The effectiveness of acellular nerve allografts compared to autografts in animal models: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background Treatment of nerve injuries proves to be a worldwide clinical challenge. Acellular nerve allografts are suggested to be a promising alternative for bridging a nerve gap to the current gold standard, an autologous nerve graft. Objective To systematically review the efficacy of the acellular nerve allograft, its difference from the gold standard (the nerve autograft) and to discuss its possible indications. Material and methods PubMed, Embase and Web of Science were systematically searched until the 4th of January 2022. Original peer reviewed paper that presented 1) distinctive data; 2) a clear comparison between not immunologically processed acellular allografts and autologous nerve transfers; 3) was performed in laboratory animals of all species and sex. Meta analyses and subgroup analyses (for graft length and species) were conducted for muscle weight, sciatic function index, ankle angle, nerve conduction velocity, axon count diameter, tetanic contraction and amplitude using a Random effects model. Subgroup analyses were conducted on graft length and species. Results Fifty articles were included in this review and all were included in the meta-analyses. An acellular allograft resulted in a significantly lower muscle weight, sciatic function index, ankle angle, nerve conduction velocity, axon count and smaller diameter, tetanic contraction compared to an autologous nerve graft. No difference was found in amplitude between acellular allografts and autologous nerve transfers. Post hoc subgroup analyses of graft length showed a significant reduced muscle weight in long grafts versus small and medium length grafts. All included studies showed a large variance in methodological design. Conclusion Our review shows that the included studies, investigating the use of acellular allografts, showed a large variance in methodological design and are as a consequence difficult to compare. Nevertheless, our results indicate that treating a nerve gap with an allograft results in an inferior nerve recovery compared to an autograft in seven out of eight outcomes assessed in experimental animals. In addition, based on our preliminary post hoc subgroup analyses we suggest that when an allograft is being used an allograft in short and medium (0-1cm, > 1-2cm) nerve gaps is preferred over an allograft in long (> 2cm) nerve gaps.

[1]  Joshua M. Adkinson,et al.  Donor site morbidity after sural nerve grafting: A systematic review. , 2021, Journal of plastic, reconstructive & aesthetic surgery : JPRAS.

[2]  J. C. Nakamoto,et al.  Evaluation of the Use of Nerve Allograft Preserved in Glycerol , 2021, Plastic and reconstructive surgery. Global open.

[3]  Ting Li,et al.  Fabrication and evaluation of an optimized acellular nerve allograft with multiple axial channels. , 2020, Acta biomaterialia.

[4]  Ulrich Dirnagl,et al.  The ARRIVE guidelines 2.0: Updated guidelines for reporting animal research* , 2020, BMC Veterinary Research.

[5]  D. Kong,et al.  Mechanical properties of the sciatic nerve following combined transplantation of analytically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve and adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cells 1 , 2020, Acta cirurgica brasileira.

[6]  Daping Quan,et al.  Decellularized nerve matrix hydrogel and glial‐derived neurotrophic factor modifications assisted nerve repair with decellularized nerve matrix scaffolds , 2020, Journal of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.

[7]  V. Carriel,et al.  Detergent‐based decellularized peripheral nerve allografts: An in vivo preclinical study in the rat sciatic nerve injury model , 2020, Journal of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.

[8]  N. Baldini,et al.  Auto-Allo Graft Parallel Juxtaposition for Improved Neuroregeneration in Peripheral Nerve Reconstruction Based on Acellular Nerve Allografts. , 2019, Annals of plastic surgery.

[9]  J. K. Kim,et al.  Comparison of systematically combined detergent and nuclease‐based decellularization methods for acellular nerve graft: An ex vivo characterization and in vivo evaluation , 2019, Journal of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.

[10]  C. Voigt,et al.  No Difference in Outcomes Detected Between Decellular Nerve Allograft and Cable Autograft in Rat Sciatic Nerve Defects , 2019, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[11]  Ying Guo,et al.  Role of Demyelination Efficiency within Acellular Nerve Scaffolds during Nerve Regeneration across Peripheral Defects , 2017, BioMed research international.

[12]  P. Cederna,et al.  Comparative outcome measures in peripheral regeneration studies , 2017, Experimental Neurology.

[13]  Feifan Xiang,et al.  Tissue-engineered nerve graft with tetramethylpyrazine for repair of sciatic nerve defects in rats , 2017, Neuroscience Letters.

[14]  Xinchao Zhang,et al.  Study of synergistic role of allogenic skin-derived precursor differentiated Schwann cells and heregulin-1β in nerve regeneration with an acellular nerve allograft , 2016, Neurochemistry International.

[15]  Wei Wang,et al.  Comparative study of the efficacy of decellularization treatment of allogenic and xenogeneic nerves as nerve conduits. , 2016, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A.

[16]  A. Shin,et al.  The influence of vascularization of transplanted processed allograft nerve on return of motor function in rats , 2016, Microsurgery.

[17]  Liangfu Jiang,et al.  Nerve defect repair by differentiated adipose-derived stem cells and chondroitinase ABC-treated acellular nerves , 2015, The International journal of neuroscience.

[18]  C. Kim,et al.  Semi-automated counting method of axons in transmission electron microscopic images. , 2016, Veterinary ophthalmology.

[19]  Hai-tao Huang,et al.  A comparative study of acellular nerve xenografts and allografts in repairing rat facial nerve defects. , 2015, Molecular medicine reports.

[20]  Wei Wang,et al.  An Experimental Study to Bridge a Nerve Gap with a Decellularized Allogeneic Nerve , 2015, Plastic and reconstructive surgery.

[21]  Lihua Zhou,et al.  Co-Graft of Bone Marrow Stromal Cells and Schwann Cells Into Acellular Nerve Scaffold for Sciatic Nerve Regeneration in Rats. , 2015, Journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery : official journal of the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons.

[22]  R. Banegas.  Nerve allografts - a review , 2015, BMC Proceedings.

[23]  Xiaoping Zhou,et al.  Ginkgo Biloba Extract (EGb 761) Promotes Peripheral Nerve Regeneration and Neovascularization After Acellular Nerve Allografts in a Rat Model , 2014, Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology.

[24]  B. Botterman,et al.  Detergent-free Decellularized Nerve Grafts for Long-gap Peripheral Nerve Reconstruction , 2014, Plastic and reconstructive surgery. Global open.

[25]  Jian Xu,et al.  Etifoxine provides benefits in nerve repair with acellular nerve grafts , 2014, Muscle & nerve.

[26]  Hui Zhang,et al.  Chemically extracted acellular allogeneic nerve graft combined with ciliary neurotrophic factor promotes sciatic nerve repair , 2014, Neural regeneration research.

[27]  P. Zhang,et al.  Combination of Acellular Nerve Graft and Schwann Cells-Like Cells for Rat Sciatic Nerve Regeneration , 2014, Neural plasticity.

[28]  M. Rovers,et al.  SYRCLE’s risk of bias tool for animal studies , 2014, BMC Medical Research Methodology.

[29]  S. Mackinnon,et al.  Limited regeneration in long acellular nerve allografts is associated with increased Schwann cell senescence , 2013, Experimental Neurology.

[30]  A. Shin,et al.  Return of motor function after segmental nerve loss in a rat model: comparison of autogenous nerve graft, collagen conduit, and processed allograft (AxoGen). , 2012, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[31]  Renata V Weber,et al.  Processed nerve allografts for peripheral nerve reconstruction: A multicenter study of utilization and outcomes in sensory, mixed, and motor nerve reconstructions , 2012, Microsurgery.

[32]  S. Mackinnon,et al.  Acellular nerve allografts in peripheral nerve regeneration: A comparative study , 2011, Muscle & nerve.

[33]  Yan Liu,et al.  Repair of nerve defect with acellular nerve graft supplemented by bone marrow stromal cells in mice , 2011, Microsurgery.

[34]  Dong Wang,et al.  Repairing large radial nerve defects by acellular nerve allografts seeded with autologous bone marrow stromal cells in a monkey model. , 2010, Journal of neurotrauma.

[35]  P. Tang,et al.  Repair of whole rabbit facial nerve defects using facial nerve allografts. , 2010, Journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery : official journal of the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons.

[36]  M. Ritskes-Hoitinga,et al.  A Gold Standard Publication Checklist to Improve the Quality of Animal Studies, to Fully Integrate the Three Rs, and to Make Systematic Reviews More Feasible , 2010, Alternatives to laboratory animals : ATLA.

[37]  J. Roland,et al.  Processed Allograft: Novel Use in Facial Nerve Repair after Resection of a Rare Racial Nerve Paraganglioma , 2010, The Laryngoscope.

[38]  A. Shin,et al.  Treatment of a segmental nerve defect in the rat with use of bioabsorbable synthetic nerve conduits: a comparison of commercially available conduits. , 2009, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[39]  Christina K. Magill,et al.  Processed allografts and type I collagen conduits for repair of peripheral nerve gaps , 2009, Muscle & nerve.

[40]  M. Jarvis,et al.  Neuropathic pain: models and mechanisms. , 2009, Current pharmaceutical design.

[41]  X. Sui,et al.  Improvement of peripheral nerve regeneration in acellular nerve grafts with local release of nerve growth factor , 2009, Microsurgery.

[42]  Q. Guo,et al.  Effects of local release of hepatocyte growth factor on peripheral nerve regeneration in acellular nerve grafts , 2008, Experimental Neurology.

[43]  U. Dirnagl,et al.  Evidence for the Efficacy of NXY-059 in Experimental Focal Cerebral Ischaemia Is Confounded by Study Quality , 2008, Stroke.

[44]  Zhen-hua Li,et al.  Experimental Study of Low Dose Ultrashortwave Promoting Nerve Regeneration after Acellular Nerve Allografts Repairing the Sciatic Nerve Gap of Rats , 2008, Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology.

[45]  Bingyao Chen,et al.  Nerve regeneration and functional recovery after a sciatic nerve gap is repaired by an acellular nerve allograft made through chemical extraction in canines. , 2007, Journal of reconstructive microsurgery.

[46]  James B. Graham,et al.  Chondroitinase treatment increases the effective length of acellular nerve grafts , 2007, Experimental Neurology.

[47]  Xiaolin Liu,et al.  Repair of extended peripheral nerve lesions in rhesus monkeys using acellular allogenic nerve grafts implanted with autologous mesenchymal stem cells , 2007, Experimental Neurology.

[48]  S. Mackinnon,et al.  A review of research endeavors to optimize peripheral nerve reconstruction , 2004, Neurological research.

[49]  P. Cederna,et al.  Effects of vascular endothelial growth factor on nerve regeneration in acellular nerve grafts. , 2004, Journal of reconstructive microsurgery.

[50]  G. Keilhoff,et al.  Reconstruction of peripheral nerves using acellular nerve grafts with implanted cultured Schwann cells , 2002, Microsurgery.

[51]  T. Hadlock,et al.  Quantification of Functional Recovery Following Rat Sciatic Nerve Transection , 2001, Experimental Neurology.

[52]  K. Smith,et al.  A prospective, quantitative study on the clinical outcome of lingual nerve repair. , 2000, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery.

[53]  J. Vacanti,et al.  A comparison of assessments of functional recovery in the rat. , 1999, Journal of the peripheral nervous system : JPNS.

[54]  K. Tohyama,et al.  Long Acellular Nerve Transplants for Allogeneic Grafting and the Effects of Basic Fibroblast Growth Factor on the Growth of Regenerating Axons in Dogs: A Preliminary Report , 1998, Experimental Neurology.

[55]  R. Midha,et al.  Analysis of upper and lower extremity peripheral nerve injuries in a population of patients with multiple injuries. , 1998, The Journal of trauma.

[56]  G. Lundborg,et al.  Regeneration of the rat sciatic nerve into allografts made acellular through chemical extraction , 1998, Brain Research.

[57]  A. K. Gulati,et al.  Nerve graft immunogenicity as a factor determining axonal regeneration in the rat. , 1990, Journal of neurosurgery.

[58]  A L Dellon,et al.  Selection of the Appropriate Parameter to Measure Neural Regeneration , 1989, Annals of plastic surgery.

[59]  G. ALLEN,et al.  Raw data , 1989, Nature.

[60]  A L Dellon,et al.  An Alternative to the Classical Nerve Graft for the Management of the Short Nerve Gap , 1988, Plastic and reconstructive surgery.

[61]  P. McMillan,et al.  A review of experimental methods measuring peripheral nerve regeneration in animals. , 1988, The Orthopedic clinics of North America.

[62]  H. Millesi,et al.  Nerve grafting. , 1984, Clinics in plastic surgery.

[63]  R. Hiles.  Freeze Dried Irradiated Nerve Homograft: A preliminary report , 1972, The Hand.

[64]  A. Ward.  Nerves and Nerve Injuries , 1970, Neurology.