Visual acuity and contrast sensitivity comparison between Tecnis and AcrySof SA60AT intraocular lenses: A multicenter randomized study

Purpose: To evaluate best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) and photopic and mesopic contrast sensitivity in pseudophakic patients implanted either with the aspheric intraocular lens (IOL) designed to correct for corneal spherical aberration or with a conventional IOL. Setting: Three surgical centers participated this prospective randomized masked comparative study. Methods: Thirty eyes of 30 patients after aspheric lens implantation (Pfizer/Pharmacia Tecnis Z9000) were compared with 30 eyes of 30 age‐matched patients after conventional lens implantation (Alcon AcrySof SA60AT). Two to three months after surgery, best spectacle corrected distance visual acuity was measured using the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study chart. Contrast sensitivity was measured by sinusoidal grating charts for distance at photopic (85 cd/m2) and mesopic (6 cd/m2) luminance level with optical correction in place. Tested spatial frequencies were 1.5, 3, 6, 12, and 18 cycles per degree (cpd). Results: The mean BCVA was −0.053 ± 0.044 logMAR in eyes with the aspheric Tecnis IOL and 0.006 ± 0.059 logMAR in eyes with the conventional AcrySof IOL (P = .0001). Eyes with the aspheric IOL showed better contrast sensitivity at spatial frequencies of 3 cpd (P<.05) and 6, 12, and 18 cpd (P<.01) in photopic and in mesopic conditions. Peak improvement occurred at 18 cpd and was 36% (0.29 log units) in photopic and 54% (0.27 log units) in mesopic conditions. Conclusions: The aspheric Tecnis IOL yielded better BCVA and better distance contrast sensitivity than the conventional IOL. The differences were clinically significant for higher spatial frequencies. The results give some suggestions for further studies.

[1]  F Krummenauer,et al.  Objective and subjective evaluation of photic phenomena after monofocal and multifocal intraocular lens implantation. , 1999, Ophthalmology.

[2]  M. Campbell,et al.  Presbyopia and the optical changes in the human crystalline lens with age , 1998, Vision Research.

[3]  A P Ginsburg,et al.  Large‐Sample Norms for Contrast Sensitivity , 1984, American journal of optometry and physiological optics.

[4]  F. Mutlu,et al.  The Role of Capsulotomy and Intraocular Lens Type on Tilt and Decentration of Polymethylmethacrylate and Foldable Acrylic Lenses , 1998, Ophthalmologica.

[5]  R. Woods,et al.  A comparison of visual performance between a rigid PMMA and a foldable acrylic intraocular lens , 1999, Eye.

[6]  H. Hayashi,et al.  Decentration and tilt of polymethyl methacrylate, silicone, and acrylic soft intraocular lenses. , 1997, Ophthalmology.

[7]  R. Sekuler,et al.  Contrast sensitivity throughout adulthood , 1982, Vision Research.

[8]  Mark Packer,et al.  Prospective randomized trial of an anterior surface modified prolate intraocular lens. , 2002, Journal of refractive surgery.

[9]  Arthur P. Ginsburg,et al.  Contrast Sensitivity and Functional Vision , 2003, International ophthalmology clinics.

[10]  Marrie van der Mooren,et al.  A new intraocular lens design to reduce spherical aberration of pseudophakic eyes. , 2002, Journal of refractive surgery.

[11]  Mark Packer,et al.  Improved functional vision with a modified prolate intraocular lens , 2004, Journal of cataract and refractive surgery.

[12]  D A Atchison,et al.  Design of aspheric intraocular lenses , 1991, Ophthalmic & physiological optics : the journal of the British College of Ophthalmic Opticians.

[13]  George Smith,et al.  The spherical aberration of the crystalline lens of the human eye , 2001, Vision Research.

[14]  Pablo Artal,et al.  Contribution of the cornea and internal surfaces to the change of ocular aberrations with age. , 2002, Journal of the Optical Society of America. A, Optics, image science, and vision.

[15]  C. Akkın,et al.  Tilt and decentration of bag-fixated intraocular lenses: A comparative study between capsulorhexis and envelope techniques , 2005, Documenta Ophthalmologica.

[16]  P. Piers,et al.  Comparison of wavefront aberrations and optical quality of eyes implanted with five different intraocular lenses. , 2004, Journal of refractive surgery.

[17]  Ulrich Mester,et al.  Impact of a modified optic design on visual function: Clinical comparative study , 2003, Journal of cataract and refractive surgery.