Immunocytochemical localization of neuron specific enolase in small cell carcinomas and carcinoid tumours of the lung

Carcinoid tumours and small cell carcinomas of the lung share many characteristics with normal neuroendocrine cells. While carcinoid tumours contain many dense‐cored neurosecretory granules and are frequently argyrophil, small cell carcinomas are poorly granulated and rarely argyrophil, which casts doubt on their neuroendocrine nature. Immunostaining of the enzyme neuron specific enolase (NSE) was recently used to demonstrate the neuroendocrine components of the lung including nerves and neuroendocrine cells. We therefore used NSE immunostaining to investigate neuroendocrine differentiation in 79 lung tumours, including 18 bronchial carcinoids and 31 small cell carcinomas, and compared these results with those obtained with silver stains. Thirteen of the 18 carcinoids were reactive to silver, all other types being negative. NSE‐immunoreactivity occurred in 16 carcinoids and 18 small cell carcinomas. None of the squamous cell carcinomas, large cell anaplastic carcinomas and adenocarcinomas examined showed NSE‐immucoreactivity. Radioimmunoassay of extractable NSE from 10 fresh lung tumours correlated well with the immunostaining results, demonstrating large amounts in two small cell carcinomas (334 and 517 ng/mg protein) and three carcinoids (152, 908, and 1143 ng/mg protein). Values were much lower for four squamous cell carcinomas (31–44 ng/mg protein) and one large cell anaplastic carcinoma (30 ng/mg protein) and were accounted for by the presence of NSE‐positive nerves and neuroendocrine cells in the surrounding lung. NSE immunostaining is a useful marker of neuroendocrine differentiation in lung tumours and should prove particularly valuable in the diagnosis of small cell anaplastic tumours and their metastases.