Is volar locking plate superior to external fixation for distal radius fractures? A comprehensive meta-analysis

Objective The aim of this meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (RCT) and retrospective cohort studies (CS) regarding the use of volar locking plate (VLP) and external fixation (EF) in distal radius fractures was to determine whether there was any evidence that one treatment was superior to the other. Methods The meta-analysis followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Electrical databases (PubMed, EMBASE and the Cochrane library) were retrieved to find RCTs and CSs met the eligibility criteria. Two reviewers screened the studies, extracted the data and evaluated the methodological quality, and performed data analysis with RevMan 5.1. The publication bias was test by Stata 14.0. The Begg's and Egger's test were performed by Stata 14.0. The quality of evidence was graded according to the criteria of GRADE. We ultimately included ten RCTs and eleven CSs. Results A total of 1590 subjects were reported. Publication bias was detected by funnel plot in RCTs. VLP could provide better results such as DASH scores (RCT: MD = −6.12, 95%CI = −12.07–0.17; CS: MD = −6.43, 95%CI = −12.53–0.3), ulnar variance (RCT: MD = −0.81, 95%CI = −1.25–0.37) and infection rate (RCT: RR = 0.25, 95%CI = 0.10–0.65; CS: RR = 0.15, 95%CI = 0.06–0.40). There were no significant differences for G-W scores, VAS and grip strength between the VLP group and EF group. There was significantly greater loss of volar tilt (P = 0.01) and radial inclination (P = 0.02) in patients receiving EF, basing on the CSs. Conclusions VLP could provide better results, such as DASH scores, ulnar variance, volar tilt, radial inclination and infection rate. The use of VLP appear to be associated with better results of ROM (flexion, pronation, supination and radial deviation), radiographic parameters (volar tilt and radial inclination) and lower total complication rate and CRPS rate in CSs. Level of evidence Level 1, Therapeutic study.

[1]  P. Evans,et al.  Biomechanical properties of fixed-angle volar distal radius plates under dynamic loading. , 2012, The Journal of hand surgery.

[2]  M. Walsh,et al.  Bridging external fixation and supplementary Kirschner-wire fixation versus volar locked plating for unstable fractures of the distal radius: a randomised, prospective trial. , 2008, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. British volume.

[3]  Wang Ya-nan,et al.  Volar locking plate versus external fixation for the treatment of unstable distal radial fractures: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. , 2015, The Journal of surgical research.

[4]  G. Guyatt,et al.  Grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations , 2004, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[5]  D. Cecilia-López,et al.  Comparison Between External Fixators and Fixed-Angle Volar-Locking Plates in the Treatment of Distal Radius Fractures , 2012, Journal of Hand and Microsurgery.

[6]  M. McQueen,et al.  Colles fracture: does the anatomical result affect the final function? , 1988, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. British volume.

[7]  M. Banerjee,et al.  Current and future national costs to medicare for the treatment of distal radius fracture in the elderly. , 2011, The Journal of hand surgery.

[8]  M. Rizzo,et al.  Comparison of Locked Volar Plating Versus Pinning and External Fixation in the Treatment of Unstable Intraarticular Distal Radius Fractures , 2008, Hand.

[9]  M. Kayalar,et al.  A new complication in volar locking plating of the distal radius: longitudinal fractures of the near cortex. , 2016, Acta orthopaedica et traumatologica turcica.

[10]  L. Kucuk,et al.  Comparison of ultrasound and dorsal horizon radiographic view for the detection of dorsal screw penetration , 2017, Acta Orthopaedica et Traumatologica Turcica.

[11]  M. Henry,et al.  Early active rehabilitation for operatively stabilized distal radius fractures. , 2004, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[12]  S Solgaard,et al.  Epidemiology of distal radius fractures. , 1985, Acta orthopaedica Scandinavica.

[13]  B. Kocaoglu,et al.  Comparison of palmar locking plate and K-wire augmented external fixation for intra-articular and comminuted distal radius fractures. , 2010, Acta orthopaedica et traumatologica turcica.

[14]  J. Wang,et al.  Open reduction and internal fixation versus external fixation for unstable distal radial fractures: a meta-analysis. , 2013, Orthopaedics & traumatology, surgery & research : OTSR.

[15]  B. Dong,et al.  [EFFECTIVENESS COMPARISON OF EXTERNAL FIXATION AND VOLAR LOCKING COMPRESSION PLATE IN TREATMENT OF DISTAL RADIUS FRACTURES OF TYPE C]. , 2015, Zhongguo xiu fu chong jian wai ke za zhi = Zhongguo xiufu chongjian waike zazhi = Chinese journal of reparative and reconstructive surgery.

[16]  Emmanuel P. Estrella,et al.  Outcome of unstable distal radius fractures treated with open reduction and internal fixation versus external fixation. , 2012, Hand surgery : an international journal devoted to hand and upper limb surgery and related research : journal of the Asia-Pacific Federation of Societies for Surgery of the Hand.

[17]  S. Suso,et al.  Comminuted intra-articular fractures of the distal end of the radius treated with the Hoffmann external fixator. , 1993, The Journal of trauma.

[18]  P. Shekelle,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement , 2015, Systematic Reviews.

[19]  E. Hannan.  Randomized clinical trials and observational studies: guidelines for assessing respective strengths and limitations. , 2008, JACC. Cardiovascular interventions.

[20]  T. Wright,et al.  Functional outcome of unstable distal radius fractures: ORIF with a volar fixed-angle tine plate versus external fixation. , 2005, The Journal of hand surgery.

[21]  L. A. Koman,et al.  Randomized comparison of volar locking plates and intramedullary nails for unstable distal radius fractures. , 2015, The Journal of hand surgery.

[22]  R. Nanda,et al.  Treatment of unstable distal radius fractures: non-invasive dynamic external fixator versus volar locking plate – functional and radiological outcome in a prospective case-controlled series , 2015, SICOT-J.

[23]  T. Mittlmeier,et al.  Non-bridging external fixation employing multiplanar K-wires versus volar locked plating for dorsally displaced fractures of the distal radius , 2013, Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery.

[24]  P. Boyer,et al.  Treatment of complex fractures of the distal radius: a prospective randomised comparison of external fixation 'versus' locked volar plating. , 2012, Injury.

[25]  Gwo‐Jaw Wang,et al.  Use of an external fixation combined with the buttress-maintain pinning method in treating comminuted distal radius fractures in osteoporotic patients. , 2006, The Journal of trauma.

[26]  T. Boll,et al.  Two procedures for Kirschner wire osteosynthesis of distal radial fractures. A randomized trial. , 2004, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[27]  Management of distal radial fractures. , 2007, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[28]  J. Orbay,et al.  Volar fixed-angle plate fixation for unstable distal radius fractures in the elderly patient. , 2004, The Journal of hand surgery.

[29]  D. Ruch,et al.  Analysis of the complications of palmar plating versus external fixation for fractures of the distal radius. , 2011, The Journal of hand surgery.

[30]  R. Jain,et al.  External fixation versus volar locking plate for displaced intra-articular distal radius fractures: a prospective randomized comparative study of the functional outcomes , 2014, Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology.

[31]  S. Schubert,et al.  Outcome after surgery of distal radius fractures: no differences between external fixation and ORIF , 2005, Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery.

[32]  M. Rosenwasser,et al.  Unstable distal radial fractures treated with external fixation, a radial column plate, or a volar plate. A prospective randomized trial. , 2009, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[33]  L. Kucuk,et al.  Retrospective comparison of external fixation versus volar locking plate in the treatment of unstable intra-articular distal radius fractures , 2014, European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology.

[34]  M. Guzzini,et al.  Is it really necessary to restore radial anatomic parameters after distal radius fractures , 2014 .

[35]  J. Kanis,et al.  Algodystrophy following Colles' fracture. , 1989, Journal of hand surgery.

[36]  I. Atroshi,et al.  Wrist-bridging versus non-bridging external fixation for displaced distal radius fractures: A randomized assessor-blind clinical trial of 38 patients followed for 1 year , 2006, Acta orthopaedica.

[37]  K. Chung,et al.  The frequency and epidemiology of hand and forearm fractures in the United States. , 2001, The Journal of hand surgery.

[38]  S. Ponzer,et al.  Volar Locking Plate or External Fixation With Optional Addition of K-Wires for Dorsally Displaced Distal Radius Fractures: A Randomized Controlled Study , 2016, Journal of orthopaedic trauma.

[39]  I. Sofianos,et al.  External fixation versus "pi" plate for distal radius fractures. , 2010, The Journal of trauma.

[40]  M. Safdari,et al.  Comparing the effect of volar plate fixators and external fixators on outcome of patients with intra-articular distal radius fractures: A clinical trial , 2015, Electronic physician.

[41]  M. Erdil,et al.  Flexor tendon complications in comminuted distal radius fractures treated with anatomic volar rim locking plates , 2016, Acta orthopaedica et traumatologica turcica.

[42]  W. Haenszel,et al.  Statistical aspects of the analysis of data from retrospective studies of disease. , 1959, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[43]  A. Martini,et al.  Comparison of external fixation, locking and non-locking palmar plating for unstable distal radius fractures in the elderly , 2009, International Orthopaedics.

[44]  Safdari Mohammadreza,et al.  Comparing the effect of volar plate fixators and external fixators on outcome of patients with intra-articular distal radius fractures: A clinical trial. , 2015 .

[45]  G. Baek,et al.  A randomized comparison of volar plate and external fixation for intra-articular distal radius fractures. , 2015, The Journal of hand surgery.

[46]  T. Husby,et al.  External Fixation and Adjuvant Pins Versus Volar Locking Plate Fixation in Unstable Distal Radius Fractures: A Randomized, Controlled Study With a 5-Year Follow-Up. , 2015, The Journal of hand surgery.

[47]  D. Mastella.  Trends in the United States in the Treatment of Distal Radial Fractures in the Elderly , 2010 .

[48]  H. Abbaszadegan,et al.  Wrist function recovers more rapidly after volar locked plating than after external fixation but the outcomes are similar after 1 year , 2011, Acta orthopaedica.

[49]  Claire Bombardier,et al.  2009 Updated Method Guidelines for Systematic Reviews in the Cochrane Back Review Group , 2009, Spine.

[50]  T. Shimamura,et al.  Comparison of the volar locking plate and the bridging external fixator in the treatment of distal radius fracture based on range of wrist motion assessed by functional radiography. , 2010, Medical science monitor : international medical journal of experimental and clinical research.

[51]  G. Marco,et al.  Is it really necessary to restore radial anatomic parameters after distal radius fractures? , 2014, Injury.

[52]  T. Husby,et al.  Volar locking plates versus external fixation and adjuvant pin fixation in unstable distal radius fractures: a randomized, controlled study. , 2013, The Journal of hand surgery.