A rigorous empirical comparison of two stochastic solvers is important when one of the solvers is a prototype of a new algorithm such as multi-walk (MWA). When searching for global minima in $\mathbb{R}^{p}$, the key data structures of MWA include: $p$ rulers with each ruler assigned $m$ marks and a set of $p$ neighborhood matrices of size up to $m\ast(m - 2)$, where each entry represents absolute values of pairwise differences between $m$ marks. Before taking the next step, a controller links the tableau of neighborhood matrices and computes new and improved positions for each of the m marks. The number of columns in each neighborhood matrix is denoted as the neighborhood radius $r_{n} < = m - 2$. Any variant of the DEA (differential evolution algorithm) has an effective population neighborhood of radius not larger than 1. Uncensored first-passage-time performance experiments that vary the neighborhood radius of a MW-solver can thus be readily compared to existing variants of DE-solvers. This paper considers seven test cases of increasing complexity and demonstrates, under uncensored first-passage-time performance experiments: (1) significant variability in convergence rate for seven DE-based solver configurations, and (2) consistent, monotonic, and significantly faster rate of convergence for the MW-solver prototype as we increase the neighborhood radius from 4 to its maximum value.
[1]
Franc Brglez.
On Self-Avoiding Walks across n-Dimensional Dice and Combinatorial Optimization: An Introduction
,
2013,
ArXiv.
[2]
Stan Wagon,et al.
The SIAM 100-Digit Challenge - A study in High-Accuracy Numerical Computing
,
2004,
The SIAM 100-Digit Challenge.
[3]
Janez Brest,et al.
Low-autocorrelation binary sequences: On improved merit factors and runtime predictions to achieve them
,
2014,
Appl. Soft Comput..
[4]
Katharine M. Mullen,et al.
Continuous Global Optimization in R
,
2014
.
[5]
J. Borwein.
The SIAM 100-Digit challenge: a study in high-accuracy numerical computing
,
1987
.
[6]
S. Redner.
A guide to first-passage processes
,
2001
.
[7]
M. Kac.
Random Walk and the Theory of Brownian Motion
,
1947
.
[8]
David Ardia,et al.
DEoptim: An R Package for Global Optimization by Differential Evolution
,
2009
.
[9]
Pranab Kumar Sen,et al.
Censoring in theory and practice: statistical perspectives and controversies
,
1995
.