Measuring and Monitoring Illegal Use of Natural Resources

Illegal use of natural resources is a threat to biodiversity globally, but research on illegal activities has methodological challenges. We examined 100 studies that empirically identify targeted resources, techniques used to procure resources illegally, locations of illegal activities, characteristics of typical violators, incentives driving illegal use of resources, magnitude of the problem of illegal use (e.g., quantities used), or frequency of illegal activity. We based our evaluation of the methods used in these studies on their ability to provide these empirical data, relative labor demands, training and technology requirements, and levels of uncontrollable bias. We evaluated eight different methods: law-enforcement records, indirect observation, self-reporting, direct observation, direct questioning, randomized response technique (a survey method designed to improve accuracy of responses to sensitive questions), forensics, and modeling. Different situations favored different methods, each with distinct advantages and limitations. Six context-specific factors-location of resource use (in situ vs. ex situ), budget, technology and training capacity, ease of detection of illegal activity, scope of illegal activity (limited vs. widespread), and researchers' willingness to accept bias in results-help narrow the choice of methods. Several methodological concerns applied to any study of illegal resource use: regular monitoring can detect trends; modeling can incorporate sampling error and data uncertainties; researchers must manage levels of bias that vary between methods; triangulation of results from multiple methods can improve accuracy. No method is a panacea, but a combination of techniques can help address the lack of data on illegal activity. Researchers empirically compared results from different methods in only four studies, and no one has compared more than two methods simultaneously. Conservation would benefit from more research focused on: methods comparisons that include cost effectiveness, time efficiency, and statistical rigor; unique applications of the eight techniques currently in use; and testing of new methods.

[1]  Walter W. Hauck,et al.  Effects of Interviewer Gender, Interviewer Choice, and Item Wording on Responses to Questions Concerning Sexual Behavior , 1996 .

[2]  E. Milner‐Gulland,et al.  A model of incentives for the illegal exploitation of black rhinos and elephants : poaching pays in Luangwa Valley, Zambia , 1992 .

[3]  R. Kaminski,et al.  Illegal waterfowl hunting in the Mississippi Flyway and recommendations for alleviation. , 1994 .

[4]  K. Patterson.  Assessing fish stocks when catches are misreported: model, simulation tests, and application to cod, haddock, and whiting in the ICES area , 1998 .

[5]  R. Francini-Filho,et al.  Dynamics of fish assemblages on coral reefs subjected to different management regimes in the Abrolhos Bank, eastern Brazil , 2008 .

[6]  D. Baranga.  Observations on resource use in Mabira Forest Reserve, Uganda. , 2007 .

[7]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Effective Enforcement in a Conservation Area , 2006, Science.

[8]  Stephen Blake,et al.  Forest Elephant Crisis in the Congo Basin , 2007, PLoS biology.

[9]  E. Wikramanayake,et al.  The Fate of Wild Tigers , 2007 .

[10]  Surveillance and Poaching on Inshore Reefs of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park , 2004 .

[11]  B. Mann.  Quantification of illicit fish harvesting in the Lake St Lucia Game Reserve, South Africa , 1995 .

[12]  Milani Y. Chaloupka,et al.  Application of the randomized response technique to marine park management: an assessment of permit compliance , 1985 .

[13]  Paul E. Tracy,et al.  Randomized Response: A Method for Sensitive Surveys , 1986 .

[14]  J. Allard,et al.  A strategy to detect fish discarding by combining onboard and onshore sampling , 1997 .

[15]  Yonariza,et al.  Rural household participation in illegal timber felling in a protected area of West Sumatra, Indonesia , 2007, Environmental Conservation.

[16]  J. Mcneely.  Biodiversity, War, and Tropical Forests , 2003, War and Tropical Forests: Conservation in Areas of Armed Conflict.

[17]  Wendy Visscher,et al.  The Item Count Technique as a Method of Indirect Questioning: A Review of Its Development and a Case Study Application , 2011 .

[18]  The randomized response technique as a tool for estimating non-compliance rates in fisheries: a case study of illegal red abalone (Haliotis rufescens) fishing in Northern California , 2009, Environmental Conservation.

[19]  M. Bérubé,et al.  DNA Registers of Legally Obtained Wildlife and Derived Products as Means to Identify Illegal Takes , 2006, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[20]  H. Jachmann,et al.  Elephant poaching and law enforcement in the central Luangwa Valley, Zambia , 1997 .

[21]  E. Milner‐Gulland,et al.  Policies for the enforcement of Wildlife laws : the balance between detection and penalties in Luangwa Valley, Zambia , 1993 .

[22]  R. McGarvey,et al.  The South Australian lobster fishery management model , 1999 .

[23]  Raymond M. Lee,et al.  Researching Sensitive Topics , 1994 .

[24]  T. Pitcher,et al.  Estimating illegal and unreported catches from marine ecosystems: a basis for change , 2002 .

[25]  J. Kinch.  Giant clams: Their status and trade in Milne Bay Province, Papua New Guinea , 2002 .

[26]  J. Vogel,et al.  Isotope fingerprints in elephant bone and ivory , 1990, Nature.

[27]  E. Webb,et al.  A survey of stock of the donkey’s ear abalone, Haliotis asinina L. in the Sagay Marine Reserve, Philippines: evaluating the effectiveness of marine protected area enforcement , 2004 .

[28]  E. K. Pikitch,et al.  Genetic tracking of basking shark products in international trade , 2007 .

[29]  E. J. Milner-Gulland,et al.  Testing the use of interviews as a tool for monitoring trends in the harvesting of wild species , 2008 .

[30]  T. Pitcher,et al.  Towards sustainability in world fisheries , 2002, Nature.

[31]  H. Jachmann.  Monitoring law-enforcement performance in nine protected areas in Ghana , 2008 .

[32]  Reinhard Renneberg,et al.  Cyanide fishing and cyanide detection in coral reef fish using chemical tests and biosensors. , 2005, Biosensors & bioelectronics.

[33]  Kevin J. Gaston,et al.  Balancing the Earth's accounts , 1999, Nature.

[34]  Peter G. M. van der Heijden,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Randomized Response Research , 2005 .

[35]  Seymour Sudman,et al.  Contributions of cognitive psychology to advertising research. , 1989 .

[36]  C. Woodley,et al.  Use of restriction fragment length polymorphisms to identify sea turtle eggs and cooked meats to species , 2004, Conservation Genetics.

[37]  Assessment of Threat Status and Management Effectiveness in Kakamega Forest, Kenya , 2006 .

[38]  Rajan Amin,et al.  Intelligent data analysis for conservation: experiments with rhino horn fingerprint identification , 2003, Knowl. Based Syst..

[39]  L. P. Chow,et al.  The Randomized Response Technique as Used in the Taiwan Outcome of Pregnancy Study , 1972 .

[40]  R. Lorenzini.  DNA forensics and the poaching of wildlife in Italy: a case study. , 2005, Forensic science international.

[41]  G. Caughley,et al.  Projected decline of the African elephant , 1990 .

[42]  N. Leader‐Williams,et al.  Illegal exploitation of black rhinoceros and elephant populations : patterns of decline, law enforcement and patrol effort in Luangwa Valley, Zambia , 1990 .

[43]  I. Cowx,et al.  Are the exploitation pressures on the Nile perch fisheries resources of Lake Victoria a cause for concern , 2006 .

[44]  P. Hostert,et al.  Post-socialist forest disturbance in the Carpathian border region of Poland, Slovakia, and Ukraine. , 2007, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[45]  L. Tacconi,et al.  Illegal Logging: Law Enforcement, Livelihoods and the Timber Trade , 2007 .

[46]  J. McCrary,et al.  Illegal extraction of forest products in Laguna de Apoyo Nature Reserve, Nicaragua. , 2004 .

[47]  U. Edirisinghe.  Sustainable aquatic resources management in the 21stcentury: some important issues , 2003, Tropical Agricultural Research and Extension.

[48]  R. Mace,et al.  Managing Protected Woodlands: Fuelwood Collection and Law Enforcement in Lake Malawi National Park , 1999 .

[49]  W. J. Nichols,et al.  Estimates of sea turtle mortality from poaching and bycatch in Bahía Magdalena, Baja California Sur, Mexico , 2006 .

[50]  Tomas Holmern,et al.  Local law enforcement and illegal bushmeat hunting outside the Serengeti National Park, Tanzania , 2007, Environmental Conservation.

[51]  S. Valencia-Díaz,et al.  Local illegal trade reveals unknown diversity and involves a high species richness of wild vascular epiphytes , 2007 .

[52]  D. Smethurst,et al.  The distribution of manatees (Trichechus manatus) in the coastal waterways of Tortuguero, Costa Rica , 1999 .

[53]  M. Guard,et al.  Dynamite fishing in Southern Tanzania, geographical variation, intensity of use and possible solutions , 1997 .

[54]  D. Edderai,et al.  A census of the commercial bushmeat market in Yaoundé, Cameroon , 2006, Oryx.

[55]  K. Macdicken,et al.  Quantifying the direct social and governmental costs of illegal logging in the Bolivian, Brazilian, and Peruvian Amazon , 2008 .

[56]  J. Kalpers,et al.  Ranger Based Monitoring in the Virunga–Bwindi Region of East-Central Africa: A Simple Data Collection Tool for Park Management , 2005, Biodiversity and Conservation.

[57]  T. Pitcher,et al.  Estimating the unreported catch of Eritrean Red Sea fisheries , 2007 .

[58]  Y. Yom-Tov.  Poaching of Israeli wildlife by guest workers , 2003 .

[59]  M. Gavin.  Foraging in the fallows: Hunting patterns across a successional continuum in the Peruvian Amazon , 2007 .

[60]  Michael Burton,et al.  An assessment of alternative methods of estimating the effect of the ivory trade ban on poaching effort , 1999 .

[61]  P. Arctander,et al.  Effective population size dynamics reveal impacts of historic climatic events and recent anthropogenic pressure in African elephants , 2008, Molecular ecology.

[62]  C. S. Baker.  Predicted decline of protected whales based on molecular genetic monitoring of Japanese and Korean markets , 2000, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[63]  P. Kline,et al.  Use of Random Response to Estimate Angler Noncompliance with Fishing Regulations , 1995 .

[64]  J. E. Byers,et al.  Poaching, enforcement, and the efficacy of marine reserves. , 2007, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[65]  Matthew Stephens,et al.  Combating the Illegal Trade in African Elephant Ivory with DNA Forensics , 2008, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[66]  K. S. Murali,et al.  Extraction of non-timber forest products in the forests of Biligiri Rangan Hills, India. 4. impact on floristic diversity and population structure in a thorn scrub forest , 1998, Economic Botany.

[67]  S. Jacobson,et al.  Estimating Illegal Resource Use at a Ugandan Park with the Randomized Response Technique , 2007 .

[68]  Hugo Jachmann,et al.  Illegal wildlife use and protected area management in Ghana , 2008 .

[69]  G. Anderson,et al.  Wildlife forensic entomology: determining time of death in two illegally killed black bear cubs. , 1999, Journal of forensic sciences.

[70]  Guy Cowlishaw,et al.  Do wildlife laws work? Species protection and the application of a prey choice model to poaching decisions , 2004, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[71]  Ineke Haen Marshall,et al.  The Self-Report Methodology in Crime Research , 1999, Crime and Justice.

[72]  Seymour Sudman,et al.  Measurement errors in surveys , 1993 .

[73]  T. Pitcher,et al.  Estimating illegal, unreported and unregulated catch in British Columbia's marine fisheries , 2005 .

[74]  S. Vermeulen,et al.  Cutting of trees by local residents in a communal area and an adjacent state forest in Zimbabwe , 1996 .

[75]  Robert A. Peterson,et al.  A Critical Evaluation of the Randomized Response Method , 1991 .

[76]  J. Kritzer,et al.  Effects of Noncompliance on the Success of Alternative Designs of Marine Protected‐Area Networks for Conservation and Fisheries Management , 2004 .

[77]  C. Raymakers,et al.  Slipping the net : Spain's compliance with ICCAT recommendations for swordfish and bluefin tuna , 1999 .

[78]  J. Clarence Davies.  Comparing Environmental Risks: Tools for Setting Government Priorities , 1996 .

[79]  D. Agnew.  The illegal and unregulated fishery for toothfish in the Southern Ocean, and the CCAMLR catch documentation scheme , 2000 .

[80]  Larry M. Gigliotti,et al.  The Effect of Illegal Harvest on Recreational Fisheries , 1990 .

[81]  I. Gordon,et al.  Local community attitudes to wildlife utilisation in the changing economic and social context of Mongolia , 2004, Biodiversity & Conservation.

[82]  S L Warner,et al.  Randomized response: a survey technique for eliminating evasive answer bias. , 1965, Journal of the American Statistical Association.

[83]  G. Anderson,et al.  Testing a rapid quantitative ethnobiological technique: First steps towards developing a critical conservation tool , 2005, Economic Botany.