Competition and Ideological Diversity: Historical Evidence from Us Newspapers

We study the competitive forces that shaped ideological diversity in the US press in the early twentieth century. We find that households preferred like-minded news and that newspapers used their political orientation to differentiate from competitors. We formulate a model of newspaper demand, entry, and political affiliation choice in which newspapers compete for both readers and advertisers. We use a combination of estimation and calibration to identify the model's parameters from novel data on newspaper circulation, costs, and revenues. The estimated model implies that competition enhances ideological diversity, that the market undersupplies diversity, and that optimal competition policy requires accounting for the two-sidedness of the news market.

[1]  Michael s. Sweeney.  E.W. Scripps and the Business of Newspapers , 2000 .

[2]  Gerald J. Baldasty.  The commercialization of news in the nineteenth century , 1992 .

[3]  Liran Einav,et al.  Not All Rivals Look Alike: Estimating an Equilibrium Model of the Release Date Timing Game , 2010 .

[4]  Adam Candeub.  Media Ownership Regulation, the First Amendment, and Democracy's Future , 2007 .

[5]  Tim Groseclose,et al.  A Measure of Media Bias , 2005 .

[6]  A. Ambrus,et al.  Exclusive vs Overlapping Viewers in Media Markets , 2006 .

[7]  B. S. Skrainka,et al.  High Performance Quadrature Rules: How Numerical Integration Affects a Popular Model of Product Differentiation , 2011 .

[8]  Liran Einav,et al.  Seasonality in the U.S. motion picture industry , 2007 .

[9]  Paul Murschetz,et al.  State Support for the Daily Press in Europe: A Critical Appraisal , 1998 .

[10]  David Strömberg,et al.  Radio's Impact on Public Spending , 2004 .

[11]  Media Coverage of Political Scandals , 2008 .

[12]  Matthew Gentzkow,et al.  The Rise of the Fourth Estate: How Newspapers Became Informative and Why it Mattered , 2004 .

[13]  Florian Heiss,et al.  Likelihood approximation by numerical integration on sparse grids , 2008 .

[14]  Ambarish Chandra,et al.  Mergers in Two-Sided Markets: An Application to the Canadian Newspaper Industry , 2008 .

[15]  Victor Aguirregabiria,et al.  Advances in Economics and Econometrics: Recent Developments in Empirical IO: Dynamic Demand and Dynamic Games , 2013 .

[16]  Brian G. Knight,et al.  Media Bias and Influence: Evidence from Newspaper Endorsements , 2008 .

[17]  Jesse M. Shapiro,et al.  The Effect of Newspaper Entry and Exit on Electoral Politics , 2009 .

[18]  Dan Levin,et al.  Equilibrium in Auctions with Entry , 1994 .

[19]  Ambarish Chandra,et al.  TARGETED ADVERTISING: THE ROLE OF SUBSCRIBER CHARACTERISTICS IN MEDIA MARKETS* , 2009 .

[20]  Ralf Dewenter,et al.  Semi-collusion in media markets , 2011 .

[21]  S. Ruggles.  Integrated Public Use Microdata Series , 2021, Encyclopedia of Gerontology and Population Aging.

[22]  M. Armstrong.  Competition in Two-Sided Markets ¤ , 2005 .

[23]  Janet S. Netz,et al.  Why do all the flights leave at 8 am?: Competition and departure-time differentiation in airline markets , 1999 .

[24]  Dora L. Costa.  Estimating Real Income in the United States from 1888 to 1994: Correcting CPI Bias Using Engel Curves , 2001, Journal of Political Economy.

[25]  P. Lawson,et al.  Federal Communications Commission , 2004, Bell Labs Technical Journal.

[26]  James N. Dertouzos,et al.  ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF MEDIA CONCENTRATION: ESTIMATES FROM A MODEL OF THE NEWSPAPER FIRM , 1990 .

[27]  Hans Jarle Kind,et al.  Hotelling competition with multi-purchasing , 2010 .

[28]  Murray Wolfson,et al.  Secret origins of modern microeconomics: Dupuit and the engineers , 2000 .

[29]  Christopher R. Taber,et al.  Selection on Observed and Unobserved Variables: Assessing the Effectiveness of Catholic Schools , 2000, Journal of Political Economy.

[30]  Competition Between Networks , 2011 .

[31]  Joel Waldfogel,et al.  Who Affects Whom in Daily Newspaper Markets? , 2003, Journal of Political Economy.

[32]  L. Bogart.  Press and public: Who reads what, when, where, and why in American newspapers , 1981 .

[33]  Jesse M. Shapiro,et al.  Do Newspapers Serve the State? Incumbent Party Influence on the Us Press, 1869-1928 , 2012 .

[34]  S. Eldersveld.  The Independent Vote: Measurement, Characteristics, and Implications for Party Strategy , 1952, American Political Science Review.

[35]  L. Filistrucchi,et al.  Estimating Market Power in a Two-Sided Market: The Case of Newspapers , 2005 .

[36]  F. Chapin.  The Variability of the Popular Vote at Presidential Elections , 1912, American Journal of Sociology.

[37]  Riccardo Puglisi.  Being the New York Times: The Political Behaviour of a Newspaper , 2004 .

[38]  Joel Waldfogel,et al.  Free Entry and Social Inefficiency in Radio Broadcasting , 1996 .

[39]  Stefano DellaVigna,et al.  The Fox News Effect: Media Bias and Voting , 2006 .

[40]  Ruben Enikolopov,et al.  Media and Political Persuasion: Evidence from Russia , 2009 .

[41]  C. Dyer.  Scripps and the Business of Newspapers , 1999 .

[42]  J. Rusk,et al.  The Effect of the Australian Ballot Reform on Split Ticket Voting: 1876–1908 , 1970, American Political Science Review.

[43]  Pablo T. Spiller,et al.  Competition and Entry in Small Airline Markets , 1989, The Journal of Law and Economics.

[44]  A. Priest.  Turning the Watchdog into a Lapdog: Why the Proposed Newspaper Bailout is the Wrong Solution for a Failing Industry , 2011 .

[45]  Hans Jarle Kind,et al.  Newspaper Differentiation and Investments in Journalism: The Role of Tax Policy , 2009, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[46]  Attila Ambrus,et al.  Either or Both Competition: A "Two-Sided" Theory of Advertising with Overlapping Viewerships , 2016 .

[47]  A. Dixit,et al.  Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity , 1977 .

[48]  Keith Ian Polakoff.  Politics and the American Press: The Rise of Objectivity, 1865–1920 , 2002 .

[49]  Robert Fildes,et al.  Journal of business and economic statistics 5: Garcia-Ferrer, A. et al., Macroeconomic forecasting using pooled international data, (1987), 53-67 , 1988 .

[50]  E. Glaeser,et al.  Myths and Realities of American Political Geography , 2005 .

[51]  Benjamin Van Roy,et al.  Effects of Mergers in Two-sided Markets: Examination of the U.S. Radio Industry , 2012 .

[52]  S. Oppenheim,et al.  Newspapers and the antitrust laws , 1981 .

[53]  Robert G. Picard,et al.  Joint Operating Agreements: The Newspaper Preservation Act and its Application , 1993 .

[54]  Jacques-François Thisse,et al.  Competition in Multi-Characteristics Spaces: Hotelling Was Almost Right , 1996 .

[55]  Andrew Sweeting,et al.  Horizontal Mergers on Product Positioning : Evidence from the Music Radio Industry , 2008 .

[56]  H. Greeley.  The Autobiography of Horace Greeley: Or, Recollections of a Busy Life: To Which Are Added Miscellaneous Essays and Papers , 2009 .

[57]  J. Rochet,et al.  Platform competition in two sided markets , 2003 .

[58]  Jorge J. Moré,et al.  User Guide for Minpack-1 , 1980 .

[59]  J. Rochet,et al.  Two-sided markets: a progress report , 2006 .

[60]  J. Geanakoplos,et al.  Free Entry and Social Inefficiency , 1986 .

[61]  M. Roma,et al.  Large-Scale Nonlinear Optimization , 2006 .

[62]  James M. Snyder,et al.  Newspaper Coverage of Political Scandals , 2011 .

[63]  L. Filistrucchi,et al.  Collusion and the Political Differentiation of Newspapers , 2012 .

[64]  Gerald J. Baldasty,et al.  E. W. Scripps and the Business of Newspapers. , 2000 .

[65]  M. Gentzkow.  Valuing New Goods in a Model with Complementarity: Online Newspapers , 2007 .

[66]  Ulrich Kaiser,et al.  Do Media Consumers Really Dislike Advertising? An Empirical Assessment of the Role of Advertising in Print Media Markets , 2008 .

[67]  Ulrich Kaiser.  Do Media Consumers Really Dislike Advertising? An Empirical Assessment of a Popular Assumption in Economic Theory , 2007 .

[68]  Donna L. Halper.  Stay Tuned: A History of American Broadcasting , 2002 .

[69]  A. Millspaugh.  Irregular Voting in the United States , 1918 .

[70]  André de Palma,et al.  Discrete Choice Theory of Product Differentiation , 1995 .

[71]  Richard Kielbowicz.  Postal Subsidies for the Press and the Business of Mass Culture, 1880–1920 , 1990, Business History Review.

[72]  Kevin M. Murphy,et al.  Efficiency Wages Reconsidered: Theory and Evidence , 1990 .

[73]  Steven N. Durlauf,et al.  Identification of binary choice models with social interactions , 2007 .

[74]  V. Fuchs.  Individual and Social Responsibility , 1996 .

[75]  Peter S. Arcidiacono,et al.  Conditional Choice Probability Estimation of Dynamic Discrete Choice Models With Unobserved Heterogeneity , 2011 .

[76]  Ali Hortaçsu,et al.  Winner's Curse, Reserve Prices and Endogenous Entry: Empirical Insights from Ebay Auctions , 2003 .

[77]  Jesse M. Shapiro,et al.  Media Bias and Reputation , 2005, Journal of Political Economy.

[78]  Philip Rabinowitz,et al.  Numerical methods for nonlinear algebraic equations , 1970 .

[79]  S. Mullainathan.  The Market for News , 2003 .

[80]  Øystein Foros,et al.  Hotelling Competition with Multi-Purchasing: Time Magazine, Newsweek, or Both? , 2010, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[81]  N. Sonnac,et al.  Readers' Attitudes Toward Press Advertising: Are They Ad-Lovers or Ad-Averse? , 2000 .

[82]  H. Hotelling.  THE GENERAL WELFARE IN RELATION TO PROBLEMS OF TAXATION AND OF RAILWAY AND UTILITY RATES. IN: RAILWAYS , 1938 .

[83]  R. Kaplan.  Politics and the American Press: The Rise of Objectivity, 1865–1920 , 2002 .

[84]  Kevin M. Murphy,et al.  Estimation and Inference in Two-Step Econometric Models , 1985 .

[85]  Michaela Draganska,et al.  Beyond plain vanilla: Modeling joint product assortment and pricing decisions , 2008 .

[86]  John M. Sides,et al.  Self-Segregation or Deliberation? Blog Readership, Participation, and Polarization in American Politics , 2010, Perspectives on Politics.

[87]  P. Steiner.  Program Patterns and Preferences, and the Workability of Competition in Radio Broadcasting , 1952 .

[88]  Jean Jaskold Gabszewicz,et al.  Press advertising and the political differentiation of newspapers , 2002 .

[89]  W. D. Burnham.  The Changing Shape of the American Political Universe , 1965, American Political Science Review.

[90]  Kenneth C. Wilbur.  A Two-Sided, Empirical Model of Television Advertising and Viewing Markets , 2008, Mark. Sci..

[91]  Competition and Democracy , 1958, The Journal of Law and Economics.

[92]  J. Rauch,et al.  All the News That's Fit to Sell: How the Market Transforms Information Into News , 2006 .

[93]  L. Einav,et al.  Estimating Welfare in Insurance Markets Using Variation in Prices , 2008, The quarterly journal of economics.

[94]  Jorge Nocedal,et al.  Knitro: An Integrated Package for Nonlinear Optimization , 2006 .

[95]  Marc Rysman,et al.  Unobserved Product Differentiation in Discrete Choice Models: Estimating Price Elasticities and Welfare Effects , 2002 .

[96]  Valentino Larcinese,et al.  NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES PARTISAN BIAS IN ECONOMIC NEWS: EVIDENCE ON THE AGENDA-SETTING BEHAVIOR OF U.S. NEWSPAPERS , 2007 .

[97]  Qihong Liu,et al.  Multi-Dimensional Price Discrimination , 2013 .

[98]  Andrew Sweeting,et al.  The effects of mergers on product positioning: evidence from the music radio industry , 2010 .

[99]  Ownership Consolidation and Product Quality : A Study of the U . S . Daily Newspaper Market , 2010 .

[100]  Joel Waldfogel,et al.  Public Monopoly and Economic Efficiency: Evidence from the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board&Apos;S Entry Decisions , 2010 .

[101]  Michael J. Mazzeo.  Product Choice and Oligopoly Market Structure , 2002 .

[102]  Matthew Gentzkow,et al.  Television and Voter Turnout , 2005 .

[103]  Steven T. Berry,et al.  Do Mergers Increase Product Variety? Evidence from Radio Broadcasting , 2001 .

[104]  Steven T. Berry,et al.  Automobile Prices in Market Equilibrium , 1995 .

[105]  Andrea Prat,et al.  The Political Economy of Mass Media , 2011 .

[106]  A. Downs.  An Economic Theory of Political Action in a Democracy , 1957, Journal of Political Economy.

[107]  Gideon Fishelson,et al.  Advances in the theory and measurement of unemployment , 1990 .

[108]  Political Differentiation in Newspaper Markets , 2010 .

[109]  Allan Collard-Wexler,et al.  Mergers and Sunk Costs: An Application to the Ready-Mix Concrete Industry , 2014 .

[110]  Gordon Tullock,et al.  Secret Origins of Modern Microeconomics: Dupuit and the Engineers , 1994 .

[111]  Marc Rysman,et al.  Competition between Networks: A Study of the Market for Yellow Pages , 2002 .

[112]  E. Glaeser,et al.  Front matter, Corruption and Reform. Lessons from America's Economic History , 2006 .

[113]  A. Spence.  Monopoly, Quality, and Regulation , 1975 .

[114]  M. Beney.  Cost of living in the United States 1914-1936 , 1938 .

[115]  Pradeep K. Chintagunta,et al.  Nonparametric Discrete Choice Models With Unobserved Heterogeneity , 2010 .

[116]  Christopher H. Sterling,et al.  Stay Tuned : A History of American Broadcasting , 2001 .

[117]  Ulrich Kaiser,et al.  Price structure in two-sided markets: Evidence from the magazine industry , 2006 .

[118]  Edward L. Glaeser,et al.  The Rise of the Fourth Estate , 2006 .

[119]  K. Gustafsson.  Press subsidies and local news : the Swedish case , 2009 .

[120]  M. Petrova.  Newspapers and Parties: How Advertising Revenues Created an Independent Press , 2011, American Political Science Review.

[121]  Simon P. Anderson,et al.  Media Mergers and Media Bias with Rational Consumers , 2010 .

[122]  Brian G. Knight,et al.  Partisan Control, Media Bias, and Viewer Responses: Evidence from Berlusconi’s Italy , 2012 .

[123]  Timothy F. Bresnahan,et al.  Entry and Competition in Concentrated Markets , 1991, Journal of Political Economy.

[124]  Ying Fan.  Ownership Consolidation and Product Characteristics: A Study of the US Daily Newspaper Market , 2013 .

[125]  Jean Jaskold Gabszewicz,et al.  Press advertising and the ascent of the 'Pensee Unique' , 2001 .

[126]  Jesse M. Shapiro,et al.  Competition and Truth in the Market for News , 2008 .

[127]  Richard B. Kielbowicz.  The Press, Post Office, and Flow of News in the Early Republic , 1983 .