Effect of screening sigmoidoscopy and screening colonoscopy on colorectal cancer incidence and mortality: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials and observational studies

Objectives To review, summarise, and compare the evidence for effectiveness of screening sigmoidoscopy and screening colonoscopy in the prevention of colorectal cancer occurrence and deaths. Design Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials and observational studies. Data sources PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science. Two investigators independently extracted characteristics and results of identified studies and performed standardised quality ratings. Eligibility criteria Randomised controlled trials and observational studies in English on the impact of screening sigmoidoscopy and screening colonoscopy on colorectal cancer incidence and mortality in the general population at average risk. Results For screening sigmoidoscopy, four randomised controlled trials and 10 observational studies were identified that consistently found a major reduction in distal but not proximal colorectal cancer incidence and mortality. Summary estimates of reduction in distal colorectal cancer incidence and mortality were 31% (95% confidence intervals 26% to 37%) and 46% (33% to 57%) in intention to screen analysis, 42% (29% to 53%) and 61% (27% to 79%) in per protocol analysis of randomised controlled trials, and 64% (50% to 74%) and 66% (38% to 81%) in observational studies. For screening colonoscopy, evidence was restricted to six observational studies, the results of which suggest tentatively an even stronger reduction in distal colorectal cancer incidence and mortality, along with a significant reduction in mortality from cancer of the proximal colon. Indirect comparisons of results of observational studies on screening sigmoidoscopy and colonoscopy suggest a 40% to 60% lower risk of incident colorectal cancer and death from colorectal cancer after screening colonoscopy even though this incremental risk reduction was statistically significant for deaths from cancer of the proximal colon only. Conclusions Compelling and consistent evidence from randomised controlled trials and observational studies suggests that screening sigmoidoscopy and screening colonoscopy prevent most deaths from distal colorectal cancer. Observational studies suggest that colonoscopy compared with flexible sigmoidoscopy decreases mortality from cancer of the proximal colon. This added value should be examined in further research and weighed against the higher costs, discomfort, complication rates, capacities needed, and possible differences in compliance.

[1]  Harminder Singh,et al.  Risk of developing colorectal cancer following a negative colonoscopy examination: evidence for a 10-year interval between colonoscopies. , 2006, JAMA.

[2]  G. Friedman,et al.  A case-control study of screening sigmoidoscopy and mortality from colorectal cancer. , 1992, The New England journal of medicine.

[3]  H. Brenner,et al.  Subsite-specific colorectal cancer risk in the colorectal endoscopy era. , 2012, Gastrointestinal endoscopy.

[4]  A. Sonnenberg,et al.  Colorectal cancer prevention 2000: screening recommendations of the American College of Gastroenterology , 2000, American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[5]  E. Loftus,et al.  Risk of colorectal cancer after colonoscopy compared with flexible sigmoidoscopy or no lower endoscopy among older patients in the United States, 1998-2005. , 2013, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[6]  D. Urbach,et al.  Effect of colonoscopy on colorectal cancer incidence and mortality: an instrumental variable analysis. , 2012, Gastrointestinal endoscopy.

[7]  I. Olkin,et al.  Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology - A proposal for reporting , 2000 .

[8]  L. Holmberg,et al.  A 9-Year Follow-up Study of Participants and Nonparticipants in Sigmoidoscopy Screening: Importance of Self-Selection , 2008, Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention.

[9]  H. Brenner,et al.  Utilization of lower gastrointestinal endoscopy and fecal occult blood test in 11 European countries: evidence from the Survey of Health, Aging and Retirement in Europe (SHARE) , 2010, Endoscopy.

[10]  N. Laird,et al.  Meta-analysis in clinical trials. , 1986, Controlled clinical trials.

[11]  L. Bachmann,et al.  Colonoscopy screening markedly reduces the occurrence of colon carcinomas and carcinoma-related death: a closed cohort study. , 2012, Gastrointestinal endoscopy.

[12]  A. Sonnenberg,et al.  Prevention of Colorectal Cancer by Flexible Endoscopy and Polypectomy: A Case-Control Study of 32 702 Veterans , 1995, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[13]  H. Brenner,et al.  Protection from colorectal cancer after colonoscopy: Population-based case-control study , 2010 .

[14]  Charles J. Kahi,et al.  Effect of screening colonoscopy on colorectal cancer incidence and mortality. , 2009, Clinical gastroenterology and hepatology : the official clinical practice journal of the American Gastroenterological Association.

[15]  G. Friedman,et al.  Screening sigmoidoscopy and colorectal cancer mortality , 1990, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[16]  A. Sonnenberg,et al.  Protection by endoscopy against death from colorectal cancer. A case-control study among veterans. , 1995, Archives of internal medicine.

[17]  L. Bisanti,et al.  Once-only sigmoidoscopy in colorectal cancer screening: follow-up findings of the Italian Randomized Controlled Trial--SCORE. , 2011, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[18]  H. Brenner,et al.  Long-lasting reduction of risk of colorectal cancer following screening endoscopy , 2001, British Journal of Cancer.

[19]  G. Macfarlane,et al.  Systematic review and meta‐analysis of the evidence for flexible sigmoidoscopy as a screening method for the prevention of colorectal cancer , 2012, The British journal of surgery.

[20]  U. Ladabaum,et al.  Comparative Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness of Screening Colonoscopy vs. Sigmoidoscopy and Alternative Strategies , 2013, The American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[21]  Patrick C. Walsh,et al.  American Cancer Society Guidelines for the Early Detection of Cancer , 2002, CA: a cancer journal for clinicians.

[22]  T. Stukel,et al.  Association Between Colonoscopy Rates and Colorectal Cancer Mortality , 2010, The American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[23]  Reiko Nishihara,et al.  Long-term colorectal-cancer incidence and mortality after lower endoscopy. , 2013, The New England journal of medicine.

[24]  A. Zauber,et al.  Prevention of colorectal cancer by colonoscopic polypectomy. The National Polyp Study Workgroup. , 1993 .

[25]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[26]  Tzuyung D Kou,et al.  Complications following colonoscopy with anesthesia assistance: a population-based analysis. , 2013, JAMA internal medicine.

[27]  Linda Rabeneck,et al.  Rates of new or missed colorectal cancers after colonoscopy and their risk factors: a population-based analysis. , 2007, Gastroenterology.

[28]  T. Stukel,et al.  Risk of Proximal and Distal Colorectal Cancer Following Flexible Sigmoidoscopy: A Population-Based Cohort Study , 2008, The American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[29]  T. Sauerbruch,et al.  [S3-Guidelines Conference "Colorectal Carcinoma" 2004]. , 2004, Zeitschrift fur Gastroenterologie.

[30]  H. Brenner,et al.  Colonoscopy and fecal occult blood test use in Germany: results from a large insurance-based cohort. , 2011, Endoscopy.

[31]  S. Saini,et al.  Effect of Flexible Sigmoidoscopy-Based Screening on Incidence and Mortality of Colorectal Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials , 2012, PLoS medicine.

[32]  E. Kliewer,et al.  The reduction in colorectal cancer mortality after colonoscopy varies by site of the cancer. , 2010, Gastroenterology.

[33]  Jingsong He,et al.  Colonoscopic miss rates for right-sided colon cancer: a population-based analysis. , 2004, Gastroenterology.

[34]  Christian Stock,et al.  Adverse events requiring hospitalization within 30 days after outpatient screening and nonscreening colonoscopies. , 2013, Gastrointestinal endoscopy.

[35]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[36]  M. Hernán,et al.  The NordICC Study: Rationale and design of a randomized trial on colonoscopy screening for colorectal cancer , 2012, Endoscopy.

[37]  S D Walter,et al.  The results of direct and indirect treatment comparisons in meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. , 1997, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[38]  H. Brenner,et al.  In the era of widespread endoscopy use, randomized trials may strongly underestimate the effects of colorectal cancer screening. , 2013, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[39]  Chyke A Doubeni,et al.  Screening Colonoscopy and Risk for Incident Late-Stage Colorectal Cancer Diagnosis in Average-Risk Adults , 2013, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[40]  Robert A Smith,et al.  American Cancer Society Guidelines for the Early Detection of Cancer, 2005 , 2005, CA: a cancer journal for clinicians.

[41]  V. Gilbertsen,et al.  The prevention of invasive cancer of the rectum , 1978, Cancer.

[42]  Sandra L. Edwards,et al.  Colon cancer screening, lifestyle, and risk of colon cancer , 2000, Cancer Causes & Control.

[43]  H. Brenner,et al.  Potential for Colorectal Cancer Prevention of Sigmoidoscopy Versus Colonoscopy: Population-Based Case Control Study , 2007, Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers & Prevention.

[44]  S. Gallinger,et al.  Colorectal Screening is Associated with Reduced Colorectal Cancer Risk: A Case–Control Study within the Population-Based Ontario Familial Colorectal Cancer Registry , 2005, Cancer Causes & Control.

[45]  J. Bond,et al.  CIMP Status of Interval Colon Cancers: Another Piece to the Puzzle , 2010, The American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[46]  H. Brenner,et al.  Population-based prevalence estimates of history of colonoscopy or sigmoidoscopy: review and analysis of recent trends. , 2010, Gastrointestinal endoscopy.

[47]  G. Colditz,et al.  Screening endoscopy and risk of colorectal cancer in United States men , 1998, Cancer Causes & Control.

[48]  Mark P Purdue,et al.  Colorectal-cancer incidence and mortality with screening flexible sigmoidoscopy. , 2012, The New England journal of medicine.

[49]  J. Potter,et al.  Long-term efficacy of sigmoidoscopy in the reduction of colorectal cancer incidence. , 2003, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[50]  J. Barkin.  Risk of Developing Colorectal Cancer Following a Negative Colonoscopy Examination: Evidence for a 10-Year Interval Between ColonoscopiesSingh H, Turner D, Xue L, et al (Univ of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada) JAMA 295:2366–2373, 2006§ , 2007 .

[51]  M. Vatn,et al.  Population-based surveillance by colonoscopy: effect on the incidence of colorectal cancer. Telemark Polyp Study I. , 1999, Scandinavian journal of gastroenterology.

[52]  T. Stukel,et al.  Association between colonoscopy and colorectal cancer mortality in a US cohort according to site of cancer and colonoscopist specialty. , 2012, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[53]  B. Iacopetta.  Are there two sides to colorectal cancer? , 2002, International journal of cancer.

[54]  M. Bretthauer,et al.  Risk of colorectal cancer seven years after flexible sigmoidoscopy screening: randomised controlled trial , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[55]  Case-Control Studies of the Efficacy of Cancer Screening: Overcoming Bias From Nonrandom Patterns of Screening , 2004, Epidemiology.

[56]  D. Ahlquist,et al.  Colorectal cancer screening: a community case-control study of proctosigmoidoscopy, barium enema radiography, and fecal occult blood test efficacy. , 1999, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[57]  S. Woolf,et al.  Colorectal cancer screening and surveillance: clinical guidelines and rationale-Update based on new evidence. , 2003, Gastroenterology.

[58]  Christian Stock,et al.  Reduced risk of colorectal cancer up to 10 years after screening, surveillance, or diagnostic colonoscopy. , 2014, Gastroenterology.

[59]  L. Seeff,et al.  Outpatient colonoscopy complications in the CDC's Colorectal Cancer Screening Demonstration Program , 2013, Cancer.

[60]  S. Thompson,et al.  Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta‐analysis , 2002, Statistics in medicine.

[61]  G. Smith,et al.  Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test , 1997, BMJ.

[62]  L. Rabeneck,et al.  Association of Colonoscopy and Death From Colorectal Cancer , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[63]  Ahmedin Jemal,et al.  Trends in Colorectal Cancer Incidence Rates in the United States by Tumor Location and Stage, 1992–2008 , 2012, Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention.

[64]  Jun Kato,et al.  Differences between right‐ and left‐sided colon cancer in patient characteristics, cancer morphology and histology , 2008, Journal of gastroenterology and hepatology.

[65]  E. Kuipers,et al.  Exposure to colorectal examinations before a colorectal cancer diagnosis: a case–control study , 2010, European journal of gastroenterology & hepatology.

[66]  Cancer,et al.  Once-only flexible sigmoidoscopy screening in prevention of colorectal cancer: a multicentre randomised controlled trial , 2010, The Lancet.

[67]  L. Seeff,et al.  Patterns of Colorectal Cancer Test Use, Including CT Colonography, in the 2010 National Health Interview Survey , 2012, Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention.

[68]  M. Vatn,et al.  Polypectomy of adenomas in the prevention of colorectal cancer: 10 years' follow-up of the Telemark Polyp Study I. A prospective, controlled population study. , 1996, Scandinavian journal of gastroenterology.

[69]  J. Mossong,et al.  Colorectal cancer incidence is low in patients following a colonoscopy. , 2011, Digestive and liver disease : official journal of the Italian Society of Gastroenterology and the Italian Association for the Study of the Liver.