Does Consent Bias Research?

Researchers increasingly rely on large data sets of health information, often linked with biological specimens. In recent years, the argument has been made that obtaining informed consent for conducting records-based research is unduly burdensome and results in “consent bias.” As a type of selection bias, consent bias is said to exist when the group giving researchers access to their data differs from the group denying access. Therefore, to promote socially beneficial research, it is argued that consent should be unnecessary. After analyzing the biostatistics evidence and bioethics arguments, the article concludes that (1) claims about the amount of consent bias are overstated; (2) commonly used statistical methods usually can account for consent bias; and (3) any residual effects of consent bias are below an acceptable level of imprecision and constitute a reasonable social cost for conducting ethically responsible research.

[1]  Clare Jinks,et al.  Patterns of consent in epidemiologic research: evidence from over 25,000 responders. , 2004, American journal of epidemiology.

[2]  S. Rennie Viewing Research Participation as a Moral Obligation: In Whose Interests? , 2011, The Hastings Center report.

[3]  J. Robins,et al.  Estimation of Regression Coefficients When Some Regressors are not Always Observed , 1994 .

[4]  M. Rothstein Currents in Contemporary Ethics: Improve Privacy in Research by Eliminating Informed Consent? IOM Report Misses the Mark , 2009, The Journal of law, medicine & ethics : a journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine & Ethics.

[5]  Andy Podgurski,et al.  Balancing Privacy, Autonomy, and Scientific Needs In Electronic Health Records Research. , 2012, SMU law review : a publication of Southern Methodist University School of Law.

[6]  G. Watt,et al.  The impact of consent on observational research: a comparison of outcomes from consenters and non consenters to an observational study , 2008, BMC medical research methodology.

[7]  Ishan C. Williams,et al.  Investigator beliefs and reported success in recruiting minority participants. , 2006, Contemporary clinical trials.

[8]  Karen Glanz,et al.  The impact of HIPAA authorization on willingness to participate in clinical research. , 2007, Annals of epidemiology.

[9]  E. Clayton,et al.  Principles of Human Subjects Protections Applied in an Opt‐Out, De‐identified Biobank , 2010, Clinical and translational science.

[10]  Ezekiel J Emanuel,et al.  Reforming the regulations governing research with human subjects. , 2011, The New England journal of medicine.

[11]  J. Ioannidis Why Most Published Research Findings Are False , 2005, PLoS medicine.

[12]  S. Woolf,et al.  Selection bias from requiring patients to give consent to examine data for health services research. , 2000, Archives of family medicine.

[13]  S. Haneuse,et al.  Adjustment for Selection Bias in Observational Studies with Application to the Analysis of Autopsy Data , 2009, Neuroepidemiology.

[14]  E. Emanuel,et al.  The obligation to participate in biomedical research. , 2009, JAMA.

[15]  T. Beauchamp,et al.  Principles of biomedical ethics , 1991 .

[16]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  Science mapping analysis characterizes 235 biases in biomedical research. , 2010, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[17]  Liam Glynn,et al.  Selection bias resulting from the requirement for prior consent in observational research: a community cohort of people with ischaemic heart disease , 2007, Heart.

[18]  Onyebuchi A Arah,et al.  Bias Formulas for Sensitivity Analysis of Unmeasured Confounding for General Outcomes, Treatments, and Confounders , 2011, Epidemiology.

[19]  I. Bross,et al.  Pertinency of an extraneous variable. , 1967, Journal of chronic diseases.

[20]  Wolzt,et al.  World Medical Association Declaration of Helsinki: ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects. , 2003, The Journal of the American College of Dentists.

[21]  S. Greenland Quantifying Biases in Causal Models: Classical Confounding vs Collider-Stratification Bias , 2003, Epidemiology.

[22]  H. Draper,et al.  The effect of seeking consent on the representativeness of patient cohorts: iron‐deficiency anaemia and colorectal cancer , 2011, Colorectal disease : the official journal of the Association of Coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland.

[23]  Laura A. Levit,et al.  Beyond the HIPAA Privacy Rule: Enhancing Privacy, Improving Health Through Research. Washington, DC: National Academies Press , 2009 .

[24]  R. Rhodes In Defense of the Duty to Participate in Biomedical Research , 2008, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[25]  K. Glanz,et al.  Preconsent education about research processes improved African Americans' willingness to participate in clinical research. , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[26]  Melissa C Brouwers,et al.  Written informed consent and selection bias in observational studies using medical records: systematic review , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[27]  H. Jonas Philosophical Reflections on Experimenting with Human Subjects , 1979 .

[28]  S Greenland,et al.  Basic methods for sensitivity analysis of biases. , 1996, International journal of epidemiology.

[29]  Charles F Lynch,et al.  Racial differences in factors that influence the willingness to participate in medical research studies. , 2002, Annals of epidemiology.

[30]  Sara Chandros Hull,et al.  Patients' Views on Identifiability of Samples and Informed Consent for Genetic Research , 2008, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[31]  Lehana Thabane,et al.  Consent for use of personal information for health research: Do people with potentially stigmatizing health conditions and the general public differ in their opinions? , 2009, BMC medical ethics.

[32]  Jack V Tu,et al.  Impracticability of informed consent in the Registry of the Canadian Stroke Network. , 2004, The New England journal of medicine.

[33]  J. Robins,et al.  A Structural Approach to Selection Bias , 2004, Epidemiology.

[34]  D. Wendler How to enroll participants in research ethically. , 2011, JAMA.

[35]  M. Rothstein Is Deidentification Sufficient to Protect Health Privacy in Research? , 2010, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[36]  Joan Scott,et al.  Public opinion about the importance of privacy in biobank research. , 2009, American journal of human genetics.

[37]  Brahmajee K Nallamothu,et al.  Potential impact of the HIPAA privacy rule on data collection in a registry of patients with acute coronary syndrome. , 2005, Archives of internal medicine.

[38]  H. Beecher,et al.  Ethics and clinical research. , 1966, The New England journal of medicine.

[39]  Takashi Yanagawa,et al.  Case-control studies: Assessing the effect of a confounding factor , 1984 .

[40]  E. Emanuel,et al.  Are Racial and Ethnic Minorities Less Willing to Participate in Health Research? , 2005, PLoS medicine.

[41]  K. Schulz,et al.  Bias and causal associations in observational research , 2002, The Lancet.

[42]  D. Orentlicher Making Research a Requirement of Treatment: Why We Should Sometimes Let Doctors Pressure Patients to Participate in Research , 2005, The Hastings Center report.

[43]  John Harris,et al.  Scientific research is a moral duty , 2005, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[44]  C. Warlow,et al.  Bias from requiring explicit consent from all participants in observational research: prospective, population based study , 2005, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[45]  M. Camilleri,et al.  The HIPAA Authorization Form and Effects on Survey Response Rates, Nonresponse Bias, and Data Quality: A Randomized Community Study , 2007, Medical care.

[46]  G. Mcquillan,et al.  Consent for future genetic research: the NHANES experience in 2007-2008. , 2011, IRB.

[47]  Sander Greenland,et al.  Modern Epidemiology 3rd edition , 1986 .

[48]  R. Kronmal,et al.  Assessing the sensitivity of regression results to unmeasured confounders in observational studies. , 1998, Biometrics.

[49]  James H. Jones Bad Blood: The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment , 1981 .

[50]  B. Lo,et al.  Protecting research participants while reducing regulatory burdens. , 2011, Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).

[51]  J. Schlesselman Assessing effects of confounding variables. , 1978, American journal of epidemiology.

[52]  B. Wilfond,et al.  Pediatric biobanks: approaching informed consent for continuing research after children grow up. , 2009, The Journal of pediatrics.