  Of strategies, deliberate and emergent , 1985, Strategic Management Journal.

[3]  Un Desa.  Transforming our world : The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development , 2016 .

[4]  Aihua Huang,et al.  Metrics-based approach to evaluate sustainable manufacturing performance at the production line and plant levels , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[5]  Alfons G.J.M. Oude Lansink,et al.  Measuring corporate sustainability performance– the case of European food and beverage companies , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[6]  J. Rowley.  Using case studies in research , 2002 .

[7]  Biagio Ciuffo,et al.  A systemic framework for sustainability assessment , 2015 .

[8]  Shaw C. Feng,et al.  An Overview of a Proposed Measurement Infrastructure for Sustainable Manufacturing | NIST , 2009 .

[9]  Mark Pagell,et al.  How Plant Managers' Experiences and Attitudes Toward Sustainability Relate to Operational Performance , 2009 .

[10]  V. Sloan,et al.  Measuring the Sustainability of Global Supply Chains: Current Practices and Future Directions , 2010 .

[11]  Joseph A. Ritter,et al.  Measuring Decent Work with Statistical Indicators , 2002 .

[12]  Seleshi Sisaye,et al.  Corporate sustainability: historical development and reporting practices , 2012 .

[13]  Andrea Trianni,et al.  A review of industrial sustainability indicators for Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment , 2017 .

[14]  André Luís Helleno,et al.  Integrating sustainability indicators and Lean Manufacturing to assess manufacturing processes: Application case studies in Brazilian industry , 2017 .

[15]  M. Martín-Peña,et al.  Analysis of benefits and difficulties associated with firms' Environmental Management Systems: the case of the Spanish automotive industry , 2014 .

[16]  Michael J. Ellenbecker,et al.  Indicators of sustainable production: framework and methodology , 2001 .

[17]  Heather L. MacLean,et al.  Expert assessments of emerging oil sands technologies , 2017 .

[18]  Claes Wohlin,et al.  Guidelines for snowballing in systematic literature studies and a replication in software engineering , 2014, EASE '14.

[19]  Todd C. Lehmann,et al.  Assessing citation networks for dissemination and implementation research frameworks , 2017, Implementation Science.

[20]  Marika Arena,et al.  A process‐based operational framework for sustainability reporting in SMEs , 2012 .

[21]  Cristina Alpopi,et al.  Measuring Corporate Sustainability Performance , 2015, Corporate Social and Environmental Responsibility.

[22]  I. S. Jawahir,et al.  Model-based Approach for Assessing Value Creation to Enhance Sustainability in Manufacturing , 2014 .

[23]  S. M. Yusof,et al.  Interpretive structural model of key performance indicators for sustainable manufacturing evaluation in automotive companies , 2012, 2012 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management.

[24]  Alain Bernard,et al.  Towards a holistic sustainability index for measuring sustainability of manufacturing companies , 2015 .

[25]  Steven E. Stemler,et al.  An Overview of Content Analysis. , 2001 .

[26]  S. Elo,et al.  Qualitative Content Analysis , 2014 .

[27]  L. Dooley.  Case Study Research and Theory Building , 2002 .

[28]  Dusan Schreiber,et al.  An analysis of the sustainability index of micro- and small-sized furniture industries , 2017, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy.

[29]  Katharina Fellnhofer,et al.  Drivers of innovation success in sustainable businesses , 2017 .

[30]  Patrick T. Hester,et al.  An improvement selection methodology for key performance indicators , 2016, Environment Systems and Decisions.

[31]  Erkan Bayraktar,et al.  Achieving economic and social sustainability through hyperconnectivity , 2018, Benchmarking: An International Journal.

[32]  Cory Searcy,et al.  Classification of Trade-offs Encountered in the Practice of Corporate Sustainability , 2017 .

[33]  Thomas Y. Choi,et al.  Renaissance of case research as a scientific method , 2014 .

[34]  Jacqueline Cramer,et al.  Exploring corporate sustainability integration into business activities. Experiences from 18 small and medium sized enterprises in the Netherlands , 2017 .

[35]  Ezutah Udoncy Olugu,et al.  Fuzzy-based sustainable manufacturing assessment model for SMEs , 2014, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy.

[36]  Patrik Thollander,et al.  Improving Energy Efficiency in Industrial Energy Systems: An Interdisciplinary Perspective on Barriers, Energy Audits, Energy Management, Policies, and Programs , 2012 .

[37]  D. Huisingh,et al.  Inter-linking issues and dimensions in sustainability reporting , 2011 .

[38]  S. N. Musa,et al.  Development of Sustainable Manufacturing Performance Evaluation Expert System for Small and Medium Enterprises , 2016 .

[39]  Lisa Scordato,et al.  Policy mixes for the sustainability transition of the pulp and paper industry in Sweden , 2018 .

[40]  Tao Li,et al.  A principal component analysis based three-dimensional sustainability assessment model to evaluate corporate sustainable performance , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[41]  Erik Lebret,et al.  The use of expert elicitation in environmental health impact assessment: a seven step procedure , 2010, Environmental health : a global access science source.

[42]  Riccardo Stacchezzini,et al.  Sustainability management and reporting: the role of integrated reporting for communicating corporate sustainability management , 2016 .

[43]  Bo Meng,et al.  More than half of China’s CO2 emissions are from micro, small and medium-sized enterprises , 2018, Applied Energy.

[44]  Abolfazl Gharaei,et al.  Optimization of rewards in single machine scheduling in the rewards-driven systems , 2015 .

[45]  Asta Laurinkevičiūtė,et al.  SMS for decision making of SMEs , 2011 .

[46]  Andy Neely,et al.  Performance measurement system design: developing and testing a process‐based approach , 2000 .

[47]  Mats Winroth,et al.  Sustainable Production Indicators at Factory Level , 2016 .

[48]  F. Kohlbacher.  The Use of Qualitative Content Analysis in Case Study Research , 2006 .

[49]  Ming Dong,et al.  Comparison of order-fulfilment performance in MTO and MTS systems with an inventory cost budget constraint , 2012 .

[50]  Johnny Saldaña,et al.  The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers , 2009 .

[51]  Dicksen Tanzil,et al.  Assessing impacts: Overview on sustainability indicators and metrics , 2006 .

[52]  Ivete Delai,et al.  Sustainability measurement system: a reference model proposal , 2011 .

[53]  Martin L. Martens,et al.  Engaging small‐ and medium‐sized businesses in sustainability , 2010 .

[54]  Dahlia K. Remler,et al.  Research Methods in Practice: Strategies for Description and Causation , 2010 .

[55]  Graham Hubbard,et al.  Measuring organizational performance: beyond the triple bottom line , 2009 .

[56]  A. Calabrese,et al.  A fuzzy analytic hierarchy process method to support materiality assessment in sustainability reporting , 2016 .

[57]  An Analysis of a Sustainability Index , 2021, Sustainable Consumption and Production, Volume I.

[58]  Farzad Dehghanian.  Sustainability in Supply Chain Management , 2012 .

[59]  Alain Martel,et al.  The design of robust value-creating supply chain networks , 2010, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[60]  Adel Badri,et al.  A novel tool for evaluating occupational health and safety performance in small and medium-sized enterprises: the case of the Quebec forestry/pulp and paper industry , 2018 .

[61]  Steve Cayzer,et al.  Design of indicators for measuring product performance in the circular economy , 2016 .

[62]  Peter Glavič,et al.  A model for integrated assessment of sustainable development , 2005 .

[63]  Marc J. Epstein,et al.  Identification and Use of Sustainability Performance Measures in Decision-Making , 2010 .

[64]  Adam Lindgreen,et al.  What makes a good case study? A positivist review of qualitative case research published in Industrial Marketing Management, 1971–2006 , 2010 .

[65]  Matthew P. Johnson,et al.  Sustainability Management and Small and Medium‐Sized Enterprises: Managers' Awareness and Implementation of Innovative Tools , 2015 .

[66]  Anissa Frini,et al.  Making Decisions in a Sustainable Development Context: A State-of-the-Art Survey and Proposal of a Multi-period Single Synthesizing Criterion Approach , 2018 .

[67]  A. K. Dikshit,et al.  Development of composite sustainability performance index for steel industry , 2007 .

[68]  Andrea Trianni,et al.  Measuring industrial sustainability performance: Empirical evidence from Italian and German manufacturing small and medium enterprises , 2019, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[69]  Saurabh Gupta,et al.  An overview of sustainability assessment methodologies , 2009 .

[70]  Lanndon A. Ocampo,et al.  Computing sustainable manufacturing index with fuzzy analytic hierarchy process , 2016 .

[71]  Joseph A. Ritter,et al.  Measuring Decent Work with Statistical Indicators , 2003 .

[72]  Adisa Azapagic,et al.  Indicators of Sustainable Development for Industry: A General Framework , 2000 .

[73]  Christoph Herrmann,et al.  Development of a Sustainability Assessment Tool for Manufacturing Companies , 2018, Sustainable Production, Life Cycle Engineering and Management.

[74]  Dusan Schreiber,et al.  Selection and identification of the indicators for quickly measuring sustainability in micro and small furniture industries , 2015 .

[75]  K. Eisenhardt.  Building theories from case study research , 1989, STUDI ORGANIZZATIVI.

[76]  Shlomo Globerson,et al.  Issues in developing a performance criteria system for an organization , 1985 .

[77]  Dennis Stindt,et al.  A generic planning approach for sustainable supply chain management - How to integrate concepts and methods to address the issues of sustainability? , 2017 .

[78]  Igor Linkov,et al.  Multi-criteria decision analysis framework for sustainable manufacturing in automotive industry , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[79]  Luiz Flávio Autran Monteiro Gomes,et al.  Assessment of Efficiency and Sustainability in a Chemical Industry Using Goal Programming and AHP , 2015, ITQM.

[80]  Ulrich Steger,et al.  The Business Case for Corporate Sustainability:: Literature Review and Research Options , 2005 .

[81]  Daniel Tyteca,et al.  Towards indicators of sustainable development for firms: A productive efficiency perspective , 1999 .

[82]  D. Thrän,et al.  How not to compare apples and oranges: Generate context-specific performance reference points for a social life cycle assessment model , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[83]  Marco Melacini,et al.  Linking environmental accounting to reward systems: the case of the Environmental Profit and Loss Account , 2015 .

[84]  P. Garengo,et al.  Performance Measurement Systems in SMEs: A Review for a Research Agenda , 2005 .

[85]  Oa Us Epa.  Overview of Greenhouse Gases , 2015 .

[86]  Jian-Bo Yang,et al.  Looking for the sweet spot in sustainability: a framework for corporate assessment in sugar manufacturing , 2015 .

[87]  Danny Samson,et al.  Effective case research in operations management: a process perspective , 2002 .

[88]  Cristina Gimenez,et al.  Sustainable operations: Their impact on the triple bottom line , 2012 .

[89]  Andrea Trianni,et al.  Industrial sustainability: Modelling drivers and mechanisms with barriers , 2018, Journal of Cleaner Production.

[90]  Ifeyinwa Juliet Orji,et al.  Examining barriers to organizational change for sustainability and drivers of sustainable performance in the metal manufacturing industry , 2019, Resources, Conservation and Recycling.

[91]  S. G. Deshmukh,et al.  An integrated sustainability assessment framework: a case of turning process , 2016, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy.

[93]  Robert B. Gibson.  Beyond The Pillars: Sustainability Assessment As A Framework For Effective Integration Of Social, Economic And Ecological Considerations In Significant Decision-Making , 2006 .

[94]  Silvia Avasilcai,et al.  The Assessment of The Companies' Sustainable Development Performance , 2015 .

[95]  A. Verbruggen,et al.  Sustainability assessment and indicators: Tools in a decision-making strategy for sustainable development , 2014 .

[96]  João C. O. Matias,et al.  Proposal of a Sustainability Index for the Automotive Industry , 2015 .

[97]  Mark Pagell,et al.  Building a More Complete Theory of Sustainable Supply Chain Management Using Case Studies of 10 Exemplars , 2009 .

[98]  Braden Allenby,et al.  Hierarchical metrics for sustainability , 2002 .

[99]  Jurgis Kazimieras Staniškis,et al.  Sustainability Performance Indicators for Industrial Enterprise Management , 2009 .

[100]  Therese Nehler,et al.  How do firms consider non-energy benefits? Empirical findings on energy-efficiency investments in Swedish industry , 2016 .

[101]  Tao Li,et al.  A PCA-based method for construction of composite sustainability indicators , 2012, The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

[102]  S. Lynham.  The General Method of Theory-Building Research in Applied Disciplines , 2002 .

[103]  Christopher A. Voss,et al.  Case research in operations management , 2002 .

[104]  Michael A. Gonzalez,et al.  Sustainability Indicators for Chemical Processes: I. Taxonomy , 2012 .

[105]  Elita Amrina,et al.  Interpretive structural model of key performance indicators for sustainable manufacturing evaluation in cement industry , 2014, 2014 IEEE International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management.

[106]  Izak Benbasat,et al.  The Case Research Strategy in Studies of Information Systems , 1987, MIS Q..

[107]  S. Schaltegger,et al.  Integrative management of sustainability performance, measurement and reporting , 2006 .

[108]  J. Hailey,et al.  MEASURING SUCCESS Issues in Performance Measurement , 2005 .

[109]  R. Yin,et al.  Case Study Research: Design and Methods (4th ed. , 2009 .

[110]  Adisa Azapagic,et al.  Developing a framework for sustainable development indicators for the mining and minerals Industry , 2004 .

[111]  Wouter Bam,et al.  Comparing the Sustainable Development Potential of Industries: A Role for Sustainability Disclosures? , 2018 .

[112]  P. Glavič,et al.  Indicators of sustainable production , 2003 .

[113]  M. Patton,et al.  Qualitative evaluation and research methods , 1992 .

[114]  Kuan Yew Wong,et al.  A Comprehensive and Integrated Stochastic-Fuzzy Method for Sustainability Assessment in the Malaysian Food Manufacturing Industry , 2019, Sustainability.

[115]  M. Patton.  Qualitative evaluation and research methods, 2nd ed. , 1990 .

[116]  Diolino J. Santos Filho,et al.  A Framework to Evaluate the Performance of a New Industrial Business Model , 2016 .

[117]  E. Amrina,et al.  Interpretive Structural Model of Key Performance Indicators for Sustainable Maintenance Evaluatian in Rubber Industry , 2018 .

[119]  John W. Sutherland,et al.  Development of social, environmental, and economic indicators for a small/medium enterprise , 2011 .

[120]  Sophie Hallstedt,et al.  Assessing Sustainability and Value of Manufacturing Processes:: A case in the aerospace industry , 2015 .

[121]  Steve Evans,et al.  Transforming sustainability challenges into competitive advantage: Multiple case studies kaleidoscope converging into sustainable business models , 2017 .

[122]  B. Crabtree,et al.  The qualitative research interview , 2006, Medical education.

[123]  Catherine Da Cunha,et al.  Tailoring performance evaluation to specific industrial contexts – application to sustainable mass customisation enterprises , 2015 .

[124]  Noordin Mohd Yusof,et al.  A weighted fuzzy approach for product sustainability assessment: a case study in automotive industry , 2012 .

[125]  S. Schaltegger,et al.  Two Decades of Sustainability Management Tools for SMEs: How Far Have We Come?* , 2016 .

[126]  Andrea Trianni,et al.  Modelling barriers to the adoption of industrial sustainability measures , 2017 .

[127]  Wahidul K. Biswas,et al.  An evaluation of holistic sustainability assessment framework for palm oil production in Malaysia. , 2015 .

[128]  Björn Johansson,et al.  Framework and indicators for a Sustainable Manufacturing Mapping methodology , 2010, Proceedings of the 2010 Winter Simulation Conference.

[129]  J. Klemeš.  Assessing and measuring environmental impact and sustainability , 2015, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy.

[130]  C. Garcés‐Ayerbe,et al.  Barriers to the adoption of proactive environmental strategies , 2011 .

[131]  S. G. Deshmukh,et al.  An integrated approach for analysing the enablers and barriers of sustainable manufacturing , 2017 .

[132]  Jack R. Meredith,et al.  Building operations management theory through case and field research , 1998 .

[133]  Marc Journeault,et al.  Eco-Efficiency and Organizational Practices: An Exploratory Study of Manufacturing Firms , 2009 .

[134]  Ju Yeon Lee,et al.  A framework for a research inventory of sustainability assessment in manufacturing , 2014 .

[135]  Wolfgang Kersten,et al.  Supply chain sustainability performance indicators - a content analysis based on published standards and guidelines , 2017, Logist. Res..

[136]  Tobias Bestari Tjandra,et al.  A Sustainability Indicator Framework for Singapore Small and Medium-Sized Manufacturing Enterprises , 2015 .

[137]  Salvador F. Capuz-Rizo,et al.  Assessment of the public administration tools for the improvement of the eco-efficiency of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises , 2013 .

[138]  Alessandra Cozzolino,et al.  Sustainability in Supply Chain Management - A Literature Review , 2014 .

[139]  R. Yin.  Case Study Research: Design and Methods , 1984 .

[140]  G. Noci,et al.  Sustainability Report in Small Enterprises:Case Studies in Italian Furniture Companies , 2009 .

[141]  Joe Miemczyk,et al.  The regenerative supply chain: a framework for developing circular economy indicators , 2018, Int. J. Prod. Res..

[142]  Alena Kocmanová,et al.  Composite indicator for measuring corporate sustainability , 2016 .

[143]  Andrea Trianni,et al.  Broadening to sustainability the perspective of industrial decision-makers on the energy efficiency measures adoption: some empirical evidence , 2018 .

[144]  A. Gunasekaran,et al.  Explaining sustainable supply chain performance using a total interpretive structural modeling approach , 2017 .

[145]  C. Prahalad,et al.  The dominant logic: A new linkage between diversity and performance , 1986 .

[146]  Robert A.W. Kok,et al.  Theory-Testing Using Case Studies: A Comment on Johnston, Leach, and Liu , 2001 .

[147]  Giovanni Azzone,et al.  Process based approach to select key sustainability indicators for steel companies , 2010 .

[148]  N. Denzin,et al.  Introduction: The Discipline and Practice of Qualitative Research. , 2005 .

[149]  Sasa Baskarada.  Qualitative Case Study Guidelines , 2014 .

[150]  Philip E. T. Lewis,et al.  Research Methods for Business Students , 2006 .

[151]  H. Boer,et al.  A sustainability assessment system for Chinese iron and steel firms , 2016 .

[152]  Ibrahim H. Garbie,et al.  An analytical technique to model and assess sustainable development index in manufacturing enterprises , 2014 .

[153]  Mei Li,et al.  Qualitative case studies in operations management: Trends, research outcomes, and future research implications , 2011 .

[154]  Andy Neely,et al.  Performance measurement system design , 1995 .

[155]  Vesela Veleva,et al.  Indicators for measuring environmental sustainability , 2003 .

[156]  Douglas D. Heckathorn,et al.  Network Sampling: From Snowball and Multiplicity to Respondent-Driven Sampling , 2017 .

[157]  Steven A. Melnyk,et al.  The scientific theory‐building process: a primer using the case of TQM , 1998 .

[158]  Maha Shakir,et al.  The selection of case studies: strategies and their applications to IS implementation case studies , 2002 .

[159]  C. K. Prahalad,et al.  THE DOMINANT LOGIC: RETROSPECTIVE AND EXTENSION , 1995 .

[160]  Stefan Seuring,et al.  From a literature review to a conceptual framework for sustainable supply chain management , 2008 .

[161]  R. Kolbe,et al.  Content-Analysis Research: An Examination of Applications with Directives for Improving Research Reliability and Objectivity , 1991 .

[162]  Aborode Abdullahi,et al.  Industrial Policy for a Sustainable Growth Path , 2020 .

[163]  Alena Kocmanová,et al.  Corporate Sustainability Measurement and Assessment of Czech Manufacturing Companies Using a Composite Indicator , 2017 .