Comment on “Preserved Feedforward But Impaired Top-Down Processes in the Vegetative State”

Boly et al. (Reports, 13 May 2011, p. 858) investigated cortical connectivity patterns in patients suffering from a disorder of consciousness, using electroencephalography in an auditory oddball paradigm. We point to several inconsistencies in their data, including a failure to replicate the classical mismatch negativity. Data quality, source reconstruction, and statistics would need to be improved to support their conclusions.

[1]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Probing consciousness with event-related potentials in the vegetative state , 2011, Neurology.

[2]  R. J. Ilmoniemi,et al.  Instrumentation for the measurement of electric brain responses to transcranial magnetic stimulation , 1999, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[3]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  a K.E. Stephan, a R.B. Reilly, , 2007 .

[4]  P. Morosan,et al.  Probabilistic Mapping and Volume Measurement of Human Primary Auditory Cortex , 2001, NeuroImage.

[5]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Topological inference for EEG and MEG , 2010, 1011.2901.

[6]  Dominique Morlet,et al.  Late auditory and event-related potentials can be useful to predict good functional outcome after coma. , 2005, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[7]  B. de Gelder,et al.  Mismatch negativity predicts recovery from the vegetative state , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[8]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Bayesian estimation of synaptic physiology from the spectral responses of neural masses , 2008, NeuroImage.

[9]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modeling of evoked responses in EEG and MEG , 2006, NeuroImage.

[10]  E. Whitham,et al.  Scalp electrical recording during paralysis: Quantitative evidence that EEG frequencies above 20Hz are contaminated by EMG , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[11]  Marcello Massimini,et al.  A perturbational approach for evaluating the brain's capacity for consciousness. , 2009, Progress in brain research.

[12]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling of induced responses , 2008, NeuroImage.

[13]  G. Tononi,et al.  Breakdown in cortical effective connectivity during midazolam-induced loss of consciousness , 2010, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[14]  Ross Zafonte,et al.  Assessment scales for disorders of consciousness: evidence-based recommendations for clinical practice and research. , 2010, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[15]  宁北芳,et al.  疟原虫var基因转换速率变化导致抗原变异[英]／Paul H, Robert P, Christodoulou Z, et al//Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A , 2005 .

[16]  T. Lewis,et al.  Event-related potentials — neurophysiological tools for predicting emergence and early outcome from traumatic coma , 2005, Intensive Care Medicine.

[17]  D. Vernon,et al.  Event-Related Brain Potential Correlates of Human Auditory Sensory Memory-Trace Formation , 2005, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[18]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling of evoked responses in EEG/MEG with lead field parameterization , 2006, NeuroImage.

[19]  G. Tononi,et al.  Consciousness and Anesthesia , 2008, Science.

[20]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic Causal Modeling of the Response to Frequency Deviants , 2009, Journal of neurophysiology.

[21]  Karl J. Friston.  The free-energy principle: a unified brain theory? , 2010, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[22]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Modelling event-related responses in the brain , 2005, NeuroImage.

[23]  D L Woods,et al.  Lesions of frontal cortex diminish the auditory mismatch negativity. , 1994, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[24]  C. Grau,et al.  Theta EEG oscillatory activity and auditory change detection , 2008, Brain Research.

[25]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  A neural mass model for MEG/EEG: coupling and neuronal dynamics , 2003, NeuroImage.

[26]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Evoked brain responses are generated by feedback loops , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[27]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  A dynamic causal model study of neuronal population dynamics , 2010, NeuroImage.

[28]  V. Lamme.  Towards a true neural stance on consciousness , 2006, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[29]  Steven Laureys,et al.  Magnetic resonance spectroscopy and diffusion tensor imaging in coma survivors: promises and pitfalls. , 2009, Progress in brain research.

[30]  M. Fuchs,et al.  Boundary element method volume conductor models for EEG source reconstruction , 2001, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[31]  Matthew C. Keller,et al.  Increased sensitivity in neuroimaging analyses using robust regression , 2005, NeuroImage.

[32]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling , 2003, NeuroImage.

[33]  J. Changeux,et al.  Experimental and Theoretical Approaches to Conscious Processing , 2011, Neuron.

[34]  C. Degueldre,et al.  Auditory processing in the vegetative state. , 2000, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[35]  G Tononi,et al.  Cortical reactivity and effective connectivity during REM sleep in humans , 2010, Cognitive neuroscience.

[36]  John J. Foxe,et al.  The neural circuitry of pre-attentive auditory change-detection: an fMRI study of pitch and duration mismatch negativity generators. , 2005, Cerebral cortex.

[37]  S. R. Butler,et al.  Electrophysiological indicator of awakening from coma , 1993, The Lancet.

[38]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic Causal Models for phase coupling , 2009, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[39]  Erich Schröger,et al.  Prefrontal cortex involvement in preattentive auditory deviance detection: neuroimaging and electrophysiological evidence , 2003, NeuroImage.

[40]  R. Knight,et al.  A distributed cortical network for auditory sensory memory in humans , 1998, Brain Research.

[41]  R. Näätänen,et al.  The mismatch negativity (MMN) in basic research of central auditory processing: A review , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[42]  G. Karmos,et al.  Adaptive modeling of the unattended acoustic environment reflected in the mismatch negativity event-related potential , 1996, Brain Research.

[43]  C. Fischer,et al.  Improved prediction of awakening or nonawakening from severe anoxic coma using tree-based classification analysis* , 2006, Critical care medicine.

[44]  P. Fries.  A mechanism for cognitive dynamics: neuronal communication through neuronal coherence , 2005, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[45]  Yung-Yang Lin,et al.  Memory-based mismatch response to changes in duration of auditory stimuli: An MEG study , 2010, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[46]  H. Lau.  A higher order Bayesian decision theory of consciousness. , 2008, Progress in brain research.

[47]  Dominique Morlet,et al.  Predictive value of sensory and cognitive evoked potentials for awakening from coma , 2004, Neurology.

[48]  Yung-Yang Lin,et al.  Theta oscillation during auditory change detection: An MEG study , 2009, Biological Psychology.

[49]  Á. Pascual-Leone,et al.  α-Band Electroencephalographic Activity over Occipital Cortex Indexes Visuospatial Attention Bias and Predicts Visual Target Detection , 2006, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[50]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  The functional anatomy of the MMN: A DCM study of the roving paradigm , 2008, NeuroImage.

[51]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Preserved Feedforward But Impaired Top-Down Processes in the Vegetative State , 2011, Science.

[52]  J. Winn,et al.  Brain , 1878, The Lancet.

[53]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Repetition suppression and plasticity in the human brain , 2009, NeuroImage.

[54]  D. J. Felleman,et al.  Distributed hierarchical processing in the primate cerebral cortex. , 1991, Cerebral cortex.

[55]  A. Dale,et al.  Human posterior auditory cortex gates novel sounds to consciousness. , 2004, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[56]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modeling for EEG and MEG , 2009, Human brain mapping.

[57]  K. Alho,et al.  Separate Time Behaviors of the Temporal and Frontal Mismatch Negativity Sources , 2000, NeuroImage.

[58]  Adrian M. Owen,et al.  Diffusion weighted imaging distinguishes the vegetative state from the minimally conscious state , 2011, NeuroImage.

[59]  D Morlet,et al.  Mismatch negativity and late auditory evoked potentials in comatose patients , 1999, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[60]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Converging Intracranial Markers of Conscious Access , 2009, PLoS biology.

[61]  Risto N t nen.  Attention and brain function , 1992 .

[62]  B. Kotchoubey,et al.  Predicting coma and other low responsive patients outcome using event-related brain potentials: A meta-analysis , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[63]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Neural signature of the conscious processing of auditory regularities , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[64]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  The mismatch negativity: A review of underlying mechanisms , 2009, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[65]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling of evoked responses: The role of intrinsic connections , 2007, NeuroImage.

[66]  Raymond J. Dolan,et al.  Consistent spectral predictors for dynamic causal models of steady-state responses , 2011, NeuroImage.

[67]  C. Fischer,et al.  Event-related potentials (MMN and novelty P3) in permanent vegetative or minimally conscious states , 2010, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[68]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling of evoked potentials: A reproducibility study , 2007, NeuroImage.

[69]  Ben H. Jansen,et al.  Electroencephalogram and visual evoked potential generation in a mathematical model of coupled cortical columns , 1995, Biological Cybernetics.

[70]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Classical and Bayesian Inference in Neuroimaging: Theory , 2002, NeuroImage.

[71]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamical causal modelling for M/EEG: Spatial and temporal symmetry constraints , 2009, NeuroImage.

[72]  P Berg,et al.  A multiple source approach to the correction of eye artifacts. , 1994, Electroencephalography and clinical neurophysiology.

[73]  Manjit,et al.  Neurology , 1912, NeuroImage.

[74]  Raymond J. Dolan,et al.  Dynamic causal models of steady-state responses , 2009, NeuroImage.

[75]  Perrine Ruby,et al.  Odd Sound Processing in the Sleeping Brain , 2008, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[76]  J. Giacino,et al.  The JFK Coma Recovery Scale-Revised: measurement characteristics and diagnostic utility. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[77]  E. Schröger,et al.  Differential Contribution of Frontal and Temporal Cortices to Auditory Change Detection: fMRI and ERP Results , 2002, NeuroImage.

[78]  J. Ashby.  References and Notes , 1999 .

[79]  M. Boly,et al.  Auditory processing in severely brain injured patients: differences between the minimally conscious state and the persistent vegetative state. , 2004, Archives of neurology.

[80]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Dynamic causal modelling of distributed electromagnetic responses , 2009, NeuroImage.

[81]  T. Gunter,et al.  Sequential Effects of Increasing Propofol Sedation on Frontal and Temporal Cortices as Indexed by Auditory Event-related Potentials , 2004, Anesthesiology.

[82]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Bayesian model selection for group studies , 2009, NeuroImage.

[83]  G. Tononi,et al.  Breakdown of Cortical Effective Connectivity During Sleep , 2005, Science.

[84]  Josep Marco-Pallarés,et al.  Combined ICA-LORETA analysis of mismatch negativity , 2005, NeuroImage.

[85]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Comparing Families of Dynamic Causal Models , 2010, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[86]  D. Wilkin,et al.  Neuron , 2001, Brain Research.