A comparison of the reproducibility and the sensitivity to change of visual analogue scales, Borg scales, and Likert scales in normal subjects during submaximal exercise.

OBJECTIVE To assess which subjective scale, the visual analogue scale (VAS), the Borg CR10 (Borg) scale, or the Likert scale (LS), if any, is decidedly more reproducible and sensitive to change in the assessment of symptoms. DESIGN Prospective clinical study. SETTING Exercise laboratory. PARTICIPANTS Twenty-three physically active male subjects (mean +/- SD age of 30 +/- 4 years old) were recruited. INTERVENTION Each subject attended the exercise laboratory on four occasions at intervals of 1 week. Three subjective scales were used: (1) the VAS (continuous scale); (2) the Borg scale (12 fixed points); and (3) the Likert scale (LS; 5 fixed points). Four identical submaximal tests were given (2 min at 60% maximum oxygen uptake [VO(2)max] and 6 min at 70% VO(2)max). Two tests were undertaken to assess the reproducibility of scores that were obtained with each subjective scale. Two other tests were undertaken to assess the sensitivity of each scale to a change in symptom perception: a double-blind treatment with propranolol, 80 mg, (ie, active therapy; to increase the sensation of breathlessness and general fatigue during exercise) or matching placebo. The subjective scale scores were measured at 1 min 30 s, 5 min 30 s, and 7 min 15 s of exercise. Reproducibility was defined as the proportion of total variance (ie, between-subject plus within-subject variance) explained by the between-subject variance given as a percentage. Sensitivity was defined as the effect of the active drug therapy over the variation within subjects. RESULTS Overall, the VAS performed best in terms of reproducibility for breathlessness and general fatigue, with reproducibility coefficients as high as 78%. For sensitivity, the VAS was best for breathlessness (ratio, 2.7) and the Borg scale was most sensitive for general fatigue (ratio, 3.0). The relationships between the respective psychological and physiologic variables were reasonably stable throughout the testing procedure, with overall typical correlations of 0.73 to 0.82 CONCLUSION This study suggests that subjective scales can reproducibly measure symptoms during steady-state exercise and can detect the effect of a drug intervention. The VAS and Borg scales appear to be the best subjective scales for this purpose.

[1]  J. Lewis,et al.  Methods to assess breathlessness in healthy subjects: a critical evaluation and application to analyse the acute effects of diazepam and promethazine on breathlessness induced by exercise or by exposure to raised levels of carbon dioxide. , 1981, Clinical science.

[2]  J. Mooij,et al.  Submaximal endurance exercise performance during enalapril treatment in patients with essential hypertension , 1991, Clinical pharmacology and therapeutics.

[3]  R. Binkhorst,et al.  Effects of propranolol and metoprolol on haemodynamic and respiratory indices and on perceived exertion during exercise in hypertensive patients. , 1979, British heart journal.

[4]  P. Tesch,et al.  Effects of beta-adrenergic blockade on O2 uptake during submaximal and maximal exercise. , 1983, Journal of applied physiology: respiratory, environmental and exercise physiology.

[5]  G. Borg.  Psychophysical bases of perceived exertion. , 1982, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[6]  F. Simpson,et al.  The effects of beta-adrenoceptor blockade on breathing during progressive exercise in normal man. , 1987, British journal of clinical pharmacology.

[7]  L. Adams,et al.  Effect of hyperoxia and hypoxia on exercise-induced breathlessness in normal subjects. , 1988, Clinical science.

[8]  G. Guyatt,et al.  A comparison of Likert and visual analogue scales for measuring change in function. , 1987, Journal of chronic diseases.

[9]  P. Jones,et al.  A comparison of the visual analogue scale and modified Borg scale for the measurement of dyspnoea during exercise. , 1989, Clinical science.

[10]  I. Ford,et al.  Submaximal, but not maximal, exercise testing detects differences in the effects of beta-blockers during treadmill exercise: a study of celiprolol and atenolol. II. , 1991, American heart journal.

[11]  T. B. Stretton,et al.  The relationship between breathlessness and ventilation during steady-state exercise. , 1986, Bulletin europeen de physiopathologie respiratoire.

[12]  Sophia Kluge,et al.  Physiology of exercise. , 1966, Maryland state medical journal.

[13]  P. Jones,et al.  Long-term reproducibility of Borg scale estimates of breathlessness during exercise. , 1991, Clinical science.

[14]  N. Jones,et al.  Breathlessness during exercise with and without resistive loading. , 1986, Journal of applied physiology.

[15]  S. S. Chatterjee,et al.  An exercise test to assess clinical dyspnoea: estimation of reproducibility and sensitivity. , 1982, British journal of diseases of the chest.

[16]  A. Skene,et al.  The effects of acute or chronic ingestion of propranolol or metoprolol on the physiological responses to prolonged, submaximal exercise in hypertensive men. , 1984, British journal of clinical pharmacology.

[17]  J. Patrick,et al.  The effect of beta-adrenoceptor blockade on factors affecting exercise tolerance in normal man. , 1979, British journal of clinical pharmacology.

[18]  E C Rhodes,et al.  A Critical Review of the Literature on Ratings Scales for Perceived Exertion , 1985, Sports medicine.

[19]  M. Busse,et al.  Relation between plasma K+ and ventilation during incremental exercise after glycogen depletion and repletion in man. , 1991, The Journal of physiology.

[20]  D. Costill,et al.  Fractional utilization of the aerobic capacity during distance running. , 1973, Medicine and science in sports.

[21]  S. Jennings,et al.  Effect of adrenergic and vagal blockade on the normal human airway response to exercise. , 1983, Clinical science.

[22]  P. Sharman,et al.  Effects of codeine on the respiratory responses to exercise in healthy subjects. , 1983, British journal of clinical pharmacology.

[23]  S. Kelsen,et al.  Comparison of scales used to quantitate the sense of effort to breathe in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. , 1990, The American review of respiratory disease.

[24]  K. Alberti,et al.  Effect of beta-adrenergic blockade on respiratory and metabolic responses to exercise. , 1981, Journal of applied physiology: respiratory, environmental and exercise physiology.

[25]  C T Davies,et al.  The effects of atropine and practolol on the perception of exertion during treadmill exercise. , 1979, Ergonomics.

[26]  A. Guz,et al.  Voluntary isocapnic hyperventilation and breathlessness during exercise in normal subjects. , 1987, Clinical science.

[27]  J. E. Hansen,et al.  Optimizing the exercise protocol for cardiopulmonary assessment. , 1983, Journal of applied physiology: respiratory, environmental and exercise physiology.

[28]  P. Tesch,et al.  Skeletal muscle glycolysis during submaximal exercise following acute beta-adrenergic blockade in man. , 1985, Acta physiologica Scandinavica.

[29]  P. Komi,et al.  Effects of beta-adrenergic blockade on EMG signal characteristics during progressive exercise. , 1984, Acta physiologica Scandinavica.