Does the Therapeutic Relationship Predict Outcomes of Psychiatric Treatment in Patients with Psychosis? A Systematic Review

Background: Numerous studies have shown that the quality of the therapeutic relationship (TR) between the patient and the clinician is an important predictor of the outcome of different forms of psychotherapy. It is less clear whether the TR also predicts outcomes of psychiatric treatment programmes in patients with psychosis (i.e. outside conventional psychotherapy). Methods: We conducted a systematic review and identified 9 primary studies that prospectively tested the association of the TR with 3 outcomes, i.e. hospitalisation, symptom levels and functioning. Because of the heterogeneity of the methods used, a meta-analysis was not feasible. A vote counting method was used to determine the number of statistically significant effects in the hypothesised direction (i.e. that a more positive TR predicts more favourable outcomes). Results: For each outcome, a χ2 analysis showed that the number of statistically significant findings in the hypothesised direction was greater than expected if the null hypothesis of no association were true. However, studies had methodological shortcomings, and the effect sizes of positive associations were rather small. Conclusion: It may be concluded that there is some, but not overwhelming, evidence that the TR predicts outcomes of complex psychiatric treatment programmes in patients with psychosis, and that methodologically more rigorous research is required. Such research should measure the TR at initial stages of treatment and use validated assessment instruments for both TR and outcomes.

[1]  E. Struening,et al.  SLOF: a behavioral rating scale for assessing the mentally ill. , 1983, Social work research & abstracts.

[2]  R. McCabe,et al.  Are therapeutic relationships in psychiatry explained by patients’ symptoms? Factors influencing patient ratings , 2003, European Psychiatry.

[3]  R. Liberman,et al.  Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS) Expanded Version (4.0): Scales, Anchor Points, and Administration Manual , 1993 .

[4]  B. Kirsh,et al.  Developing a Comprehensive Understanding of the Working Alliance in Community Mental Health , 2006, Qualitative health research.

[5]  A. Horvath.  Research on the alliance. , 1994 .

[6]  S. Priebe,et al.  Processes of disengagement and engagement in assertive outreach patients: qualitative study , 2005, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[7]  J. Garske,et al.  Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: a meta-analytic review. , 2000, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[8]  F. Gueyffier,et al.  Cognitive Therapy versus Rogerian Supportive Therapy in Borderline Personality Disorder , 2009, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics.

[9]  Lars Hansson,et al.  A new scale to assess the therapeutic relationship in community mental health care: STAR , 2006, Psychological Medicine.

[10]  Lars Hansson,et al.  Structured patient–clinician communication and 1-year outcome in community mental healthcare , 2007, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[11]  S. Priebe,et al.  The Role of the Helping Alliance in Psychiatric Community Care: A Prospective Study , 1993, The Journal of nervous and mental disease.

[12]  Håkan Johansson,et al.  Patients' opinion on what constitutes good psychiatric care. , 2003, Scandinavian journal of caring sciences.

[13]  R. Rosenheck,et al.  Therapeutic alliance and outcome in a VA intensive case management program. , 1995, Psychiatric services.

[14]  B. Mcfarland,et al.  A community ability scale for chronically mentally Ill consumers: Part I. Reliability and validity , 1994, Community Mental Health Journal.

[15]  L. Covi,et al.  The Hopkins Symptom Checklist (HSCL). A measure of primary symptom dimensions. , 1974, Modern problems of pharmacopsychiatry.

[16]  S. Priebe,et al.  Be Good to Your Patient: How the Therapeutic Relationship in the Treatment of Patients Admitted to Assertive Outreach Affects Rehospitalization , 2007, The Journal of nervous and mental disease.

[17]  D. Wasylenki,et al.  Process and outcome in a hostel outreach program for homeless clients with severe mental illness. , 1997, The American journal of orthopsychiatry.

[18]  R. Rosenheck,et al.  The case management relationship and outcomes of homeless persons with serious mental illness. , 2000, Psychiatric services.

[19]  S. K. Lo,et al.  Reliability and Validity , 2020, International Encyclopedia of Human Geography.

[20]  M. Eklund.  Working Relationship, Participation and Outcome in a Psychiatric Day Care Unit Based on Occupational Therapy , 1996 .

[21]  L. Luborsky.  Clinicians' Judgments of Mental Health: A Proposed Scale , 1962 .

[22]  T. Tracey,et al.  Factor structure of the Working Alliance Inventory. , 1989 .

[23]  M. Hopkins,et al.  Which factors predict case management services and how do these services relate to client outcomes? , 2006, Psychiatric rehabilitation journal.

[24]  R. McCabe,et al.  Therapeutic relationships in psychiatry: The basis of therapy or therapy in itself? , 2008, International review of psychiatry.

[25]  L. Luborsky.  Clinician's judgments of mental health. , 1962, Archives of general psychiatry.

[26]  J. Catty,et al.  The therapeutic relationship in secondary mental health care: a conceptual review of measures , 2007, Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica.

[27]  J. Overall,et al.  The Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale , 1962 .

[28]  R. McCabe,et al.  Communication and psychosis: it's good to talk, but how? , 2008, The British journal of psychiatry : the journal of mental science.

[29]  J. Catty.  'The vehicle of success': theoretical and empirical perspectives on the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy and psychiatry. , 2004, Psychology and psychotherapy.

[30]  Stefan Priebe,et al.  Patient's experiences of involuntary hospital admission and treatment: A review of qualitative studies , 2007, Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale.

[31]  L. Del Piccolo,et al.  Communication Skills in Psychiatry Residents – How Do They Handle Patient Concerns? , 2006, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics.

[32]  J. G. Allen,et al.  Assessment of therapeutic alliances in the psychiatric hospital milieu. , 1988, Psychiatry.

[33]  J. Gunderson,et al.  The role of the therapeutic alliance in the treatment of schizophrenia. Relationship to course and outcome. , 1990, Archives of general psychiatry.

[34]  Gary Kielhofner,et al.  Model of human occupation : theory and application , 1985 .

[35]  S. Hollon,et al.  The Selection and Design of Control Conditions for Randomized Controlled Trials of Psychological Interventions , 2009, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics.

[36]  D. Druckman,et al.  Theory, research, and practice , 2003 .

[37]  W. D. Klinkenberg,et al.  The Helping Alliance in Case Management for Homeless Persons with Severe Mental Illness , 1998, Community Mental Health Journal.

[38]  Pierre Pichot,et al.  Psychological measurements in psychopharmacology , 1974 .

[39]  W. D. Klinkenberg,et al.  Client Outcomes and the Working Alliance in Assertive Community Treatment Programs , 2004, Care Management Journals.

[40]  A. Horvath,et al.  Development and validation of the Working Alliance Inventory. , 1989 .

[41]  L. Hansson,et al.  Therapeutic alliance in cognitive therapy for schizophrenic and other long‐term mentally ill patients: development and relationship to outcome in an in‐patient treatment programme , 1999, Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica.