论文信息 - Limitations of Spacecraft Redundancy: A Case Study Analysis

Limitations of Spacecraft Redundancy: A Case Study Analysis

Redundancy can increase spacecraft safety by providing the crew or ground with multiple means of achieving a given function. However, redundancy can also decrease spacecraft safety by 1) adding additional failure modes to the system, 2) increasing design “opaqueness”, 3) encouraging operational risk, and 4) masking or “normalizing” design flaws. Two Loss of Crew (LOC) events—Soyuz 11 and Challenger STS 51-L—are presented as examples of these limitations. Together, these case studies suggest that redundancy is not necessarily a fail-safe means of improving spacecraft safety.

Robert P. Ocampo

[1] David S. F. Portree. Mir Hardware Heritage , 2013 .

[2] Scott D. Sagan,et al. The Limits of Safety , 2020, The Limits of Safety.

[3] T. Higgins. Book reviewSystems engineering handbook: edited by R. E. Machol, W. P. Tanner, Jr., and S. N. Alexander. 1054 pages, diagrams, illustr., New York, McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1965. Price, $29.50 , 1966 .

[4] J. Carroll,et al. Moving Beyond Normal Accidents and High Reliability Organizations: A Systems Approach to Safety in Complex Systems , 2009 .

[5] John Downer,et al. When failure is an option: redundancy, reliability and regulation in complex technical systems , 2009 .

[6] Ninety-Ninth Congress,et al. Investigation of the Challenger Accident, Report of the House of Representatives Science and Technology Committee , 1986 .

[7] Ricky W. Butler. A Primer on Architectural Level Fault Tolerance , 2008 .

[8] Grujica S. Ivanovich. Salyut - The First Space Station: Triumph and Tragedy , 2008 .

[9] D. L. Simms,et al. Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies , 1986 .

[10] Diane Vaughan,et al. The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA , 1996 .

[11] Scott D. Sagan,et al. The Problem of Redundancy Problem: Why More Nuclear Security Forces May Produce Less Nuclear Security † , 2004, Risk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis.