An historically grounded critical analysis of research articles in IS

In order to explore scientific writing in Information Systems (IS) journals, we adopt a combination of historical and rhetorical approaches. We first investigate the history of universities, business schools, learned societies and scientific articles. This perspective allows us to capture the legacy of scientific writing standards, which emerged in the 18th and 19th centuries. Then, we focus on two leading IS journals (EJIS and MISQ). An historical analysis of both outlets is carried out, based on data related to their creation, evolution of editorial statements, and key epistemological and methodological aspects. We also focus on argumentative strategies found in a sample of 436 abstracts from both journals. Three main logical anchorages (sometimes combined) are identified, and related to three argumentative strategies: ‘deepening of knowledge’, ‘solving an enigma’ and ‘addressing a practical managerial issue’. We relate these writing norms to historical imprints of management and business studies, in particular: enigma-focused rhetorics, interest in institutionalized literature, neglect for managerially grounded rhetoric and lack of reflexivity in scientific writing. We explain this relation as a quest for academic legitimacy. Lastly, some suggestions are offered to address the discrepancies between these writing norms and more recent epistemological and theoretical stances adopted by IS researchers.

[1]  Lucas D. Introna,et al.  Truth, Journals, and Politics: The Case of the MIS Quarterly , 2004, Relevant Theory and Informed Practice.

[2]  Alan G. Gross,et al.  Communicating Science: The Scientific Article from the 17th Century to the Present , 2002 .

[3]  George Barlow,et al.  History of Universities , 1967, The International Encyclopedia of Higher Education Systems and Institutions.

[4]  Guy Paré,et al.  Re-examining the causal structure of information technology impact research , 2007, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[5]  Marc Wingens,et al.  Christophe Charle & Jacques Verger, Histoire des universités, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France, 1994, (Que sais-je ? ; 391) , 1996 .

[6]  Barbara Czarniawska Narrating the Organization: Dramas of Institutional Identity , 1997 .

[7]  Vicky Arnold,et al.  The Differential Use and Effect of Knowledge-Based System Explanations in Novice and Expert Judgement Decisions , 2006, MIS Q..

[8]  Nick Tiratsoo,et al.  The “Americanization” of Management Education in Britain , 2004 .

[9]  Elizabeth Du,et al.  The discourse-level structure of empirical abstracts: an exploratory study , 1991, Inf. Process. Manag..

[10]  A. Manning,et al.  Abstracts in Relation to Larger and Smaller Discourse Structures , 1990 .

[11]  Jacques Le Goff,et al.  Marchands et banquiers du moyen âge , 1956 .

[12]  James Robert Brown,et al.  Thought experiments since the scientific revolution , 1986 .

[13]  W. Bainbridge The Scientific Research Potential of Virtual Worlds , 2007, Science.

[14]  Ananth Srinivasan,et al.  Increasing the Number of A+ Published Papers in the Information Systems Discipline: Improving the Journal Review Process , 2007 .

[15]  N. Fjällbrant Scholarly Communication - Historical Development and New Possibilities , 2012 .

[16]  Erik J. DeVries Episyemology and Methodology in Case Research: A Comparison Between European and American IS Journals , 2005 .

[17]  R. Merton,et al.  Patterns of evaluation in science: Institutionalisation, structure and functions of the referee system , 1971 .

[18]  Bernard Forgues Writing Up the research , 2001 .

[19]  E. Swanson,et al.  Publishing in the Majors: A Comparison of Accounting, Finance, Management, and Marketing , 2002 .

[20]  R. Thomas British business schools , 1980 .

[21]  Stephen P. Banks,et al.  Fiction and social research : by ice or fire , 1998 .

[22]  Robert D. Galliers,et al.  Vive les differences? Developing a profile of European information systems research as a basis for international comparisons , 2007, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[23]  Steven P. Feldman Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author , 1989 .

[24]  Detmar W. Straub,et al.  Trust and TAM in Online Shopping: An Integrated Model , 2003, MIS Q..

[25]  John Mingers,et al.  Combining IS Research Methods: Towards a Pluralist Methodology , 2001, Inf. Syst. Res..

[26]  N. Jackson,et al.  For the sake of argument: towards an understanding of rhetoric as process , 2004 .

[27]  François-Xavier de Vaujany,et al.  The Espoused Theories of IS: A Study of General Editorial Statements , 2008, ICIS.

[28]  M. Alvesson,et al.  Taking the Linguistic Turn in Organizational Research , 2000 .

[29]  Brian S. Butler,et al.  Reliability, Mindfulness, and Information Systems , 2006, MIS Q..

[30]  C. Charle,et al.  Histoire des universités , 2012 .

[31]  Yogesh Kumar Dwivedi,et al.  Investigating the Research Approaches for Examining Technology Adoption Issues , 2005 .

[32]  René Aigrain,et al.  Histoire des universités , 1949 .

[33]  Martin Davies,et al.  Critical Management Studies , 1993 .

[34]  Frederic S. Lee,et al.  Research Selectivity, Managerialism, and the Academic Labor Process: The Future of Nonmainstream Economics in U.K. Universities , 1997 .

[35]  Ali F. Farhoomand,et al.  Scientific progress of management information systems , 1987, DATB.

[36]  M. Alvesson,et al.  Critical Management Studies , 1993 .

[37]  Julie Moote,et al.  European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction , 2011 .

[38]  P. Draper Reflexive methodology - new vistas for qualitative research: Media Reviews , 2008 .

[39]  Paul Gray,et al.  Managing academic e-journals , 2004, CACM.

[40]  Bernard Fallery,et al.  Vingt-cinq ans de recherche en Systèmes d'Information , 2002 .

[41]  Kathleen M. Carley,et al.  Communication at a Distance: The Influence of Print on Sociocultural Organization and Change , 1994 .

[42]  Eduard Bonet,et al.  Rhetoric in management and in management research , 2010 .

[43]  Fred D. Davis Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User Acceptance of Information Technology , 1989, MIS Q..

[44]  Will Venters,et al.  Reflexive Evaluation of an Academic–Industry Research Collaboration: Can Mode 2 Management Research Be Achieved? , 2009 .

[45]  D. Atkinson Scientific discourse in sociohistorical context: The philosophical transactions of the Royal Society , 1998 .

[46]  H. G. Richardson Business Training in Medieval Oxford , 1941 .

[47]  H. Perkin,et al.  History of Universities , 2007 .

[48]  James A. Hendler,et al.  Reinventing Academic Publishing-Part 1 , 2007, IEEE Intelligent Systems.

[49]  R. J. Bogumil,et al.  The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action , 1985, Proceedings of the IEEE.

[50]  A. Robert,et al.  L'analyse de contenu , 2002 .

[51]  J. V. Maanen Tales of the Field: On Writing Ethnography , 1989 .

[52]  Larry D. Browning,et al.  The Application of Rhetorical Theory in Managerial Research , 2008 .

[53]  K. Fitzpatrick Planned Obsolescence: Publishing, Technology, and the Future of the Academy , 2011 .

[54]  Christopher Grey,et al.  What are Business Schools for? On Silence and Voice in Management Education , 2002 .

[55]  Hilkka Stotesbury,et al.  Evaluation in research article abstracts in the narrative and hard sciences , 2003 .

[56]  B. Jackson,et al.  A Fantasy Theme Analysis of Peter Senge’s Learning Organization , 2000 .

[57]  A. Gross Starring the Text: The Place of Rhetoric in Science Studies , 2006 .

[58]  J. Kam Ring a Ring O' Roses: Quality Journals and Gamesmanship in Management Studies , 2007 .

[59]  D. Schoen,et al.  The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action , 1985 .

[60]  Ian Glover,et al.  The Collapse of the American Management Mystique , 2000 .

[61]  Daniel Robey,et al.  Identity, Legitimacy and the Dominant Research Paradigm: An Alternative Prescription for the IS Discipline: A Response to Benbasat and Zmud's Call for Returning to the IT Artifact , 2003, J. Assoc. Inf. Syst..

[62]  Steve Smithson,et al.  Banning organizational secrecy can threaten research too , 1994 .

[63]  J. Verger,et al.  Les universités au Moyen Age , 2013 .

[64]  Florence Rodhain,et al.  La spécificité de la recherche francophone en Systèmes d'Information , 2007 .

[65]  C. Grey Organizing Studies: Publications, Politics and Polemic , 2010 .

[66]  Edgar A. Whitley,et al.  Doing the politics of technological decision making: due process and the debate about identity cards in the U.K. , 2008, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[67]  Lucas D. Introna,et al.  Imagine : thought experiments in information systems research , 1997 .

[68]  Gordon B. Davis,et al.  User Acceptance of Information Technology: Toward a Unified View , 2003, MIS Q..

[69]  Jacques Le Goff,et al.  Les intellectuels au moyen âge , 1957 .

[70]  Daniel Gouadain,et al.  Les enseignements de gestion dans les universités avant et après la création des IAE , 1997 .

[71]  Geoff Walsham,et al.  Interpretive case studies in IS research: nature and method , 1995 .

[72]  A. Sinclair Teaching Managers about Masculinities: Are You Kidding? , 2000 .

[73]  L. Smircich,et al.  Voicing Seduction to Silence Leadership , 1991 .

[74]  Frank C. Pierson,et al.  The Education of American Businessmen , 1959 .

[75]  D. Kronick A history of scientific & technical periodicals: The origins and development of the scientific and technical press, 1665-1790 , 1976 .

[76]  Kalle Lyytinen,et al.  Nothing At The Center?: Academic Legitimacy in the Information Systems Field , 2004, J. Assoc. Inf. Syst..

[77]  M. Biagioli From Book Censorship to Academic Peer Review , 2002 .

[78]  David R. Geelan,et al.  Writing Our Lived Experience: Beyond the (Pale) Hermeneutic?. , 1998 .

[79]  K. Peffers,et al.  Identifying and Evaluating the Universe of Outlets for Information Systems Research: Ranking the Journals , 2003 .

[80]  S. P. Keeble,et al.  The Ability to Manage: A Study of British Management, 1890-1990 , 1992 .

[81]  Vincent Mangematin,et al.  Global Contests in the Production of Business Knowledge , 2008 .

[82]  Daniel Beimborn,et al.  A Unified Economic Model of Standard Diffusion: The Impact of Standardization Cost, Network Effects, and Network Topology , 2006, MIS Q..

[83]  Michael Rosen Breakfast at Spiro's: Dramaturgy and Dominance , 1985 .

[84]  Wanda J. Orlikowski,et al.  Studying Information Technology in Organizations: Research Approaches and Assumptions , 1991, Inf. Syst. Res..

[85]  Lars Engwall,et al.  Management Education in Historical Perspective , 2002 .

[86]  Janne Tienari,et al.  Hegemonic Academic Practices: Experiences of Publishing from the Periphery , 2008 .

[87]  Michael Sanderson The Universities and British Industry 1850–1970 , 1972 .

[88]  Paul Jeffcutt,et al.  From Interpretation to Representation in Organizational Analysis: Postmodernism, Ethnography and Organizational Symbolism , 1994 .

[89]  Detmar W. Straub,et al.  Editor's Comments: Type II Reviewing Errors and the Search for Exciting Papers , 2008 .

[90]  Richard Whately Elements of Rhetoric , 2005 .

[91]  Karen Locke,et al.  Appealing Work: An Investigation of How Ethnographic Texts Convince , 1993 .

[92]  A. Niemi,et al.  Management and Higher Education Since 1940: The Influence of America and Japan on West Germany, Great Britain and France. By Robert R. Locke. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1989. Pp. xiii, 328. $59.50 , 1990, The Journal of Economic History.

[93]  Behlül Üsdiken,et al.  Between Contending Perspectives and Logics: Organizational Studies in Europe , 2010 .

[94]  Pierre Le Gentil,et al.  Jacques Le Goff, Les Intellectuels au Moyen Age, Éditions du Seuil, Paris 1957 , 1957 .

[95]  Bénédicte Sère,et al.  La disputatio dans l’université médiévale : esquisse d’un usage public du raisonnement ? , 2011 .

[96]  Nikolaos A. Mylonopoulos,et al.  On site: global perceptions of IS journals , 2001, CACM.

[97]  Anne Sigismund Huff Designing research for publication , 2008 .

[98]  François-Xavier de Vaujany,et al.  Strategic Alignment: What Else? A Practice Based View of IS Value , 2009, ICIS.

[99]  Thomas Basbøll,et al.  Substitutes for Strategy Research: Notes on the source of Karl Weick's anecdote of the young lieutenant and the map of the Pyrenees , 2006 .

[100]  C. Geertz,et al.  Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. , 1988 .

[101]  Rudy Hirschheim,et al.  A paradigmatic and methodological examination of information systems research from 1991 to 2001 , 2004, Inf. Syst. J..

[102]  Armand Hatchuel,et al.  Rebuilding Management: A Historical Perspective , 2004 .

[103]  Alfred Kieser,et al.  Organizational, Institutional, and Societal Evolution: Medieval Craft Guilds and the Genesis of Formal Organizations , 1989 .

[104]  Barbara Czarniawska Writing Management: Organization Theory as a Literary Genre , 1999 .

[105]  S. Linstead,et al.  On Reading Organizational Culture , 1992 .

[106]  Anne Sigismund Huff Learning to be a Successful Writer , 2002 .

[107]  Kalle Lyytinen,et al.  Why the old world cannot publish? Overcoming challenges in publishing high-impact IS research , 2007, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[108]  O Höök,et al.  Scientific communications. History, electronic journals and impact factors. , 1999, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[109]  Erik J. De Vries Epistemology and Methodology in Case Research: A Comparison between European and American IS Journals , 2005, ECIS.