Problem structuring methods in action

This paper provides a review and evaluation of the use of problem structuring methods (PSMs) in practice. It starts by describing the origins of PSMs, the type of problem situation for which they are suitable, and the characteristics of some leading methods. An overview of the practice of PSMs is provided from a number of angles, including case studies and surveys of applications. A number of issues in the application of PSMs are discussed, in particular an account of the debate about evaluation of the success of PSMs; the selection of an appropriate method; multimethodology; and a variety of aspects of the maintenance of relationships with the client organisation(s). Finally, some possible future developments are suggested, especially through productive interactions with similar or related practices.

[1]  A. Taket,et al.  Beyond appraisal : Participatory Appraisal of Needs and the Development of Action (PANDA) , 1997 .

[2]  R. Harnden,et al.  The languaging of models: The understanding and communication of models with particular reference to Stafford Beer's cybernetic model of organization structure , 1990 .

[3]  R. Asch,et al.  A case study in development planning using a systems learning approach: Generating a master plan for the livestock sector in Nepal , 1995 .

[4]  Paul N. Finlay.  On evaluating the performance of GSS: Furthering the debate , 1998, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[5]  David J. Worthington,et al.  An Example of a Good but Partially Successful OR Engagement: Improving Outpatient Clinic Operations , 1998, Interfaces.

[6]  John Mingers,et al.  The use of multimethodology in practice—results of a survey of practitioners , 2002, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[7]  L. M. Bennett,et al.  A systems approach to the implementation of total quality management , 1996 .

[8]  Johan Strümpfer.  Planning as a means of social change: The Durban Functional Region Forum case , 1997 .

[9]  Peter Cressey,et al.  Doing research in organisations: Edited by Alan Bryman, Routledge, 1988, 268p, £8.95 , 1988 .

[10]  P. Ledington,et al.  Soft OR and management practice: a study of the adoption and use of Soft Systems Methodology , 1997 .

[11]  T. Hindle,et al.  Developing a Methodology for Multidisciplinary Action Research: A Case Study , 1995 .

[12]  Peter Bennett,et al.  Designing a Parliamentary Briefing System: an OR Look at the Commons , 1994 .

[13]  Russell L. Ackoff,et al.  Creating the Corporate Future: Plan or be Planned For , 1981 .

[14]  Leroy White,et al.  Size matters: large group methods and the process of operational research , 2002, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[15]  David G. Platt.  BUILDING PROCESS MODELS FOR DESIGN MANAGEMENT , 1996 .

[16]  Jean-Louis Malouin,et al.  Model validation in operations research , 1983 .

[17]  Heinz Weihrich.  DAIMLER‐BENZ′S MOVE TOWARDS THE NEXT CENTURY WITH THE TOWS MATRIX , 1993 .

[18]  J. Gough,et al.  Environmental Decision-Making and Lake Management , 1996 .

[19]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Decision support for organisational risk management by problem structuring , 2001 .

[20]  John Mingers,et al.  The Use of Soft Systems Methodology in Practice , 1992 .

[21]  C. Curran,et al.  All together now: The circular organization in a university Hospital. Part II. Implementation , 1996 .

[22]  Sven Rasegård.  A comparative study of Beer's and Miller's systems designs as tools when analyzing the structure of a municipal organization , 1991 .

[23]  L Abdel-Malek,et al.  OR Practice: survey results and reflections of practising INFORMS members , 1999, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[24]  John Knowles.  A soft system analysis of a CD-ROM network for a multi-site polytechnic , 1993 .

[25]  César A. Macías-Chapula,et al.  Development of a soft systems model to identify information values, impact and barriers in a health care information system , 1995, J. Inf. Sci..

[26]  J. Walker.  Diagnosis and implementation: How a large cooperative employed a series of proposals for restructuring based upon the Viable Systems Model , 1990 .

[27]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Investigating Risk, Organisations and Decision Support through Action Research , 2002 .

[28]  F Ülengin,et al.  Cognitive map: KBDSS integration in transportation planning , 1997 .

[29]  James F. Courtney,et al.  Automated Discovery in Managerial Problem Formulation: Formation of Causal Hypotheses for Cognitive Mapping , 1993 .

[30]  Jason Magidson.  Systems practice in several communities in Philadelphia , 1992 .

[31]  G. Johns.  Discontent without focus? An analysis of nurse management and activity on a psychiatric in-patient facility using a 'soft systems' approach. , 1995 .

[32]  S. R. Watson,et al.  Decision Synthesis: The Principles and Practice of Decision Analysis@@@Strategic and Tactical Decisions , 1989 .

[33]  Tony Hindle,et al.  Rational Analysis for a Problematic World , 1990 .

[34]  Simon Peck,et al.  Group Model Building: Facilitating Team Learning Using System Dynamics , 1996, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[35]  Gerardine DeSanctis,et al.  A foundation for the study of group decision support systems , 1987 .

[36]  Pamela A. Mills-Packo,et al.  Highlights from the use of the soft systems methodology to improve agrotechnology transfer in Kona, Hawaii , 1991 .

[37]  Peter Checkland,et al.  From Optimizing to Learning: A Development of Systems Thinking for the 1990s , 1985 .

[38]  Michael Jackson.  Towards coherent pluralism in management science , 1999, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[39]  Edward Lumsdaine,et al.  Creative problem solving , 1995 .

[40]  Sylvia M. Brown,et al.  Cognitive mapping and repertory grids for qualitative survey research: some , 1992 .

[41]  Michael Jackson,et al.  Towards a System of Systems Methodologies , 1984 .

[42]  Colin Thunhurst,et al.  Housing in the Dearne Valley: Doing Community OR with the Thurnscoe Tenants Housing Co-operative. Part 2 — An Evaluation , 1992 .

[43]  M. G. Haynes,et al.  The business team standard: A means of improving the effectiveness of individual businesses in a multibusiness corporation , 1997 .

[44]  Barbara J Kennedy.  Soft Systems Methodology in Applying Psychology , 1996 .

[45]  B Lehaney,et al.  Simulation modelling for resource allocation and planning in the health sector , 1995, Journal of the Royal Society of Health.

[46]  Richard Poxton,et al.  Working Whole Systems: Putting Theory into Practice in Organisations , 2006 .

[47]  Graham Winch.  Consensus building in the planning process: Benefits from a “hard” modeling approach , 1993 .

[48]  Barbara Wilmot.  Creative Problem Solving and Red Yarn. , 1985 .

[49]  Paul Ledington.  Intervention and the management process: An action-based research study , 1992 .

[50]  Muhittin Oral,et al.  Model legitimisation in operational research , 1996 .

[51]  Paul Jeffrey,et al.  The Use of Operational Research Tools: A Survey of Operational Research Practitioners in the UK , 1995 .

[52]  G. Kreweras.  Creating the corporate future: Russell L. ACKOFF Wiley, New York, 1981, xi + 297 pages, £10.85 , 1982 .

[53]  Deirdre Boden,et al.  The Business of Talk , 1994 .

[54]  R. G. Coyle,et al.  Two approaches to qualitative modelling of a nation's drugs trade† , 1997 .

[55]  R. Ackoff.  The Future of Operational Research is Past , 1979 .

[56]  J. S. Wells.  Discontent without focus? An analysis of nurse management and activity on a psychiatric in-patient facility using a 'soft systems' approach. , 1995, Journal of advanced nursing.

[57]  Werner Ulrich,et al.  Reflective Practice in the Civil Society: The contribution of critically systemic thinking , 2000 .

[58]  John Mingers,et al.  Multimethodology : the theory and practice of combining management science methodologies , 1997 .

[59]  Barbara Benedict Bunker,et al.  Large Group Interventions: Engaging the Whole System for Rapid Change , 1996 .

[60]  T. Hall.  Ethnography: Principles in Practice. By M. Hammersley & P. Atkinson. Pp. 323. (Routledge, London, 1995.) , 1997, Journal of Biosocial Science.

[61]  Dean Tjosvold,et al.  Book review : Group model building : facilitating team learning using system dynamics , 1998 .

[62]  R. Lawrence,et al.  Operational Research and the Social Sciences. , 1966 .

[63]  R. Chambers.  Whose reality counts? Putting the last first , 1997 .

[64]  Michael Jackson,et al.  Evaluating organizations: A systems and contingency approach , 1992 .

[65]  D. C. Sutton.  Making strategy: the journey of strategic management , 2001 .

[66]  John Mingers.  What are Real Friends for? A Reply to Mike Jackson , 1992 .

[67]  H. Rittel,et al.  Dilemmas in a general theory of planning , 1973 .

[68]  E. Trist,et al.  A Socio-Technical Perspective , 1993 .

[69]  Fran Ackermann,et al.  Modeling for Litigation: Mixing Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches , 1997 .

[70]  Colin Eden,et al.  On evaluating the performance of 'wide-band' GDSS's , 1995 .

[71]  John Mingers,et al.  Multimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies , 1997 .

[72]  David C. Lane,et al.  Should system dynamics be described as a ‘hard’ or ‘deterministic’ systems approach? , 2000 .

[73]  Robert Fildes,et al.  The management of OR groups: results of a survey , 1999, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[74]  Ray J. Paul,et al.  The Use of Soft Systems Methodology in the Development of a Simulation of Out-patient Services at Watford General Hospital , 1996 .

[75]  J. Mingers,et al.  Rational analysis for a problematic world revisited : problem structuring methods for complexity, uncertainty and conflict , 1989 .

[76]  Fran Ackermann,et al.  The Effects of Design Changes and Delays on Project Costs , 1995 .

[77]  N.A.D. Connell,et al.  Evaluating soft OR: some reflections on an apparently ‘unsuccessful’ implementation using a Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) based approach , 2001, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[78]  A. J. Cole,et al.  Integrated process improvement in design and manufacture using a systems approach , 1996 .

[79]  R. Mason.  Challenging strategic planning assumptions , 1981 .

[80]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  What's the Problem? An Introduction to Problem Structuring Methods , 1996 .

[81]  John Mingers,et al.  Recent Developments in Critical Management Science , 1992 .

[82]  Muhittin Oral,et al.  The facets of the modeling and validation process in operations research , 1993 .

[83]  Masaya Nakano,et al.  Research on how to develop R&D strategies using the soft systems approach , 1997 .

[84]  Anne D. O'Connor.  Soft Systems Methodology - A Case Study of its use within an : Australian Organisation , 1992, Aust. Comput. J..

[85]  B Lehaney,et al.  Using Soft Systems Methodology to Develop a Simulation of Out-Patient Services , 1994, Journal of the Royal Society of Health.

[86]  John Brocklesby,et al.  Using soft systems methodology to identify competence requirements in HRM , 1995 .

[87]  John Mingers,et al.  Multimethodology: Mixing and Matching Methods , 2001 .

[88]  Gerald Midgley,et al.  Creating Employment Opportunities for People with Mental Health Problems: A Feasibility Study for New Initiatives , 1995 .

[89]  C. Jotin Khisty.  Soft-systems methodology as learning and management tool , 1995 .

[90]  Joel R. Brown,et al.  Integrating ecology into natural resource management policy , 1996, Environmental management.

[91]  John Brocklesby,et al.  Designing a Viable Organization Structure , 1996 .

[92]  P. Schoemaker.  Scenario Planning: A Tool for Strategic Thinking , 1995 .

[93]  M Thorén.  Systems approach to clothing for disabled users. Why is it difficult for disabled users to find suitable clothing. , 1996, Applied ergonomics.

[94]  H. Scarbrough,et al.  The Social Engagement of Social Science: A Tavistock Anthology , 1995 .

[95]  L. Phillips.  People-centred group decision support , 1989 .

[96]  G. Johnson,et al.  Ceos' cognitive maps and the scope of the organization , 1994 .

[97]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Problem structuring for medical quality assurance , 1993 .

[98]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited , 2001 .

[99]  D. Schon.  Educating the Reflective Practitioner. Toward a New Design for Teaching and Learning in the Professions. The Jossey-Bass Higher Education Series. , 1987 .

[100]  Brian Pratt,et al.  Choosing Research Methods: Data Collection for Development Workers , 1992 .

[101]  C Eden.  On evaluating the performance of GSS: furthering the debate,by Paul Finlay [European Journal of Operational Research 107,pp.193-201] , 2000 .

[102]  H. Schwartzman.  Ethnography in Organizations , 1992 .

[103]  S. Anderson,et al.  Applying Large-Group Interaction Methods in the Planning and Implementation of Major Change Efforts. , 2000 .

[104]  John Mingers,et al.  Diverse Unity: Looking Inward and Outward , 2001 .

[105]  Robert G. Dyson,et al.  Strategic Development: Methods and Models , 1998 .

[106]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  The Evolution of a Performance Measurement Project at RTZ , 1998, Interfaces.

[107]  J. F. Courtney,et al.  A system for organizational learning using cognitive maps , 1992 .

[108]  Roger Popper,et al.  Knowledge and beliefs regarding agricultural pesticides in rural Guatemala , 1996 .

[109]  Kyoichi Kijima,et al.  An enriched soft systems methodology (SSM) and its application to cultural conflict under a paternalistic value system , 1994 .

[110]  Frank Land,et al.  Knowledge based management support systems , 1989 .

[111]  Ann Taket,et al.  Wanted: Dead OR alive—ways of using problem-structuring methods in community OR , 1997 .

[112]  Henk Akkermans,et al.  Capturing the dynamics of facility allocation , 1996 .

[113]  Robert Bolton,et al.  Career Management: Matching the Needs of Individuals with the Needs of Organizations , 1994 .

[114]  Murielle Bendeck Asfura,et al.  Problem structuring methods for development : a conceptual clarification with an application to participative health services planning in Mexico , 2001 .

[115]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  Putting soft OR methods to work: Information systems strategy development at Palabora , 1998 .

[116]  Donald A. Schön.  Educating the Reflective Practitioner: Toward a New Design for Teaching and Learning in the Professions , 1987 .

[117]  Peter Checkland,et al.  Soft Systems Methodology in Action , 1990 .

[118]  Philip M. Morse,et al.  Methods of Operations Research , 1952 .

[119]  John L. Scott,et al.  Strategic Level MS/OR Tool Usage in the United Kingdom: An Empirical Survey , 1995 .

[120]  Charles Ritchie,et al.  Housing in the Dearne Valley: Doing Community OR with the Thurnscoe Tenants Housing Co-operative , 2004 .

[121]  Werner Schuhmann.  Strategy for information systems in the Film Division of Hoechst AG , 1990 .

[122]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Project review and learning in the construction industry: Embedding a problem structuring method within a partnership context , 2004, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[123]  Richard Gott,et al.  In the Shadow of the Liberator: Hugo Chavez and the Transformation of Venezuela , 2000 .

[124]  John Mingers,et al.  A classification of the philosophical assumptions of management science methods , 2003, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[125]  R. Vidal,et al.  Community works - 26 case studies showing community Operational Research in action: C. Ritchie, A. Taket and J. Bryant (eds.) Pavic Publications, Sheffield Hallam University, UK; distributed by the Operational Research Society, Birmingham, UK , 1996 .

[126]  Peter Checkland,et al.  Systems Thinking, Systems Practice , 1981 .

[127]  Lee Robbins.  Using Interactive Planning in the Entrepreneurial Class: A Live Fieldwork-Based Case and Simulation Exercise , 1994 .

[128]  L. Phillips,et al.  Faciliated Work Groups: Theory and Practice , 1993 .

[129]  Robert L. Flood,et al.  Contours of diversity management and triple loop learning , 1996 .

[130]  Peter Checkland,et al.  OR and Social Science: Fundamental Thoughts , 1989 .

[131]  D. Fielden,et al.  Systemic approach to energy rationalisation in island communities , 1998 .

[132]  C. Curran,et al.  All together now: The circular organization in a University Hospital. Part I. Planning and design , 1996 .

[133]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  Information Systems Strategy Development at Sainsbury's Supermarkets Using Soft OR , 1996 .

[134]  Jonathan Rosenhead,et al.  Enabling analysis: Across the developmental divide , 1993 .

[135]  F. Ackermann.  Participants' perceptions on the role of facilitators using Group Decision Support Systems , 1996 .

[136]  Richard J. Ormerod,et al.  Putting Soft OR Methods to Work: Information Systems Strategy Development at Richards Bay , 1996 .

[137]  J. K. Friend,et al.  Housing in the Dearne Valley: Doing Community OR with the Thurnscoe Tenants Housing Co-Operative Part 1 — The Involvement of the Community OR Unit , 1992 .

[138]  Robert Fildes,et al.  Success and survival of operational research groups—A review , 1997 .

[139]  Noel Dickover.  Reflection-in-Action: Modeling a specific organization through the Viable Systems Model , 1994 .

[140]  John Mingers,et al.  Variety is the spice of life: combining soft and hard OR/MS methods , 2000 .

[141]  Richard J. Ormerod.  Putting Soft OR Methods to Work: Information Systems Strategy Development at Sainsbury's , 1995 .